Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that mumsnetters are getting more mean?

59 replies

UnhappyFan · 25/04/2023 16:43

I joined mumsnet about two years ago and while mumsnetters weren’t always a barrel of sunshine they generally seemed to give honest, sincere and genuinely helpful replies and always seemed to have the well being off OP at heart even if what they said was a difficult pill to swallow.

That’s why I loved mumsnet. You could get away from all the online BS here and talk to honest helpful people who aren’t going to coddle me or use kid gloves when giving advice. They would just cut straight to the chase.

Now though things don’t seem to be about constructive criticism or even anything remotely helpful anymore. It really seems to me like mumsnet has changed for the worst.

Some of it I think are trolls. They are expected and in every forum. But some of it I really think I see as a cultural shift on mumsnet.

Many mumsnetters really only seem interested in testing at OP’s throats merely for the sake of tearing the person down or intentionally trying to get them to take down the thread.

Here is my most recent example.
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/relationships/4792379-34-weeks-pregnant-and-we-just-found-out-he-has-another-child?page=1

A new mother who went through several rounds of IVF and lost several pregnancies found out that the love of her life had another adult child that even he didn’t know about. OP said that it was very painful to discover particularly because of the timing as she is heavily pregnant with her first child.

The first solid wall of comments were generally unhelpful and instead of providing support or advice they only criticized her for expressing her pain and emotional struggle with this.

Am I being unreasonable to think that mumsnet has gotten more unfriendly in the last few years or is it I that has changed?

34 weeks pregnant and we just found out he has another child | Mumsnet

My husband and I have been together 6 years and we're expecting our first child next month. I'm so happy to be pregnant as it was a difficult journey...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/relationships/4792379-34-weeks-pregnant-and-we-just-found-out-he-has-another-child?page=1

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Sceptre86 · 26/04/2023 19:07

I think sometimes the responses are written in frustration. I just avoid posts about useless partners or worse (in my opinion) are the ones where the op attempts to be lighthearted about having a useless partner and 3 kids. At first I found myself trying to give constructive responses but realised that I was getting more and more blunt to the point where I'd re-read and think to myself I was too harsh. I then decided that if I was actually going to respond to that type of post it needed to include some actual constructive advice or empathy otherwise I shouldn't bother.

Posters do pile on you though and I've had it on me when responding to a post about why women get with and have several children with men that were always useless. I didn't mean for my response to come across as condescending but rather that I understood that other women would have had different upbringing from my own (perhaps no positive male influence or lack of supportive patents, no financial security, low self esteem etc) so could appreciate why they might put up with things I wouldn't. The poster who have me a bashing backed down as soon as I challenged them but I think tone can easily get missed when you are posting.

I hate the advice of just going out and leaving a lazy partner to it re kids. I don't know of any mother who would do this in real life.

anon666 · 26/04/2023 18:41

Coffeeandbourbons · 25/04/2023 18:42

I think it’s a weird kind of ‘punish by proxy’ thing because IRL they can’t call people out on stuff.

Smelly colleague? Take it out on the posters who shower every other day.

Got cheated on? Take it out on a poster who admitted she was once an OW

Feel jealous of your rich friend? Tell that person struggling on 40k in London that they don’t know they’re born

…and so on

Agree with this completely. Everyone takes out their personal grievances and resentments on the poor OP

Sevenbells · 26/04/2023 12:00

Those who want thoughtful advice or thought provoking discussion should just skip over those posts, as there is usually so much more to threads than that, with some absolute gems of humour, empathy and wisdom amongst them.

I agree with this too. I don't know who Mumsnetters are in real life, and that's the beauty of it. There are lurkers and trolls and weirdoes but there is also a hive mind of women here that are far more experienced in some fields, professions, cultures etc than I am and some of the things I've read have completely rewired my thinking. I can't begin to imagine how many women have got out of abusive relationships thanks to MN. It's generally a force for the good and you do need to sift/not get drawn in by those that are clearly her to bait and derail. A fair few are men, I suspect - I was at a poetry reading recently and a very well known poet (a man) had a real go at Mumsnet - people are aware of the site's power and don't like it.

Strugglingtodomybest · 26/04/2023 10:07

Those who want thoughtful advice or thought provoking discussion should just skip over those posts

I agree with this. On the rare occasion I have started a thread, I ignore the obvious trolls and those who can't even be bothered to read my OP properly, and I concentrate on answering the helpful posts.

5128gap · 26/04/2023 09:49

When polarised and emotive subjects are discussed, people have varying abilities to debate with those with opposing views and remain on topic, without becoming personal.
We can't discuss the issues around cosmetic procedures for example without people insulting the appearance of those who have them.
We can't discuss the political context around the SAHM model without someone piping up to accuse people of jealousy.
We can't give a view on an action or behaviour in AIBU without someone extrapolating that the incident in question means the OP is 'insecure' 'a lazy parent' etc.
To resort to this sort of thing rather than making an insightful contribution is often indicative that the poster is only understanding the topic at a very superficial level. Those who want thoughtful advice or thought provoking discussion should just skip over those posts, as there is usually so much more to threads than that, with some absolute gems of humour, empathy and wisdom amongst them.

