Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to reconnect with estranged friend?

116 replies

ThePensivePig · 26/04/2023 18:23

Long story, sorry....

For 10+ years, I was very good friends with a woman who lived in another part of the UK. We met online and we just clicked. We enjoyed years of enjoyable friendship, meeting up 2-3 times a year in person and chatting every day on the phone.

I supported my friend through an unpleasant divorce and the death of both parents and she helped me when I had any ups and downs. Over time, she became close to my husband and children and I considered her to be the sister I'd never had.

Things became difficult when I took a more senior job. It was a massive stretch and I struggled to manage a demanding role alongside a young family. My mental health began to suffer and I definitely leaned on my friend. She was initially supportive, until one day, out of the blue, she told me she needed to take a step back. This 'step back' involved us going no contact for a while. She didn't explain why, just said she needed a complete break.

I really struggled with the no contact thing. To go from daily contact to nothing at all felt awful and I was bereft. In my unwell state, I panicked and assumed I must have done something terrible to upset her. I ignored the no contact request and asked (begged, in fact) to be given a second chance, asked why I was being pushed out and so on. My friend responded once to say I'd done nothing wrong and that it was to do with her issues (which she didn't want to discuss at that time). Then silence.

Silence that lasted a decade.

In the meantime, I had a breakdown, lost my job and struggled to cope. I became severely mentally ill, was sectioned twice as my life was at serious risk. It took me YEARS to recover and although I'll never be the way I was before my breakdown, things are better now.

My former friend has recently been in touch by email. She says she wants to re-establish contact with a view to potentially building our relationship again.

AIBU to say 'no thank you' and continue with my life as it is? I'll always love my friend and understandably I'm curious as to why she's got in touch now. Having said that, I've worked hard to regain my sanity and don't want to revisit that awful time in my life. Could I ever get past the fact she ditched me at my most vulnerable?

Any thoughts please?

OP posts:
lemonchiffonpie · 27/04/2023 05:31

She didn't even have the decency to tell you why at the time.

Yes, she did.

After the OP, in her own words, "leaned heavily" on her for some time, the friend told her she needed to take a step back. When the OP did not respect that boundary she replied.

My friend responded once to say I'd done nothing wrong and that it was to do with her issues (which she didn't want to discuss at that time).

Do you think it would have been helpful for the friend to say things like: you're draining, I'm going under, I am not a paid therapist and don't have the skills to keep dealing with your ongoing problems, etc, or whatever her feelings were?
She asked for space, for breathing room, it was not allowed. All of this is in the OP.

All this talk of "ghosting" is ridiculous. When someone says they need to take a step back, it means you are demanding too much of them, and they are informing you of that. Perhaps, if she'd been given space, she would have been back in OP's life much sooner; perhaps not. OP does not want to reconnect, but OP was not ghosted. Sometimes we have to put on our oxygen masks and remove ourselves from someone who is taking us down with them.

emptythelitterbox · 27/04/2023 03:32

I wouldn't bother. She didn't even have the decency to tell you why at the time.

It would be extra shitty if you replied and she just ghosted you again.

Nicecow · 27/04/2023 03:31

Peterpiperpickedapeckof · 26/04/2023 22:08

I think you should wish her well and say you think it’s best if things stay as they are. But you hope that all is good in her life etc etc.

Your friendship sounded really too intense and that is not healthy as I expect you realise.

I really like this. I think send something positive like this.

Nicecow · 27/04/2023 03:28

I think for both of you it would be best not to reconnect. They probably had to end the friendship for their own mental health. Speaking from experience supporting someone who was having some problems, it had become so intense and stressful I had to leave my job, and we are now NC (their choice) so I do sympathise with your friend. They probably feel guilty about it, even though it was the right thing for them to do for their own sake. Leave this in the past.

Bellagio40 · 27/04/2023 03:23

No chance

HamBone · 27/04/2023 03:17

*probably felt that cutting you off was the only way she should cope. Supporting someone suffering who’s struggling with their MH is very draining and while what she did was hurtful, she may have been buckling under the strain.

You don’t sound as if you want to reconnect with her, so don’t. I would send a quick message saying that you wish her well, but you don’t want to get back in touch.

HamBone · 27/04/2023 03:12

Like others, I think that she wasn’t able to provide the intense support you needed when you were struggling and p

Angelina1972 · 27/04/2023 03:11

@bffGone

Don’t do it.

I had a very similar situation whereby my xbff ghosted me literally over night. She told me what it was 3 months later and then ended the friendship completely when she got the wrong end of a massive fuck off stick. If she ever contacts me again she will trigger all the awful anxiety and stress she caused back then to the point I actually wanted to end my life because I felt hated by the world and by her. No one’s ever gonna get the chance to do that to me again let alone her, so it’d be a massive fuck off N O from me.

