Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how kids had downtime before TV

207 replies

someladdersandsnakes · 26/04/2023 21:06

I saw a post earlier on a Facebook group from someone who had managed to keep their 3 year old screen free, until out of desperation recently she started giving her one cartoon a day so she could put the younger child down for a nap. And she feels she's destroyed her kid's creativity. And most people were saying it's admirable you've managed this long but go easy on yourself because screen time is incredibly helpful and gives your child a chance to wind down too.

Now I see a moderate amount of screen time as pretty much essential to my own parenting. It's not just that it gives me time to get things done without being interrupted. There are also times particularly after a long day at nursery when my DD seems too tired to engage with play, and can't maintain interest in anything and just needs TV/tablet to zone out a bit. And this seems pretty normal/common to me.

So I'm just wondering, before TV was invented (and/or if you're genuinely a screen free parent but I've never met one of those) what did young kids do when they were too frazzled to play? Were they more creative than modern kids and just played nicely anyway? Or did they sit there whinging? What if they were ill? Did they just lie in bed staring into space? I'm a 90s kid and always had TV so I have no idea and cannot imagine this world 😂

OP posts:
Tinybrother · 27/04/2023 07:44

I think the only real difference when you’re talking about really small children who need you right next to them to keep them physically safe a lot of the time, is that now they have TV to keep them (more) reliably in one place when a parent just needs to get on with something, whereas in the past a more literal restriction of playpen/playroom might have been used. I had mine in a carrier a lot (because they wanted me to carry them everywhere but it kept my hands free) which did a similar job

Tinybrother · 27/04/2023 07:41

All these things people are describing, my children do most of them now (other than playing in the street, that’s not safe here). I’m not sure what’s so unusual about them, most children do all this stuff plus have a bit of TV now.

loislovesstewie · 27/04/2023 07:39

Oh, and mum would listen to the wireless, as she called it, so Woman's Hour would be on and I would join her in listening. And Listen with Mother of course. I would also be given the brasses to polish when I was quite small and spent ages with the Brasso polishing. If I complained of boredom mum found me a chore to do.

Bk1000 · 27/04/2023 07:38

In was born in the 80s but my parents didn’t agree with tvs so we didn’t have one until I was a teenager! I have no idea what my mum did when we were very small as we were all quite close in age, she had 3 under 5 at one point. I do remember being allowed out to wander the farmyard where we lived from a very young age so I guess my parents found it more acceptable for us to risk our lives outside instead 🤷‍♀️ I was always outdoors as a child and I still prefer being outside now I’m an adult.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 27/04/2023 07:17

@mellicauli , I loved Listen with Mother! ‘If you’re sitting comfortably, then I’ll begin.’

There was nothing else for pre schoolers then - needless to say I am very ancient. We didn’t have a TV until I was 11.

Lcb123 · 27/04/2023 07:10

I’m a 90s kid and we had very limited Tv. Did a lot of reading, and imaginative play. And we played out on the street all the time (in London!). I don’t think you need TV to calm down

HAF1119 · 27/04/2023 07:06

Mine was fully screen free until 3. We have autism in the family and this was something we read about as a good idea to do to avoid dependence and find tools to deflect from the hard moments other than tv

It was hard Grin there were some very easy times as he had to learn to self entertain, I could walk away while he did some sticker crafts etc but at a young age couldn't leave to do anything very 'messy'

He did flick through books looking at the pictures a lot, we were outdoors a great deal, and he napped until a later age than many of his peers, he's still napping some of the time now at nearly 4

We didn't tell friends of his (well their parents) that he was screen free though as it doesn't get an amazing response and we felt it was a personal choice and didn't want to be judged on it (and when you say it most the time I think people think you are judging their choice to use screens)

When I was cooking etc and he was alone he was great for entertaining himself and going to the book corner, but I do not pop the tv on when I'm busy and need peace and it's pretty nice! It is easy to have it creep up on you that it's being used a lot though! Definately if I added it up now having had tv in his world for 9 months I think we started with 15 mins a day or something and now sometimes have an hour and a half without thinking about it

If we were to have a second they would have more tv from the start owing to the older having it, such is life!

FancyCurtains · 27/04/2023 06:54

Suzannargh · 26/04/2023 21:35

TV/screen time is very much linked with ADHD, lack of self-regulation, lack of creativity and inability to visualise things in one’s mind. Society’s already changed so much with a generation having phones and handheld screens as opposed to a family TV.

Would you mind providing some evidence for this? Those are quite some claims that you’re making.

WonderingWanda · 27/04/2023 06:52

@Snoken your post has reminded me that I used to listen to Storyteller tapes and I had a record player.

Snoken · 27/04/2023 06:41

I grew up in Sweden and we had 2 TV channels. There wasn’t anything airing during the days at all, the mornings only had news from what I remember. There was one kids show on at 6.15-6.45pm during the week and then one hour of cartoons on Sunday mornings. That was the screen time I had. 3.5h/week total.
what I remember doing if I needed downtime was listening to stories on cassette tapes in my room, or on LPs in the sitting room. Sometimes just sitting there listening, sometimes whilst pottering with other things.

WonderingWanda · 27/04/2023 06:40

I was little in the 80's so there was tv but it wasn't constant kids tv like now. My Mum used to just put me in the garden to play. I would dig, ride my trike, play with dolls, search for worms, make perfume etc. As I got older I would play with the kids next door in the street.

flutterbyebaby · 27/04/2023 06:40

I had to put up with the Sullivans if I was off school poorly

Tinybrother · 27/04/2023 06:35

In terms of toddlers and smaller ones, who wouldn’t be reading, playing out etc while their mother did jobs, it was much more acceptable to put them in a playpen and let them cry/moan for you while you cracked on with it. These days you would be judged for that.

Riapia · 27/04/2023 06:30

Before TV children didn’t have down time.
The boys went down t’pit or up chimneys.
The girls worked in t’mill or went into domestic service.
HTH.
😁😁

Confusion101 · 27/04/2023 06:28

Hardbackwriter · 26/04/2023 21:18

But isn't OP asking about nursery-aged children?

My niece is nursery age. When she comes home, she potters around outside (in the backyard, not roaming around the neighbourhood like kids used to), has a swing (under supervision), plays with dolls, "reads" (picture books, flip books or books with words but she flicks through them for ages)...

Seaweasel · 27/04/2023 06:16

I remember, I had Sindy dolls and a toy horse and I used to cut up material and make them clothes and blankets. I had a spirograph and stencils and I made lots of drawings and patterns. I read a lot and wrote my own story comic books. My grandad turned up every week with 'Mandy' magazine, which was exciting. We had a garden so I made assault courses and dug about and we had a rabbit which I messed about with and a swing. I rearranged the horse posters on my wall and made things out of cereal boxes. We had a book called 'making science fun' so I found stuff round the house for little experiments. I had a nice time, as I recall.

loislovesstewie · 27/04/2023 06:14

I'm 67 , there was no TV before tea time. Kids programmes were on for a very short while until the news started and that was all we got. We played in the kitchen in bad weather, if fine we went out to the backyard and played. When we got older we played in the surrounding fields. We went fishing in the stream, rode bikes walked around. I'm from a rural area so being outside was just what we did. We read, played card/board games etc. Basically we amused ourselves. I think it was perceived that a bit of boredom made us more self-reliant.

electriclight · 27/04/2023 06:12

I didn't have a tv when my children were young. If they were tired or needed down time, they played with imaginative toys (dolls house, train track), read, coloured, drew, lazed in the garden.

I am not against screens for kids. There are some fantastic programmes and apps. But I do think they can be overused. I don't like to see children with iPads in pushchairs or in restaurants when they should be learning and interacting.

This week the worst I've seen is a child walking around a supermarket with a blaring iPad, and a mum handing an iPad to a child the very second he finished his food in a family restaurant. Later, they wanted to leave but he wouldn't let them until the programme finished. I teach and do think it contributes to the way some children really struggle to entertain themselves and find even seconds of 'boredom' quite difficult to cope with.

Strongvibes · 27/04/2023 06:11

I used to enjoy colouring, painting, drawing, reading, playing with dolls or Lego. I collected stamps, made stuff out of material scraps, cut out pictures from an old clothes catalogue to make a wardrobe of clothes 😂 played out with friends etc. My mother monopolised the TV so I didn’t watch a lot of it and she didn’t want me making noise or mess.

VisionsOfSplendour · 27/04/2023 06:10

I grew up not watching TV during the day and whilst there was cbebiea I think when my children were young we never had TV on as I brought them up in the same way that I was. They played with toys, played outside, helped me aroind the house, went out and about, just everyday things

I don't really know what you mean by frazzled and downtme

My children are older now and do watch netflix etc, there are no negatives to them not watching stuff as small children whereas I suspect there are to screens for pre schoolers

Augend23 · 27/04/2023 06:05

Orders76 · 26/04/2023 23:56

Well my dad had 14 siblings and they all worked on the farm. Education past very low years was for the rich, so they worked on the farm and played in the fields. Learned music, sewing knitting and tapestry.
Although there's no way now to avoid screens I insisted on keeping them minimal and including outdoor play, Freeplay indoors and music to fill the day along with art/ craft

How old is your dad?

I'm pretty sure they raised the school leaving age to 14 in 1918, and it was 11 from 1893. (Though I think this is England again, not sure about Scotland/NI etc.)

ellaballoo · 27/04/2023 06:01

https://poets.org/poem/land-counterpane

This poem sprang to mind straight away , I used to love it as a child. I hope to come across my old poetry book in my loft one day ! I remember in the 70’s in the UK there was at least one children’s programme at lunchtime .Bod, Rupert and Mary ,Mungo and Midge spring to mind. I use to cry when Rupert ended.

The Land of Counterpane by Robert Louis Stevenson - Poems | poets.org

The Land of Counterpane - When I was sick and lay a-bed

https://poets.org/poem/land-counterpane

Clymene · 27/04/2023 05:55

It's bizarre that people seem to have read my first post on this thread, one challenging it and yet missed the multiple follow up posts where I confirmed that no, I did not grow up in the U.K. GrinGrin

Seeleyboo · 27/04/2023 05:26

AlwaysAuntie · 26/04/2023 21:14

I was outside most of the day, playing with friends in the street (on the path, we never went in the road as it was shark infested waters), or st the swing park around the corner. If I weren't outside I was probably in my room playing with my barbies or quietly reading a book.

I grew up with only 3 tv channels and Children's tv programs were only on a couple hours in the morning, an hour at lunch and from 3:45-5:30 (ish) after school.

Exactly this. Bring it back.

Happyhappyday · 27/04/2023 05:14

DD is 4.5, we didn’t do any screen time until 3 and then only did Daniel Tiger on long road trips (so maybe once a month?), now she probably gets 1-2 hours every other weekend and most of that is on long car trips. We do pod casts, she plays kinetic sand a lot, we read to her a lot and did A LOT before we did screens (like maybe 1-1.5 hours a day). I don’t actually find it super hard to get things done, this evening for example, she drew outside with chalk for half an hour while I cooked dinner, we ate together and then she put all her stuffed animals to bed with pretend baths while I cleaned up for 30 mins after. She often wants to help so I’ll give her parsley to strip or something (ie, takes a long time and isn’t that important for my cooking).

she does sleep a lot - friend pointed out their DC slept 3 hours less a day and over the course of the week, that’s a lot of extra parenting! If she was up at 5:30 every day we might have a lot more screens!

She also had a couple minor meltdowns etc so it’s not like she’s blissful all the time. But definitely possible to skip screens.