Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the radiologist shouldn’t have said anything?

88 replies

ThemysteriousH · 26/04/2023 22:56

So have a wide variety of symptoms, different conditions but new ones that need investigating.

Had an abdominal/internal ultrasound to check for cysts. Chatted generally throughout and how long waiting times are for gynae (I’m under them for endometriosis and not had an appointment for a few years, I understand Covid’s impact etc).

As I was getting ready to leave asked when would I get results and she said,
“You’re GP will get them within days, you’ve no ovarian cysts, your scans abnormal, but at least you’ll get that gynae appt quicker now!”

Not coming here looking for a diagnosis but AIBU in thinking she should’ve just said “you’re Gp will do receive the results in such and such time” rather than above?

Now I’m unnecessarily worrying about it. Doesn’t help my CA-125 blood test was abnormal. (Work in ED which doesn’t see gynae/peads etc and not asking a colleague).

OP posts:
ThisNameIsNotAvailable · 27/04/2023 06:02

Well I’ve just googled it (should have done that first) a radiologist is a doctor so is fine to interpret. Radiographer isn’t so shouldn’t.

ThisNameIsNotAvailable · 27/04/2023 05:58

I’m confused
a) Endo doesn’t show up on a scan which is why it’s hard to diagnose
b) You don’t have to be a doctor to be a radiographer - it’s a three year degree to qualify as either a diagnostic or therapeutic radiographer.

wrinkleintime · 27/04/2023 05:44

She shouldn't have told you that your scan is abnormal as she's not qualified to discuss the implications of that with you.

I would complain. Hope you don't have too long a wait to find out more.

ArcticSkewer · 27/04/2023 05:29

They probably shouldn't have said anything, going back to the op, and left it to your GP to speak to you. I always want to get the news straight away but if it was just from the sonographer - probably not!
Hope you hear soon and it's nothing too worrying

rwalker · 27/04/2023 05:26

You know there’s something wrong that’s why your having a scan in the first place

ArcticSkewer · 27/04/2023 05:24

Wishiwasatailor · 27/04/2023 04:58

@HoppingPavlova @negomi90 aren’t there radiographers/sonographers who have done extra training to be able to report on X-rays and ultrasounds?

There are no radiographers or sonographers who have done an additional four or five years of medical school to become doctors followed by years of specific training in radiology, to get a double degree in effect.

Any that did follow that extremely arduous route are going to call themselves radiologists!

TerfIngOnTheBeach · 27/04/2023 05:13

Wishiwasatailor · 27/04/2023 04:58

@HoppingPavlova @negomi90 aren’t there radiographers/sonographers who have done extra training to be able to report on X-rays and ultrasounds?

Yes, there are Advanced Clinical Practioners who are Reporting Radiographers with additional post graduate qualifications.

DD is a senior Radiographer, that’s one of the next career progression opportunities available to her.

MedievalMadness · 27/04/2023 05:04

YANBU. SayIng that was bound to leave you worried. I agree they should have just said when your report would be back and that you’d get an appointment soon. Unless they have the time to talk things through it’s unfair to leave you to speculate on what they might have found and what that might mean. I hope you soon get the answers you need OP

Wishiwasatailor · 27/04/2023 04:58

@HoppingPavlova @negomi90 aren’t there radiographers/sonographers who have done extra training to be able to report on X-rays and ultrasounds?

HoppingPavlova · 27/04/2023 04:48

@Emeraldsrock Sonographers and radiologists do the same thing. They report on what they see and suggest follow ups. Sonographers tend to do gynae scans though. Most radiologists don’t

None of that is correct.

A radiologist is a qualified doctor, who has completed specialty training in radiology. They ‘read’ x-rays/scans and use these in combination with clinical notes to write reports, and in some cases provide advice to the referring service.
A sonographer is not a doctor, not a specialist, but someone who has completed training in the act of sonography. Similar with radiographers. Not all radiographers are sonographers but these days most would have also done that training.

In short, be it radiographer/sonographer, they should not be providing any clinical feedback whatsoever to patients. That’s completely inappropriate. It should be limited to ‘a report will be sent to the referrer, that should be received in x days’. Otherwise they do risk saying ‘all good’ when something may subsequently be picked up via radiologist review. In regards to fetal monitoring via u/s there is no issue at all saying a patient would need to come back as positioning meant that x and y could not be observed today. Any diagnosis though is not within their remit, it is the remit of a clinician so they either need to bring one into the room and they look, confirm and discuss with the patient. If appropriate clinicians are not available at that site, they need to refer on to a specialised fetal monitoring unit where these clinicians will be present and will be the ones to make diagnosis, write associated reports, have relevant discussions with patient and associated obstetric services etc.

