Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Made in Chelsea blokes - twins via surrogate

358 replies

HermioneKipper · 25/04/2023 19:39

More “celebs” commissioning a woman’s body to buy a baby.

When is this going to be made illegal 😡

And twins again. So many of them have twins. I think I get a bit triggered by this especially as I have twins and know how dangerous twin pregnancy can be for both mother and babies. And what it does to a woman’s body. No one could consent to this.

Had to switch off Giovanna Fletcher and her simpering podcast when they started talking about “their” miscarriages. Horrific amounts of bleeding, pain and horrendous wrenching emotional pain for you was it mates? No, didn’t think so.

OP posts:
FoodCentre · 26/04/2023 12:06

Also the emotional and psychological implications are potentially huge. You have no idea how you'd react to 'giving away' the baby you carried or the impact that would have on you for the rest of your life.

Most surrogacy stories in the media are news articles from the parents (with parental responsibility) POV, or documentaries with inspirational background music - also their POV

We rarely hear of when it goes wrong or any difficulties the surrogate mothers have. There must be physical and emotional repercussions, I don't believe it's all sweetness and rainbows. It's weirdly sanitised, at least the western commercial surrogacy market is.

KimberleyClark · 26/04/2023 11:39

00100001 · 26/04/2023 11:33

I think it's absolutely crackers that the mother of the child is also the grandmother.

It’s a reversal of what used to happen with teen pregnancies where the girl’s mother pretended the baby was hers and the child grew up not knowing their “sister” was in fact their mother.

KimberleyClark · 26/04/2023 11:34

00100001 · 26/04/2023 11:27

Fairly sure you can get all this without going "abroad"

Plenty of women do go abroad. Ukraine was a popular destination before the Russian invasion. Donor eggs are in short supply here which is why clinics have egg sharing schemes.

monsteramunch · 26/04/2023 11:34

@pontipinemum

What a staggeringly dangerous thing for her to have done, both for herself and the baby involved. Including rates of foetal mortality.

What about the fact her son chose a route to becoming a parent that directly places the child in question at greater risk of birth complications and death, due to his mum's age? Is that really a loving thing to do when it comes to creating a baby?

"The risk of pregnancy complications increases as the mother's age increases. Risks associated with childbearing over the age of 50 include an increased incidence of gestational diabetes, hypertension, delivery by caesarean section, miscarriage, preeclampsia, and placenta previa.[3][11] In comparison to mothers between 20 and 29 years of age, mothers over 50 are at almost three times the risk of low birth weight, premature birth, and extremely premature birth; their risk of extremely low birth weight, small size for gestational age, and fetal mortality was almost double.[12]"

00100001 · 26/04/2023 11:33

FoodCentre · 26/04/2023 11:25

Re the grandmother, there's nothing wrong with her motivations. It's still altruistic surrogacy and it's great that the baby status within the birth family unlike commercial surrogacy.

However, having a baby in your 50s is wild. Not even just turned 50, but in your fifties 😮

I think it's absolutely crackers that the mother of the child is also the grandmother.

00100001 · 26/04/2023 11:31

GneissGuysFinishLast · 26/04/2023 10:22

Most people who do it for free are doing it for a very close friend or family member. Personally I found pregnancy and birth totally fine, and I’d be happy to take the (actually very minimal) risks for someone I cared about, for free (aside maybe some expenses covered to give me a little extra time off beyond my employers maternity leave as it’s only 13 weeks and I’d have a c section)

You say 'minimal' risks. But you would actually be risking your life to do this, you're risking some decisions about your body being taken away from you, you're risking lifelong physical damage.

Also the emotional and psychological implications are potentially huge. You have no idea how you'd react to 'giving away' the baby you carried or the impact that would have on you for the rest of your life.

00100001 · 26/04/2023 11:27

KimberleyClark · 26/04/2023 10:31

Although it is ethically questionable if it involves going abroad for donor egg IVF in dodgy clinics in countries where poor young women are being targeted as egg donors.

Fairly sure you can get all this without going "abroad"

Weddingpuzzle · 26/04/2023 11:26

I can predict people born into this situation in two to three decades taking the individuals/organisations/clinics who facilitate this to the court of human rights. I would resent to my life being initiated on the background of a financial transaction and expolitation.

If this MIC couples children's biological mothers eggs are from Brazil there may be unconscious trauma from being denied the opportunity to understand and explore 50 per cent of their biological heritage and link to place of birth. They could also argue that being denied a link in early life course to their mother, their biological links and family and their heritage is emotional abuse as this was based on financial transactions not a decision to safeguard them. People aren't taking a long view of this at all. They just think 'baby' but that baby will have a life and a complex set of signals and thoughts surrounding how they came to be.

I was born to a 15 year old mother who nowadays would be seen to have experienced child sexual exploitation as my father is a good few years older than her. This is something I wrangle with. Being born to an exploited child bothers me. I have felt a level of guilt that I disrupted my mum's development and she was exploited - even though she has been a good Mum and has always made me feel loved, there has been an impact on me that I have subconsciously carried. Your beginnings are very important. People underestimate it.

FoodCentre · 26/04/2023 11:25

Re the grandmother, there's nothing wrong with her motivations. It's still altruistic surrogacy and it's great that the baby status within the birth family unlike commercial surrogacy.

However, having a baby in your 50s is wild. Not even just turned 50, but in your fifties 😮

Wishawisha · 26/04/2023 11:21

KimberleyClark · 26/04/2023 11:06

A mother having a baby for her daughter can’t be said to be truly altruistic as she is getting a grandchild out of it.

Is anything ever truly altruistic though? We do kind things for loved ones because it makes us feel good and because we like to see those people happy (and it makes us happy)…. Whether that means it’s ever the right thing to do is debatable though even if it’s making all the adults in the scenario feel happy.

pontipinemum · 26/04/2023 11:19

@TinaYouFatLard we will have to disagree on that so. I think she offered something unbelievable and he accepted.

@KimberleyClark true she got a grandchild from it. But in fairness how much in this world is ever 100% altruistic? I gave money when the earthquake hit in Turkey because I wanted to help but also because I felt awful there was nothing I could do for those people in real terms so threw money at it. It made me feel like I was able to do something, which made me feel better and less guilty. So it was not truly altruistic.
I see giving blood is quoted as an act of altruism, I give blood, yes I do mostly want to help people, but I also think well some day the person who needs it might be someone I love or me. So again there is a selfish undertone there.

monsteramunch · 26/04/2023 11:13

monsteramunch · 26/04/2023 11:03

@pontipinemum

What a staggeringly dangerous thing for her to have done, both for herself and the baby involved. Including rates of foetal mortality.

The risk of pregnancy complications increases as the mother's age increases. Risks associated with childbearing over the age of 50 include an increased incidence of gestational diabetes, hypertension, delivery by caesarean section, miscarriage, preeclampsia, and placenta previa.[3][11] In comparison to mothers between 20 and 29 years of age, mothers over 50 are at almost three times the risk of low birth weight, premature birth, and extremely premature birth; their risk of extremely low birth weight, small size for gestational age, and fetal mortality was almost double.[12]

And staggeringly selfish of her son, frankly.

ChestermanBeach · 26/04/2023 11:13

All surrogacy and egg and sperm donors should be banned. None of it is about the child. It’s just about selfish adults with entitled attitudes.

KimberleyClark · 26/04/2023 11:06

pontipinemum · 26/04/2023 10:56

I had a baby last summer. One lady in a group I was on was in her 50s was a surrogate for her DS and his wife. It was such an amazing selfless thing to do. The baby is biologically her granddaughter.

A mother having a baby for her daughter can’t be said to be truly altruistic as she is getting a grandchild out of it.

FanFckingTastic · 26/04/2023 11:04

I find commercial surrogacy abhorrent and de-humanising. As previous posters have said, you'll never find a rich women opting to be a surrogate, which speaks volumes to me.

What makes me most uncomfortable about commercial surrogacy is that the rights of the baby are right at the bottom of the pile, it's just a commodity to be bought.

TinaYouFatLard · 26/04/2023 11:03

pontipinemum · 26/04/2023 10:56

I had a baby last summer. One lady in a group I was on was in her 50s was a surrogate for her DS and his wife. It was such an amazing selfless thing to do. The baby is biologically her granddaughter.

And it’s unbelievably selfish of her DS to accept this risk to his mother in her 50s.

monsteramunch · 26/04/2023 11:03

@pontipinemum

What a staggeringly dangerous thing for her to have done, both for herself and the baby involved. Including rates of foetal mortality.

The risk of pregnancy complications increases as the mother's age increases. Risks associated with childbearing over the age of 50 include an increased incidence of gestational diabetes, hypertension, delivery by caesarean section, miscarriage, preeclampsia, and placenta previa.[3][11] In comparison to mothers between 20 and 29 years of age, mothers over 50 are at almost three times the risk of low birth weight, premature birth, and extremely premature birth; their risk of extremely low birth weight, small size for gestational age, and fetal mortality was almost double.[12]

Wishawisha · 26/04/2023 11:03

*Wow. It really shocks me when I come across such sickening views as yours OP.

I’m so glad I don’t know anyone like you in real life OP*

Re this - I really don’t think support for surrogacy is so universal that it’s unusual to meet someone in real life who disagrees with surrogacy. I know someone who used a surrogate as a single man who simply wanted a child (parenting done 90% by a stream of nannies). Perhaps this is unusual, I don’t know. I suspect most people disagree with what he has done but no one is going to come out and say it, especially as a lot of people I know know him through work and surely it would be a disciplinary offence to say something so confrontational. People just don’t say anything.

I also disagree that gay men are being discriminated against (other than by biology). A heterosexual couple that meets later in life are “discriminated” against in the same way. It’s not discrimination, it’s just biology. I know a lesbian couple who had a child via a sperm donor - yes they managed to have a child, but the child is only biologically related to one of them and it’s impossible to produce a child related to both partners - this isn’t discrimination, it’s just life.

pontipinemum · 26/04/2023 10:56

DyslexicPoster · 25/04/2023 21:09

How would feel if a woman had a baby for her daughter or sister and no money changed hands?

I had a baby last summer. One lady in a group I was on was in her 50s was a surrogate for her DS and his wife. It was such an amazing selfless thing to do. The baby is biologically her granddaughter.

pansiesinmygarden · 26/04/2023 10:53

YANBU OP

They shouldn't be implanting two embryos either

TinaYouFatLard · 26/04/2023 10:50

I think even truly altruistic surrogacy has major potential for exploitation. Imagine the pressure put on a woman to make her sister/friend/brother’s dream come true. These decisions aren’t made in a vacuum and women are conditioned to be kind, agreeable and put others first.

I have a lovely family member who would do this in an instant for a friend. She is extremely kind and a people-pleaser to a damaging (to herself) degree. She is always seeking the approval of others and is desperate for the good opinion of people around her.

We can only protect all women if this was completely outlawed.

fryanddry · 26/04/2023 10:48

this is going to make me sound horrible but ive noticed alot of gay couples, when they break up they lose interest in the child they adopted..

HermioneKipper · 26/04/2023 10:47

GneissGuysFinishLast · 26/04/2023 10:22

Most people who do it for free are doing it for a very close friend or family member. Personally I found pregnancy and birth totally fine, and I’d be happy to take the (actually very minimal) risks for someone I cared about, for free (aside maybe some expenses covered to give me a little extra time off beyond my employers maternity leave as it’s only 13 weeks and I’d have a c section)

Would you really?

Are you aware the complications are likely to be much higher if the egg implanted is not yours?

Do you agree with celebs putting multiple eggs back increasing chances of multiple births?

OP posts:
ClematisWren · 26/04/2023 10:44

Nobody has a right to have a child. Yes, it's very sad that some men and women who want them are unable to have biological children, but that doesn't mean that their wants should trump the health and wellbeing of other human beings.

I'm against commercial surrogacy, because in the vast majority of cases there is a significant power divide between the surrogate and the purchasing 'parents'. I see it as little different to prostitution in the way that it objectifies women.

I've heard male gay friends talking about 'ordering a baby' in a way that was completely dismissive of what pregnancy and birth actually entails. Pregnancy remains the most significant risk to health/life that most younger women will experience.

It's a different thing if a woman chooses for altruistic reasons to carry a child for friends/family members, with no financial incentive.

KimberleyClark · 26/04/2023 10:31

FoodCentre · 26/04/2023 09:54

Currently buying one with my ivf 😘

Assisted conception is nothing like commercial surrogacy

Although it is ethically questionable if it involves going abroad for donor egg IVF in dodgy clinics in countries where poor young women are being targeted as egg donors.