Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's impossible to actually have conversations these days?

114 replies

IAteAllTheTomatoes · 25/04/2023 22:15

Can I just check if I am losing it?

Two instantances this week where I was pulled up on really well intended comments that we taken up the wrong way & I'm baffled.

Friend 1 sent me a photo of her new hairstyle. I replied, I really like the new colour. Are you happy with it?

The response I got was "should I not be? What's wrong with it? Why are you even asking me that? Tell me what you really think.

Friend B - we were talking about something that happened it the past and I said "you seemed happy about it"

Response "seemed? I am happy with it. Did you think I was pretending?"

Am I unreasonable or is my use of the English language really poor an insulting?

Both friends are genuinely annoyed & I've no idea why.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Sartre · 05/05/2023 15:36

First one was a bit of a weird thing to say because I think if someone is sending you a photo of their new hair it’s because they really like it. Second one just sounds like an arsey friend.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 26/04/2023 20:02

I think it's slightly off to ask if they're happy with their hair. I'd have opted for 'how does it make you feel?' Or 'do you feel great or what?'

gulz · 26/04/2023 14:14

I genuinely feel that the fact that you're overanalysing their instinctive responses in detail (and generalising it into an "everyone else but me" thing) says a lot, though... It seems that in the long term, you're more offended than they were honestly.

It's not even clear that your first friend was offended. Maybe she was asking you a clarifying question.

I also have pet phrases / favoured ways of speaking that have offended or made people misunderstand. If I realise it happens more than once or twice, I just change the way I speak. No sweat, no fuss.

DrManhattan · 26/04/2023 08:46

You sound really awkward and defensive

pizzaHeart · 26/04/2023 08:39

itsayouproblem · 25/04/2023 22:39

Also, you're example isn't an example of it being "impossible to actually have a conversation" - you asked a question, it was slightly shady. You got asked some questions back.

If it's ok for you to ask if she's happy about her hair then it's ok for her to ask why you're asking that.

That's a conversation.

I agree with this 100% ^.
Your question was weird so she rightly asked for clarification.

GretaGood · 26/04/2023 08:28

Are you happy with it implies You might not be / you don't like it but hope she does

You seemed happy implies 'You seemed happy but do I sense regrets?' /You seemed happy but from what you say now you may not have been?'

I wouldn't discuss with someone if they are happy. Instead I would congratulate them, admire them, be pleased for them, just say that's great.

It's your choice of language OP.

the80sweregreat · 26/04/2023 08:28

I'm also fed up with people contradicting me all the time about things , so I tend to try and watch I say. I have noticed people are much more spiky since the pandemic too
I have given up on some people as you can never say the right thing to them , yet it's fine for them to be forthright with you or whatever

GeekyThings · 26/04/2023 08:17

Maybe I just don't seek reassurance on things, if I'm happy woth my hair, I really don't care what others think. I don't mind their opinions but I don't need others to confirm my own thoughts.

But by asking if they're happy with it, you're seeking reassurance. You may not seek reassurance on your own looks, but you do about other people's feelings and whether or not they match yours. It's still reassurance.

Simplelobsterhat · 26/04/2023 08:16

IAteAllTheTomatoes · 26/04/2023 08:03

I'm surprised by a lot of the comments, especially those saying it's weird phrasing or asking why I talk like that, that it's passive agressive or a needy question or it's more about me than them.

It really is just a question! A sincere one too. To me, It's important that people are happy regardless of what others think anyway. Maybe I just don't seek reassurance on things, if I'm happy woth my hair, I really don't care what others think. I don't mind their opinions but I don't need others to confirm my own thoughts.

The topic is so trival, I'm just surprised these things matter so much to some people.

For what it's worth, I woke up to a text from friend 2 saying sorry, he was tired & cranky last night, thought he was happy with the situation but is now having second thoughts.

Ok so you did hit a nerve in the second one by the sound of it. That's not your fault so glad he apologised, but it explains the reaction.

With the first one, maybe take on board that although you mean it sincerely, many people on here says they would take it as your friend did, even if they wouldn't let on to you it made them feel that way.

Strugglingtodomybest · 26/04/2023 08:07

CrunchyCarrot · 26/04/2023 07:34

It's not you, OP. I think it's their 'wounded inner child'. Have been listening to a podcast about it just now. People who perceive any comment as a criticism. The person involved will often reply defensively or even go on the attack. It's linked to their childhood experiences and has nothing to do with what you said, which was absolutely fine!

Do you have a link for this please. It may help me to understand my mum.

OP, I think you sound like a lovely friend, showing interest in your friend's feelings on things.

As a pp said, I'd have replied to "are you happy with it?" with something like "as happy as I ever am after being to the hairdresser's, but I'm sure I'll get used to it!".

I can't bear all this "what are you implying " shit. In my head I always think, I wasn't implying anything, do you think so little of me that you think I'd resort to passive aggression?

IAteAllTheTomatoes · 26/04/2023 08:03

I'm surprised by a lot of the comments, especially those saying it's weird phrasing or asking why I talk like that, that it's passive agressive or a needy question or it's more about me than them.

It really is just a question! A sincere one too. To me, It's important that people are happy regardless of what others think anyway. Maybe I just don't seek reassurance on things, if I'm happy woth my hair, I really don't care what others think. I don't mind their opinions but I don't need others to confirm my own thoughts.

The topic is so trival, I'm just surprised these things matter so much to some people.

For what it's worth, I woke up to a text from friend 2 saying sorry, he was tired & cranky last night, thought he was happy with the situation but is now having second thoughts.

OP posts:
SquashedSquashess · 26/04/2023 07:58

A slightly different issue, but linked to the difficulty of conversation, is I find people don’t know how to respond if you disagree with them. I expect this is because many of us like to find support for our own views in an online echo chamber.

I don’t go out looking for disagreement, but I’ve noticed people often state opinions as fact. If I disagree with an opinion, I’ll calmly say so (literally just “oh I don’t agree actually”). Most often it causes an uncomfortable silence, but it isn’t really my problem if people can’t consider the idea someone might not agree with their subjective opinion. It is frustrating though that we’ve lost the art of calm (or at least not personal) debate

Theeaglesoared · 26/04/2023 07:51

Just be nice. Say it looks lovely. No need to ask if they're happy with it - they'd tell you if they weren't.

SpeckledlyHen · 26/04/2023 07:49

NoName12345678 · 26/04/2023 00:10

A huge flaw in communicating by text is the lack of tone of voice. In your head you read a sentence in one tone of voice and it sounds enthusiastic and positive however the same sentence could also read flat and dubious of you were feeling insecure... it helps to use more emphatic language, or emojis, or perhaps respond by voice note instead. If you find text tedious then perhaps that's also coming across in unintended ways...

This.

In your OP I think the first text I would take the same way as your friend. I would have said something like, ‘I bet you’re really happy with it’. The way you have phrased it sounds like others have said and implying you don’t think it’s great.

Simplelobsterhat · 26/04/2023 07:48

The first one would have me thinking you didn't really like it. I'll hold my hand up and say that's on me - I'm an overthinker and over analyser and I lack self confidence. I wouldn't have pulled you up on it though (unless you were my mother who for some reason I can't stop myself taking offence with!) because I'm not confident enough to do that, and also I'd think you were trying to be tactful rather than rude, but I would go away thinking you probably didn't like it. I believe you that it's not what you meant, but it's not a bad thing you knowing how other people may interpret things you say if they have more self doubt than you obviously do.

The second one is odder, but depends what you were talking about and tone of voice etc (or was it text). Is it something the person may have a bit of doubt about, or a 'chip on their shoulder '. It does seem overly defensive.

The emoji thing is ridiculous though!

StupidFaces · 26/04/2023 07:48

Why do you talk like this? It’s annoying me just thinking about it.

In both examples you sound like you think they’re wrong to be happy and want them to know. Why can’t you just say “your hair looks lovely” or “it was great to see you so happy”

Your constant questioning of my feelings would drive me up the wall.

GeekyThings · 26/04/2023 07:47

I think I agree with most above about the first one, it was a weird question to throw in at that point. It does sound like you were unsure about the hair, so you were confirming. I have a friend at work who does this, who has been confronted by colleagues more than once about it, and she has a habit of talking about other people's appearances, which is generally speaking best to not do.

She said she does it for similar reasons as you've said here, but think about it - you're asking because YOU want to know they're happy; the question isn't about them, it's about you, which makes it quite a needy sort of question. And if you're talking about someone else's body and appearance really THEY need to lead the conversation, not you. As a role of thumb it's generally not ok to question other people about their physical appearances.

In this instance she obviously invited comment, but, I think we can presume that because she sent you a photo of herself with the hairdo that she was most likely happy with it, so the question was redundant - of course she was happy with it. Asking if she was happy with it was always likely to be misinterpreted. Don't ask the question next time - a nice, friendly comment would have ended after the first sentence, where you said you liked it. If she then wants to carry on with the conversation she can, it's her body, she only has to talk about it for the time that she wants to, she doesn't have to answer questions about it.

I don't agree with most here about the second comment, though - it was also a weird thing to say. The only time I can think of where that phraseology would have been appropriate would have been if he'd said "remember this place? I was so unhappy there" - "really? but you seemed so happy there". That's fine, that's normal. He says "remember this place?", and you say "yes, you seemed happy there" - weird. It's like you're saying he doesn't seem very happy now in comparison, and isn't that sad!

I think though that one you can just put down to a phrasing error though, once he's pointed it out, you say you didn't mean it like that, you both laugh because it was funny, move on.

rubytubeytubes · 26/04/2023 07:39

The fact that this has happened twice to you when talking about being happy about something suggests that’s it’s you not them that has an issue.
perhaps stop using that term in conversations- it is an odd thing to say ‘are you happy’ as it does suggest that they shouldn’t be.

If someone said ‘you seemed happy’ about when I got married for example - I would be thinking well I was happy, I think you have chosen those words deliberately as they both seem like a dig.
if you are repeatedly offending people ask yourself about your motivation for using that phrase?

CrunchyCarrot · 26/04/2023 07:34

It's not you, OP. I think it's their 'wounded inner child'. Have been listening to a podcast about it just now. People who perceive any comment as a criticism. The person involved will often reply defensively or even go on the attack. It's linked to their childhood experiences and has nothing to do with what you said, which was absolutely fine!

TheHandbag · 26/04/2023 07:32

This is similar to a conversation I have with my sister, she is one of life's permanently offended. A conversation with her deteriorates very quickly and you never know when or why. I don't talk to her unless I really have to because it's too much hard work.

Flipperdippers · 26/04/2023 07:30

I hate texting for this, because there is no tone to it, it's easy to infer a different meaning than the one intended. That's why I litter my texts with emojis, so that people know my emotion. But even then it can be misread

pictoosh · 26/04/2023 07:24

Next time don't say "are you happy with it?" - say "love the colour, you must be delighted with it."

StupidFaces · 26/04/2023 07:23

First one sounded like you didn’t like the hair and was therefore questioning whether they like

Second one was just a weird thing to say.

You seemed happy about it … sounds like your questioning their feelings

Feelinadequate23 · 26/04/2023 07:23

Agree with others. If you actually thought the haircut was great you wouldn’t ask “are you happy with it?” Because you’d know they would be. Why even comment on their feelings, it’s clear she likes it as she’s sending you a photo. If she was unhappy she’d have said something like “oh god, look what my hairdresser did to me!!” You are putting doubt into her mind as to whether she should be happy with it.

the second example we need more context. But why would you say “seemed”? Makes it sound like they weren’t but put on a good act? Why not just say, “you were so happy!” ?

I think your delivery comes across ruder than you think it does and this might be something to work on. I had to work on similar as I upset a few people in a row unintentionally but I now understand that I’m blunter than most and it doesn’t make people feel good.

Swipe left for the next trending thread