Im still angry and hurt

Oh my goodness I had exactly the same thing happen to me and felt like an awful person and quite suicidal for months. I had to be so strong to continue working and forging ahead with life! So sorry you felt similar.

if my ex friend ever contacted me again I’d be dumbfounded. I’d never be able to trust her again and it would trigger awful anxiety and sadness. If I didn’t have a really responsible job I’d have gone round to her house when her husband was at work and chinned her so hard she’d have been on the floor.

Hope you are much better now in terms of your mental health.

changeme4this · 27/04/2023 03:07

Not voting, who is to know what was going on in her life at the time too. Maybe it was just too much for her to juggle..?

If she meant a lot to me, I would meet up over lunch somewhere neutral. It's easy to call it a day and leave or kick on together longer.

Deathmetal · 27/04/2023 02:42

I’m in 2 minds about this as you were clearly going through a severe time.

one one hand, your mental health could unfortunately have impacted her mental health and she needed to protect herself. 2013 wasn’t as mental health positive as 2023 and she might have felt overwhelmed and unsure what to do as you were going through a complete crisis that required a MH professional

on the other hand, she effectively abandoned you and a decade is a long time

personally I don’t like reconnecting with people from awkward times in my life. I hate having to fill in the gap and be judged on past me.

MillieOns · 27/04/2023 02:31

They say “A friend in need is a friend indeed”. That’s certainly true in the friendships I’ve had throughout my life. When they no longer have a need for you - or you need a friendly shoulder to cry on - they dump you.

It sounds like your friend is in need of a friend OP. In your shoes I wouldn’t bother responding 💐

lemonchiffonpie · 27/04/2023 01:58

Gymnopedie · 27/04/2023 01:29

Whatever the ins and outs, the friend chose to cut off the relationship. Therefore it isn't her choice whether or not to revive it. OP decides that. And if that decision is to leave the friend in the past that's fine.

Well, yes, that's obvious. The estranged friend has reached out, the ball is now in the OP's court.

She says in her title that she doesn't want to reconnect. That is perfectly valid. What is not valid is this insistance all through the thread that the estranged friend 'ghosted' the OP. She did not.

Perhaps if they got back in touch however briefly, the OP would understand why it was necessary for the friend to withdraw at such length - what was going on in her life at the time and in the years following.

One person's mental health struggles does not negate another's. The friend, for whatever reasons, felt unable to withstand the pressure of OP's need. She is offering to reconnect, OP doesn't want to. Fair enough.

JudgeRudy · 27/04/2023 01:30

It's a difficult one but I'd say it's probably best to decline (in a pleasant way)
Supporting somene with their mental health is draining and it sounds like it was quite intense. Id imagine the daily calls were just too much and she probably had fragile mental health too. She stepped away and you did not respect her boundaries. I had a friend like this. I had to cut her out as she didnt listen and she was making me unhappy. You must have been very unwell because you went on to have a nervous breakdown. Youre not in that situation now but it sounds as if youre not really 100% well.
It sounds as if you feel she has wronged you in some way, yet for 10 years you've made no attempt to contact her again and let her know your back. I could be friends with someone who had episodes of poor mental health but I'd struggle to stay friends with someone who was too needy.
What would you want from the friendship and are you in a position to 'give' at all?
Maybe you could be more like penpals chatting on line. Do you have to make a proactive decision to be best friends again? Why can't you just message her back with a light hearted response and just let things evolve.

Gymnopedie · 27/04/2023 01:29

Whatever the ins and outs, the friend chose to cut off the relationship. Therefore it isn't her choice whether or not to revive it. OP decides that. And if that decision is to leave the friend in the past that's fine.

lemonchiffonpie · 27/04/2023 01:02

I don't think she ditched you. She abdicated her role of your unpaid daily therapist. She didn't ghost you, either. She told you she needed to step back for a time, after you had admittedly "definitely leaned on her". After being told she needed a complete break from you and your problems and your quite understandable desire for support, you pursued her. She's made it clear that she had issues arising out of being your one woman support team.

It's hardly an unclear situation. Her physical, mental, and emotional health are also important, and she felt the need to look after herself.

I would send her a reply that acknowledged you asked too much from her in that time, and if you don't want to see her again, tell her so, but taking this whole scenario from the point of view of the victim who was victimised is a bit much.

Ilovetea42 · 27/04/2023 00:33

To be honest I'm a firm believer in protecting your own emotional bandwidth. If she wasn't in a place where she could support you when you were struggling then she has every right to step back to protect herself and avoid you both becoming utterly burnt out. It absolutely sucks but I think she had the right to make that decision for herself and you don't really know the circumstances around that decision.

I equally think it's now your turn to decide whether getting back in touch will be something you have the emotional bandwidth for. Would meeting up and chatting it through answer any unresolved questions for you or would that be too upsetting if you don't like the answers or if she refused to give you more information? I think you'd need to think about what you would want and expect from her and what that would add to your life. You also have the option of not trying to make it what it was before and instead just let things happen organically and see what new relationship forms. Or you decide its not for you at least for now and you politely decline. Or maybe you ask a few questions first so you know what you need to ahead of meeting. The ball is entirely in your court now and it sounds like you're in a much more empowered place in yourself to make a decision so I say trust your gut. You know yourself best.

Shoelacesundone · 27/04/2023 00:25

Yes @Dithyramb but Mumsnwt comprehension skills are poor and OP hasn't responded to refraining techniques so here we all are lost in a "cheeky bitch drive ne to suicide now demands my friendship" where women (most of whom hold a non dominant role in their own lives) compete to tell OP to tell friend to fuck off as if to escape the powerlessness they hold in their own lives by proxy.

Some threads go bad.

Dithyramb · 27/04/2023 00:01

OlivePinkSky · 26/04/2023 23:36

@Dithyramb

The op s mental health started to deteriorate whilst they were still in contact. So the friend was very aware but still chose to piss off.

Yes, but the OP says the sectioning, breakdown etc happened after they stopped contact, and only that she was struggling with a stressful job when they were.

Plus, to be perfectly honest, the friend isn’t a therapist, and had her own major stuff to deal with, and the OP admits she ignored the no contact stipulation and begged for a second chance. It sounds scarily intense, and it’s not hard to see why someone might not have been prepared/able to deal with it.

whynotwhatknot · 26/04/2023 23:51

IM foreever reading on here how some friends are very dependant on some posters and theyve always been adivsed to step back its too much

on the other hand 10 years is a long time to step back and not explain why

i guess id always wonder what happened

mainsfed · 26/04/2023 23:43

You can’t go back to the friendship you used to have.

Don’t sacrifice your dignity for curiosity. Let sleeping dogs lie.

OlivePinkSky · 26/04/2023 23:36

@Dithyramb

The op s mental health started to deteriorate whilst they were still in contact. So the friend was very aware but still chose to piss off.

SparklyBlackKitten · 26/04/2023 23:35

Wow
No op.
She didnt push you out at your most vulnerable . She chose to focus on herself and you dont know the backstory.

Now AFTER your friendship ended, your life started to fall apart. But you decided that you'll blame her for not being there for you as you hold on to resentment and being petty

Her coming back in your life could be amazing. But you are not even willing to do that because you are being petty.

You have no clue what happened to her. What if she's been through in a decade of hell and could basely uphold her own mental health.

At least give her a chance. Hear her out. You can always still pull away later if you wanted. But dont say no merely because she left you 10 years ago and you blame her for not being there for you, eventhough you were there for her in the years prior.

Let go of all the resentment and try
Or give it no more headspace. Block her and move on.

Only you know what you want in you heart. But don't make a choice based on being petty

Dithyramb · 26/04/2023 23:30

Some of these replies are batshit partly because people are misreading the OP, I think. The serious mental illness, breakdown, and sectionings happened, as I read it, after the friendship had ended, not before. If so, the friend presumably knew about none of it. Before that, it was a mutually-supportive, if very intense, friendship. The OP says her friend had both parents die and a nasty divorce and that the friend supported her through her own ‘ups and downs’. Things only started to unravel once the OP got a new job.

Obviously the OP should not reconnect with the friend unless she wants to, but what the OP describes sounds like an unhealthily co-dependent relationship between two fragile people who had a lot to deal with. I don’t see the point of demonising the friend. We obviously only know what the OP has told us about the dynamic, but by her own account the friend was doubly bereaved and divorced. Which of us could say, hand on heart, we could deal with that AND support a friend who is having her own struggles with daily phone calls?

scoobydoo1971 · 26/04/2023 23:27

Please protect your mental health recovery by ignoring this woman and blocking her on social media if she attempts contact. You have proved what a strong, resilient individual that you are to have coped with so much. Your former friend maybe reaching out as she has hit upon a crisis, or been abandoned by other people who have seen her for what she is. Avoid like the plague, you managed a decade without her. She had every right to step away, but ghosting someone in distress is just cruel and exposes her as a fair-weathered friend.

MsRosley · 26/04/2023 23:12

OlivePinkSky · 26/04/2023 18:50

Honestly? No way. You were at your lowest, most desperate and vulnerable point in your life and she bailed on you. Ask yiursekf, if the boot was on the other foot - would you have done that to her? Good friends don't do a runner when the going gets tough. Block and ignore

Yup. No two ways about it, it was an utterly shitty thing to do. Leave her to stew in her regrets.

Swipe left for the next trending thread