Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to share CF in law stories from your weddings?

685 replies

Sconesandgravy · 26/04/2023 08:30

Please share your CF in law stories from your weddings. I need to know it's not just me that has one.

I got married on Saturday. We had a micro wedding for multiple reasons. Our daughter, our closest friend each and their partner, and our parents or in my case parental. No siblings or other family.

My Mother in Law is weirdly emeshed with DH's two older siblings and can't cope if they aren't included in everything.

As we were cutting the cake, and having our moment, She shouts out "Make sure you save a piece for BIL, SIL and grandad!" After we'd served everyone she hacked off a huge messy chunk for them, rather than take the finger slices we'd been cutting rendering the rest of the top tier unusable.

It sounds childish but out of all the "petty" moments of the day this one stuck out the most. I think it's because she "stole" my moment.

I'm sure I'll laugh about it in years to come, but it's been four days and amongst the nastier things she did I am beyond angry. So I'm using MN as a form of catharsis, in the hopes that other people have nightmare in laws 😁

OP posts:
Nagado · 26/04/2023 13:29

The first clue I had that things were going on behind the scenes were when I tried to book a local hairdresser (I’d never met her but DH’s cousin had recommended her and everyone in the family went to her) but was told that she couldn’t fit me in as she was going to a wedding herself. It turns out that it was our wedding she was going to and that DH’s family had been randomly inviting people as they bumped into them. They hadn’t mentioned it to us and appear to have taken us saying we wanted a very informal day as us having a ‘No invite necessary’ policy. We had a big wedding but there had to have been a good 20 people there who we hadn’t invited.

I invited her to come dress shopping with me (she hasn’t got any daughters and BiLs both married women who live abroad) and she just didn’t respond to me. I showed her my dress and she simply said ‘oh’ and then changed the subject to what we were having for dinner that evening.

We’d decided not to have a cake. We had lots of different puddings, sweets, etc and neither of us were that bothered about having one. Halfway through the evening I noticed a pile of sweaty looking doughnuts on a table and discovered that MiL had been horrified at the thought of no cake so had sent FiL out to Asda to get the doughnuts. An absolute waste.

Then we had her not saying a word to me all day. Or my family. No ‘Congratulations’ or ‘Welcome to the family’. She just avoided us all from start to finish. She spent most of the reception in the photo booth with BiL’s now ex DP and DP’s aunts.

Then DH’s father tried to invite himself on honeymoon with us and DH’s wonderful step mum had to explain to him why we might not want to spend the week with him.

All of that was more comical than anything else. What was worse was my sister (we are not at all close) announcing that she would be my bridesmaid but would be choosing her own dress that I would pay for, being outraged that I would decline her offer, making very hurtful comments about my actual bridesmaid in front of my young niece (who promptly repeated them), telling me that it didn’t matter what anyone else thought about the dresses for the flower girls, so long as I liked them, and then ambushing me outside the church as I was about to walk in, to tell me that she’d wait outside with her DH and my nieces (both flower girls) as there was nowhere for them to sit (she hadn’t bothered to walk down any further than the first couple of pews so hadn’t seen the one reserved for her). Aside from that, it was a brilliant day!

Nonverbalmum · 26/04/2023 13:28

MIL made a massive song and dance about wanting to pay for the bar at our wedding, made a big thing throughout the day that ‘drinks were on her’ to all the guests. Fine. A generous thing to do and we appreciated it.

Two months later I get a call from the company to say mother in law is refusing to pay the invoice and told him that I was settling it. He then threatens small claims court. It was around £2000. I spoke to her and she denied she’d ever said that and accused us of having forged her signature on the contract she’d signed.

I think she caved and paid him a few further months after that. The poor bloke really didn’t care as long as he got his money, I remember him ringing me daily for weeks and constantly telling him his contract wasn’t with me and he needed to speak to MIL.

MIL also ‘tested’ the pen for the signing book and drew a biro penis on the table cloth. The hotel were not pleased.

She’s an utter tit 😁

Tootsweets84 · 26/04/2023 13:27

RosaBonheur · 26/04/2023 13:12

@KILM and @Tootsweets84 The OP talks about her husband wanting to celebrate his birthday with his brother and sister though. Unless there's been a massive fall out since said birthday, it sounds like they get on fine.

'Getting on fine' isn't the same as being very close though. The OP has also mentioned that they are both very close to their best friends. Blood relatives don't take precedence just because they are blood relatives. OP also mentions that none of the siblings minded.

ZekeZeke · 26/04/2023 13:26

Our wedding was small, immediate family only.
Registry office, no church, no white dress, bridesmaids etc very very low key.
Immediate family only, we paid for our familiea to stay overnight in a 5 star hotel. The meal was held in a very small alcove in hotel restaurant.
A la carte menu, could choose whatever you wanted.
We had an lovely meal and next thing the waiter brings out a wedding cake. A wedding cake that we didn't organise.
Turns out MIL organised the cake. I thought it was her overstepping the mark. It's not something we wanted. If we wanted a cake it certainly wouldn't have been the one she bought.
To this day it annoys me no end.

Awoooga · 26/04/2023 13:24

I can’t understand why OP is getting shit. Threads where people ask if they are BU to be upset about not receiving an invite to a relative’s wedding are full of comments like ‘omg they can invite who they want, it’s not YOUR wedding’ 🙄

Saschka · 26/04/2023 13:23

My DM was buying my wedding dress for me (we were paying for everything else - no contribution from PIL, which was fine, we could afford it). We were looking forward to it, and planned to make a girly day of it with lunch afterwards.

MIL announced she wanted to take me dress shopping instead of DM, as she worked in fashion and would have a better eye. I could just send DM the bill.

Funnily enough I didn’t take her up on that “kind” offer.

EverythingEverywhereButNotAllAtOnce · 26/04/2023 13:23

DH’s family are Greek and a couple of years after our civil ceremony we had a religious wedding there, mainly for their benefit (neither of us really care about religion). MIL was a nightmare from start to finish. A few examples:

I had the bridesmaids dresses custom made in the UK. Asked if DH’s nieces wanted dresses to be made for them and was told, no, will get them made in Greece, much cheaper etc. I sent the fabric 6 months in advance, two months before the wedding the dresses still hadn’t been made. So MIL hired dresses she wanted. These were nice, but nothing like the others. She claimed she would sew parts of the fabric (silver stars) onto the dresses so they matched. She didn’t and then gaslit me about ever having said she would do.

We wanted blue, purple and white flowers at the wedding. She didn’t and told the florist to do red, orange and yellow ones. The only reason we found out was the florist phoned us to check (we were paying for the whole wedding) and we were able to change them.

On the wedding day she saw me having a single solitary glass of champagne (the horror!) and then proceeded to make multiple comments about me being a “drunk” bride. Right.

She insisted on getting her hair and makeup done last and seemed to think that as the bride I should wait for her. I didn’t. The wedding party walked off towards the church and she had to sprint to catch up with us. She arrived at the church puffing and sweating.

She confiscated the wedding favours I had ordered and saved for my family that couldn’t make it and insisted on giving these to all her neighbours, that I neither knew nor had ever met. This was apparently fine.

She decided the shorts and shirt outfits I picked out for our sons were not “suitable”. It was hot and I wanted them to be comfortable. So she bought and insisted they wear trouser suits which they hated and which got torn and dirty within 30 minutes of them putting them on. I got them changed into the cooler, more comfortable outfits I picked and she had a tantrum about this .
She also took my bouquet that I was saving to be pressed as a memento from the wedding and threw it away because I “didn’t need it”.

Ah that was cathartic! For this and many other reasons we are low contact with her.

Sconesandgravy · 26/04/2023 13:23

RichardHeed · 26/04/2023 12:56

OP stop explaining yourself to this idiots who can't grasp toxic families. You'll always be wrong in their ignorant eyes.

Thank you for this!
I genuinely don't think people understand how to read between the lines or that some families are absolutely toxic.