Reallifelurker · 26/04/2023 09:37

This just suggests to me that you'd be better off posting on Reddit as you have already established.

I was just using Reddit as an example. A lot of other forums are the same in that they are better moderated.

There’s no real etiquette on MN (or at least AIBU) so people can be as mean spirited as they like. I think a lot of people just come here to pick a fight.

Not everyone is like that of course but quite a few are.

Neededanewuserhandle · 26/04/2023 09:21

Reallifelurker · 26/04/2023 09:12

I remember pile on’s happening when I first started to lurk here (around 2013/2014). Maybe they’re more frequent now tho.

The trouble is people can say what they like on here. On most forums people would be roasted for the “robust” responses you see here, or down voted to oblivion or something.

Like I’ve just been reading a thread where the OP is asking a (presumably) genuine question and it’s page after page of “why are you even asking that” 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄

That’s not the response you’d get on somewhere like Reddit. They’d just answer the question.

This just suggests to me that you'd be better off posting on Reddit as you have already established.

Neededanewuserhandle · 26/04/2023 09:20

I really value the range of responses from helpful to batshit. Also it helps me to know there are real people out there with the weirdest opinions (the recent thread by moon landing deniers was a treat).

I am glad MN doesn't bowdlerise everything to fuckery and that people post things on here they wouldn't say to my face. That's the point of it.

Reallifelurker · 26/04/2023 09:12

I remember pile on’s happening when I first started to lurk here (around 2013/2014). Maybe they’re more frequent now tho.

The trouble is people can say what they like on here. On most forums people would be roasted for the “robust” responses you see here, or down voted to oblivion or something.

Like I’ve just been reading a thread where the OP is asking a (presumably) genuine question and it’s page after page of “why are you even asking that” 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄

That’s not the response you’d get on somewhere like Reddit. They’d just answer the question.

SquashedSquashess · 26/04/2023 08:14

A lot of it comes across as people who aren’t very bright trying to be righteous.

The thread where OP’s child was asphyxiating and she parked in a disabled bay to rush her into A&E was a good example of this. The OP’s child could have died if medical care was delayed, but a lot of posters got hung up on how terrible and wrong it is to park in disabled bays if you aren’t disabled, as if OP had used a disabled bay at the local Tesco.

So I think, whilst some people are mean on purpose, many just don’t see the wood for the trees as they’re more concerned with virtue signalling than critical thinking.

Strugglingtodomybest · 26/04/2023 07:40

punish by proxy - love this expression and will be stealing it! My mum does this...

MooPointCowsOpinion · 25/04/2023 22:03

Totally agree. I joined 12 years ago and I would often think “wonder what people on MN would recommend/think about this”, I made some real life friends in here and we are still in touch now.
But now I think “why the fuck do I still have these subscription emails on I hate that site” and it’s because so many women are so hideously spiteful and nasty in posts. Like, no empathy at all. I feel sorry for them because that’s a miserable life, but I feel more sorry for the poor unsuspecting first time poster who gets skewered by their toxic replies.
Moderation used to be so much stricter, and people used to take pride in keeping the same UN and recognising each other and making long term friendships.

Sevenbells · 25/04/2023 19:07

I think there are more trolls, those baiting, nasty weirdoes who try to inflame the OP and derail the thread. But if you completely ignore them then you still get brilliant advice from the genuine posters.

KTheGrey · 25/04/2023 19:04

@Desperatelyseekingbunny Thank you for sharing that - it's the kind of story that makes me instantly feel happier about life 😀

Coffeeandbourbons · 25/04/2023 18:42

FrostyFifi · 25/04/2023 18:26

What does my tits in is people wilfully refusing to read properly and twisting a post beyond all recognition to suit their highly subjective narrative and then mercilessly berating the OP as if their weird angry projections were objective truth.

I think it’s a weird kind of ‘punish by proxy’ thing because IRL they can’t call people out on stuff.

Smelly colleague? Take it out on the posters who shower every other day.

Got cheated on? Take it out on a poster who admitted she was once an OW

Feel jealous of your rich friend? Tell that person struggling on 40k in London that they don’t know they’re born

…and so on

Plantgeumstoday · 25/04/2023 18:34

I agree with you OP. disappointing to see the shift towards online bullying and abuse of people who often find themselves in a difficult situation and are asking for help or advice.

Thanks to MN, several years ago, I asked for advice and after numerous replies I realised I was in an abusive relationship. It was like light bulb moments and a turning point for me.

Im now divorced and happy with a new partner.

I’ve noticed, especially in the relationships threads that people are often attacking OP with unkind remarks and detailing the thread. So sad and unhelpful.
MN has changed for the worst for sure.

UnhappyFan · 25/04/2023 18:34

FrostyFifi · 25/04/2023 18:26

What does my tits in is people wilfully refusing to read properly and twisting a post beyond all recognition to suit their highly subjective narrative and then mercilessly berating the OP as if their weird angry projections were objective truth.

THIS RIGHT HERE. 😫

OP posts:
DangerNoodles · 25/04/2023 18:34

I joined 10 years ago when I was pregnant with my first. It's great for many things, but I wouldn't use mumsnet to ask for parenting advice, for that I would always try and find real life help even though parenting stuff is what I originally signed up for. I don't think it's particularly mum friendly, a recent example being the mum that got a roasting for parking in a disabled bay at hospital in order to save her dying child's life.

GoldenGorilla · 25/04/2023 18:32

I feel that the general tone has changed a lot. I’m not sure when I joined - around 2004? - but over the past few months I’ve increasingly felt like leaving. So many threads now are just bullying pile ons. I think it’s part of a general stress/unhappiness in the country (it’s still mainly a uk site), which comes out on here as people won’t be so nasty in real life. It’s unpleasant on here a lot of the time now.

Americano75 · 25/04/2023 18:27

It's not all bad but there are some absolute throbbers kicking about, saying the sort of crap they wouldn't have the balls to say in real life for fear of getting a sore face. So nasty and unnecessary.

FrostyFifi · 25/04/2023 18:26

What does my tits in is people wilfully refusing to read properly and twisting a post beyond all recognition to suit their highly subjective narrative and then mercilessly berating the OP as if their weird angry projections were objective truth.

UnhappyFan · 25/04/2023 18:26

Arewehumanorarewecupboards · 25/04/2023 18:13

There are definitely some amazing people here too. It’s not all bad.

Yes sometimes mumsnet has the most amazing lovely caring people which is why someone’s I get really taken off guard. 😅

OP posts:
UnhappyFan · 25/04/2023 18:23

alaran · 25/04/2023 17:23

AIBU attracts a lot of bitter, miserable women and possibly quite a few with mental health problems. This is very evident in any thread about SAHMs - it's the same few posters trolling every time. Their so-called 'concern' about SAHMs is bordering on pathological. Also any thread about 'high earners' will also go to 1000 posts (with a lot of nastiness / jealousy thrown in) which says a lot about how disgruntled people are in the U.K. in general.

I’m glad that you mentioned this about SAHM. Actually I’ve had three threads taken down and in all of them I mentioned I was a SAHM but I didn’t make the connection because I had other threads go quite well before that. It really had me scratching my head.

I think some people might assume my husband has a lot of money because I don’t work but it’s actually just that we were forced into this lifestyle because of a daycare crisis in my area and we were out of options. 😂

My daughter has been on waitlists for daycare since I was 6 weeks pregnant. She is now 2. 🤪

The funny thing is though I really don’t hate it. That seems to be the thing that triggers some folks. I guess I’m supposed to moan and groan about how awful it is or something.

I do agree that it isn’t moderated well. The reason I had these threads taken down in the past was because the conversation has gotten so far off track and I was being terribly taken out of context and accused of things that were blatantly untrue.

I tried reporting the comments but was told they weren’t violating anything so they stayed up with zero intervention. So I did the next best thing and asked for the thread to be removed. The mods actually had the nerve to try to talk me out of it like they thought I was being unreasonable. 3 pages in and being completely destroyed in the comments section and having my character assassinated. There was clearly no hope of getting the advice I was seeking anymore and the moderators weren’t helping or looking to make the thread bearable why keep it up?

I am not blaming the mods necessarily because I don’t know how the system works. Perhaps there is some red tape they are dealing with on their end of things however… Perhaps the talk guidelines or whatever system the mods use needs to be looked into a bit more deeply if there is no recourse when things like this happen?

OP posts:
ANiceBigCupOfTea · 25/04/2023 18:22

I was also shocked at the post where the lady said she was upset as she'd had a mc and her dp didn't want to try again. Now I get they did say they didn't walk kids, but mcs are fucking horrible and the lack of empathy in some posters was disgusting. Comments like 'he's 50. He's sensible to have a vasectomy'. Right fucking hell mate. She's just had a mc. Lay off.
Some threads are full of support, and others even for the same issues are not. It's the personal nastiness thats really insidious at times, but there's a poster who comes along every now and then who's lovely and able to give poor feedback without ripping the OP a new one.

anon666 · 25/04/2023 18:14

I've looked at the thread in question.

Reflecting on what it is - it's that people are very narcissistic. Whatever their situation is - they are biased towards that and not empathetic towards other feelings.

E.g. if I am struggling to make ends meet and see a question about "what is a high earner" I see it as my job to wade in there and give everybody a telling off. Instead of thinking "that will just wind me up, I'll stay away" or staying quiet.

Equally if someone trapped on benefits as a carer comes on for a bit of a justified moan about their lot, they'll get some self-righteous smug idiot telling them to get a higher paid job.

I've noticed it's very smug, I'm alright Jack at times, especially about health. People don't "deserve" their health. It's not all brought upon yourself by lifestyle.

I think this comes from it being a bigger community. In the "old" days I used to recognise half the "names" so people knew to behave. The more anonymous it becomes the safer it is for people to be arseholes.