Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy my white daughter a brown doll - thats OK right?

261 replies

Capaldifan94 · 25/04/2023 16:41

Just that really..

OP posts:
Hayliebells · 25/04/2023 17:48

In what way is your DM "old fashioned"? Old fashioned in that she's a bit racist? If not, I'm not sure what relevance her being "old fashioned" has? Being mindful of cultural appropriation is must definitely not old fashioned. If you mean he's old fashioned in the way that some very elderly people can be a bit racist, how old is your mum? If she's not in her 90s, I'd absolutely be calling her out on that. If she's in her 60s/70s, she really should know better...

Loraloralaughs · 25/04/2023 17:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

GP75 · 25/04/2023 17:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Vivalaive · 25/04/2023 17:45

Yes ofc.

Goodread1 · 25/04/2023 17:44

Oops Sorry about Typo mistake
I ment to say,

I don't know, why this should be a issue

Buying a black doll for your daughter to play with,

No problem whatsoever with you doing this

No offence about you doing this

As a Black British Welsh Afro Caribbean woman as myself

slowquickstep · 25/04/2023 17:44

pastaandpesto · 25/04/2023 17:31

I do think this is a bit more nuanced than some of the faux wide-eyed responses are claiming.

There is clearly nothing wrong with a young white child choosing and playing with a black doll.

But for an adult to choose a black doll for a white child is a bit more complicated, because, unfortunately, the dominance of white dolls means that choosing a non-white doll is a deliberate choice. So this means it becomes a question of why the adult has chosen a black doll.

Perhaps its simply because the doll in question has cooler accessories, in which case all good.

Or perhaps it might be because the adult wants to normalise diversity, which is at least well-intentioned.

But it could be because the adult just wants an easy way (consciously or unconsciously) to signal to other adults just how right-on they are as parents, while not concerning themselves in any way with the real issues surrounding diversity and racism. Which while not cultural appropriation, is something not completely dissimilar.

Or maybe it was on sale therefore it was cheaper. It isn't always deep and meaningful. Sometimes we just buy things

DustyLee123 · 25/04/2023 17:44

I had one in the 70’s, I don’t see the problem.

Yummymummy2020 · 25/04/2023 17:43

My kids have black dolls, and white dolls. Nobody has batted an eyelid when they bring them out and about. I don’t think you need to worry!

Msloverlover · 25/04/2023 17:43

I’m assuming you have teddy bears and are not in fact a family of bears?

Goodread1 · 25/04/2023 17:41

Yes of course it is, @Capaldifan94

I know why this should be a issue at all

I think this a good thing, that you have brought your daughter,

Hope your daughter has lots of enjoyment playing with her new doll

Speaking as a middle aged British Welsh Afro Caribbean woman

Nachobowls · 25/04/2023 17:35

Yes of course it’s fine, though reminds me of the time when my ex asked me what dd (mixed race) would like for her birthday, I said a Cinderella doll, he refused to buy it and said she needed to have a doll that “looked like her” he came back with a jasmine doll as it was the “one that looks like her the most” dd doesn’t like Aladdin and we are not Asian so not sure how it represented her

nighthawk99 · 25/04/2023 17:35

Out of interest ,If your daughter was black, would you buy her a white doll?

FancyFanny · 25/04/2023 17:32

YANBU I'm not sure if you should refer to it as 'brown' though.

MargaretThursday · 25/04/2023 17:31

DD2 had one because when we were ELC one time I hadn't realised she'd picked one off the shelf (in her buggy) and had "kissed" it very wetly all over. I didn't really have the money to pay for it, but there wasn't a choice! She called her "Dodo" because that was her word for doll, and it stuck.

Several years down the line I was doing a nativity display for church and I called into her room to ask to borrow one of her (many) dolls for it. I put it in a bag without looking and when I got to church there was Dodo. Didn't think too much of it, till we started getting comments of how lovely it was to have her as baby Jesus. I think people thought it had been done deliberately, but it hadn't.

pastaandpesto · 25/04/2023 17:31

I do think this is a bit more nuanced than some of the faux wide-eyed responses are claiming.

There is clearly nothing wrong with a young white child choosing and playing with a black doll.

But for an adult to choose a black doll for a white child is a bit more complicated, because, unfortunately, the dominance of white dolls means that choosing a non-white doll is a deliberate choice. So this means it becomes a question of why the adult has chosen a black doll.

Perhaps its simply because the doll in question has cooler accessories, in which case all good.

Or perhaps it might be because the adult wants to normalise diversity, which is at least well-intentioned.

But it could be because the adult just wants an easy way (consciously or unconsciously) to signal to other adults just how right-on they are as parents, while not concerning themselves in any way with the real issues surrounding diversity and racism. Which while not cultural appropriation, is something not completely dissimilar.

Merryoldgoat · 25/04/2023 17:30

I’m worried now as I gave my child a farm playset and we aren’t farmers.

MrsTerryPratchett · 25/04/2023 17:30

At one point all my white DD's dolls were Black because they were hand-me-downs and her cousins are all Black. And I'm too cheap to buy new when I can use old.

No one ever said anything and DD loved them. They were all passed on years ago.

OnedayIwillfeelfree · 25/04/2023 17:28

So if your child does not have a a triangle on their head they can’t play with a Tinky Winky toy? Your Mother needs to stop reading the Daily Mail.

Ortiguilla · 25/04/2023 17:28

Capaldifan94 · 25/04/2023 17:01

Its just a normal doll yes, the boy baby born doll.

DD has friends from all backgrounds and just doesn't see colour like that. We live in a really diverse city and are a mixed race family ourselves (I'm British, the children are British/Thai and my brother and his half siblings are British/Indian and Indian) so we all have varying skin tones. DD has black friends she's v close to at nursery who she'll be going up to primary with in September.

It was cultural appropriation i was worried about after DM made the comment.

So you live in a mixed-race family and city, full of people from all parts of the world, but you defer to your 'very old-fashioned' mother for what is and is not acceptable in terms of cultural politics?

Sounds legit.

lookingthroughthekeyhole · 25/04/2023 17:28

Children don't notice the colour, my dd picked up a plastic figure at a parent and toddler group of a black man with an Afro and said daddy.
Daddy is bald with pale freckly skin.

Male101 · 25/04/2023 17:27

jannier · 25/04/2023 17:26

You're joking right?

Unfortunately I dont think she is. I was hoping this was a troll post .

jannier · 25/04/2023 17:26

Whatsthefrequencykenny · 25/04/2023 16:45

We did as she picked it out in the store but then I gave it away. Didn't want to be accused of cultural appropriation.

You're joking right?

TheKeatingFive · 25/04/2023 17:26

Of course 🤷‍♀️

moofolk · 25/04/2023 17:25

It's mad to think that it would be offensive, assuming it's just a doll and not a golliwog or something?!

jannier · 25/04/2023 17:25

Capaldifan94 · 25/04/2023 16:46

My v old fashioned DM suggested it might be seen as offensive. God only knows why. She hasn't elaborated.

It never occurred to me that it might be a problem. I'm glad it doesn't seem to be! :)

Tell her it's preparing your child for their next sibling that will shut her up or you will be dialing 999