Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to share CF in law stories from your weddings?

685 replies

Sconesandgravy · 26/04/2023 08:30

Please share your CF in law stories from your weddings. I need to know it's not just me that has one.

I got married on Saturday. We had a micro wedding for multiple reasons. Our daughter, our closest friend each and their partner, and our parents or in my case parental. No siblings or other family.

My Mother in Law is weirdly emeshed with DH's two older siblings and can't cope if they aren't included in everything.

As we were cutting the cake, and having our moment, She shouts out "Make sure you save a piece for BIL, SIL and grandad!" After we'd served everyone she hacked off a huge messy chunk for them, rather than take the finger slices we'd been cutting rendering the rest of the top tier unusable.

It sounds childish but out of all the "petty" moments of the day this one stuck out the most. I think it's because she "stole" my moment.

I'm sure I'll laugh about it in years to come, but it's been four days and amongst the nastier things she did I am beyond angry. So I'm using MN as a form of catharsis, in the hopes that other people have nightmare in laws 😁

OP posts:
Noidlet · 26/04/2023 12:10

We had a low key wedding followed by a nice meal for about 15 guests. That evening we had a 'reception style' party for 80 wider friends and family.
Our relationship with FIL and Step-MIL had always been a bit strained but she seems to behave herself for the wedding itself. She went a bit unhinged for the nice lunch, only wanting to discuss an upcoming football match and condiment preferences but it could have been worse.

We learned later that in the 2 hour break between lunch and the start of the party she refused to come out of her room, watched the football match and then decided she wasn't coming to the Reception at all. DH told his Dad that their non attendance would cause concern with the extended family and that DH would not hold back in explaining everything that had gone on.
FIL probably didn't want the embarrassment and agreed that they would come.
They turned up really late, dressed in casual clothes and S-MIL refused to come into the actual room, choosing to lurk at the secondary bar all evening (We referred to her as the Vampire!) Our only interaction was when he tried to shove £20 in my husband's pocket for him 'to buy himself a drink'.

This was 7 years ago, been pretty much NC since. They have not met our DC (3yrs & 4m). At this point it's a relief to not have to deal with it. We tried for years before this point, so stressful. Can definitely sympathise with you OP.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 26/04/2023 12:10

At our wedding we had exh’s cousin mithering to bring his new girlfriend, and uncles and aunts etc getting involved. Then he had invited some family friends from abroad, who said “oh yes we’re coming and bringing an extra guest, y, whose is x’s girlfriend”. Not even asking, or “I’m terribly sorry but” or anything.

Fantina · 26/04/2023 12:09

OP. you can invite who you like to your wedding. And the problem is that if you want a v small wedding, the more guests you are persuaded to have the bigger it gets.

My irritating wedding story is about BIL whose entire best man’s speech was about DH’s first wedding and wife. One joke could have been ok but not the whole speech. Dick.

SchoolShenanigans · 26/04/2023 12:06

YANBU. I think every family is different, so I get why some people think it's harsh that you invited best friends over siblings, but in some families, that really wouldn't be a problem. It depends on what types of relationships you have.

What MIL thought about your choice is irrelevant really. It's your wedding, she was invited and either goes or doesn't go. She doesn't get the right to make a big point about the invite list throughout the wedding.

But let if go OP. You wanted a small wedding, presumably because you don't want the drama and you care more about the marriage than the wedding. So, in that spirit, acknowledge that MIL isn't perfect and overspoke, then move on.

FWIW - your wedding sounds perfect to me.

Astababe · 26/04/2023 12:06

Unnecessarily aggressive and unpleasant take on the situation. OP has explained her reasons perfectly well

Hoppinggreen · 26/04/2023 12:05

My uncle offered to do a wedding video as his gift to us.
There is nothing of our vows or anything, just lots of close ups of Bridesmaids cleavage and bottoms. As he got drunker the close ups got closer and there is footage of a bridesmaids husband threatening to punch him
Married over 20 years and find it funny now

Sconesandgravy · 26/04/2023 12:04

SingAlongAndItMightJustGetYouThrough · 26/04/2023 11:58

Who are the "parental figures"? Your grandparents?

No. My aunty and uncle. My parents weren't there. Hence why I said his parents and my parental figures.

OP posts:
escapingthecity · 26/04/2023 12:04

@dancinfeet but it would on the groom to request that the catering incorporated food from his culture. Would you go to for example an Indian wedding and expect to be served things like poached salmon? For the relatives to bring stuff uninvited and unplanned is incredibly rude. I'd be livid about that for years.

Starlitestarbright · 26/04/2023 12:03

How is she weirdly enmeshed with her children? I can't imagine any parent not being disappointed that they child's siblings were not included but friends were.

OrangeRock · 26/04/2023 12:03

@Sconesandgravy people are being dicks today. (Not autocorrect I didn’t mean ducks).
Your wedding sounds lovely. Of course you can have a small wedding without siblings and parents. People are weird. Your wedding is for you.
Your MIL was a total dick saying and doing that with your cake. Just minimise contact going forth.

margarine17 · 26/04/2023 12:01

Iwasafool · 26/04/2023 12:00

My late MIL turned up dressed in black from head to foot and cried through the service. Made me feel very welcomed into the family.

I'm so sorry but that did make me giggle as I thought of Maree in Everybody Loves Raymond. I hope things improved!

SmallFerret · 26/04/2023 12:01

Thatsveryniceofyou · 26/04/2023 09:40

This is very revealing but my MIL did cry on our wedding day and told my husband it wasn't too late to call off the wedding (it's all caught on our wedding video as well). I laugh about it now but it was hurtful at the time.

My FIL is generally great and I get on well with him.

