Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family member has planned 2nd wedding to coincide with our baby's 1st birthday.

212 replies

saythatagaintome · 25/04/2023 19:16

I'm trying to be the bigger person, and was doing so well at it until my husband suggested we celebrate our first child's FIRST birthday on another day. I basically said that wasn't happening. I told him HE can chose to attend the wedding and skip out on our baby's First if that is what HE choses to do. For his sake I hope the times don't coincide.

I am planning her bday as an open house type of party, where friends can pop by in the late am for tea, and then meet us at a nearby beach for late lunch. I was planning on taking that day to celebrate our baby and us for making it through the first year, alive and well.

The couple in question eloped some months back. They are generally secretive people, and seem to like to keep family members at arms length. We wouldn't have even known that they had been planning to marry had my husband not asked them.
To be fair, we don't have much details other than the fact that they have chosen that day to celebrate their union.

They just sent the family thread a text asking us to "save the date." I know I don't own that date, I'm just peeved my husband seems to think that we should celebrate this very important milestone on a different day, when it's been known for weeks that we are planning a small party to celebrate her 1st as well as our first year as parents (and before you say "first bdays are for the parents", yes you're correct! it's OUR First).

Some context: this family member (middle son) is a sibling to my husband (who's the younger son, and boycotted our wedding some years back. My husband and I are a mixed race couple and I have always felt that he hasn't ever valued me as a person. I mention the race dynamic because it very much was relevant at the time.

We (BIL and I) aren't close at all, but are very civil with one another. He and my husband have a relationship, but it's taken many years of repair (we were extremely hurt over the wedding situation, which lead to years of not talking to one another).

AIBU? to be peeved that they've chosen this day? More so, AIBU to be upset at my husband for suggestion that our baby's First bday isn't as big of a deal, and should be planned AROUND family members 2nd wedding celebration?

and re the family thread text that was sent to everyone: No one replied to it, when they shared the date. My MIL also mentioned to my husband this am "They planned their wedding celebration on the baby's first bday---"

I'm going to remain stoic, but I do plan on moving forward with planning the day I'm envisioning. And as I wrote previously, hopefully the times don't clash for my husbands sake.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GoodChat · 26/04/2023 11:17

saythatagaintome · 26/04/2023 11:12

Nasty, @Liorae !

I thought the same. Just unnecessary.

saythatagaintome · 26/04/2023 11:12

Nasty, @Liorae !

OP posts:
Strawberrydelight78 · 26/04/2023 11:03

Same with our family even if it's just a meal out now they're older. They would at least know the month the baby was born. The grandparents want a celebration so obviously know the date. They could have checked with them.

Blondeshavemorefun · 26/04/2023 10:32

So both can happen. Theirs starts at 4 going into evening

Yours is lunchtime /afternoon

Are they popping into the 1st birthday party or not coming at all

Liorae · 26/04/2023 09:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

RoseFl0wers · 26/04/2023 08:24

Soontobe60 · 26/04/2023 06:27

This!

There is absolutely nothing in your post that points to your BIL being racist, apart from you saying you’re mixed race. You said he didn’t come to your wedding, but you didn’t say why. You also said he’s always civil. You also said you’re a mixed race couple, so surely that means your BIL is also mixed race?

You sound completely wacky!

OP probably meant ‘interracial couple’ as in her DH is a different race to OP. This isn’t a wedding and the BIL is racist so I don’t blame OP for not wanting to go, especially when the party is on the same day as her baby’s first birthday.

OhMerde · 26/04/2023 08:10

You think an evening costume and cocktails party isn't fancy? What do you think is fancy then?

Sailingaround · 26/04/2023 08:02

user1492757084 · 26/04/2023 05:59

It's not their wedding but they want to share the celebration.
Your husband needs to phone and have an actual conversation with his brother.
Did he realise there was already a special occasion on that date? etc. A polite discussion.
It might be that they are planning a very simple meet up that can easily be changed to the evening.

I don't think people committ to memory other people's children's birthdays so I wouldn't take offence.

I would start from a position of respect to family and a hope that there will be an ongoing close relationship.

I know my goddaughters birthday and all her siblings birthdays too. As well as a few of my other close friends kids birthdays.
I don’t know how many nieces the BIL has but considering this one is only little and was recently born I’d expect him to know. and if he doesn’t, considering his self confessed prejudice and history of treating non-white family members poorly it’s even more disappointing.

Apparently there will be no clash anyway but
it will be hard for Op to be close to someone who is racist and still “working through bias” as he calls it. Sounds like it will be hard for BIL too since he couldn’t even bring himself to attend the wedding.

Emotionalstorm · 26/04/2023 07:57

I wouldn't care and work just celebrate it another day but you're entitled to your feelings.

Sailingaround · 26/04/2023 07:55

You also said he’s always civil. You also said you’re a mixed race couple, so surely that means your BIL is also mixed race?

I think Op meant she’s in an inter-racial marriage but yes the way it’s worded could also mean her husband is mixed race which apparently isn’t the case judging from rest of her posts.

OP,I’m glad there’s not going to be a clash after all but personally I am uncomfortable your husband would continue a close relationship with his racist brother and consider prioritising any of their events over your family events . You say he’s educated himself etc but I think he needs to do more work to see that minimising racism and giving racist family/friends a pass is literally a central reason why racism lives on. (Especially in America if that’s where you are)

It’s not “kindness” it’s quietly enabling a racist, and it basically means deep down racism doesn’t shock him as much as it should hence he can continue this relationship.

I know many people who have racists in their family, but few if any would be so extreme to be a no-show for their siblings wedding to a POC. This is more than some “bias” as your BIL describes it. My white friends would have little if anything to do with an immediate family member if they were racist to that extreme.

For the person who questioned how one sibling can be racist, I can totally believe one sibling is overtly racist and others aren’t - it happens a lot. And not saying OP’s husband is racist but marrying a POC doesn’t necessarily mean someone is NOT racist anyway.

Namechange1345677 · 26/04/2023 07:53

OK. 2 separate things. 1. They are racist.

  1. No one likes baby parties. .no one even knows your baby's birthday except your very very close family.

Wedding > birthday

Beautiful3 · 26/04/2023 07:52

I get how you feel because it's the baby's 1st birthday. You bil is already married as he eloped, so it isn't a wedding but a party right? I would message back saying, sorry we can't make that date as we're having baby's 1st birthday party that day. However be prepared that many from that side of the family, might not come. If you feel that you can still run the party without that side, then go ahead.

Nimbostratus100 · 26/04/2023 07:44

Victoria69c · 26/04/2023 04:35

Your baby is only 1 once. You do the best for your child. If your husband wants to go to his brothers wedding party. Politely tell him to tell his brother he will be there after he has celebrated his child's big day. I'm sure if it was the other way around his brother would have to be telling your husband the same. Never allow anyone to take from your child. They grow up to fast you'll never be able to get that day back. U can't do it again. They eloped for a reason. Happy 1st birthday to your little one.

o come on, a first birthday party is never what's best for the child, and it isn't even what's best for the parents, particularly when number 2 comes along, and they feel they HAVE to do the same, or it looks unfair in the family photo album, then number 3, and they wonder why they did this terrible thing to themselves!

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 26/04/2023 07:33

Your bil is racist, so for that reason I wouldn't go. However if he is genuinely repentant about his past treatment of you, then its truly your decision whether you accept him back into your life.
It wouldn't have occurred to me that I had double booked a baby's 1st birthday, of a sibling I was close too, unless I had been specifically invited to a party. You said you aren't close to your BIL, so it wouldn't have been on his radar.
I do understand why you are hurt. My dc's big religious event looked like it was going to clash with a family wedding, and all of my family made it clear that the wedding would take priority.

Sceptre86 · 26/04/2023 07:18

For my kids first birthdays dh and I did something fun with the baby on their birthday but had parties at the weekend, although ds's first birthday party was on his actual birthday as it was a Saturday.

I have been to a wedding on my son's birthday (5th so not quite the same as his first). The groom was my cousin and he got all the guests to sing happy birthday to my son and gave him a little gift. Any chance your bil would do the same and acknowledge your child? Could it be this is a strange way to offer you an olive branch?

If not then no I wouldn't go but based on the racism more than anything else. You could be shooting yourself in the foot by keeping the birthday on that date as surely any other siblings will attend and your mil or fil, grandparents etc. You could also do the birthday open house earlier in the day to accommodate people who want to go to both events assuming it's in the same city.

ShandaLear · 26/04/2023 07:07

Turn it on its head. Reply ‘Brilliant idea, thanks for the invite and we’ll be there will bells on. It’s baby Ermintrude’s first birthday that day so it’ll be a great opportunity to celebrate that too with so many family and friends. I hope you don’t mind if we bring a small cake and candles, and some balloons, to share later in the afternoon. I know grandma Mildred would be so excited’.

Dedodee · 26/04/2023 06:59

OctopusComplex · 25/04/2023 23:14

You laboured without drugs. This means you had an uneventful birth. Why did you bring this into the thread?

Really!
I laboured without drugs for my 2nd because the midwives refused to believe I was in labour until 30 minutes before dd was born. I wouldn’t describe my dd’s birth as uneventful.

Sleepyandconfused · 26/04/2023 06:43

You’re being SO unreasonable but it’s funny because I was exactly the same with my first and can totally imagine myself reacting the same way 😂 It’s a first birthday for goodness sake! The baby has NO idea that it is their birthday and they definitely don’t need a party and any celebration is only for the parents and doesn’t benefit or even affect the baby in any way! Of course you should attend a family member’s wedding! Your child will have many other birthdays that they will actually remember. If you insist on having a party, of course you can have it on another day. This is so ridiculous but also I feel for you because I was totally like this. I cringe looking back on it now and I’m sure you will too!

YoBeaches · 26/04/2023 06:39

I think no matter who's birthday it is or how old they are going to be, it is always bad form to plan a major event on a very close family Members birthday, without at least discussing first. Like "really sorry this is the only date we can get for the venue we want would you be ok with it? "

First birthdays are a major
Milestone for first time
MimsX it's normal to feel the way you do. We just don't know whether it was intentional or not so assume it's. It and have your dh explain that you can't make it because you have plans.

Summerfun54321 · 26/04/2023 06:31

It's totally fine to want to celebrate your baby's birthday in a way that reflects your culture. But if your BIL is British then us brits don't put a lot of importance on first birthdays and even if he had known there was a clash, wouldn't have thought much of it. This sounds more like a culture clash than intentional racism.

Soontobe60 · 26/04/2023 06:27

Irritateandunreasonable · 25/04/2023 19:37

My gosh - it’s almost like these peoples life’s (that you have very little to do with) don’t revolve around you 🤣

Is this a weekend day? If LO was 1 on a Thursday would you still refuse to celebrate on another day.

This isn’t about your baby, they have no idea what’s going on. You’re making your babies bday about you, you’re not a victim here, neither is your baby, stop being so silly and self centred.

This!

There is absolutely nothing in your post that points to your BIL being racist, apart from you saying you’re mixed race. You said he didn’t come to your wedding, but you didn’t say why. You also said he’s always civil. You also said you’re a mixed race couple, so surely that means your BIL is also mixed race?

You sound completely wacky!

readbooksdrinktea · 26/04/2023 06:16

Movinghousehelp · 25/04/2023 19:24

I think you’re being a bit OTT in the way you are describing the importance of your baby’s birthday - it really isn’t that big a deal to anyone but you. I presume it has happened to fall on a weekend day, if it hadn’t you’d have probably celebrated on a different day?

Having said that I don’t doubt that your BIL is a dick head from what you have said here. So YABU and YANBU.

Agree with this.

GoodChat · 26/04/2023 06:06

user1492757084 · 26/04/2023 05:59

It's not their wedding but they want to share the celebration.
Your husband needs to phone and have an actual conversation with his brother.
Did he realise there was already a special occasion on that date? etc. A polite discussion.
It might be that they are planning a very simple meet up that can easily be changed to the evening.

I don't think people committ to memory other people's children's birthdays so I wouldn't take offence.

I would start from a position of respect to family and a hope that there will be an ongoing close relationship.

OP's said it doesn't start til 4 so there won't necessarily be a clash

user1492757084 · 26/04/2023 05:59

It's not their wedding but they want to share the celebration.
Your husband needs to phone and have an actual conversation with his brother.
Did he realise there was already a special occasion on that date? etc. A polite discussion.
It might be that they are planning a very simple meet up that can easily be changed to the evening.

I don't think people committ to memory other people's children's birthdays so I wouldn't take offence.

I would start from a position of respect to family and a hope that there will be an ongoing close relationship.

Victoria69c · 26/04/2023 04:35

Your baby is only 1 once. You do the best for your child. If your husband wants to go to his brothers wedding party. Politely tell him to tell his brother he will be there after he has celebrated his child's big day. I'm sure if it was the other way around his brother would have to be telling your husband the same. Never allow anyone to take from your child. They grow up to fast you'll never be able to get that day back. U can't do it again. They eloped for a reason. Happy 1st birthday to your little one.

Swipe left for the next trending thread