Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH wanting to move abroad

139 replies

purplejeanie · 26/04/2023 19:15

DH is from another country. He left that country when he was 18, moved to the states for a decade and then moved to another country where we met and he then moved to England to be with me. He's been in uk more than a decade and we have 4 children, the oldest has just started secondary school. He has a very black and white personality and is either v happy or v down. Throughout his time in the uk he intermittently has said he wants to move. As a result we've moved location 3x (including to his home country for a year-the other places were in the uk), but he's never been consistently happy anywhere. We've been in our present place since the summer and children are happy in schools and settled. He now wants to move again (to a random sunny country where we have no roots and don't speak the language). He is trying to convince the children we'd be happier there. He's managing to persuade them but they're obviously conflicted and tell me how worried they are. Moving would mean I'd lose my job and be in a country far from my home, it would be a huge and another difficult adjustment for the children. He says he can't deal with being here-he hates the rat race and the weather. Aibu to just say no? I don't know how to find a compromise in this situation. I hate that the kids are being pulled in different directions.

OP posts:
isthismylifenow · 03/05/2023 14:39

I was married to a serial mover OP. He just could not settle anywhere and kept expecting the dc to uproot as well. I know that moving my ds whilst really young did him no favours .. for various reasons. I am not saying that all children don't cope well, but I knew my ds wouldn't and he didn't and I don't think I can ever forgive myself for not standing up for him.

Once we moved to where were are now, he wanted to move on elsewhere. And I was not having it. He took a job that entailed him travelling a lot, which kept him at bay for a bit.

We divorced for all sorts of reasons, but this was one of them. The grass is always greener on the other side in his mind.... until you get to that grass. Then other grass is better etc etc.

With your update today, I would seriously think about your future with him. Yours and your dc. He will never be happy anywhere. And this is going to affect your marriage, your family and your dc.

(ps my ex moved to another country again the same month we got divorced, and a few years later decided to come back here again. He since remarried and now plans are in place to them to move again. It is never going to end).

purplejeanie · 03/05/2023 14:36

I think he thinks the marriage is already over because I'm refusing to leave and he can't be here. And no, as far as I know he hasn't looked into any practicalities-ie legal right to work there, schools etc

OP posts:
purplejeanie · 03/05/2023 14:35

They are 12, 10, 8. Yes I'll go to a solicitor. No I don't think he has appetite to go through court but who knows. Thanks for advice re persuading them-that's really useful.

OP posts:
katmarie · 03/05/2023 14:31

If your oldest has just started secondary school, then your kids are around 13 and younger? I think you should seriously consider seeing a solicitor if he's really determined to go. I can't imagine a judge agreeing that they can be permanently moved out of the country, out of their schools, and most importantly, away from their mother, but you should really arm yourself with a good solicitor and expert advice. The kids have a right to a relationship with you as well as with him, and if you're refusing to go, and refusing your permission to let them go, then he would have to try and force the issue through legal proceedings. Do you think he has the appetite to take you to court over this? And if so, it will likely be the end of your marriage as well, does he understand that?

GOW56 · 03/05/2023 14:23

How old are your children?
You need to talk to them about the reality of living in a country where they can't speak the language, how they will be away from all their friends and activities, TV shows they like and everything they enjoy. Are they members of any clubs etc ask them to imagine never going to them again. Tell them living in a foreign place is not the same as being on holiday. They would have to go to school and would find it hard to make friends when they can't speak the language.
Show them some words in Greek, and play them some films of people speaking Greek. look up information about the Greek education system and show them. Ask them how they will cope if they are ill and cant explain to the doctor what is wrong.
You shouldn't scare them buy they need to understand the reality opposed to the fantasy from their father.
On a practical level he won't be able to take them out of the country without your consent if you are worried he may try that get some legal advice asap.
But also would be even get a work permit, or residence permit to live in Greece?
He sounds as though he is also living in a fantasy world and needs a reality check.

purplejeanie · 03/05/2023 14:21

I love him but finding this madness harder and harder to bear. I think life would be more straightforward and more stable without him but financially would be very tough-and he does have a strong bond with the children.

OP posts:
Codlingmoths · 03/05/2023 14:13

Hide their passports for sure. How do you feel about him? How much does he do for the dc? If you asked him to move out what would happen? One possibility is he finds hosting his children solo 3 days a week far too hard, so realises he isn’t moving them overseas on his own.

GOW56 · 03/05/2023 14:09

Say no. He won't he happy anywhere. He will take his problems with him. Obviously he is someone who isn't satisfied with life but instead of trying to change things to make it work he blames the location.

You have to think about stability for your children. The sort of move he proposes even if it is possible financially sounds disastrous, what about the children's schools? They would need to learn another language. What about health care? How would you support yourselves?
Ok to move like that if you are single and have no responsibility but it sounds as though he has never grown up

mischlerischler · 03/05/2023 14:04

Get a legal help advice asap.

He doesn't sound well.

StillWantingADog · 03/05/2023 13:16

ps tell the children do they really want to go to a foreign country with no friends, where they can’t speak the language. emphasise all the extra curricular they won’t be able to do.