Wowsers, well done you for finding the funny side.
Also .. that is one hell of a piece of video ammunition now in your possession ... Wink

Iwasafool · 26/04/2023 12:01

SmallFerret · 26/04/2023 11:58

Blimey.
Did you get married at Fawlty Towers?

Why should your MiL not wish to see a tiny harmless tradition from the groom's side of the family at her son's wedding? More bafflingly, why was the head waiter so rude to an important guest?

Absolutely, I'd be furious if my guests were treated like that. He must have been trained by Basil Fawlty.

Iwasafool · 26/04/2023 12:00

My late MIL turned up dressed in black from head to foot and cried through the service. Made me feel very welcomed into the family.

SmallFerret · 26/04/2023 11:58

Choice4567 · 26/04/2023 09:28

My MIL was very put out that our wedding in England was so English. She very loudly clinked her glass half way through the meal. Apparently where she’s from it means the bride and groom have to kiss. She looked so smug that she was introducing something to do ‘her way’

I felt very smug back when the head waiter came over and told her quite strictly that it wasn’t time for speeches so stop making that noise

Blimey.
Did you get married at Fawlty Towers?

Why should your MiL not wish to see a tiny harmless tradition from the groom's side of the family at her son's wedding? More bafflingly, why was the head waiter so rude to an important guest?

SingAlongAndItMightJustGetYouThrough · 26/04/2023 11:58

Who are the "parental figures"? Your grandparents?

TedLasto · 26/04/2023 11:57

We had a similar small weekend wedding. We hired a house and everyone stayed two nights (we paid). There was another house on the grounds with 3 bedrooms. MIL and FIL insisted on having the entire house to themselves so some friends had to stay in a separate B&B. Also obviously we were then paying for two empty rooms. MIL and FIL were late for the wedding despite staying 2 minutes away. I had to wait outside the room with my dad for them. And various other things that meant we couldn’t have the venue we had originally wanted as they didn’t think it was suitable for them, nor the date we originally wanted as it was near their wedding anniversary (!)

Convovulus · 26/04/2023 11:57

takealettermsjones · 26/04/2023 09:23

She sounds annoying but I do think it's weird that you invited friends' partners but not the groom's actual siblings.

(Unless there's some huge back story and the siblings are raging arseholes, obviously. In which case I'd have gaily said to MIL "nope, they're not getting any!")

I agree

Sconesandgravy · 26/04/2023 11:57

SchoolTripDrama · 26/04/2023 10:52

@Sconesandgravy You refused to invite his Grandpa? Oh that's just awful. You should be ashamed of that. I bet your Grandparents & sibling were welcomed!

No we didn't refuse to invite his grandpa. His grandpa is actually incredibly poorly and cannot leave his nursing home without a tremendous amount of intervention, and it then leaves him poorly for weeks.

No matter what wedding we'd have had his grandpa wouldn't have been able to come. It's a similar situation with my grandma, except she's in a totally different part of the country so there was no way we could have had either there

OP posts:
margarine17 · 26/04/2023 11:56

Yes. I agree. You can stand by it, but not inviting your own siblings and grandpa to your wedding is highly unusual. I guess as long as you don't complain if they all treat you the same it's ok. Not expecting an invite to any of your siblings weddings? grandpas wake ?. Gosh people are weird about weddings. Odds on one of the 2 friends that you invited will get divorced and you won't remember their now partners name in 10 years. Very odd behaviour.

ReadersD1gest · 26/04/2023 11:55

What "moment" were you having, cutting cake? How did someone speaking to you ruin it?

mogtheexcellent · 26/04/2023 11:55

MIL made a second cake and decorated it specific to DHs job eg. camouflage ribbon and army tank for military DH. Sadly the cake remained in the box which was hidden by the caterers who then forgot where it was.

SmallFerret · 26/04/2023 11:55

Dacadactyl · 26/04/2023 09:20

I didn't have an issue with my in laws at our wedding. I also think you were perhaps a bit naive to think that it wouldn't cause issues by not inviting your husbands siblings.

No siblings were invited from either side.

The issue wasn't caused by siblings not being invited. It was caused by inappropriate remarks & actions by OP's MiL.

As OP reports no such rudeness from her own side of the family, you can't level naivete at her. She simply expected everyone to behave like adults, as her own family did.

Weasellyrecognised · 26/04/2023 11:55

Not a wedding one, rather at the other end of things, but my MIL left a long letter to the family when she died detailing all her feelings for each of them and saying how lucky she had been. Left me out.

Sconesandgravy · 26/04/2023 11:53

ZenNudist · 26/04/2023 09:35

Pretty awful not to invite close family but some friends made the cut. In a few years time you may not speak to them life gets in the way friends diverge but a grandpa would have died happier with memories of his grandsons wedding.

I think she wasn't cheeky to say to save the cake. I think you should have planned cake for family who should have been there and not just a "finger slice". Plus she didn't ruin your moment. You are oversensitive.

My MIL invited 6 random guests out of 25 to our wedding abroad. They weren't close family. She said she'd pay I think it cost me £600 which was a lot then. She didn't pay. They didn't give a gift either. She also asked us to get A wedding video which cost £400 for dh ill grandmother who couldn't have come even if we had been in the uk. So we did but she didn't give us the money when she offered to pay. We didn't chase it up. She probably would have if reminded.

I didn't mind though, the extra guests made it more of a party and I don't watch the video but we might be glad of it if we find it one day and can convert it to a watchable file. I think its a cd.

Why is it awful to let the friends who have been there through everything be at our wedding?

Maybe it's awful that people feel so entitled to other people's events?

In a few years we will talk to these friends. My friend and I have been friends for 25 years.

And we did plan cake for them. I just think it's inappropriate to demand cake in the middle of a couple's moment. Why couldn't she have approached us afterwards when everyone had been served? She didn't need to hack at it and make the rest unshareable because it was so wonky

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread