Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband sent cringy email to recruiter. If you’re a recruiter would this put you off?

269 replies

Winterleaves1 · 25/04/2023 17:20

My husband is a qualified doctor but not eligible to work in the U.K. at the moment as he has exams to complete specific to the U.K.
While he’s studying for his exams I work in clinical trials and found a job that would be perfect for him. He’s Indian and has good English but doesn’t know how to word job applications so I helped him with the application. It took two hours as it was really long and I wanted to make sure it was spot on. I submitted the application for him. I have no connection with the employer at all. I just work in a similar field.
He came back to me and said the job application has an email for an informal chat or to ask any questions. He said he would email to introduce himself and let the manager know he is interested in the position.
Now I know in some countries this may be seen as proactive and increase your chances but I know from my managers opinion it’s been seen as annoying and socially awkward. It has definitely put them off and generally made them think the applicant didn’t understand British culture and wouldn’t fit in well within the team. Bit harsh but I’m just going by what their reaction has been when someone has done this.
They’ve also said the email should only be used for questions as the managers are busy and may have many applications where they are the manager and need their inbox clear. It’s also just not a ‘done thing’ here. I explained all this to him and told him it could negatively affect his chances of getting the job.
Well today I’m reading emails on our joint email account and he’s sent this email
‘Dear miss xxxxx,
i am writing to let you know I am very interested in your position and have completed the application. I think my skills and experience matches job well. Please consider my application’.
I know that this manager is married but no title was given so ‘miss’ was inappropriate. Also his grammar and English wasn’t the best in the email.

I’m really annoyed because the application was really strong and while he may not have got an interview I’d have at least felt that we’d given it our best shot. I feel this cringy email has really ruined his chance at an interview and will be viewed negatively.
If it was just this one application I could forget about it but it seems that he refuses to take my advice and I am sure he will continue sending an email to managers for all jobs he applies for moving forwards.
I know I sound really mean. I promise I’m not, just trying to help him as o know he wants to be in work.
So AIBU to think this email has affected his chances? If you are responsible for recruiting would this put you off? I’m hoping I’m overthinking.

OP posts:
User339406 · 25/04/2023 17:49

I'd probably just ignore it. I might think "oh this guy is a bit keen" but I wouldn't write him off. Equally I wouldn't go and dig out his application and move it to the top of the pile becauae hes sent an extra email, I'd just review his application or cv in the same way as all the others.
I would assume he wasn't a native English speaker from his use of Miss but again I wouldn't let that stop me interviewing him if his application was decent.
You're over-thinking. It won't make or break his application.

StandUpForYourRights · 25/04/2023 17:48

TheSaturdayAfternoonnessOfIt · 25/04/2023 17:46

The main problem is it's too generic, and the poor grammar makes it sound like something sent by a spam bot.

I'm not trying to criticise your husband's English - that's a sight better than I'd manage in any other language - just trying to be honest about the impression it would give.

He needs to name the position and highlight one or two key skills he has that would make him a good match. Not War and Peace but: 'As a qualified doctor, I have clinical experience that would make me an excellent fit for this role' - type of thing.

That all needs to go into the supporting statement. Additional information / CVs etc often don't get anywhere near the recruiting manager

murasaki · 25/04/2023 17:48

But the fit re skills should be covered in the application.

TheSaturdayAfternoonnessOfIt · 25/04/2023 17:46

The main problem is it's too generic, and the poor grammar makes it sound like something sent by a spam bot.

I'm not trying to criticise your husband's English - that's a sight better than I'd manage in any other language - just trying to be honest about the impression it would give.

He needs to name the position and highlight one or two key skills he has that would make him a good match. Not War and Peace but: 'As a qualified doctor, I have clinical experience that would make me an excellent fit for this role' - type of thing.

Shoelacesundone · 25/04/2023 17:45

I've lived and recruited in both India and the UK. The entire cultural norms are very different.

I think in as far as you can help your understand there's no better way, just two different ways, and avoid words like "cringy" etc the easier it is for him to not feel criticised and like has a choice to your insight to adapt to a different way.

In India that would be an entirely appropriate email.

murasaki · 25/04/2023 17:45

Yep, an email for further info is fine, this one would annoy me and I'd remember when it came to shortlisting

TrueScrumptious · 25/04/2023 17:44

DH was an NHS manager for quite a while. It is fine, even expected, for applicants to send an email asking for further information or even to have a brief meeting. Job adverts often say to contact xx for more information. The email your DH has sent, though, doesn’t ask about those, so it is a bit cringey.

StandUpForYourRights · 25/04/2023 17:43

literalviolence · 25/04/2023 17:41

I can match up anonymity emails. I don't try to but when only one applicant went to uni in India and the name on the email is clearly Indian, it doesn't take much analytical thinking! I always think you can just tell people not to call people miss though so thats kind of language, which in the UK assuming people are a miss can seem a little sexist, does not mean they're not the best candidate.

