Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's impossible to actually have conversations these days?

114 replies

IAteAllTheTomatoes · 25/04/2023 22:15

Can I just check if I am losing it?

Two instantances this week where I was pulled up on really well intended comments that we taken up the wrong way & I'm baffled.

Friend 1 sent me a photo of her new hairstyle. I replied, I really like the new colour. Are you happy with it?

The response I got was "should I not be? What's wrong with it? Why are you even asking me that? Tell me what you really think.

Friend B - we were talking about something that happened it the past and I said "you seemed happy about it"

Response "seemed? I am happy with it. Did you think I was pretending?"

Am I unreasonable or is my use of the English language really poor an insulting?

Both friends are genuinely annoyed & I've no idea why.

OP posts:
TheShade · 26/04/2023 07:23

They’re being a bit sensitive yeah!

briansgardenshed · 26/04/2023 07:19

The problem is text. It's a normal question. A friend who knows you would understand that you were interested in how she felt. She may not have been happy with it and her response might have been "I'm not sure - it the colour a bit dark??". It's a conversation.
But it is getting harder.

GoFasterKnickers · 26/04/2023 07:18

bananaboats · 25/04/2023 22:40

I think the first example it sounds like you didn't like her hair and couldn't think of anything nice to say about it. Second example too hard to say without context.

Agree.

Second example I don’t get at all, first you used weird language.

daisymoonlight · 26/04/2023 07:15

I will say that the phrase 'are you happy with it?' after a hair cut or some other supposed improvement in appearance does come across a little like there could be a reason not to be happy about it. It just does, sorry

Completely agree with this. After all, if the haircut and colour really is as fab as your first compliment then why would you need to even ask if they like it? "are you happy with it" to me, comes across as if you dont really like it AT ALL and are wondering if they also have doubts about it so you can then open up a convo about it. Saying "you must be so happy with it" or "So glad you love it" would be a far less ambiguous way of asking if they really do like it without this added implication.

JenniferBarkley · 26/04/2023 07:06

I've switched to using "you must be delighted with it?" for stuff like this. Asks the question but is a compliment too iykwim. Much less likely to be misconstrued.

Emotionalsupportviper · 26/04/2023 07:06

Offence is taken, not given.

For whatever reason - possibly nothin to do with you or anything you have said or done - they are spoiling for an argument.

Ignore.

Wallywobbles · 26/04/2023 07:04

My kids tell me texts are angry because I use punctuation.

Walkingintheminefield · 26/04/2023 07:03

You are negotiating the linguistic swamp that contorts our conversations nowadays. If your friends choose to be crocodiles in the swamp snatching at what to you are innocuous words, they have made that choice. Conversations are possible provided both parties are prepared not to take immediate offence.

cushioncovers · 26/04/2023 06:56

Both your comments seem slightly passive aggressive to me.

Vallmo47 · 26/04/2023 06:51

Mm, I think possibly this might be a case of “no smoke without fire”, maybe you are asking this kind of thing a bit too much and it’s always coming across badly and they’ve only just now dared to say something to you about it? Clearly you don’t think there’s anything wrong in your delivery, but they do, so if you want to keep these friends you will have to change the way you speak a bit. For what it’s worth, if a friend sends me a picture of something new I do try to say something positive about it. Clearly they like it enough to share? I assume if someone isn’t happy about something they’d at least send me a message beforehand saying “God, I’ve done something stupid. Look at this!” I mean, even in such a situation surely a good friend would try to ease the blow and make out it looks okay? That’s what friends do. I would personally just say “That’s lovely, the colour really suits you! ♥️“ and if they then say they hate it, well, that’s their choice.

I wouldn’t personally be offended if you asked me if I was happy with my new hairdo, but it might make me second guess myself slightly to be honest. I’m far more at ease when the convo goes “Oh you’ve done your hair- looks great!” because my mum was old school and taught me it’s wrong to compliment oneself. Also I’d worry you hate it and my taste is being questioned. But like I said, that would be my insecurities speaking. I guess what I’m saying is that if you keep throwing out that question eventually I might be more reluctant to share things with you.

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/04/2023 06:51

@IAteAllTheTomatoes

Surely people ask their friends if they are happy, sad, worried etc? How they are feeling etc?

Of course but the positioning of "are you happy with it" in this situation immediately after a compliment is slightly odd. It is not a huge source of offense but it sounds as if you are opening the door to saying you don't like it. I've known people do this and it's made me slightly uncomfortable, like they are looking for an opportunity to say something negative.

Most people if they are genuinely paying a compliment will just pay it without qualifying or questioning it or trying to throw it back to the person.

I don't think you've done anything wrong but your way of complimenting people is a bit hesitant and lacking in conviction. Maybe people are just picking up on this.

