Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the radiologist shouldn’t have said anything?

88 replies

ThemysteriousH · 26/04/2023 22:56

So have a wide variety of symptoms, different conditions but new ones that need investigating.

Had an abdominal/internal ultrasound to check for cysts. Chatted generally throughout and how long waiting times are for gynae (I’m under them for endometriosis and not had an appointment for a few years, I understand Covid’s impact etc).

As I was getting ready to leave asked when would I get results and she said,
“You’re GP will get them within days, you’ve no ovarian cysts, your scans abnormal, but at least you’ll get that gynae appt quicker now!”

Not coming here looking for a diagnosis but AIBU in thinking she should’ve just said “you’re Gp will do receive the results in such and such time” rather than above?

Now I’m unnecessarily worrying about it. Doesn’t help my CA-125 blood test was abnormal. (Work in ED which doesn’t see gynae/peads etc and not asking a colleague).

OP posts:
worldwidetravel2017 · 19/10/2023 20:11

Hows things?
I have abnormal ca125

Had an urgent colonoscopy 4 other reasons & bowel polyps removed

Had a transvaginal scan and ovarian cancer ruled out

Had gastroscopy ' stomach fine..

Had an appt with gynae - not gynacological

Now ct abdomen scan :(

JudgeRudy · 25/07/2023 18:15

I think that's a reasonable response, particularly if you've asked 'does everything seem OK?' or 'so what happens next?'
The alternative would be to lie

Saz12 · 27/04/2023 16:25

I had an abdominal ultrasound, it was very obvious from the radiologists expressions that she thought it was really bad news. But she wouldnt tell me anything at all. It would've been better if shed either just told me or had a better poker face!

As it turned out, what looked like lots of small secondary tumours on the ultrasound was clearly something completely different after the follow up ct scan.

DaaamnYoullDo · 27/04/2023 16:01

Personally I'd rather be told.

Emeraldsrock · 27/04/2023 15:59

Given that I am a sonographer I think I am qualified to say what they do! Both sonographer and radiologists report. And most radiologists don’t do transvaginal scans!!

HoppingPavlova · 27/04/2023 10:49

@Wishiwasatailor aren’t there radiographers/sonographers who have done extra training to be able to report on X-rays and ultrasounds

It’s country specific. Some it does exist as a role and others, with a strong medical association, it tends to be blocked as a role (medical association protectionism of members jobs and salaries). Irrespective, where it exists as a role, I thought they could only write the report and provide to the referring service, could not offer associated medical counsel to patients, that is the role of the receiving clinician. May have changed since I last worked where this existed. Maybe someone who currently works in this role or a radiologist in a country where clinical radiologists currently exist could comment on where that aspect currently sits with what is formally permissible (as opposed to what people just choose to do irrespective of the rules which is rife).

SleepyRich · 27/04/2023 10:11

I don't think there was anything wrong in what they said, ultimately if you've got persistent symptoms in a weird way you want the scan to be abnormal so they can identify the problem and hopefully treat it. They might have thought you'd be relieved at hearing the results had found a problem/hopefully identified the cause, as opposed to 'sorry the scan was completely normal so likely you'll be discharged to get on with it'. I suppose everyone's different though so nothing wrong with you not appreciating that candour.

Rowthe · 27/04/2023 10:00

Maybe I'm being overly harsh.

But most people want some information,.and they complain about not being told anything.

This radiologist did you a favour and gave you a quick explanation, so you're not waiting 2- 4 months for your results without any information at all.

They really cant win.

Rowthe · 27/04/2023 09:55

If they give you information they've done the wrong thing.

If they dont tell you anything- again people complain that they have done the wrong thing.

They cant win.

I think it should be left to the patient to state whether they want to be told anything about the scan and if you didnt say anything then the radiologist should complain about you.

Batalax · 27/04/2023 09:32

That’s a worrying long wait till June. I hope the gp can be more reassuring.

Nordicrain · 27/04/2023 09:24

Yes, this isn't on. Preferably she shouldnt' comment but if she did she should explain what she meant properly.

Try not worry OP, I had a sonographer tell me I had polycystic ovaries when I didn't at all. Odd.

ThemysteriousH · 27/04/2023 09:18

To answer a few things - endometriosis typically doesn’t show on a scan, I had to have a Laparoscopic procedure to diagnose it.

Could well have been a sonographer, that’s my mistake - they all wear the same black uniform but she did seem to know what she was talking about.

Had a phone call yesterday from the hospital I’m being squeezed onto the end of a clinic the first week of June but have a GP appointment sooner. (We all know how hard those are to get atm!)

I know I should’ve been grateful for some information I think last night I was just overthinking the whole scenario.

Mentioned my job/tests because if I asked a colleague advice on what it could be/my abnormal ovarian ca-125 result, they wouldn’t know much either, like myself, as all things gynaecology emergency’s automatically go to another hospital so they’ve no reason to be clued up on things.

I hope that’s cleared some things up, I do appreciate all your responses and can see that I probably IABU a bit.

OP posts:
YeOldeTrout · 27/04/2023 08:02

I had a gynae exam last year using ultrasound. Was very appreciative to imager for telling me exactly what he saw & what he would put in his report. I would have felt same whether it was good or bad news, they were giving me as much information as they could perceive and it was MY information so appropriate to give it to me. It sounds like they should have given more info what was the "abnormal" flag they saw in the scan, I suppose.

Agree with others that the word abnormal doesn't mean anything bad in itself.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 27/04/2023 06:48

There is also the concept of a "warning shot", this may often be delivered by someone other than the treating clinician, often other HCP such as specialist nurses, no reason it could be a radiographer saying something like " I need to get someone to take another look at this". Ultimately we are human and very few of us could keep a deadpan face in the face of an image which is obviously worrying and/ or puzzling. Do you have an appointment now OP ?

TheInterceptor · 27/04/2023 06:45

If her only job was to scan for ovarian cysts, and she found none, wouldn't it make more sense that she said 'your scans are normal' (ie. no cysts) and you misheard?

GretaGood · 27/04/2023 06:45

Are you sure she said abnormal and not normal - I can see someone reassuring a patient by telling them all is normal.

Wheresthebeach · 27/04/2023 06:38

She shouldn’t have said anything about the scan and I think her comment about getting a fast appointment was flippant.

I have abdominal and pelvic mri’s yearly - they always just ask if I’ve my appointment for results booked but never comment on the results.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 27/04/2023 06:35

Mortimercat · 27/04/2023 06:26

It was t really information though was it. No I would not welcome being told something was abnormal without further discussion.

Yes and no, diagnosis is an iterative process, most of the time there is no one test which gives you all the answers (if it does then the news is either very good eg: everything is normal or very, very bad) most of the time it's somewhere between. It is quite normal for people to be sent off for more tests, specialist opinions etc on their journey. This usually takes days to weeks, waiting months and months is obviously unacceptable, but a few days is pretty much inevitable unless your GP's surgery is located in a teaching hospital or you go private.

Holidaywwyd · 27/04/2023 06:34

Well surely you asked in what way it was abnormal?

Mortimercat · 27/04/2023 06:26

Murdoch1949 · 27/04/2023 04:48

Most people would welcome the information.

It was t really information though was it. No I would not welcome being told something was abnormal without further discussion.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 27/04/2023 06:18

Themermaidspool · 26/04/2023 23:07

You have endometriosis. So your scan to be abnormal isnt unexpected. Either she should say nothing (but then it might be a shock when it comes back with something) or have told you exactly whats going on (and then youd still have to wait a few weeks for the next step and that might cause further stress). Theres no right or wrong answer.
Also make sure you arnt getting confused between a sonographer and radiologist. A sonographer doesnt have the same skillset or responsibilities as a radiologist. I wouldnt expect a sonographer to give bad news for example.
In the short term ring your doctor and ask them to go through the report to explain.

I think radiologists are in an impossible position TBH. Bad news travels fast in hospitals and very bad news travels very quickly. Last time one of my patients had an abnormal scan they had it on the Thursday, I got a call on the Friday and I saw them on the Monday.

Which was as fast as was feasible, but they already knew it was abnormal , the radiologist had something similar. I don't know what they are supposed to say really.

NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 27/04/2023 06:16

I think maybe the problem was with the word "abnormal". Which sounds scary and has you thinking a while host of things.
I had a full abdo scan and the person doing it talked me through it as she did it. I don't know what her qualifications were. When we got to my gallbladder she said "there's sludge in here and a couple of stones hiding inside the sludge."

Plingston · 27/04/2023 06:15

I'm on the fence here. I was recently told by the lady who scanned and x-rayed my breast lump that she was 99% certain I had cancer after a consultant had just told me it was a cyst. She also took the biopsies, so I'm not sure what her job is exactly. It seemed entirely normal and expected for her to do these things. I had always assumed that you got sat down in a room by a doctor after waiting for results and that a cancer diagnosis was a shock, but it didn't happen like that.

But I don't think telling you it was abnormal with no other information is very helpful. It leaves too much unknown for your imagination to start running wild. Did you ask what was abnormal about it?

stressbucket1 · 27/04/2023 06:13

And yes there are reporting radiographers that complete another course on top of degree to be able to report some plain film xrays.

stressbucket1 · 27/04/2023 06:10

Sonographers do report their own scans. That is their speciality.
Radiologists also report their own ultrasound scans but have many more responsibilities as a Dr.
Don't know if you had a radiologist or a sonographer doing your scan OP. They are "allowed" to tell you the results and I'm sure they would have clarified if you asked. Hope all goes well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread