Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH wanting to move abroad

139 replies

purplejeanie · 26/04/2023 19:15

DH is from another country. He left that country when he was 18, moved to the states for a decade and then moved to another country where we met and he then moved to England to be with me. He's been in uk more than a decade and we have 4 children, the oldest has just started secondary school. He has a very black and white personality and is either v happy or v down. Throughout his time in the uk he intermittently has said he wants to move. As a result we've moved location 3x (including to his home country for a year-the other places were in the uk), but he's never been consistently happy anywhere. We've been in our present place since the summer and children are happy in schools and settled. He now wants to move again (to a random sunny country where we have no roots and don't speak the language). He is trying to convince the children we'd be happier there. He's managing to persuade them but they're obviously conflicted and tell me how worried they are. Moving would mean I'd lose my job and be in a country far from my home, it would be a huge and another difficult adjustment for the children. He says he can't deal with being here-he hates the rat race and the weather. Aibu to just say no? I don't know how to find a compromise in this situation. I hate that the kids are being pulled in different directions.

OP posts:
Plantgeumstoday · 26/04/2023 22:20

Put your foot down and say a huge no to this!

My dad was a bit like this as I was growing up.He’d move us all from one end of the country to another at the drop of an hat and it was very destabilising as a child.

Always felt an outsider at school.
Once I’d made friends we’d be off again and being the “new girl “once more.

As a result, left school having no real friends.

If your dh wants to move, let him go alone. This will be never ending and he won’t change as to him the grass is always greener somewhere else.

Stand up for you and the kids.
Far better to break up with him and have some stability if that’s what it takes.

AliceMcK · 26/04/2023 22:17

I’m like your DH, I’d happily up-sticks and move countries on a whim. It’s not just about me though, now I have children I have to think about them. We’ve done 2 big moves in the last 4 years, at the time they were the right decisions and DCs young enough to adjust, but I’ve no intentions on doing any more as dcs entering high school age. I will be trying to save for big overseas adventures instead.

TheaBrandt · 26/04/2023 22:11

Studies show that moving more than 3 times in your childhood is damaging. So no way.

WhereYouLeftIt · 26/04/2023 22:10

And another thing - following his whim will make you unemployed, meaning you would be completely dependant on him financially. This is not a man I would trust to have such a hold over me.

crew2022 · 26/04/2023 22:10

And in a few more years ? Will you have to move again?
Doesn't sound as if it's the location to me but your DH

determinedtomakethiswork · 26/04/2023 22:08

If it's a much poor country will the children have to go into private education? Can you tell us which country it is? Would they even let you all in?

He is putting himself first again and again. If that ends the marriage then so be it but I don't think you and the children should go and live somewhere just because he wants to go there. He will change his mind before they're grown up anyway

WhereYouLeftIt · 26/04/2023 22:08

"He now says that them having a better quality of life (ie in sunshine on the beach) is more important than education. I don't agree that their quality of life would be better necessarily -they wouldn't speak the language and would find friendships hard-no extended family-limited opportunities."
I would rip the face off him for this shit. Stand up shouty rows. He is willing - eager, even - to damage their adult opportunities just because he's a petulant man-child.

"I agree that he's only thinking of himself and totally wrong of him to try and persuade the children. I will put my foot down but afraid of what will happen as a result. He will go on and on and on and it's really difficult to deal with, particularly if he involves the children in the discussions."
Don't be afraid of putting your foot down - be afraid of NOT putting your foot down. If he involves the children in discussions - you said "he will probably continue going on about it and so they will question what I say" then you have no choice but to go on and on yourself and so that they also question what HE says. Do not allow his manipulation to go unopposed.

I would honestly be telling him that there is no way I am moving yet again, but if he's dead set on it - fine. Go on your own. Go. Now.

determinedtomakethiswork · 26/04/2023 22:04

He is still going to be stuck with himself, no matter where he goes. He has an obligation to his children now and can't just flit around whenever he wants.

Aweebitpainful · 26/04/2023 22:01

Get a camper and let him bugger off whenever he needs to without uprooting you all.

StarDolphins · 26/04/2023 21:55

Thing is, this is his personality. Wherever he moves to, he’ll never be happy. Some people are just like that.

You need to keep grounded for your children. I would just say no. You’re settled & don’t want to move. You’ve already moved with him several times & you’re babk at square 1.

neilyoungismyhero · 26/04/2023 21:51

Baby lab I was fostering, tiny little chap. Asleep in his crate suddenly heard screaming and looked around to find somehow he'd got his tongue caught in the cage door hinge. Dear God the screams, his and mine. My German Shepherds were milling around traumatised which added to the pandemonium. I managed to open the door pup flew backwards losing a piece of his tongue. We rushed him to the French vet who patched him up and he was eventually fine. He went to a German family who adored him. My guilt had never disappeared. It was horrendous.

Minimalme · 26/04/2023 21:51

We have had to move our kids a few times because of money (lack of).

It is so difficult for kids to experience the instability of moving.

We are now settled and happy in our forever home but moving has been a scar on their childhood.

Stay put.

Aquamarine1029 · 26/04/2023 21:45

Your husband will never be happy, no matter where he lives, because he's trying to run from himself. He's unhappy with himself. Don't put your kids through this shit for a selfish, self-absorbed man.

mischlerischler · 26/04/2023 21:40

Where you go, there you are.

I also left home at 18 and lived in different countries, so I can understand the excitement it comes with. But once me and DH decided to start a family, I knew we won't be able to move with as much ease. He needs to think about your children and what's best for them. I don't think it's guaranteed he would be so much happier at this magical new place.

Once the excitement wear soff, he will ask you to move again.

It sounds like he needs therapy rather than another move - I agree with PP, it sounds like he is looking for a feeling of belonging.

purplejeanie · 26/04/2023 21:37

DivorcingEU · 26/04/2023 21:33

YADNBU.

Do not move.

I do not understand how holidays abroad are too expensive, when moving seems to be financially possible (other than you needing to find work). It's really expensive to move, while there are always bargain holidays out there to be had.

The manipulation of the kids is unacceptable. It's very destabilising for them - he's undermining them building their life here and growing roots. I think you need to speak to him about how you're not moving and there's no more discussion to be had (and mean it). And then speak separately to the kids and tell them that Dad is getting itchy feet but not to worry, you're staying out and will try to have holidays away if it's possible. It's not that you're going against what he's saying by doing that, it's that you're actively giving them stability. But if you do that, you must hold firm. You cannot cave.

Whatever you do, do not give up working now that you're back in the workplace. You need to keep yourself as financially strong as possible in this situation.

Thanks for your message. I must stand firm and will talk to the children but he will probably continue going on about it and so they will question what I say. Moving abroad may be cheaper because it's a one off cost, whereas regularly going on holiday is obviously expensive (there are 6 of us). But if we moved abroad, I'd lose my income and that would be difficult.

OP posts:
OliveToboogie · 26/04/2023 21:36

He seems not to be Happy anywhere. You can't keep uprooting kids lives on the off chance your husband might be happy. I don't think a change of scenery is what he needs but therapy.

purplejeanie · 26/04/2023 21:33

I agree re Brexit although he's not European but when we were not living in a city in the uk definitely felt like an outsider.
Money is an object (to the person who said that it's not) but he wants to live a simpler life in new foreign country where things would be cheaper. But he hasn't thought any of it through. And I can't do it! Will keep trying to encourage him to seek therapy and to go out more etc etc but he's v stubborn.

OP posts:
DivorcingEU · 26/04/2023 21:33

YADNBU.

Do not move.

I do not understand how holidays abroad are too expensive, when moving seems to be financially possible (other than you needing to find work). It's really expensive to move, while there are always bargain holidays out there to be had.

The manipulation of the kids is unacceptable. It's very destabilising for them - he's undermining them building their life here and growing roots. I think you need to speak to him about how you're not moving and there's no more discussion to be had (and mean it). And then speak separately to the kids and tell them that Dad is getting itchy feet but not to worry, you're staying out and will try to have holidays away if it's possible. It's not that you're going against what he's saying by doing that, it's that you're actively giving them stability. But if you do that, you must hold firm. You cannot cave.

Whatever you do, do not give up working now that you're back in the workplace. You need to keep yourself as financially strong as possible in this situation.

readbooksdrinktea · 26/04/2023 21:30

YANBU but I get him too. UK is hard for non-Brits after 2016. Many of us left.

Emigratingimmigrant · 26/04/2023 21:27

@NellyBarney Brexit, pandemic and current overall situation is making many plan their moves, yes. It's always quite a combination of thimgs. Adrenaline/excitment/belonging/eanting to move for better when things go bad

NellyBarney · 26/04/2023 21:24

It's so tough staying in a foreign country once the initial excitement has worn off. It's especially hard for a non-brit to feel comfortable in this country, especially after Brexit. I have lived here now for more than half of my life, paying dutyfully my taxes, and the first thing every!one asks when they meet me is: where are you from? (meaning: obviously not from here, and implying (if not intentionally) that I don't belong here). I am itching to leave somewhere overall 'warmer', but the dc and dh are settled here and have roots. I think your dh has a moral duty to stay and to put on a smile for his family's sake, but it's totally understandable that he is depressed and restless, and I don't think therapy can fix the fact that the UK, especially now, is just not a good place, especially for immigrants.

Crikeyalmighty · 26/04/2023 21:22

I also think this being able to WFH fully remotely even overseas, whilst an absolute boon in many ways has made guys like this worse- any inkling of 'not liking somewhere'or bored or want a new adrenaline rush and they have these whims- as it doesn't affect their ability to earn- many men are pretty selfish too and the children changing schools or losing friendships doesn't seem to bother some of them one bit - it's all about their wants

Crikeyalmighty · 26/04/2023 21:11

@SallyWD I'm glad it's not just me, my FIL 'pencils' us in , in his address book!!

GinnyBee · 26/04/2023 21:00

He doesn't have ADHD does he? Sounds like he's seeking excitement and stimulation, and has a general restlessness about him, rather than just being spoilt or just depressed. I get like this, and my time tolerance for staying in one place seems to be between 5-7 years. That's when the new place is feeling familiar enough and gets boring.

Emigratingimmigrant · 26/04/2023 20:56

He feels that he has no roots and doesn't understand people that do.

It's belonging. Like I don't belong to my native country anymore as I've been away for too long, nor do I belong to wherever I move. He is probably looking for that. Bad news. Not going to happen most likely.