FabFitFifties · 26/04/2023 06:47

My partner just asks "are you happy with it" about my hair. But he finds it impossible to compliment me. You on the other hand, started with a definite compliment. For me, that was fine. Your second one could be misconstrued, as goading, or snidey. Texts are very often misinterpreted. Just stick to compliments!

rolvus · 26/04/2023 06:44

It is annoying when people take things the wrong way when you don't intend it. I will say that the phrase 'are you happy with it?' after a hair cut or some other supposed improvement in appearance does come across a little like there could be a reason not to be happy about it. It just does, sorry. I think I'd wonder the same as your friend. When my friend had her braces taken off I said 'wow, they look great, you must be so happy!' Of course she'd be happy, they looked great. I would let ask 'are you happy with them?' as that would be suggesting there was reason for her not to be,

RestingMurderousFace · 26/04/2023 06:42

My mother pulls the “are you happy with it” thing. I hate it.

GarlicGrace · 26/04/2023 06:40

I'm with you! I nearly started a thread just now about how people don't seem to understand generalisations any more. Especially if it's about men, but any other group will do.

It doesn't even stop at NAMALT these days. There's always some logically-challenged nitpicker to rabbit on that generalisations are invalid if there are any exceptions (which is a generalisation itself!) The same type of fool fails to understand what averages are for, and can't grasp hypotheticals or metaphors.

I am slowly falling silent because this is all soooo fucking tedious!

I needed that Grin Thanks.

LittleCatSing · 26/04/2023 06:39

HaggisBurger · 25/04/2023 22:53

Maybe stop asking people if they are happy with stuff. It’s a slightly odd conversational gambit maybe.

This
It's introducing an element of doubt, but in a PA way.

Do you like my new hair
"Ooooh lovely, really suits you"

"Are you happy with it"

Sounds sneery and slightly negging

MathsNervous · 26/04/2023 06:38

If you ask a question back at your friend it implies that you are not keen on the hair colour.

MathsNervous · 26/04/2023 06:37

Snooks1971 · 25/04/2023 22:43

This is how I read it too.

Agree. If you had said "wow that's lovely, really nice hair colour there". It's a concrete way of being positive and cannot be misconstrued.

Greentree1 · 26/04/2023 06:33

It's very difficult getting intent across in short messages, hence the use of emojis to add feelings. I've been told using full stops is now bad as it's too abrupt and stops the conversation (really!).

I'm sure you didn't mean it but In both cases it could be taken as questioning what they had done. Unfortunate that was the way it was taken, all you can do is say you didn't mean it like that.

Is that the usual way you converse? I have a friend who talks a lot in questions, it does feel a bit like doubting me or interrogating me sometimes.

ladymaiasura · 26/04/2023 06:33

Even judging by the responses, it seems that some people don't take things at face value and over analysis minor things and assume things are implied that aren't.

This is true in my experience, especially when communicating by text when tone of voice and non verbal cues are missing. It happens a lot here on MN, state a fact and then someone goes off on a rant about what they think you mean. And the more emotive the subject, the more likely this is to happen.

Perhaps your friend wasn’t happy about the haircut and you touched a nerve…

mainsfed · 26/04/2023 06:25

Even judging by the responses, it seems that some people don't take things at face value and over analysis minor things and assume things are implied that aren't.

I'm not getting offended at all.

You are totally getting offended, OP. I think the fact that friends were unhappy about you making a comment about their happiness tells you that you do need to reframe your words.

artimesiasfootsteps · 26/04/2023 06:19

I never have people chastise me for things I say, so I think it’s a you problem, rather than a them problem.

It’s also telling that when people explain how they perceive what you said to your friend could be rude, you get defensive.

If you are offending friends/colleagues etc often, the common denominator is you.

I have an acquaintance like this. Whose tone, delivery and comments are often rude, and frequently gets negative reactions to her rudeness, but thinks everyone is too sensitive not that she’s rude. I have been slowly phasing her out as she is equally defensive and I have other friends who aren’t defensive and polite I’d rather spend time with.

Morestrangerthings · 26/04/2023 06:17

You have to be a bit more careful in a text conversation. And take care getting your meaning across. If people are taking offence perhaps you are better off speaking to them directly.

My sister recently sent me a pic of her new hairstyle asking me what I thought, I answered, "I love it. you look great." And then left it to her to offer up whether she was happy with it or not.

But I do think people have gotten a bit testier lately. Not everyone of course. But I think the pandemic, climate crisis, cost of living, shitty governments, institutions not functioning as well as they did pre-pandemic etc., has made many of us uneasy and a bit overwhelmed. And unease can lead to less patience, being quicker to anger or take offence etc.

Crazydoglady1980 · 26/04/2023 05:52

The problem with text messages is people put their own tone on it when they read it. Maybe friend one isn’t completely happy with it so read your text as critical and friend 2 wasn’t happy

Catspyjamas17 · 26/04/2023 05:40

I think if a friend sends you a photo of a new hairstyle or posts it on social media, you should assume they do like it and are looking for affirmation, unless it is clear from the accompanying text that they hate it and are looking for advice as to what to do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread