Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was I wrong for speaking out at staff meeting today

214 replies

Safarigiraffe · 26/04/2023 22:53

Had a staff meeting today after work, boss goes round asking everyone at the end of the meeting if any of us had any questions or anything to say so I said that staff in a particular room are not doing their part in what they have to do to help us out so then both my bosses tell me to watch my tone of voice & not to mention names (I mentioned no names only mentioned the room in particular) made me feel uncomfortable, guilty & awkward after for saying something. So should I of kept quiet or were my bosses being unreasonable for telling me to watch my tone of voice & not to mention names

OP posts:
drpet49 · 27/04/2023 20:12

Mightyouandiconfabulate · 26/04/2023 23:12

I also think that you were unreasonable in bringing such an obviously identifying criticism to a meeting room full of colleagues.
It’s confrontational and negative and unnecessary.

You are of course entitled to your opinion but should have taken it to a private meeting with management.

I can’t imagine that you will be very popular with the team that you identified and the other people in the room, you kind of publicly threw them under the bus there.
Don’t imagine that the atmosphere will now be very happy following this. No one wants that.

This. I can’t believe you thought this was appropriate.

strawberryfluff · 27/04/2023 20:07

If I'm honest, and I appreciate this may be tricky to hear, I think if you can you should look for another job. Your cards are marked at this one now.

SmallFerret · 27/04/2023 20:05

Safarigiraffe · 27/04/2023 20:01

Got a verbal warning over this at work & they spoke to me about being unprofessional & it came across as very harsh.

Yet still no self-reflection on how YOU came across.

You WERE harsh.
You accused an entire room of people of "not doing their part".
You didn't state facts, you didn't back it up with data & examples, you didn't ameliorate the negativity by asking to understand what was preventing them from fulfilling whatever - you just came out & claimed that a whole team of people aren't doing their job properly.

ReadersD1gest · 27/04/2023 20:04

Safarigiraffe · 27/04/2023 20:01

Got a verbal warning over this at work & they spoke to me about being unprofessional & it came across as very harsh.

It's not overly harsh, tbh. Hopefully you now know what behaviours are considered unacceptable 🤷🏻‍♀️

strawberryfluff · 27/04/2023 20:02

Safarigiraffe · 27/04/2023 20:01

Got a verbal warning over this at work & they spoke to me about being unprofessional & it came across as very harsh.

Good frankly

Safarigiraffe · 27/04/2023 20:01

Got a verbal warning over this at work & they spoke to me about being unprofessional & it came across as very harsh.

OP posts:
Anon1368 · 27/04/2023 17:13

It's a common mistake though, with new to the workforce people. You live and learn. I've seen it happen where I work recently with a school leaver. They're taught these days to speak out at school. But it's best not to at first, particularly in a large organisation, as there will be so many factors you are not yet aware of. It's very easy to get it wrong and I suspect most of us have at one time or another.

ChickenDhansak82 · 27/04/2023 12:29

Safarigiraffe · 27/04/2023 07:09

Appreciate feedback maybe I was wrong to say it there and then is this something I could be getting a warning about

MAYBE wrong??

In a staff meeting, if they ask if anyone has any questions or anything to say, they are referring to constructive comments e.g. thanking someone for something, asking for help with something, warning people about any upcoming things that might cause issues.

What you did was slag off a department to the entire company. VERY unprofessional!

So yes, it is likely they might want to have a further discussion with you about this, or you might want to get in there first and apologise.

If you have a problem with another department, you take it up in a one to one meeting with your line manager.

unflapper · 27/04/2023 12:12

How would you feel if a colleague voiced something publicly about the team you're part of? If it were me, I'd feel upset and embarrassed.

Things like this are always best raised privately.

Mortimercat · 27/04/2023 12:03

Safarigiraffe · 27/04/2023 07:09

Appreciate feedback maybe I was wrong to say it there and then is this something I could be getting a warning about

You certainly need to be spoken to about your poor judgement and raising things in the right forum and in the right manner, but I wouldn’t have thought an official “warning“ would be required.

newnamethanks · 27/04/2023 11:18

Oh dear. In you next job, attend a few meetings without voicing your concerns about other staff so you can gauge the atmosphere more adequately. Learn how to behave. Don't trash your colleagues or you'll have a miserable working life no matter where you go.

Whochangedmynamec · 27/04/2023 10:53

I learned a while ago that when you are asked if you have any questions at staff meetings the correct answer is either “No, thanks for asking” or to bring up a vaguely complimentary and quickly resolved thing so everyone can feel good.

The question is a courtesy that you are not expected to act upon.

So, a good question might be “Who brought in those real butter shortbread last week and can we get some more?”. Polite giggle from everyone as they stand up, relieved the meeting is over.

Anything you actually want to talk about you can email over before.

Similarly, many businesses only ever want polite feedback. Nothing you say will be acted on in certain workplaces and you will be marked down for mentioning it.

It sounds like this business is in the latter category.

TheKobayashiMaru · 27/04/2023 10:47

Safarigiraffe · 27/04/2023 07:09

Appreciate feedback maybe I was wrong to say it there and then is this something I could be getting a warning about

It is hard to tell OP as you've not really expended on what exactly it is you said or how you said it. Were any of the people from that room in the meeting or were other staff in the meeting or was it just your department?

What consequences depends on a lot of things.

Rosula · 27/04/2023 10:14

Presumably your tone of voice was unduly sharp or confrontational so they were right to ask you to watch it. You should have brought this issue up privately beforehand with whoever is in charge of the room in question; if you have and it didn't work, your next step would have been to raise it directly with that person's line manager or the bosses, or alternatively you could have asked for the issue of the relevant process to be put on the agenda for the meeting.

Gazelda · 27/04/2023 09:29

If I were you OP, I'd ask manager for a quick chat this morning as you've reflected on the meeting last night and realise you
Shouldn't have raised the issue then.

Apologise for any upset caused and then make sure you'll be happy to work with the other room to look at the processes to see if they can be made more effective.

Be collaborative rather than confrontational or accusing.

Mangledrake · 27/04/2023 09:12

OP has accepted she was wrong.

Unless her managers are insecure control freaks, I really wouldn't expect this to get into warning territory. They could have handled this better themselves - no need to be critical of OP in public.

Hope you are okay OP. This would be forgotten fast anywhere I've worked. Have coffee with a work friend. Don't panic.

nettie434 · 27/04/2023 09:03

If you hold a staff meeting, then you have to be make it clear beforehand why it's being held and what topics it will cover. I'm in the minority in terms of voting because while I definitely would never criticise colleagues in public this way, I also think your managers handled this badly. All they had to do was say that people should raise concerns like this privately with their line manager and that they know everyone is concerned about the company working as effectively as possible.

By focussing on you and your tone of voice, they appear to be switching away from what is happening in Room X and closing down discussion. Maybe there is a problem there that needs resolving.

The difficulty for you is that everyone in Room X will have heard what you said or will be told about it. The managers should remind you of the right way to raise your concerns but also look into what you said and make sure workplace relations aren't affected. Unfortunately you have to be prepared for the reality which is that some managers won't always want to hear about problems in the workplace.

whumpthereitis · 27/04/2023 09:01

He asked for questions. You didn’t ask a question, you assumed authority and piggybacked the meeting to make a statement that criticized your colleagues. You didn’t need to name names, presumably everyone knows who works in room X.

You approached that horribly, in completely the wrong forum.

liste · 27/04/2023 08:54

I think you took the "any questions/things to say" a bit too literally. It doesn't mean that it's appropriate to say absolutely anything. Surely you know there's a line? Would you say the following are appropriate?