Of course my opinion of MILs emeshment isn't purely based on this one thing, and of course I've explained further when asked.

But people aren't going to read the comments because that will detract their agenda

OP posts:
CuriouslyDifferent · 26/04/2023 13:23

dancinfeet · 26/04/2023 10:51

@EggInANest sounds like the bride’s family didn’t consider the groom’s family at all in what sounds like it was a multi cultural wedding, and catered only to their own likes/dislikes. I would have 100% gone for the hot food especially if it was something spicy and flavoursome, over poached salmon 🤢. From what you have said the groom’s family and culture were overlooked somewhat.

I had same thought.

poached Salmon 🤮 I’d have to have popped out for something I could eat.

if 50% of guests went to the grubs up window….. the people manning the grubs up window probably saved the wedding.

StoppinBy · 26/04/2023 13:22

My husband's Aunty didn't want us to get married on the family farm even though we had the Grandparent's permission.

Two weeks before our wedding she got real serious about us not getting married there, really nasty, she said that if we went ahead with it that she would call the police and have us thrown off on the day.

In the end we had to move our wedding to avoid the risk of that happening.

We were lucky to know someone who allowed us to use their property instead but it was an hour away from the original venue and meant we had to rearrange all our service providers, we were very lucky that the ones that couldn't do the change of venue gave us a refund of our deposit and others were able to attend the new venue.

EggInANest · 26/04/2023 13:21

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/04/2023 13:05

Surely it’s much ruder for the family to simply decide their culture is going to be represented, without any input from the bride and groom, by producing extra food as a fait accompli?

I suppose we don't know what dynamics had led to that, although I still don't think it's unreasonable for them to expect their culture to be included as well.

Did they refuse to discuss it or help with the organising at all? Did they just think that they'd be no trouble and 'sort themselves out' whilst the other side had the fancy formal provision that they wanted?

There are too many variables for those of us who weren't involved to know the full story, I guess.

They were delighted to support a highly trad 'Bride's family pay for their Dd's wedding' approach and make no constructive contributions or suggestions at all.

AND were not consulted on catering arrangements or menu choices (which of course they should have been) . And didn't engage in any discussion. They did deliberately stage the hot food as an unannounced ambush to sabotage the salmon, strawberries and asparagus. Which it did. The brides family definitely cast them as CFers.

The guests were happy though - most people had everything, in the end.

And look at the response above to the guest (was it the groom's mother?) who tinkled her glass to signal 'KISS!' and was treated to the humiliation of having a waiter tell her to shut up. It IS an American wedding tradition. People do it on and off throughout the wedding. The groom sounds American. My sister's American ILs did it at my DSis and BIL's English wedding - and everyone joined in. It takes about a second. But all the responses I have seen here have dismissed the guests introduction of a different cultural aspect to an international wedding.

Weddings, like Christmas and Funerals and Money, seem to bring out the worst in some people.

primroseknows · 26/04/2023 13:21

My BIL refused to acknowledge my DH and I being engaged (because his own girlfriend kept nagging him to her married and he didn't want to - whole other story).

We were always going to have a tiny wedding anyway, us, two kids and each of our parents. No siblings, no friends, then spend the rest of the budget on the honeymoon.

On the wedding morning BIL messaged DH saying 'I'm sorry I won't get to see if today is everything you think it will be... I hope one day when this is all over we can be friends again.'

DH hasn't spoken to him since...

Shirls2 · 26/04/2023 13:20

Disagree slightly with those a little outraged by a partner’s culture not being represented. One of my best friends who grew up here (though his parents are immigrants) and is very much British got repeatedly quite offended by ignorant people going “Ooh I bet you’re going to have all the traditional food and colours because you’re from there! What are you wearing? Will there be outfit changes?” His reply was always, “Nah, I’m from Bristol actually.”

I’m also in a mixed marriage and we had two separate celebrations as meaningfully incorporating aspects of both in one day is actually very difficult. Sure we had little touches in each one but catering is a tough one to pull off well and you’d very likely need two sets of different caterers and their teams if you want really good certain food. And that is what my FIL argued when we wondered if we could.