Murdoch1949 · 27/04/2023 04:48

Most people would welcome the information.

Berklilly · 27/04/2023 03:18

GPs, not Gaps!

Berklilly · 27/04/2023 03:17

She could have said it better, but I think she just meant to let you know that you would get the gynae referral based on her observations of the ultrasound (which I assume Gaps would follow in most cases). She probably didn't mean to diagnose or say anything more than what she saw on the scan.

Not sure if it's right or wrong. I've had that experience with baby growth scans where I would be told immediately if everything was normal or not by the person doing the scan, to let me know if I would have a follow-up with a consultant or not

FurAndFeathers · 27/04/2023 02:50

ThisSingleMama · 26/04/2023 22:59

I don't think she said anything wrong!

You don’t think dropping that a patient has an abnormal scan without further detail is a problem?

negomi90 · 27/04/2023 01:22

@Emeraldsrock sonographers and radiologists really don't do the same things. Sonographers are like radiographers but with ultrasound instead of X ray. They are trained to take pictures using ultrasound. They aren't trained in interpreting it. If you have a scan done by a sonographer they will take lots of pictures and sometimes video. They won't interpret it. The pictures will be looked at by a radiologist who will interpret it and write the report. Most sonographers will know what the report is likely to say, but they aren't officially allowed to say it or interpret it.

Radiologists are doctors, they went through medical school and if they trained in this country spent two years doing traditional doctoring post graduation. They can do ultrasounds themselves and take the pictures and write the report themselves. They also look at the pictures they take and others take.

Scans can be done by sonographers or radiologists. Radiologists can tell you while they scan you what the findings are (they will know what the findings are officially as they do the scan). Sonographers can't tell you in the room because even if they know the findings, they don't have reporting training.

Foodie6 · 27/04/2023 01:21

CA125 can be raised with endometrosis OP try not to worry

CustardySergeant · 27/04/2023 00:32

ThemysteriousH · 26/04/2023 23:06

Maybe I’m overthinking it as it’s a long preying time

What does that mean?

PollyPeptide · 27/04/2023 00:20

If you've got endometriosis, isn't that why your scan is abnormal and your CA125 is raised? Nothing to do with cancer.

I think if they're going to comment, they should explain what they mean. So for that reason, I think she was unreasonable and you are not.

Imperialleathers · 27/04/2023 00:14

Why didn't you ask what was abnormal about the scan ? Or did you and I'm not reading properly.

Plantgeumstoday · 27/04/2023 00:02

Probably said it’s abnormal, meaning the endo and assuming you’re already aware of that.

I think if it was anything sinister that was new she wouldn’t have mentioned it and would have just told you you’ll get the result from your GP.

I understand your worry though. I’m a worrier too but looking in from the outside I think she was trying to be reassuring.

Justkeepingplatesspinning · 27/04/2023 00:00

I had a pelvic ultrasound, both internal and external, today too. The radiologist just told me that she would write the report and to phone the GP in about a week for the results. When I've had them in the past, the radiologist has given me a running commentary and showed me on the screen what she's noticed. Including ovarian cysts and things. She always chatted through things and made sure I was okay etc.
Not sure which I prefer?!
I would have been a bit floored by being told that on the way out the door tbh, perhaps phone the dept and ask for some follow up about what they meant?

Spinner12345 · 26/04/2023 23:34

Given radiologists are doctors I’d be happy getting that kind of diagnostic information from them. If they were a radiographer I’d maybe be a bit more reluctant but depends on their skillset

MeinKraft · 26/04/2023 23:26

Well why didn't you say 'what was abnormal?' When I went for a scan of my gallbladder the radiologist talked me the whole way through it and showed me the stones on the screen. I asked her a few questions and she seemed happy enough to answer.

Hankunamatata · 26/04/2023 23:18

But your scan will be abnormal due to endo, so surely that's not a surprise.

Nimbostratus100 · 26/04/2023 23:14

gone are the days when radiologist are secretive and tightlipped. Mine told me she thought I had cancer, I was so grateful to her for her candour,