"I just wanted to let everyone know that Dave and Lisa are having an affair"

"I just wanted to tell you that I hate this place and hearing you drone on makes me want to gouge my own eyes out"

Presuming the answer to the above is "no" then why not? Your boss said you can use the time to ask questions/say anything?

The reason you don't is because it's unprofessional and inappropriate. Presuming you understand that my extreme examples aren't appropriate, then what people are telling you is that what you said also crossed the line into unprofessionalism.

"Any questions?" means things like "would you like us to prioritise the task we just spoke about the the task we were assigned last week?" or "would you like the first draft emailing over or shall I wait until it's finished?" - Small, easy questions to finish off the meeting.

Things to say are things like "I just wanted to let everyone know that the printer on our floor is out of order so you won't be able to use it today but it will hopefully be fixed by the morning".

It's not an appropriate place to criticise your colleagues in public and throw them under the bus in front of everyone. That's something that's more appropriate to do in private. It comes across like you were trying to have a dig and get them in trouble in front of your bosses.

ReadersD1gest · 27/04/2023 08:31

An all staff meeting was neither the time nor the place, and if they both commented on your tone there was some issue? Sounds like you were either confrontational or whiny.

AgnesX · 27/04/2023 08:30

Maybe it was how you said it, in a whiney shitstirring kind of way which is why you were told to watch your tone.

Equally it may have been watch the tone as in the content of what you were saying.

Either way if you have that sort of issue you complain about it via management, not in an open forum.

SmallFerret · 27/04/2023 08:28

Safarigiraffe · 26/04/2023 22:59

Well my boss did ask if we had any questions or anything to say so that’s why I mentioned it however telling me to watch my tone or voice and not to mention any names in particular I don’t think was right

You already seem convinced you are in the right. Have you paused to consider what your tone was like, or are you just going to insist that you are right so that must mean your boss is wrong?

You mentioned the room. You boss was doing you a favour by reminding you not to mention names. I accept that you say you didn't do so, but given that you'd already identified an entire room of people as "not doing their part", maybe your boss thought that you'd go further & incriminate yourself with a personal attack.

If you need to take this up, do so in private with your boss, & be specific.
Keep all remarks professional, tone-check yourself, & don't make waffly blame-laying statements like "team X is not doing their part."
Instead, say something like "when team X falls behind with processing ABC, it causes a logjam for us, resulting in a 15% decline in productivity. Please can you help me identify where the issue is, so that team X & my department can continue to support maximum productivity?"

Dyrne · 27/04/2023 08:23

CraftyIrishMamma · 27/04/2023 08:04

Sounds like your boss is one of those incompetent types who talk the talk but does sweet FA about problem solving because they’re afraid of dealing with conflict.

I agree that it might have been better to raise it in a 1:1 meeting but if it’s a situation that’s impacting your whole team (who were attending the meeting), then I think it WAS appropriate to raise it in a team meeting.

Not necessarily.

This could be the first time the manager’s hearing about it (likely given the OP would probably have said if it was something that previously hadn’t gotten any traction going via other routes of escalation)

The team in question may be dealing with another business priority or have a known issue that is already being dealt with; and it’s not always appropriate to share that with the wider business.

CraftyIrishMamma · 27/04/2023 08:04

Sounds like your boss is one of those incompetent types who talk the talk but does sweet FA about problem solving because they’re afraid of dealing with conflict.

I agree that it might have been better to raise it in a 1:1 meeting but if it’s a situation that’s impacting your whole team (who were attending the meeting), then I think it WAS appropriate to raise it in a team meeting.

CleverLilViper · 27/04/2023 08:03

Definitely inappropriate and unprofessional.

Regarding a warning, it depends. It’s unlikely given that they addressed it and I assume that you stopped it then and there? If you pressed the issue, maybe. It also depends on your tone.

if I was your manager, I’d have a follow up conversation with you about the issue and about how best to raise things like this in the future.

I would definitely be looking to dissuade you from continuing this behaviour. The trouble is this will likely have an impact on the dynamics of the teams going forward.