Astababe · 26/04/2023 13:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Wow, are you actually this unpleasant in real life too @ReadersD1gest ?

LookItsMeAgain · 26/04/2023 13:18

ZenNudist · 26/04/2023 09:35

Pretty awful not to invite close family but some friends made the cut. In a few years time you may not speak to them life gets in the way friends diverge but a grandpa would have died happier with memories of his grandsons wedding.

I think she wasn't cheeky to say to save the cake. I think you should have planned cake for family who should have been there and not just a "finger slice". Plus she didn't ruin your moment. You are oversensitive.

My MIL invited 6 random guests out of 25 to our wedding abroad. They weren't close family. She said she'd pay I think it cost me £600 which was a lot then. She didn't pay. They didn't give a gift either. She also asked us to get A wedding video which cost £400 for dh ill grandmother who couldn't have come even if we had been in the uk. So we did but she didn't give us the money when she offered to pay. We didn't chase it up. She probably would have if reminded.

I didn't mind though, the extra guests made it more of a party and I don't watch the video but we might be glad of it if we find it one day and can convert it to a watchable file. I think its a cd.

WOW!

  1. We don't know if the OP's DH is close or even speaks with his siblings so a close, long term friend might be preferable to a sibling giving you the cold shoulder.
  2. I know of no one who says "Save the Cake", bride or relative. It's not up to the guests to hack away at a cake. If they wanted another slice they should have asked for it or there would have been a plate with extra slices pre-cut on it.
  3. Usually for guests that can't make the wedding, they would get a slice of cake in a cake box designed for this purpose. I'm not sure I understand that you mean by planning cake for family - are you suggesting a whole tier of a cake or do you mean holding back a portion that can be sent out in slices?
  4. If the OP felt a moment was ruined, the OP felt a moment was ruined. Not a thing you could do/say that would change that. As for saying that the OP is oversensitive, that's just unnecessary and verging on being rude.

OP - I don't have any CF in-law wedding day stories.

I do hope that in time, you'll be able to laugh at this. Perhaps for your MiL's next birthday you could get what is called a smash cake where she gets to destroy a cake and it can become her 'thing'.

Sconesandgravy · 26/04/2023 13:17

margarine17 · 26/04/2023 12:47

I'm lost now- but basically you and your husband don't like anyone in either of your families. Is tht correct OP? Def not you guys though def all of them. O.K.

No, that's not the case at all.

We originally planned to get married with just our daughter, our two best friends and their partners present as witnesses. We just wanted something incredibly small as that's who we are.

MIL kicked off so after weeks of her being hysterical we felt guilty and worm down and invited her and FIL.
My Aunty and Uncle came in place of my parents.

DH has two older siblings, I have two older siblings and one younger siblings.
I have two grandparents, he has one grandparent. None were invited. It's nothing to do with like or dislike for anyone. We wanted a small wedding, grandparents wouldn't have been able to attend regardless due to health a siblings we chose not to invite. I have a decent relationship with mine and they were okay with it.

OP posts:
SmallFerret · 26/04/2023 13:15

Sconesandgravy · 26/04/2023 12:43

Nonono my mum didn't die!
She's just... Somehow even more dysfunctional than my MIL and basically has never been a particularly present mother, and also has an INTENSE hatred of MIL. She was happy when we were going down the no family route, but said she didn't want to come to the wedding because she wasn't happy we'd decided not to elope so I rescinded the invite and took a break. When I offered an olive branch to see if she wanted to come, because I knew she initially didn't want to... she tried to gaslight me into believing that she always wanted to come, even though we have messages saying otherwise. Yes. Me and DH both come from crazy. But no my mother isn't dead 😂

What ho Scones. Wasn't sure if your birth parents were around or not, only that there was a reason for their absence & that you have lost many family members.

Dysfunctional is sometimes worse than dead. Apologies for the brutality of that statement, but I think many PP are aghast at the "sibling protocol" because they - & I'm glad for them - have no experience of the impact & generational fallout of seriously dysfunctional family dynamics.

MariaRemindsMeOfAWestSideStory · 26/04/2023 13:15

SIL’s husband is a racist who hates me simply because I’m not white. We have no relationship with him at all, but DH still has a good relationship with his sister and her and I have a friendly relationship.

MIL understandably hates that there’s a split in the family, even though it’s all caused by SIL’s husband.

We had a very small wedding and invited DH’s aunts and uncle. In the lead up, MIL kept telling DH to invite SIL’s husband to keep the peace and obviously he refused.

We gave our invites for DH’s aunts and uncle to MIL. She never gave DH’s uncle his invite, which means he thinks he was never invited to our wedding, so that there would be a space for SIL’s husband.

I found this out after the wedding and DH’s response was “but my mum would never lie…”. That hurt more than the drama around the invites, that rather than accepting what I found out, he thought I was the one who was lying.

Yvetty · 26/04/2023 13:13

CoffeeCantata · 26/04/2023 13:02

OP - I think people are being very harsh!

I agree that your MIL helping herself to your wedding cake is outrageous. You get a finger piece of a special cake, not a huge hunk - it's not meant to be a meal substitute, just a symbolic sharing of the celebration. Who doesn't understand that??

And, as a guest, you get what you're given and like it or lump it - you don't barge in and grab what YOU want. Yuk - what a vulgar, ill-mannered woman.

And you can invite and not invite whoever you like, there are no rules!

Agree. Also sometimes some friends are like family. There’s nothing wrong with that.

Myfirstcarwasamini · 26/04/2023 13:12

We too had a micro-wedding, our kids and the MIL. She brought with her a bag for life containing some food saver containers that she hadn’t returned to me previously. Luckily I saw the funny side but confirmed why I had really just wanted to keep it to us and our kids.

RosaBonheur · 26/04/2023 13:12

@KILM and @Tootsweets84 The OP talks about her husband wanting to celebrate his birthday with his brother and sister though. Unless there's been a massive fall out since said birthday, it sounds like they get on fine.

Dedodee · 26/04/2023 13:11

Inthesamesinkingboat · 26/04/2023 11:44

My MIL told all her friends that I was evil because she wasn’t invited on my hen-do and she was so sad because she had always wanted a daughter and she ended up with me and I made sure to make sure she was excluded from everything.

The reason she wasn’t invited on the hen do was that I didn’t have one…

She also turned up to the wedding wearing ivory (not a problem, this bride wore emerald green, she was most put out)

My mil wore an ivory suit and I honestly can’t see a problem with ivory or white for any guest as long as the outfit doesn’t look like a wedding dress.
I wore a short white and grey dress to dn’s wedding, I was 55 and certainly wouldn’t be mistaken for a bride!

Astababe · 26/04/2023 13:10

ReadersD1gest · 26/04/2023 12:23

How have I misunderstood, exactly?

You are being deliberately obtuse. The pp is perfectly clear

MyPurpleHeart · 26/04/2023 13:10

Mines not my MIL but my own parents

They can be notoriously difficult. Complained about everything from location 'we aren't carting all the way out there' (30 mins drive) to food, mum had to have her own special dish (because she didn't like the soup, chicken, beef, tiramisu or trifle options offered) insisted on getting herself flowers to carry even though I said not to, MOB doesn't carry flowers, and then left early because the music was too loud and they didn't like it.

For context my husbands family flew out from Ireland, spent a fortune staying for a week and had a great time. Not a complaint out of them!

Oubliette86 · 26/04/2023 13:10

But this woman was so enraged that her other children weren't invited that she took it out on our autistic child.

When she was staying with them on the wedding night, she had a meltdown due to the change in routine. MIL screamed at her to shut up and when she wretched due to crying MIL threatened to make her sleep in her vomit.

So this supposedly happened yet you started a thread complaining about cake cutting, her stealing your moment & how you’re still angry about said cake incident 4 days later? Really?