Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Made in Chelsea blokes - twins via surrogate

358 replies

HermioneKipper · 25/04/2023 19:39

More “celebs” commissioning a woman’s body to buy a baby.

When is this going to be made illegal 😡

And twins again. So many of them have twins. I think I get a bit triggered by this especially as I have twins and know how dangerous twin pregnancy can be for both mother and babies. And what it does to a woman’s body. No one could consent to this.

Had to switch off Giovanna Fletcher and her simpering podcast when they started talking about “their” miscarriages. Horrific amounts of bleeding, pain and horrendous wrenching emotional pain for you was it mates? No, didn’t think so.

OP posts:
TheyAreMyBhunasPete · 26/04/2023 06:36

HermioneKipper · 25/04/2023 23:44

It’s completely different when it’s your own baby FFS.

Women acting as surrogates are being treated as vessels being paid for the use of their body.

I am not the one treating her as a body in this scenario.

And I highly doubt she knew the full risks to her health with a twin pregnancy. No one can.

it can’t and shouldn’t be able to be consented to.

But WHY is it different? You can't just say its different and have no logical explanation. We are all vessels to birth children. But you are acting as if these women are no more than vessels. They have their own families and people who love them, they have their own reasons for doing this, they have career aspirations and favourite foods. YOU are treating these women like they are nothing more than an object. You are talking about them as if they shouldn't have any control over their body. You were allowed to take the risk, possibly die, but what, so long as its for your own baby? That doesn't make any bloody sense.

Your parents or siblings or husband wouldn't have cared whether the baby was yours or not, either way they would have been heartbroken at you dying. You were allowed to take that risk, your body be used as a vessel, but its OK your husband put your life at risk because you consented right? These women consent too, they just don't take the baby home. Which is its own argument, but stop talking about these women as if they are objects with no minds of their own.

secretllama · 26/04/2023 06:22

I just can't get outraged over surrogacy when the baby is so loved and wanted when there's children who have literally never experienced an ounce of love in their life/been abused by their natural parents.
I wonder how people would feel morally about banning these people becoming mothers. Do you agree with sterilising these people? Why would that be different to literally banning loving parents having a child via surrogate?

forgotmyusername1 · 26/04/2023 06:19

Someone I know has tried to adopt with her husband

They both work in decent jobs
Own their own house
Wanted to adopt a child of 3+ not because they can't have children but because they want to give a home to a child who needs it.

After two years of classes, meetings etc they have been turned down
Reasons given were her weight (she is a size 16), lack of experience of trauma and the social worker couldn't understand their motivation to adopt rather than have their own children.

Adoption isn't as easy as some in here seem to think it is.

ohfook · 26/04/2023 05:57

Oddessa · 25/04/2023 20:24

Wow. It really shocks me when I come across such sickening views as yours OP.

You have children and yet you want to deny people that?

  • Their surrogate wasn’t forced into it
  • She could have had an abortion if she didn’t want to carry twins, it’s her body, her choice. Plus she’s legally the parent until she transfer parental rights.

I’m so glad I don’t know anyone like you in real life OP,

I think that's a very naïve way of looking at it. I'm not sure what my views on surrogacy are tbh but I think the fact that rich women aren't volunteering in droves to be surrogates whereas in poorer countries women do it in greater frequency does need examining. As does the restrictions placed upon the women while they are pregnant.

Ultimately people don't deserve children - it's not a right. It's a blessing that very sadly not everybody gets to enjoy.

Simonjt · 26/04/2023 05:46

Clymene · 26/04/2023 05:44

@Simonjt giving a home to a child or children who doesn't have one like you have is not the same thing at all.

So you do think its okay to buy children then?

Clymene · 26/04/2023 05:44

@Simonjt giving a home to a child or children who doesn't have one like you have is not the same thing at all.

Simonjt · 26/04/2023 05:39

Clymene · 25/04/2023 23:03

I am against all surrogacy, no matter what the reason. Children aren't commodities - they shouldn't be bought, sold or traded.

You’re also against adoption then as parents through adoption pay a fee for their children.

FMLWTF · 26/04/2023 02:00

Should they not be able to have children because they are a gay couple?

If one of them has a womb they can probably manage it. Otherwise, I guess nature has denied them. Having children is not a right.

Candymay · 26/04/2023 01:10

Oddessa · 25/04/2023 20:24

Wow. It really shocks me when I come across such sickening views as yours OP.

You have children and yet you want to deny people that?

  • Their surrogate wasn’t forced into it
  • She could have had an abortion if she didn’t want to carry twins, it’s her body, her choice. Plus she’s legally the parent until she transfer parental rights.

I’m so glad I don’t know anyone like you in real life OP,

Oh I’m pretty sure you do

PerryMenno · 26/04/2023 00:59

Gay couples can have children any way they like.

Really @Jazsimone ?

Can they head to a developing country with a wad of cash, wander the streets until they see a cute baby, buy it from the very poor mother?

If not, why not? The mother is consenting, it's just post-birth surrogacy right? Is this a homophobic position?

If yes, how about I start a business which makes it easier for those couples. I'll go around the world and buy cute babies from their poor mothers. Infertile couples can browse my website, and arrange to buy the ones they like. Everyone's consenting. To say this is unethical would be homophobic, right?

dailytalk · 26/04/2023 00:47

I find it bizarre that people like the Kardashian's and Paris Hilton have made it more fashionable.

I'm trying to be kind but in a world where we call people "they" because they don't feel like a man or women.... I'm really struggling.

dailytalk · 26/04/2023 00:45

merrymelodies · 26/04/2023 00:33

I frankly don't see surrogacy as a problem if the woman carrying the baby is happy to do it.

Because there are thousands of women in developing countries, including Ukraine, who do it for money. If they lose their life in childbirth, is that ok?

I think there is also the other aspect that anyone can pay for a child if they have the money.... and a lot of people are uncomfortable with gay men and lesbian women doing it. Twenty years ago it wasn't a thing, now it is.

Family and society is changing that we are becoming so disconnected with what is biological and what science can create.

Men will be implanted with cervix's before long and bleeding.

SparklyBlackKitten · 26/04/2023 00:39

Sounds like your hatred has some subconscious roots in jealousy tbh.

merrymelodies · 26/04/2023 00:33

I frankly don't see surrogacy as a problem if the woman carrying the baby is happy to do it.

dailytalk · 26/04/2023 00:33

LottiePa · 25/04/2023 23:55

OP - what if it was not the surrogate egg that was used? Then the baby is not hers in anyway biologically speaking, she carried it yes but it is not her child. What’s your opinion then?

Surrogacy is the only way for some people to have their own biological children - I do frown upon celebrities who have their children via surrogate if they’re able to have their own children naturally but fundamentally I believe that as long as a child is loved, healthy, happy, safe and provided for and the surrogate is doing this of her own free will, then really it’s none of yours, or anyone else’s business.

For the posters saying a child needs it’s mother, even with a typical family set up this isn’t guaranteed, death, illness, divorce, poor relationships etc all can mean a child only has one parent or one present parent.

In the uk if if comes out of your vagina it's your legally and your husbands..... despite a doctor putting in say for comedy's sake a gay man's sperm who's from China and a donated egg from an African lady.... The white last that's just given birth to a mixed race black African and East Asian child, legally is the mother and her husband.

Derbee · 26/04/2023 00:30

Oddessa · 25/04/2023 20:24

Wow. It really shocks me when I come across such sickening views as yours OP.

You have children and yet you want to deny people that?

  • Their surrogate wasn’t forced into it
  • She could have had an abortion if she didn’t want to carry twins, it’s her body, her choice. Plus she’s legally the parent until she transfer parental rights.

I’m so glad I don’t know anyone like you in real life OP,

I find people like you who sanitise human trafficking under the name of surrogacy much more sickening.

dailytalk · 26/04/2023 00:29

Pearfacebananapoop · 26/04/2023 00:15

The whole "just expenses" thing is also so open to abuse here. I know a gay couple who openly told me they paid their surrogate £20k expenses + legals, here in the UK approx 7 years ago. Now I don't know about you but I certainly didn't incur £20k of expenses on me when pregnant.

You worked every day? £20k is far too little,

Luminousalumnus · 26/04/2023 00:27

Indeed they should not have children, unless they are committed to adoption or fostering. They should not be able to rent a surrogate in exactly the same way as m/f couples should not be able to rent a surrogate.

Pearfacebananapoop · 26/04/2023 00:15

The whole "just expenses" thing is also so open to abuse here. I know a gay couple who openly told me they paid their surrogate £20k expenses + legals, here in the UK approx 7 years ago. Now I don't know about you but I certainly didn't incur £20k of expenses on me when pregnant.

Ilovetea42 · 26/04/2023 00:07

MonsterChopz · 25/04/2023 20:23

I'm not a supporter of surrogacy but I do think it's naive to suggest adoption as if it's an obvious alternative. Adoption is not an easy journey to go on and is very, very different to parenting a child via surrogacy

This with bells on. Children in the care system are not ready waiting replacements for people who aren't able to have their own children for whatever the reason and its deeply unfair to promote this as an easy throwaway alternative. This attitude also encourages the type of adoption system present through private adoption where people with minimal training and vetting can pay huge amounts to buy a child who has been through trauma.

Plus the main issue I have with surrogacy is the effect on attachment it can have for the child. This same issue is inherently part of adoption. In terms of what women do with their bodies, I don't have a problem with surrogacy provided the woman is financially stable to begin with and contracts are drawn up ethically - I do think some women are in a position to consensually act as surrogate. I do think it isn't ideal for the child in question though.

GneissGuysFinishLast · 25/04/2023 23:56

First, not all miscarriages are physically difficult. I’ve had lots.
Miscarriages are just as emotionally difficult for both parents, aside from hormonal changes in the mother (which again, doesn’t happen all the time - I’ve had this in less than half my miscarriages)

If my best friend or sister could not carry to term; I’d be a surrogate for them in a heartbeat. No money would change hands.

Also, it’s a fallacy that the MOTHER needs to be the one to provide the newborns needs in the early days. If a child only has its mum provide care in the early days, then of course the baby will naturally prefer their mother. However; that care provider could just as easily be the father. There are studies which back this up. Anecdotally; both my children were easily settled by either me or my partner in the first weeks and months of life.

Rainpuddle · 25/04/2023 23:56

I think I struggle with surrogacy because I don't think having children is a 'right'. You're not entitled to rent a womb and buy a baby, you don't have a right to become a parent, especially if you have to endanger the life/health of a woman in the process. Having children is a privilege.

I'm fine with any medical procedure that involves your own body, as you're not involving a third party or endangering anyone else for your own wants/desires.

For those who say 'the surrogate wants to'... Well if you were offering someone a lot of money for their kidney, and they offer it to you for that price, it's still unethical to take it, even though they 'want to give you it'. Surrogacy is very exploitative of women, and a very slippery slope IMO.

MakesMeFeelSad · 25/04/2023 23:56

Why do people always compare it to puppies and kittens staying with their mum for 8 weeks

Ever hand reared a baby animal? No one wants to be bottle feeding, washing and stimulating their puppies/kittens so they can go to the loo every 2 hours day and night until they are weaned 🙄

LottiePa · 25/04/2023 23:55

OP - what if it was not the surrogate egg that was used? Then the baby is not hers in anyway biologically speaking, she carried it yes but it is not her child. What’s your opinion then?

Surrogacy is the only way for some people to have their own biological children - I do frown upon celebrities who have their children via surrogate if they’re able to have their own children naturally but fundamentally I believe that as long as a child is loved, healthy, happy, safe and provided for and the surrogate is doing this of her own free will, then really it’s none of yours, or anyone else’s business.

For the posters saying a child needs it’s mother, even with a typical family set up this isn’t guaranteed, death, illness, divorce, poor relationships etc all can mean a child only has one parent or one present parent.

Clymene · 25/04/2023 23:47

@dailytalk - an act of love? For who? Not for the child.

In surrogacy, a child has been created in order to be removed from its mother in order to satisfy an adult's wants. It's abhorrent in a civilised society. It's banned in most of Europe for good reason

Swipe left for the next trending thread