Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have made SIL cry

334 replies

Scotlandma · 26/04/2023 13:44

A while ago whilst visiting with SIL she made a joke about giving DS lots of sweets when he comes over and said it’ll be a secret.

completely harmless.
however the next time we spoke (by text) I did just say I know you were joking but just so you know for the future when DS is older we will have a no secret rule and just sent a little information on why we want to have a no secret rule for children.

she then called DH crying saying I’ve offended her…

am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
IJustHadToLookHavingReadTheBook · 26/04/2023 16:16

This sounds both overbearing and condescending... the double!

You know and I know that the way your SIL was discussing "secrets" was a) a joke and b) harmless. Of course you're right to bring your child up saying they should never keep secrets from you- to a point, as a PP said, they will keep things from you, but no bad secrets they're told to keep from you, good blanket rule etc- but your SIL wasn't talking about "secrets" in that way, and you knew it.

Unless there's a huge drip feed here and you were abused and warned to keep it a secret and your SIL knows this or similar, there was no need. You're embarrassed and upset her for no reason other than to make a point. Are you always this black and white?

strawberryfluff · 26/04/2023 16:16

Truestorypeeps · 26/04/2023 16:14

A lot of adults without children wouldn't understand the harm in saying about keeping secrets. Maybe it would have been better to just bring it up in a more casual way when you next saw her, or ask your husband to mention it rather than send her information. I deal with my siblings, my wife deals with hers. I wouldn't be pulling up my in-laws or pointing things out to them, I don't see it as my place.

It's OP's child of course its' OP's place

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 26/04/2023 16:15

I think you did the right thing by saying no secrets, although you should have brought it up immediately, not afterwards. No trustworthy non parent adult ever tells a young child to "keep it our little secret". Of course children are going to keep secrets from you, but this is teaching your child about safeguarding.

Truestorypeeps · 26/04/2023 16:14

A lot of adults without children wouldn't understand the harm in saying about keeping secrets. Maybe it would have been better to just bring it up in a more casual way when you next saw her, or ask your husband to mention it rather than send her information. I deal with my siblings, my wife deals with hers. I wouldn't be pulling up my in-laws or pointing things out to them, I don't see it as my place.

strawberryfluff · 26/04/2023 16:14

Scotlandma · 26/04/2023 13:50

It’s not really daft to have a no secrets rule… it’s one of the most basic way to protect our child when we’re not there.

as @StupidFaces said they were made to keep a bad secret as a child it’s not a rare thing and its unfortunately likely at some point my child may come across an unsafe adult.

Secrets vs surprises is a good one

But you didn't need to send her info on it just tell her you don't do secrets

BiscuitsBiscuitsEverywhere · 26/04/2023 16:14

ArseMenagerie · 26/04/2023 15:59

It’s not about secrets.
some secrets are nice:
birthday presents
surprises
sweets with an auntie

Teach your son about things that make him uncomfortable and how whatever the secret he is ok to tell you or his dad if he is worried about it.

You really sound overconfident about child rearing and that no one else will get it. But actually you need to let your child experience all kinds of different views and opinions and methods and it’s about empowering him to be discerning and have boundaries about what makes him uncomfortable and not about blanket rules.

Exactly. Well said.

Nottamug · 26/04/2023 16:13

HNRTFT but I think you were overbearing and if I really was concerned I would have had a conversation about it and not sent a text .

Sissynova · 26/04/2023 16:11

I mean it’s totally over the top in my mind.

A close family member giving sweets and joking about it being a secret isn’t a gateway to abuse.z

HyacinthBookay · 26/04/2023 16:09

toomuchlaundry · 26/04/2023 16:07

@BiscuitsBiscuitsEverywhere I would have a huge issue with a teacher, coach, childminder or similar person telling my child to keep something secret from me, no matter how innocuous. They would have had safeguarding training that tells them that this is a big no. You should never tell a child to keep something secret from a trusted adult. Like others have said you can tell them a present for mum is a surprise for her so we don't tell her about it until her birthday, but no-one should tell you to keep it secret.

SIL was joking with OP which implies that she fully understands about not keeping secrets from parents. I agree that there are things you probably shouldn’t joke about and this is one of them.

toomuchlaundry · 26/04/2023 16:08

@saltinesandcoffeecups it would be something you tell your child, but also useful for adulst who have regular contact with your child for them to know the rule too, otherwise your child might feel awkward even if it is just about sweets.

HyacinthBookay · 26/04/2023 16:07

Yarboosucks · 26/04/2023 16:01

My ds is 23 now.... We have a very open and honest relationship even now based on our no secrets rule. He knows that he can tell me anything and I will help him to handle/manage it.

That rule, to be effective, must be absolute. Children cannot expect to differentiate between a nice secret with loving, kind Aunty X is ok but a dodgy secret with an Uncle/cousin/neighbour etc is not. So the answer to your SIL is that she falls in to the trusted sub-set of family who know about the secret rule. On that basis, she should feel pleased.

i don’t understand what you’re saying. OP does not say that auntie is one of the trusted people dc should report to with any secrets they have been asked to keep. Her text could be seen as a reprimand to SIL for her sweets-in-secret joke.

toomuchlaundry · 26/04/2023 16:07

@BiscuitsBiscuitsEverywhere I would have a huge issue with a teacher, coach, childminder or similar person telling my child to keep something secret from me, no matter how innocuous. They would have had safeguarding training that tells them that this is a big no. You should never tell a child to keep something secret from a trusted adult. Like others have said you can tell them a present for mum is a surprise for her so we don't tell her about it until her birthday, but no-one should tell you to keep it secret.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 26/04/2023 16:04

I read most of the thread…but isn’t the ‘no secrets rule’ something you enforce with your own kid and not all the adults they interact with?

I mean isn’t that the point of the rule. In other words it’s the “Jr doesn’t keep secrets from mum and dad rule” not the “I’m going to stop every adult in Jr’s life from telling them to keep a secret “

Puppylucky · 26/04/2023 16:02

StupidFaces · 26/04/2023 14:03

SIL sounds like a cry baby and a massive attention seeker. Imagine crying over something like this? Worst case scenario is you feel a bit pissed off but crying?? I’d tell her to grow the fuck up and tell her the crying made you laugh

Would you really say her crying made you laugh? Why?

Yarboosucks · 26/04/2023 16:01

My ds is 23 now.... We have a very open and honest relationship even now based on our no secrets rule. He knows that he can tell me anything and I will help him to handle/manage it.

That rule, to be effective, must be absolute. Children cannot expect to differentiate between a nice secret with loving, kind Aunty X is ok but a dodgy secret with an Uncle/cousin/neighbour etc is not. So the answer to your SIL is that she falls in to the trusted sub-set of family who know about the secret rule. On that basis, she should feel pleased.

HyacinthBookay · 26/04/2023 16:00

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 26/04/2023 15:32

It was. Cringeworthy and precious too. No need for your sister in law to cry though.

You've come across as though nobody else understands 'secrets' where children are concerned. They do.

Your child will be keeping secrets from you, don't be under any illusion about that. Better that you instil on them the 'secrets' that must never be kept rather than this really silly example.

I would have been just as upset as SIL. Especially in this day and age. I would have been so embarrassed if someone made a mental leap from my innocent joke to sending me serious information about no-secrets rules. And for a child I love? I would be devastated. You really must apologise

ArseMenagerie · 26/04/2023 15:59

It’s not about secrets.
some secrets are nice:
birthday presents
surprises
sweets with an auntie

Teach your son about things that make him uncomfortable and how whatever the secret he is ok to tell you or his dad if he is worried about it.

You really sound overconfident about child rearing and that no one else will get it. But actually you need to let your child experience all kinds of different views and opinions and methods and it’s about empowering him to be discerning and have boundaries about what makes him uncomfortable and not about blanket rules.

lunaloveroo · 26/04/2023 15:58

I think you were pedantic and overbearing. The blanket no secret rule is not realistic either in life. Better to have more nuance, for example happy/ sad secrets, safe/ scary etc. like for Mother's Day my dh took dc to a hand print place and told her to keep it a secret. It was a lovely surprise.

Boughtitdownthemarket · 26/04/2023 15:54

I think you're taking it a bit too seriously. It was a joke about sweets.

Julietand · 26/04/2023 15:50

You were melodramatic and made a joke into something awkward and weird. YABU

SandLResources · 26/04/2023 15:49

For those who say it's "daft", an abuser can start with sweets and other inane things being the secret...trust me.

Of course I'm not saying Aunty is an abuser but children can't distinguish which adults they can and can't have secrets with so make it a flat rule. From experience, this is what I did with mine.

charlie10k · 26/04/2023 15:48

I could bang your heads together Megan.

Lcb123 · 26/04/2023 15:47

You're both being unreasonable and overreacted. You've turned something light hearted into implying she'll be doing something bad that will be a secret

CurlewKate · 26/04/2023 15:43

"Let's go and buy Mummy a birthday present-but shh, it's a secret."

I understand why people talk about "no secrets" but I honestly don't see how it can possibly work in real life.

And I might very well think you were concerned about my motives if I was your SIL.

Lolaandbehold · 26/04/2023 15:42

YANBU, the safety of my DC will always usurp the feelings of my SIL or any other adult for that matter.

Swipe left for the next trending thread