Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to reconnect with estranged friend?

116 replies

ThePensivePig · 26/04/2023 18:23

Long story, sorry....

For 10+ years, I was very good friends with a woman who lived in another part of the UK. We met online and we just clicked. We enjoyed years of enjoyable friendship, meeting up 2-3 times a year in person and chatting every day on the phone.

I supported my friend through an unpleasant divorce and the death of both parents and she helped me when I had any ups and downs. Over time, she became close to my husband and children and I considered her to be the sister I'd never had.

Things became difficult when I took a more senior job. It was a massive stretch and I struggled to manage a demanding role alongside a young family. My mental health began to suffer and I definitely leaned on my friend. She was initially supportive, until one day, out of the blue, she told me she needed to take a step back. This 'step back' involved us going no contact for a while. She didn't explain why, just said she needed a complete break.

I really struggled with the no contact thing. To go from daily contact to nothing at all felt awful and I was bereft. In my unwell state, I panicked and assumed I must have done something terrible to upset her. I ignored the no contact request and asked (begged, in fact) to be given a second chance, asked why I was being pushed out and so on. My friend responded once to say I'd done nothing wrong and that it was to do with her issues (which she didn't want to discuss at that time). Then silence.

Silence that lasted a decade.

In the meantime, I had a breakdown, lost my job and struggled to cope. I became severely mentally ill, was sectioned twice as my life was at serious risk. It took me YEARS to recover and although I'll never be the way I was before my breakdown, things are better now.

My former friend has recently been in touch by email. She says she wants to re-establish contact with a view to potentially building our relationship again.

AIBU to say 'no thank you' and continue with my life as it is? I'll always love my friend and understandably I'm curious as to why she's got in touch now. Having said that, I've worked hard to regain my sanity and don't want to revisit that awful time in my life. Could I ever get past the fact she ditched me at my most vulnerable?

Any thoughts please?

OP posts:
Mixupmashup · 26/04/2023 23:10

A very close friend of mine ghosted me two years ago. No-one would ever know but that friendship meant so much to me that I still cry about losing it sometimes when I am alone. I hope I don't always miss her.

Have you seen the film the Reader? I saw it recently and could completely understand the inability to be close again to someone who has hurt you so much.

In the unlikely event that my ex friend got back in touch I know I could never trust her again so wouldn't respond.

It hurts though. I definitely leaned too heavily on my friend and went through some tough times that I opened up to my friend about. I will always wonder if I became someone she dreaded to be around and so she ghosted me.

boringingoring · 26/04/2023 23:07

I don't know enough to tell you what I think you should do, OP, but I went through something very similar - an incredibly close friend who suddenly ditched me and didn't want to explain why - and after about five years she emailed and asked to get back in touch and I said that I thought it was too late; that she'd hurt me too badly. But about a year later she followed me on Twitter and I eventually followed her back and gradually started to remember how much fun she was. So we got cautiously back in touch and now we have a more distant, but still loving, relationship, and she still makes me laugh. So my view is that you have the right to take as long as you like to feel ready to talk to her again, but if the time comes when you do, and you feel she still wants to, you should. You can avoid her hurting you again by avoiding the intensity of your previous connection, but that doesn't mean you can't find a way to revisit the good parts. Good luck!

Codlingmoths · 26/04/2023 22:53

‘thank you, but I don’t want to get back in touch. I don’t owe you an explanation but I will. The past 10 years have been very tough ones for me, and I no longer have the resilience I once had. I miss what we once had, and have for ten years, but I owe it to my mental health to not let someone who has disappeared on me with no explanation before back into my life. I hope you’re happy and doing well these days.’

OlivePinkSky · 26/04/2023 22:51

I think we are often conditioned into thinking that to 'forgive and forget ' is the best path to follow, but by doing this we are only allowing our own pain to be invalidated and minimised. She won't have a plausible reason for turning her back on you, she was just a shitty friend. Good on you for getting through such a difficult time OP. It can't have been easy, especially with so little support from people you thought you could trust.

InconvenientPeg · 26/04/2023 22:44

A very good friend did this to me, then got in contact after eight years. I dithered for ages about whether to respond but eventually, I decided that I'd already mourned the friendship. i would never trust her as freely as I had previously, so would always be waiting for signs that she was off again. And I just didn't need that level of drama.

So I haven't responded and I've made peace with that.

I guess just ponder and decide what YOU want, I considered whether to reply for two years and finally decided that fore, we were done.

EllieM27 · 26/04/2023 22:37

She showed you who she is; believe her.

She doesn’t deserve another chance and the likelihood of her repeating her crappy behaviour is high. You can ignore her, or send a brief message such as “You treated me appallingly and I have no desire to rekindle any sort of acquaintance with you. Please do not contact me again.” And then block her after you’ve sent it.

cherry2727 · 26/04/2023 22:36

@Stravaig thank you for clarifying

Stravaig · 26/04/2023 22:35

cherry2727 · 26/04/2023 22:33

A few posters have mentioned that the gap was 10 years but I can't see anywhere where this has been mentioned by the op. Op can you clarify whether the gap was actually 10 years ?

OP says: "Silence that lasted a decade."

Quitelikeit · 26/04/2023 22:35

what happened to you was hellish but I cannot imagine what you were doing and saying in the run up to it all?

You may have been a huge well not burden but similar to a burden. Friends are great but they are not mental health professionals- maybe she could foresee you were going slightly mentally unwell and didn’t know how to deal with you or just couldn’t handle the stress of it all.

cherry2727 · 26/04/2023 22:33

A few posters have mentioned that the gap was 10 years but I can't see anywhere where this has been mentioned by the op. Op can you clarify whether the gap was actually 10 years ?

IncompleteSenten · 26/04/2023 22:30

No fucking way does she deserve another chance

Hopelesscynic · 26/04/2023 22:28

Nah don't even respond to her email. She didn't give a toss about you for 10 bloody years! Now something's possessed her that she wants to contact you. You've already moved on and you don't need her in your life.
I had something similar with a so called friend. This was after we'd just returned from holiday. There were some things I know irritated her about me during the holiday (fair enough as I felt irritated with her too) but she cut me off very abruptly, without any explanation. When I asked what's happened she said she's taking a break. Then nothing for about 2 months, suddenly she calls and texts saying she's done with her break and asking to resume the friendship. No apology, no nothing. Long story short, we didn't. And better that way, because I understood then, when she gets peeved she just ditches people at a drop of a hat. She had form for it too, there were others she'd bad-mouthed to me, who she'd cut off similarly (before our fall out).

Ingrowncrotchhair · 26/04/2023 22:23

CheerIeader · 26/04/2023 20:54

I had a similar friend, we didn't meet up in real life because of the distance, but she was my best friend and I hers - spoke daily, emailed and texted loads. We fell out after I kept something private from her for a while (I did tell her, and the fallout was because I hadn't told her immediately). She was really angry at me and blocked me for a couple of years. She messaged out of the blue, said she really missed me. I replied, we picked up, and are each others ' soulmate again.
She acknowledged she over reacted, I acknowledged the hurt I caused her by not telling her something as soon as I could have, and all is fine.
I don't feel any anger at her response, though I understand you didn't do anything to warrant your estrangement, though for myself I don't think I was wrong in my situation. I am really happy we are back in touch. It's worked for me.

That’s not like OP’s situation.

and I would be very unimpressed if a friend behaved towards me like yours did over not sharing something ASAP, as if we were 14 yo

cherry2727 · 26/04/2023 22:22

I am very sorry for what you went through op but super pleased you are in a much better place .

I am going to give a slightly different perspective on this . I've had a very long term friendship with a similar set up to your previous . We both supported each other through various challenges of life , mutually . Sometime last year, my friend was going through an Incredible difficult time in her marriage , career and relationship with her siblings . I really tried to support her but it got incredibly difficult and taxing of my emotions . Her dh recommended some form of intervention via therapy which she had one session and decided it wasn't for her so continued to rely on me heavily. I found it harder and harder to support as I too had a young family and am even more demanding job than she did - I was working 60 hours a week whilst trying to juggle being mom ,wife , sister and friend . At one point it all got a bit too much for me . I was on the phone with her for hours every single day, she constantly messaged me throughout the day and I was caught on my phone at work on several occasions. I was overwhelmed as she was very down and obviously quite negative and having unhappy .

I nicely told her that I needed to take a step back but I lied about why as I didn't want to hurt her feelings . I said I too was going through a difficult time . She was quite pissed off to say the least and stopped messaging me.
It took a lot to win her back but she was forgiving and we eventually did rekindle our friendship.

My point is that - sometimes it's incredibly difficult for the other person . It's not that I didn't care - it was actually taking a toll on my life , my mood and my soul. She needed professional help and I couldn't have helped her .

Op you sounded like you too were also in a very bad place and that's a very difficult problem for your friend to have been able to help you navigate through . I'm sure she didn't give up on you immediately but eventually it becomes hard if the unhappy person isn't seeking professional help.

I'd talk to her and find out why she had to take a step back - she probably has very understanding reasons for doing so.

Ingrowncrotchhair · 26/04/2023 22:17

DangerNoodles · 26/04/2023 19:21

It can be mentally draining holding up someone with mental health problems and that's when you are well yourself. I have been there myself supporting someone and it did put a strain on my own mental health and my family life, at times I did come close to drawing a line. You said yourself you leaned on her a lot so maybe you needed more from her than she was capable of giving. Give her a chance and find out what problems she was having before cutting contact forever. You never know her problems could have been as bad as yours but she didn't get the chance to say as she was supporting you.

And what was stopping her from actually speaking to her friend, in an adult, mature manner? Once in 10 years?

Ingrowncrotchhair · 26/04/2023 22:16

OlivePinkSky · 26/04/2023 19:02

@Ingrowncrotchhair that's so awful - I hope you're doing better now.

Reminds me of the time when I was going through an awful depressive episode and my best friend told me she couldn't cope with my crying and wasn't prepared to ' mother me ' . I never asked for mothering - I just needed some empathy and support

@OlivePinkSky thanks, I’m doing much better. And found some better friends! I hope you too are doing better

Peterpiperpickedapeckof · 26/04/2023 22:08

I think you should wish her well and say you think it’s best if things stay as they are. But you hope that all is good in her life etc etc.

Your friendship sounded really too intense and that is not healthy as I expect you realise.

Nevermind31 · 26/04/2023 22:06

I’ll turn it around a bit… she left you as you were vulnerable, she explained she needed space to do with her own issues.
it might be that she needed space for her own mental health. You did nothing wrong, but she may not have been in a state to support you, and you clearly weren’t in a state to support her. It was ok for her to step back.
whether you want a friendship now - up to you.
but… it is incredibly hard to be the support of someone with mental health issues.

ShandaLear · 26/04/2023 21:51

WhereYouLeftIt · 26/04/2023 20:32

"Things became difficult when I took a more senior job. It was a massive stretch and I struggled to manage a demanding role alongside a young family. My mental health began to suffer and I definitely leaned on my friend. She was initially supportive, until one day, out of the blue, she told me she needed to take a step back. This 'step back' involved us going no contact for a while. She didn't explain why, just said she needed a complete break. "

"AIBU to say 'no thank you' and continue with my life as it is? I'll always love my friend and understandably I'm curious as to why she's got in touch now. Having said that, I've worked hard to regain my sanity and don't want to revisit that awful time in my life. Could I ever get past the fact she ditched me at my most vulnerable? "

It's absolutely fine to not want to get in touch with her again, as you say you don't want to revisit that part of your life.

You also say you're curious. My theory would be that when you say "My mental health began to suffer and I definitely leaned on my friend" that you were leaning on her VERY heavily. Heavily enough to take her down with you. She realised the effect supporting you was having on her life and her mental health, and knew it could not continue. Maybe consider that she didn't 'ditch' you, she saved herself whilst she still could.

I agree with this. Our friends, much as we love them, are not trained therapists and sometimes are not equipped to deal with the emotional difficulties being experienced by a close friend. Put simply, the demand for support exceeds their ability to provide that support and so the relationship starts to make them feel bad, claustrophobic, inadequate, anxious, and even shame, and so they withdraw. My niece had a breakdown trying to support a friend who kept threatening suicide, and eventually ended up under the care of a psychologist. So don’t be too hard on your friend if this is a possibility, but I’d avoid reopening the relationship, particularly if you know it could lead to more pain further down the line.

CantGetNoSleeeeeeep · 26/04/2023 21:41

Similar happened to me and the reason given almost the same word for word!! It would be a no from me 10 years is too long

ziggiestardust · 26/04/2023 21:38

I have ended 2 friendships in my adult life. They have both been 1 way street type decisions; hence why it's so difficult. 1 of them was intensely more sad than the other as it was a 'wider situation' type deal, and I do sometimes wonder about her and hope she's getting on well because she absolutely deserves nothing but the best. BUT. I ended the friendship, I don't have the right to just walk back in if I feel like it (I don't, but my point remains). She doesn't need me, or my input in her life.

I wonder if this is more of a catch-up for her benefit now you're on a downswing (there will be an upswing again, of course) but the timing is odd. Plus it's been 10 years; you've both moved on. I do have a couple of friendships where we can walk back into a room after years of not seeing each other and the odd 'happy birthday' text (so minimal contact because, life) and strike up like no time has passed; but those are few and far between. I can think of 3 people like that, and one of them I'm biologically related to, 1 I spent 3 years living with basically in a bedsit, and 1 we've spent years curating the friendship and telling each other the most vulnerable shit. I doubt this is a situation like that.

I personally wouldn't even reply; but if you think she's the type to persist, a quick one liner 'thank you but I'm happy to leave things as they are, all the best' is appropriate. Protect your peace, OP.

tukker · 26/04/2023 21:17

Something similar happened to me, I was happily married at the time, and our friend met this woman on a dating app. I didn't like her at first, but it was all very intense. She organised nights out, double dates, etc, and mixed our families. Looking back now, she criticised my relationship. I ended up getting a divorce. While my relationships were declining, she was building hers. I met someone else but she didn't like him and he could see through her.
She then cut me off dead 6 months later, and I didn't understand why. It was horrible.
I connected with her again on SM after she emigrated and asked her why she cut me off, but I never got an answer. I will never speak to her again.

bffGone · 26/04/2023 21:05

Don’t do it.

I had a very similar situation whereby my xbff ghosted me literally over night. She told me what it was 3 months later and then ended the friendship completely when she got the wrong end of a massive fuck off stick. If she ever contacts me again she will trigger all the awful anxiety and stress she caused back then to the point I actually wanted to end my life because I felt hated by the world and by her. No one’s ever gonna get the chance to do that to me again let alone her, so it’d be a massive fuck off N O from me.

Im still angry and hurt

Heyheyitsanotherday · 26/04/2023 21:03

No no no. She hurt you and let you down. It’s worse than a relationship break up when a friend hurts you like this. Friendship heart break hurts like hell. I’d tell her the truth, how she made you feel, and that you won’t risk being hurt again. Hope you’re ok op xxx

CheerIeader · 26/04/2023 20:54

I had a similar friend, we didn't meet up in real life because of the distance, but she was my best friend and I hers - spoke daily, emailed and texted loads. We fell out after I kept something private from her for a while (I did tell her, and the fallout was because I hadn't told her immediately). She was really angry at me and blocked me for a couple of years. She messaged out of the blue, said she really missed me. I replied, we picked up, and are each others ' soulmate again.
She acknowledged she over reacted, I acknowledged the hurt I caused her by not telling her something as soon as I could have, and all is fine.
I don't feel any anger at her response, though I understand you didn't do anything to warrant your estrangement, though for myself I don't think I was wrong in my situation. I am really happy we are back in touch. It's worked for me.