Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that mumsnetters are getting more mean?

59 replies

UnhappyFan · 25/04/2023 16:43

I joined mumsnet about two years ago and while mumsnetters weren’t always a barrel of sunshine they generally seemed to give honest, sincere and genuinely helpful replies and always seemed to have the well being off OP at heart even if what they said was a difficult pill to swallow.

That’s why I loved mumsnet. You could get away from all the online BS here and talk to honest helpful people who aren’t going to coddle me or use kid gloves when giving advice. They would just cut straight to the chase.

Now though things don’t seem to be about constructive criticism or even anything remotely helpful anymore. It really seems to me like mumsnet has changed for the worst.

Some of it I think are trolls. They are expected and in every forum. But some of it I really think I see as a cultural shift on mumsnet.

Many mumsnetters really only seem interested in testing at OP’s throats merely for the sake of tearing the person down or intentionally trying to get them to take down the thread.

Here is my most recent example.
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/relationships/4792379-34-weeks-pregnant-and-we-just-found-out-he-has-another-child?page=1

A new mother who went through several rounds of IVF and lost several pregnancies found out that the love of her life had another adult child that even he didn’t know about. OP said that it was very painful to discover particularly because of the timing as she is heavily pregnant with her first child.

The first solid wall of comments were generally unhelpful and instead of providing support or advice they only criticized her for expressing her pain and emotional struggle with this.

Am I being unreasonable to think that mumsnet has gotten more unfriendly in the last few years or is it I that has changed?

34 weeks pregnant and we just found out he has another child | Mumsnet

My husband and I have been together 6 years and we're expecting our first child next month. I'm so happy to be pregnant as it was a difficult journey...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/relationships/4792379-34-weeks-pregnant-and-we-just-found-out-he-has-another-child?page=1

OP posts:
Arewehumanorarewecupboards · 25/04/2023 18:13

Desperatelyseekingbunny · 25/04/2023 17:46

Well, my son lost his toy rabbit yesterday and the kindness of mumsnetters has been overwhelming. I have a replacement thanks to people going above and beyond to track down a replica so I have nothing but admiration.

There are definitely some amazing people here too. It’s not all bad.

anon666 · 25/04/2023 18:04

I agree. I've been around since about 2005 when my daughter was born and it wasn't as toxic about "issues" as it is now. Everyone seems more polarised.

The internet as a whole has gone very ranty and polarised, I wonder if it's going to collapse in on itself when we all decide we can't be arsed with it all.

nixnjj · 25/04/2023 17:53

I'm glad you started this. I fucked up massively today, made a post which as soon as pointed out how it came across said sorry and was banned before i could explain further. Behind scenes were fantastic, explained that I had had a very unexpected death in the very close family 3hrs sleep in 3 days and between irrational anger and desperate for some positivity and my worrying about the pedants and grammar cause something that was supposed to be one thing looked like something totally different.

I've been a member here for years and it does ebb and flow and to be honest I think it reflects the general feeling of people in general. There is also such a wide range of people, life styles and finances and the gap is getting bigger. I despair of post from single parents struggling and someone suggests a nice lunch and a hair cut and i know the reality of the situation she's probably missing breakfast and lunch already to make sure the kids are ok. Or someone who is nasty and rude in a post but the realty is she is in a toxic relationship and can't leave because they know kids lifestyle will hit the floor.

stayathomer · 25/04/2023 17:49

I honestly believe that am in general is a place where people click in quickly, grab what they want to, and let rip their own opinions. Mn is the ultimate eg and I’ve done it myself- something is driving me nuts, I see a thread about it, and offload my crap day on some poor unsuspecting op! But there are honestly also lovely lovely people on mn, in all sections and even aibu (saying that there’s topics I steer clear from, as people seem to want you to be wrong on them!)

Katherine1985 · 25/04/2023 17:49

Irritateandunreasonable · 25/04/2023 17:43

MN don’t do enough to control the vile things posters say imo.

Yes I agree more should/could be done

Katherine1985 · 25/04/2023 17:46

Compared to a few years ago I’d be less likely to post for advice or support about a really serious issue now. Those who have been here a while are used to the picking holes in first post, the minimising, gaslighting, judgement etc, but if someone joins to make a first post about something serious it could be so off putting. But overall there are still enough amazingly insightful and validating posts for me to stay here apart from taking a break sometimes

Desperatelyseekingbunny · 25/04/2023 17:46

Well, my son lost his toy rabbit yesterday and the kindness of mumsnetters has been overwhelming. I have a replacement thanks to people going above and beyond to track down a replica so I have nothing but admiration.

SeulementUneFois · 25/04/2023 17:44

Fully agree with you OP - some people were basically vicious on that thread.

I've had something similar - I've NC'd now, but on a previous username I shared that my DP was abused for a decade (domestic abuse)...And well the thread turned into a trial of my DP, and how the abusive ex must have been justified.
Disturbing.

Irritateandunreasonable · 25/04/2023 17:43

MN don’t do enough to control the vile things posters say imo.

KTheGrey · 25/04/2023 17:42

What gets me is that there are a lot of very daft pieces of advice. Yes, I find it's nastier, but mainly there seem to be a lot of posters who make very emphatic statements that are ridiculously daft.

PuffinPuffinPenguin · 25/04/2023 17:38

I think it comes and goes as well. I've been so upset by the behaviour and MNHQ's inability to moderate obvious personal attacks and even blatant ablism/racism at times that I've deregistered a few times in a flounce but then it seems to calm down again and I re-register. When you've been here a while you start to realise it comes in waves.
I wouldn't touch Legal Matters with a bargepole atm though that place seems to be full of people with zero legal advice who just want to tear others down.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 25/04/2023 17:37

I think it's always going to be the same, where you get a huge cross-section of the population commenting. Some will be helpful, some will just commiserate, some will be less than pleasant and other will wade in shouting about how much better they are than everyone else.

I actually came off MN for a couple of years (I flounced, I admit it!) because people were laying into me for expressing surprise at something financial. I live on an absolute shoestring, and was basically told to get a better job if I wanted more money (which isn't possible, for various reasons). Like I'm living my dream life but don't have much money, and it seemed certain people were jealous that I can do what I want!

magma32 · 25/04/2023 17:35

I agree, there a few threads like that on active atm, berating pregnant or new mothers who are stressed out. When I first joined mumsnet and even after there was a lot of support, a nice community of women advising, many times tough love was given but in a nice way if that makes sense. I dare not post about things now. I’d say in the last 6 months or so but then I haven’t been on it consistently. In addition to women being vile when things could be said politely I think the site attracts a lot more men who just want to be ***s to women. And of course trolls.

JaffaCake70 · 25/04/2023 17:30

Ponoka7 · 25/04/2023 16:50

It is a lot less supportive. I don't think that they are genuine opinions, because when challenged, they never reply. The thread were the OP was supposed to look for parking while her child struggled to breathe was incredible.

I was shocked by that thread too, glad it wasn't just me.

Lwrenagain · 25/04/2023 17:28

alaran · 25/04/2023 17:23

AIBU attracts a lot of bitter, miserable women and possibly quite a few with mental health problems. This is very evident in any thread about SAHMs - it's the same few posters trolling every time. Their so-called 'concern' about SAHMs is bordering on pathological. Also any thread about 'high earners' will also go to 1000 posts (with a lot of nastiness / jealousy thrown in) which says a lot about how disgruntled people are in the U.K. in general.

I often see things and think to myself... I fucking hope that's a troll because the words are so cruel.

That's when it's not fun to be apart of an online forum

Coffeeandbourbons · 25/04/2023 17:27

There’s an awful lot of moral posturing on here, people saying they would ‘LTB’ at the drop of a hat, or not park in a disabled space at A&E if their child was gasping for breath in anaphylactic shock and it was the closest one. They wouldn’t - they’re just competing to appear the most moral and correct.

The human condition is such that we all have feelings we ‘shouldn’t do’ but are perfectly natural to have - anger towards the OW (‘blame the man’ they shriek, like you can’t hate them both!), jealousy of people with more money or seemingly easier lives, shock and upset that your husband has a grown child he previously knew nothing about.

I think good posters are the ones who can admit they would feel the same even if it wasn’t the ‘correct’ way to feel, but then give advice about how they can move towards the ‘correct’ feelings. But they’re quite rare.

Even worse are the armchair detectives who desperately search for some minor detail to rubbish the OP’s version of events (‘You say you were carrying 3 items to the car? I call bull shit on this whole thing, there’s no way you could carry all that at once. It was two trips was it? Well, what else are you lying about?’). They’re frankly just mind numbing and their sense of superiority and self congratulatory attitude is just so boring and unlikable.

alaran · 25/04/2023 17:23

AIBU attracts a lot of bitter, miserable women and possibly quite a few with mental health problems. This is very evident in any thread about SAHMs - it's the same few posters trolling every time. Their so-called 'concern' about SAHMs is bordering on pathological. Also any thread about 'high earners' will also go to 1000 posts (with a lot of nastiness / jealousy thrown in) which says a lot about how disgruntled people are in the U.K. in general.

Lwrenagain · 25/04/2023 17:23

I joined for a particular forum on here where the posters are truly amazing.
Then I got sucked into aibu and it's a weird place, for sure.

I started off quite cheery and willing to engage with people with respect even with differing views, less so now because you can say something that's just how you feel and you'll be shot down in flames.
It's quite cruel.

But today I've posted in aibu and had loads of useful replies and majority kind.

I think MN has some very strong minded people who don't really care about how they speak to people because there probably very rude in person.
That's on them. Fuck em.

It's not something to take personally but it's sad when people reach out in times of need to be piled on.

NaNaNaNaNaNaBaNaNa · 25/04/2023 17:19

It's always been a nest of vipers.

AIBU has always been the worst, because it attracts drama seekers (like me, not going to lie). Then it often takes a turn when threads get posted to social media (mumsnet posting to Facey for example) or people having a bad day get "set off" by something someone has said and they get on the defensive and start attacking. Then some people see that comment and agree with the take (even if the take is wrong) and the pile-on starts up that way. It's terrifying to be in the line of fire. 😅

Lifeomars · 25/04/2023 17:16

I've been quite shocked at some of the stuff I have read on here, comments that I very much doubt anyone would say to someone's face or at least I would like to hope so. I just don't understand what motivates people to troll, if I haven't got anything that I think is useful, helpful or constructive to say I don't join in. This is the way I conduct myself IRL too. I do ponder at what motives a total stranger to lash into another total stranger, I think the worst thing I have called someone on here is "daft" due to subscribing to the belief that the moon landings were fake but I would never ever tear into someone on an anonymous forum just for entertainment value.

artimesiasfootsteps · 25/04/2023 17:08

I agree too, I’ve also seen some awful ableist posters commenting on disabled or chronically ill posters threads.

I found the infertility corner of mumsnet while I was trying to conceive a warm and supportive place, they sign posted me to the hospital and doctor that made my dream of motherhood come true, but the rest of mumsnet seems to be a snake pit.

TBH I feel like I often look at posts to see what the posters say in response to posts, it’s like looking at the dailymail comments boards, an absolute cesspool of nasty people. It both horrifies and fascinates me how nasty people can be, and wonder if these type of people I come across IRL and don’t realise. If they are nasty all the time or just behind the keyboard.

UnhappyFan · 25/04/2023 17:06

IncompleteSenten · 25/04/2023 16:58

I joined in 2004 and tbh it's really not changed all that much.
There have always been whopping great bunfights and some very blunt responses but there's always been more good than bad.

If you see posts you think are cruel, say so on the thread. Challenge it with the person. Thats the most effective way.

I know there are times I've been a dick and been told to wind my neck in.

You’re not wrong. I haven’t always been the picture of kindness either. Maybe it’s because there are more people on mumsnet so it’s more likely to be a cascade of the same frustrated responses in one go? 😑😣

I do call it out when I see it. But it can be frustrating and admittedly intimidating when it feels like the entire post is drowning in them.

OP posts:
Arewehumanorarewecupboards · 25/04/2023 17:04

Right on cue

Neededanewuserhandle · 25/04/2023 17:01

UnhappyFan · 25/04/2023 16:54

Haha yeah I expected something like that to happen. 😆🫣🫠

I have been on here more than 10 years. In that time there is about a post a week saying everyone's turned nasty and it's not like the good old days (10 seconds/10 days/10 weeks/10 months/10 years ago) when everything was wall to wall flowers and fucking unicorns.

So it's not really a surprise if people suggest you go elsewhere - that's been happening for as long as people have been posting dreary "but everyone's so mean and nasty" threads.

I posted a thread about my battles with stupid HMRC recently - some people got it and agreed, some people made helpful suggestions, and about 50% of responses posted irrelevant drivel and personal abuse. I'll take the rough with the smooth.

Yellowrosesmakemehappy · 25/04/2023 16:59

Find it quite*