Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to share CF in law stories from your weddings?

685 replies

Sconesandgravy · 26/04/2023 08:30

Please share your CF in law stories from your weddings. I need to know it's not just me that has one.

I got married on Saturday. We had a micro wedding for multiple reasons. Our daughter, our closest friend each and their partner, and our parents or in my case parental. No siblings or other family.

My Mother in Law is weirdly emeshed with DH's two older siblings and can't cope if they aren't included in everything.

As we were cutting the cake, and having our moment, She shouts out "Make sure you save a piece for BIL, SIL and grandad!" After we'd served everyone she hacked off a huge messy chunk for them, rather than take the finger slices we'd been cutting rendering the rest of the top tier unusable.

It sounds childish but out of all the "petty" moments of the day this one stuck out the most. I think it's because she "stole" my moment.

I'm sure I'll laugh about it in years to come, but it's been four days and amongst the nastier things she did I am beyond angry. So I'm using MN as a form of catharsis, in the hopes that other people have nightmare in laws 😁

OP posts:
Hubcapdiamondstarhalo · 26/04/2023 12:48

Not my MIL, but step mother. We had a smallish wedding with reception in a pub's small back room. Buffet meal and no seating plan. A couple of days before the wedding she invited four of their friends and a neighbour to come. Parents were paying back then, so cost wasn't the issue, but space was. We greeted guests at the entrance to the room, and by the time we were ready to sit down, there was nowhere left for me and DH to sit, so we ended up squeezed on the corners of a table. It was all a bit of a shambles really.

Evening dos were not common in those days, so they decided to throw a party at home for guests & family, inviting people a couple of days before or on the day itself. We already had other evening plans, so didn't find out till a couple of days later that they didn't invite DH's parents, because "they didn't seem like they would enjoy it" but did ask DH's aunt along because she looked like she would! My poor lovely in-laws were quite bewildered and hurt, as they didn't know about the party till aunt told them next day. I was both mortified and angry.

That was 43 years ago today.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/04/2023 12:48

Oh, I luffs a good CF thread!

but it would on the groom to request that the catering incorporated food from his culture. Would you go to for example an Indian wedding and expect to be served things like poached salmon? For the relatives to bring stuff uninvited and unplanned is incredibly rude. I'd be livid about that for years.

I wouldn't expect to be served poached salmon at an Indian wedding (i.e. B&G both from Indian cultural background), but if only one side of the family were from one different culture, I would expect both cultures to be represented.

When there's a clear distinction between the cultures of the two sides, I think it's incredibly rude to just pick your own and automatically ignore the other side's culture. The whole point of a wedding is that you're merging people from two different families/backgrounds.

They could have gone hybrid, and had both options - but (as PP), I'm guessing a lot of people would have 'jumped ship' and wanted the 'other' culture's delicious hot spicy food!

margarine17 · 26/04/2023 12:47

I'm lost now- but basically you and your husband don't like anyone in either of your families. Is tht correct OP? Def not you guys though def all of them. O.K.

Sconesandgravy · 26/04/2023 12:44

iwinguys · 26/04/2023 12:30

MIL wore an ivory dress identical to mine almost

My MIL wore black

OP posts:
Fairyliz · 26/04/2023 12:44

Dacadactyl · 26/04/2023 09:20

I didn't have an issue with my in laws at our wedding. I also think you were perhaps a bit naive to think that it wouldn't cause issues by not inviting your husbands siblings.

This. I would be very upset if one if my DC’s invited their friends and not their sibling.
Are older siblings married? If so did you go to their weddings?

Shirls2 · 26/04/2023 12:44

Some of my ILs decided they didn’t fancy any of the main options (nothing too out there and all dietary required adjusted for) so asked that we instruct the catering staff to make them their own special dish. They have no dietary requirements beyond eating the same junk food all the time.

My husband’s cousin and his wife asked if his son’s friend (never met them) could come to “keep him company.” The cost per head was shocking, as is the case in many weddings of course. But this cousin and his wife clearly didn’t consider this and thought it’d be totally fine for a random kid to come.

margarine17 · 26/04/2023 12:43

Hang on, so she babysat your kids for you on the wedding night too.

Sconesandgravy · 26/04/2023 12:43

SmallFerret · 26/04/2023 12:29

You clearly don't accept that every family is different, or you would have noticed that the difference between OP's family & yours is that most of hers died early. Hence her aunt & uncle being her parental figures.

& to all the other PP's having conniptions about the sibling thing: maybe you are blessed not to have grown up in such a dysfunctional family that your closest friend actually becomes your family.

Nonono my mum didn't die!
She's just... Somehow even more dysfunctional than my MIL and basically has never been a particularly present mother, and also has an INTENSE hatred of MIL. She was happy when we were going down the no family route, but said she didn't want to come to the wedding because she wasn't happy we'd decided not to elope so I rescinded the invite and took a break. When I offered an olive branch to see if she wanted to come, because I knew she initially didn't want to... she tried to gaslight me into believing that she always wanted to come, even though we have messages saying otherwise. Yes. Me and DH both come from crazy. But no my mother isn't dead 😂

OP posts:
Iwasafool · 26/04/2023 12:43

margarine17 · 26/04/2023 12:38

Oh goodness she's a real peach. Would definitely be a good sitcom though! Well done you for sticking it out. She must have managed to have somehow raised a good man though at least.

She was as mad as a box of frogs and other than the excruciating embarrassment of being asked about my sex life in front of teenage sons I didn't let her bother me too much. My husband finally lost it with her when she decided to call me "It." For years she got my name wrong, just one of those things she found hard to remember but it was odd that she always got my mother/sister/aunt's names right when she obviously saw more of me. I think she got fed up of me not reacting so decided to up her game. DH went ballistic and I was collapsed on the sofa laughing as it was so ridiculous.

I think you might be right about the sitcom, some of the stuff she did is hard to believe.

ArrrMeHearties · 26/04/2023 12:41

These stories make me so thankful that I get on really well with my mil to be 🙈

ReadersD1gest · 26/04/2023 12:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Whatsmynameagain2010 · 26/04/2023 12:40

My mil got a wedding canvas made with a photo of the wedding! However I'm not in it!! 😁

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 26/04/2023 12:38

It’s not worth shedding any tiers over, OP.

I’ll get my coat.

margarine17 · 26/04/2023 12:38

Iwasafool · 26/04/2023 12:27

Not really, on the birth of her first grandchild my DH brought her to the hospital. I know mum's are biased but she was a very lovely baby and MIL looked in the cot and her first words were, "What a shame" followed by "never ask me to babysit." One of her finest moments was in front of my teenage sons from a previous marriage when she wanted to know if my husband being circumcised as a baby have affected our sex life. She also told my husband I was having an affair, she said it in front of me. Her evidence? I referred to my other boss as "Mr Smith" and this one I referred to as "Mr Lawrence Jones" so me using his first name proved it. She didn't know his name was double barrelled and his first name was Paul (I've changed the names) She couldn't understand why we both found this so funny.

I must be very laid back or a mug because I think lots of people would have cut her off.

Oh goodness she's a real peach. Would definitely be a good sitcom though! Well done you for sticking it out. She must have managed to have somehow raised a good man though at least.

Sconesandgravy · 26/04/2023 12:35

Also, I know I said I wouldn't go into malicious. But this woman was so enraged that her other children weren't invited that she took it out on our autistic child.

When she was staying with them on the wedding night, she had a meltdown due to the change in routine. MIL screamed at her to shut up and when she wretched due to crying MIL threatened to make her sleep in her vomit.

Looking forward to someone justifying this and telling me how evil I am for making a joint decision with my husband to not invite ANY siblings or grandparents. Because mine weren't invited either. My family are just (relatively) sane 🙄

OP posts:
Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 26/04/2023 12:35

I was actually quite fond of my (now ex) MIL, but I was a bit po-faced when, a few months after our wedding we visited her in her home and found she'd got wedding pictures of all DH's siblings displayed on a special wall, and not a single one of us.

Reality · 26/04/2023 12:33

First wedding, I actually stayed at my ILs the night before as my family lived an hour away. SIL had booked a hairdresser for me and her.

On the morning of, the hairdresser had ‘somehow’ double booked so SIL said she’d have hers done and she would do mine for me. I think the fact I couldn’t have cared less really wound her up 🤣 that was a weird family. Marriage lasted less than three years.

Second wedding. SIL (DH’s brother’s wife this time).

• wouldn’t agree to her two year old being part of the wedding party (ie literally wearing a suit to match his dad who was best man) because he wouldn’t tolerate wearing a suit. Fair enough. Turned up on the day wearing…a suit (different to the wedding ones).

• sat in the front row of the (very small) ceremony with the toddler, loudly performance parenting while feeding him an incredibly messy cornetto to keep him quiet. Completely trying to disrupt the vows.

• took the one vegetarian meal from the precooked menu because she fancied it more than the chicken. Basically lied to the waiter that she had preordered it. My cousins wife (actually vegetarian) had to wait while the kitchen found something for her.

• heckled her husbands speech by screeching from the back of the room that he’d forgotten to thank the bridesmaids (he hadn’t). She was at the back of the room because she refused to sit at the sibling table so moved to sit with others.

• got drunk and corralled me out in the terrace for nearly an hour to tell me how miserable she was with her life. No shit. I was too nice (then) to extricate myself so had to be rescued. Literally sobbing in my lap.

Ive posted about her before. We no longer speak although it took 10 years for me to finally have the balls to go NC.

JudgeRudy · 26/04/2023 12:32

ZenNudist · 26/04/2023 09:35

Pretty awful not to invite close family but some friends made the cut. In a few years time you may not speak to them life gets in the way friends diverge but a grandpa would have died happier with memories of his grandsons wedding.

I think she wasn't cheeky to say to save the cake. I think you should have planned cake for family who should have been there and not just a "finger slice". Plus she didn't ruin your moment. You are oversensitive.

My MIL invited 6 random guests out of 25 to our wedding abroad. They weren't close family. She said she'd pay I think it cost me £600 which was a lot then. She didn't pay. They didn't give a gift either. She also asked us to get A wedding video which cost £400 for dh ill grandmother who couldn't have come even if we had been in the uk. So we did but she didn't give us the money when she offered to pay. We didn't chase it up. She probably would have if reminded.

I didn't mind though, the extra guests made it more of a party and I don't watch the video but we might be glad of it if we find it one day and can convert it to a watchable file. I think its a cd.

I disagree with you that family takes presidence over friends. I think it would be odd to not invite parents but if each of the couple had 2 or 3 siblings...I can see why they chose their best friend each. Many people are much closer to their friends than family members.
I agree she wasn't cheeky to ask the couple to dave cake for absent family. I think she was out of order however to chose the cake cutting moment to yell it out....and she was beyond entitled to then go hacking into someone's cake! It should make no difference if you get a large or a small slice, it's the sentiment that counts. Why couldn't she just ask later if there was a larger piece she could take to cut up and distribute to other people? Oh I know, because it would mean ASKING and entitled people don't do that!

Allfizzandfun · 26/04/2023 12:32

Op, I think your idea of a wedding sounds perfect. Honestly, ignore the expressions of horror that you didn’t include your siblings. Utterly bizarre.

As a family we’re all really close but when my brother got married 20 years ago with just both sets of parents as witness, we siblings didn’t mind at all. We were really happy for them. They are lovely people and deserved the wedding the wanted. I don’t see why others don’t get that, especially when weddings are so expensive now.

justteanbiscuits · 26/04/2023 12:31

10 days before the wedding MIL kicked off a massive row (behind our backs) due to step-FIL not being on the top table. Thing is, he was on top table and there was never any discussion he wouldn't be. FIL was also on top table (opposite end!) which she didn't like, so decided to kick up a stink and bad mouth me around the family that I was excluding step-FIL. Luckily, my SIL to be decided that speaking to me would be the sensible thing to do, so we clarified.

Obviously that blew over, so at the wedding she decided to start bitching and causing bad feeling because husbands step-niece (who I had never met before, the step siblings weren't close) wasn't a bridesmaid along with the nieces. She had 6 months to have bought this up before if it has caused the massive upset she claims. I was a pretty chilled bride, and if she's said it was causing a problem I'd have probably just agreed she could be bridesmaid. It wouldn't have been a massive deal (the dresses were fairly cheap and they only had a tiny posey for flowers). Why wait till the actual wedding to start being all snotty about it?!

iwinguys · 26/04/2023 12:30

MIL wore an ivory dress identical to mine almost

Sconesandgravy · 26/04/2023 12:30

1offnamechange · 26/04/2023 12:14

You are obviously allowed to invite/not invite whomever you like to your wedding, but you are a bit unreasonable to describe her as 'weirdly emeshed (enmeshed?)' with her children for expecting them to be invited to their siblings wedding, which is the norm in most families and a very . Her being unhappy they, and her own father, weren't there when partners of friends were (there's no reason anyone else you could have invited had to stay in the same b&b as you) is a fairly normal reaction, not a sign of 'being unable to cope.'

Also if there were only 11 of you there and you had a cake with multiple tiers, why the need for tiny finger slices? Yes it was rude of her to just jump in there, but she didn't 'ruin' the top tier or render it 'unuseable', it's a cake ffs, its 'use' is to be eaten! You'd already cut tiny slices for everyone there, so what if some of the leftovers, which presumably only you/dh/dd would get around to eating at some point, were slightly messy?

I've explained why she's weirdly emeshed in a previous comment. I left out details not relevent to the wedding in the main post as I didn't think it was relevent.

I don't know why you're demonising me, and acting like it was just DHs side who weren't invited. We both only invited parents/parental figures and our friends. Again it's in comments.

I've explained in previous comments why his grandpa wasn't there. He's ill in a nursing home and prior to the wedding we had arranged to see him and take him cake.
And finger slices was the wrong term. I meant we'd cut the cake into rectangular slices as we could get more out of it for everyone. We'd already said we'd give some to siblings. She could have just waited

And FWIW My 2 parental figures didn't act like this. Because they know how to behave.

OP posts:
SmallFerret · 26/04/2023 12:29

margarine17 · 26/04/2023 12:16

Yeah, I guess there's small, there's eloping and then there's (my aunt but not your brother). Still each to their own. But I don't blame MIL for trying to ( apparently clumsily) grab a bit of cake for her other children and her dad. She was probably in bits. My adult children are close though so maybe that's the difference. If one of them upped and eloped everyone would be thrilled. And there would be a big party for them when they returned. If they had a teensy ceremony at the registrar office all good too. Again a big party afterwards.
But asking an aunt and uncle but not a sibling would not fly in my family. I accept that every family is different but that would be verging on unforgiveable in mine. It would be like not asking your mum.

You clearly don't accept that every family is different, or you would have noticed that the difference between OP's family & yours is that most of hers died early. Hence her aunt & uncle being her parental figures.

& to all the other PP's having conniptions about the sibling thing: maybe you are blessed not to have grown up in such a dysfunctional family that your closest friend actually becomes your family.

Iwasafool · 26/04/2023 12:27

margarine17 · 26/04/2023 12:01

I'm so sorry but that did make me giggle as I thought of Maree in Everybody Loves Raymond. I hope things improved!

Not really, on the birth of her first grandchild my DH brought her to the hospital. I know mum's are biased but she was a very lovely baby and MIL looked in the cot and her first words were, "What a shame" followed by "never ask me to babysit." One of her finest moments was in front of my teenage sons from a previous marriage when she wanted to know if my husband being circumcised as a baby have affected our sex life. She also told my husband I was having an affair, she said it in front of me. Her evidence? I referred to my other boss as "Mr Smith" and this one I referred to as "Mr Lawrence Jones" so me using his first name proved it. She didn't know his name was double barrelled and his first name was Paul (I've changed the names) She couldn't understand why we both found this so funny.

I must be very laid back or a mug because I think lots of people would have cut her off.

BearsNowAsleep · 26/04/2023 12:25

Not at my wedding. But when we announced our engagement to his family MIL was very dramatic. SIL asked how he proposed and as I was telling the story MIL kept interrupting and demanding we pose the grandchildren together for some photos to try and be disruptive. She then called up my partner the next day in tears telling him that he never visits her (he does). She gaslighted him and made him feel an awful son. He called me up in tears. I've never seen him cry even at funerals. I have and will never forgive her for making him feel like that and choosing that moment to bizarrely start acting like a victim. I've always got on with MIL but I'm very wary now of her manipulative streak and always take her "woe is me" moments with a pinch of salt.