StillWantingADog · 03/05/2023 13:15

oh dear. I honestly think he’s mentally unwell. He might well just be bluffing though. Hide their passports now and ask the passport office if they can put a stop to him applying for replacements (not sure this is possible).

you probably need a solicitor unfortunately but I would have thought almost any court would see right through his plan and award you custody if it came to it.

purplejeanie · 03/05/2023 12:32

DH now saying he will definitely go, with or without me-and in interim will persuade children to go with him. He will persuade them that I want a boring life, monotonous life and he wants an amazing family life on the beach abroad. I think that he will be able to persuade them of this-because obviously it sounds like paradise to young children. Can anyone assure me that the courts will just dismiss any application he makes to take them abroad-will a court care what the children say? And secondly, has anyone got wise words of what I can say to the children? I don't want to damage them further by talking against him, but at the same time probably shouldn't keep quiet. Thank you

OP posts:
yogacushions · 28/04/2023 11:40

Can you suggest to him that he starts working away - Middle East maybe- so he gets that fulfilment and you still get the £££

notquitesoyoung · 27/04/2023 14:19

Nothing is going to change with this move. He will get bored again and you'll be in the same situation but completely at his mercy with regards to the DC and returning to the UK if you decide that's what you want. Read any expat Facebook group and you'll quickly find someone stuck in a relationship or country they don't want to be in because leaving with the children to return home would be seen as kidnapping. Stay where you are, it doesn't sound like a particularly healthy relationship and you are in the best place if you decide it's no longer the relationship for you & the DC.

TheaBrandt · 27/04/2023 13:43

Ha my Dh is learning the language and instrument! More than happy with that - rather that than uprooting the entire family trashing all our careers / schooling / social lines in the process…

Intergalacticcatharsis · 27/04/2023 13:31

Sounds like a classic case of midlife crisis to me. It is one thing when you are rich and have a great international job offer with international schools etc or can let the DC board here, it is another when it is one middle aged man’s dream because he feels claustrophobic. Just promise you will move once the youngest is finished. Keep his fantasy going. In the mean time, it is his job to make small changes to his life like new hobbies to keep himself challenged. This is why middle aged men start climbing mountains and run marathons.. the good ones that is. Or learn a new language or instrument.

Alaimo · 27/04/2023 13:23

Sorry if it's already been said, but home schooling is illegal in Greece.

Aside from that, moving somewhere when the previous moves haven't worked out is a stupid idea, don't do it.

Ramunea · 27/04/2023 13:04

Nope.

piedbeauty · 27/04/2023 12:45

Just say no. You've moved before and it hasn't helped - why does he think this will be different?

He's being really selfish. Put your dc and their happiness, stability and education first.

He can move by himself if he wants.

TheaBrandt · 27/04/2023 12:31

I felt stressed reading your post. How incredibly selfish he is. Stand firm - hard no. Moving can be incredibly disruptive to older children and teens - why do you think the MoD pay for boarding school for their staff who move around?

If you absolutely have to relocate due to work that’s one thing but this flitting about is not that. That’s without taking into account the effect on you and your career. Shocking.

Crikeyalmighty · 27/04/2023 11:53

Sadly OP I think you are going to have to put your foot down and say that it's simply not happening. It's not practical with kids. If he fancies doing this when the children have left home then fair enough depending how you feel ( although I can tell you that we ended up £17k lighter due to the moves)

Your career matters too no matter how big or small it is- not just his lifestyle fancies.

Would be cheaper to let him go and have a month away twice a year staying somewhere simple- Greece is good for this!

StillWantingADog · 27/04/2023 11:13

The issue is that your DH has depression and needs to get some kind of therapy.

The most ridiculous part of the plan is that you should give up your career and home school the kids! not dissing your ability to homeschool but crikey that is batshit and totally would affect their future career prospects. Hes totally divorced from reality, I wouldn't engage any further on the topic. Unfortunately unless he gets therapy this doesn't bode well for your marriage but you need to put your kids first here,

purplejeanie · 27/04/2023 09:12

Yeah I don't think he's abusive but is childish and immature. And he's lost --so trying to find a sense of purpose and not thinking enough or at all about impact on us -and when he does think about us, he pictures some idyllic life divorced from reality.

OP posts:
Nordicrain · 27/04/2023 08:57

So it's bascially his latest whim? Trying to satisfy whatever it is making him unhappy by moving somewhere where life actually is likely to be pretty difficult (unsettled kids, one income, no network or support). sounds like a recipe for disaster, and I am someone pretty openminded about relocating generally.

MumInBrussels · 27/04/2023 08:55

Don't move. You don't want to, the kids don't want to, and he isn't going to be happy when you get there anyway. This isn't going to be his last move, where he finds nirvana and settles down.

I moved around a fair amount as a kid and in my twenties. But you can't do that with kids, so I've (somewhat reluctantly and with some difficulty) accepted that this is where we're staying for a while, at least until our kids are grown up. Your husband needs to think about someone other than himself for once. And even if he can't do that, all the moving hasn't made him happy yet - why does he think this time would be better?

He can leave if he's so miserable - and you can kick him out if he's unbearable to live with. You have far more options here than if you moved to the middle of nowhere where you don't speak the language and don't know anyone and don't have a job, and don't understand how the system works. Don't go. Even if he does.