Yes I can too. But I tend not to waste my time doing so and just delete as they come in. I always shortlist online these days so won't be thinking about who rung me / emailed me generally

Winterleaves1 · 25/04/2023 17:43

murasaki · 25/04/2023 17:43

I see both his point and yours, but he sounds new to the UK job market, so should maybe listen to you a bit more? It may work differently in India, I don't know.

It’s common practice in India.

OP posts:
AP5Diva · 25/04/2023 17:43

Sending an email note isn’t a bad thing when contact info has been provided. I agree I’d do a covering letter style one and perhaps tailor it to the position you’re applying for so it’s not a stock generic email. I’d change the Miss to Ms.

I don’t think any honest manager would bin a strong application if they got that email. I think you’re being a bit over-sensitive.

Winterleaves1 · 25/04/2023 17:43

tinatsarina · 25/04/2023 17:41

I mean he's gonna be working as a Dr in the future so I wouldn't be worrying.

I’m about two years. I’m on maternity leave soon and we really really need him to work. So it’s very important and probably the reason I’m stressing so much.

OP posts:
murasaki · 25/04/2023 17:43

I see both his point and yours, but he sounds new to the UK job market, so should maybe listen to you a bit more? It may work differently in India, I don't know.

literalviolence · 25/04/2023 17:42

Overall OP, your advice is sound. It would drive me nuts that he won't listen!

Winterleaves1 · 25/04/2023 17:41

murasaki · 25/04/2023 17:38

I don't necessarily think sending an email is bad (saying that, I'd note it as a recruiter and would be wary, but other industries may vary) but that email was bad, both in terms of title for the recruiter and grammar. I'd definitely look askance at that one. If he's going to do it in future, can you sense check it for him?

He’s insisting he’s going to continue to do it. Nothing I can do. It’s his job search so I’m leaving him to it now.
I have offered my support and will help with applications but can’t do anything else as he’s an adult.

OP posts:
literalviolence · 25/04/2023 17:41

StandUpForYourRights · 25/04/2023 17:37

Even if the email has been sent, the recruiting manager won't be able to match it to an application as they come through for shortlisting anonymised. Personally I would just delete an email like that.

The application will stand or it's own merit (or not as the case may be) so I wouldn't worry about it.

I can match up anonymity emails. I don't try to but when only one applicant went to uni in India and the name on the email is clearly Indian, it doesn't take much analytical thinking! I always think you can just tell people not to call people miss though so thats kind of language, which in the UK assuming people are a miss can seem a little sexist, does not mean they're not the best candidate.

tinatsarina · 25/04/2023 17:41

I mean he's gonna be working as a Dr in the future so I wouldn't be worrying.

murasaki · 25/04/2023 17:40

@literalviolence is right, it shouldn't matter , but if it came to a tie break as to who to interview, it.might come into play.

Irritateandunreasonable · 25/04/2023 17:40

You’re being ridiculous, patronising and controlling.

EmbracingTheEyeBags · 25/04/2023 17:40

I recruit and this wouldn't bother me in fact it would show willingness and eagerness so I'd likely go ahead and interview and see how it went with him then 😊

burnoutbabe · 25/04/2023 17:39

i'd assume that email was from someone applying for a very low level job/their first job.

anyone more senior, IF they sent this email, would include something about WHY they are a good fit at least.

this is pointless. it won't win anyone over and could damage his chances.

Winterleaves1 · 25/04/2023 17:39

Woodywoodpeckerharrison · 25/04/2023 17:36

Yes as a hiring manager this email would put me off. I feel similar when applicants what have not yet been approached try to connect with me on LinkedIn. I'm a friendly person but find this too much when I have a lot going on and many applicants.

That’s the thing. It will put many managers off and I guess is ‘personal preference’.
so best not do is as you won’t rule yourself out from the ones that don’t like it

OP posts:
murasaki · 25/04/2023 17:38

I don't necessarily think sending an email is bad (saying that, I'd note it as a recruiter and would be wary, but other industries may vary) but that email was bad, both in terms of title for the recruiter and grammar. I'd definitely look askance at that one. If he's going to do it in future, can you sense check it for him?

literalviolence · 25/04/2023 17:38

I mean I will respond to specific queries but I don't factor emails like this into decision making.

literalviolence · 25/04/2023 17:37

When I get emails like this I think stop wasting my time and you don't understand equal equalities recruiting. The miss would be a red flag. That said, it is all about the application form and ignore everything else until interview.

Woodywoodpeckerharrison · 25/04/2023 17:37

*that have not (auto correct)!

Swipe left for the next trending thread