Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it a sin to cut down a tree?

132 replies

Mamabear04 · 25/04/2023 15:43

I have a very big eucalyptus tree in my back garden, it's about 60ft tall! We moved into our house last year and I've always loved the tree but lately it's been dropping branches. The branches are really heavy and I'm worried one of them falls on my kids and hurts them. Ontop of that I have a small garden room underneath it and I'm worried it could damage it (I use it as an office space). I just had a quote from a guy who says it will cost £750 to get the tree cut back and into order then it will need maintained regularly. He also said he can chop it down completely for £950 and cut off the VAT. I'm in 2 minds as to what to do. Here are my thoughts on cutting it down;

Pro's
Safe for children
Won't damage the garden room
Will be financially beneficial in the long run
Won't be a risk to property and neighbours property if there is a big storm/high winds

Con's
It feels like a sin to cut down such an old tree
It will be home to wildlife and I'll be taking away their home
It offers some privacy to our property

OP posts:
AppallinglyReheated · 26/04/2023 03:20

I would plan on cutting it down once bird nesting season is over.

Take into account it may affect foundations, and it will probably mean that area of your garden is now much wetter so plan for those costs too.

I murdered two massive leylandii in the garden of my old home as they cut out so much light... and then found that once they weren't slurping up the water, my garden was a fucking bog! That winter thanks to water and dogs bouncing around out there, I had a foot of black mud... digging a big soakaway drain was so much fun (and we did it all ourselves as zero money for anything but the gravel!)

givemecoffeenow · 26/04/2023 03:09

It’s a shame to cut down any tree, I wouldn’t unless absolutely necessary 🤷🏼‍♀️

EmmaGrundyForPM · 26/04/2023 03:03

I'm reading this with interest as we've just moved into a house with a massive Eucalyptus tree at thd bottom.of the garden. It's nowhere near our house but it's incredibly close to the house behind - 20 feet I think as their garden is minute. The house behind was only built two years ago so the developer knew it was there when the house was built.

maras2 · 25/04/2023 20:21

Yes

Whatevergetsyouthroughthenight · 25/04/2023 20:14

It doesn’t sound too cheap to me, I had to have a mature Ash tree cut down (ash dieback) and it was £600. Proper tree surgeon.

hereiamagainn · 25/04/2023 20:10

It’s not protected is it? There’s a massive redwood near where I live and nobody’s allowed to cut it down.

ErrolTheDragon · 25/04/2023 19:39

Not willing to comment on the quotes you have received, but since this work would require a 'climber' to carry out safely and qualified 'climbers' do not come cheap (their personal and public insurance liability premiums are horrendous!), not outside the ball park

I'm trying to remember how the eucalyptus near us were felled - they were so tall and gangly I'm not sure if they could be climbed. I think they had to chop them down from the base and ensure they fell the right way. Could be tricky in a garden, and all the more reason to deal with it before it gets any bigger.

Hedgesfullofbirds · 25/04/2023 19:26

Oh yes, it IS nesting season, but very few species of bird actually nest in trees and, provided a thorough check is made beforehand, it need not be an issue

Hedgesfullofbirds · 25/04/2023 19:21

Hi OP - my two pennyworth:

Your reasons for removing the tree are perfectly valid and I would do so. I say this as one who loves trees and owns a plot of land full of them ( also known as a woodland!), and I have no qualms about cutting down a tree for any number of reasons. Trees are a replaceable and sustainable resource so, no, it is not a 'sin', especially something like a Eucalyptus which is totally alien and of no wildlife value, unless you happen to be in the Antipodes!
Contrary to popular belief, conservation does not mean the preservation of everything at all costs - sometimes some species or individuals need removing, just ask the RSPB which routinely cull foxes, gulls, crows and some other injurious species on their reserves to allow other less successful species to have a fighting chance of increasing their numbers. They won't tell you this though, for fear of alienating their members, donors and benefactors.
Nothing wrong with removing a tree which is too big, in the wrong place, dangerous, diseased or for a host of other reasons - just replace it with a new tree of a more appropriate species and suitability for your site.
Cannot comment on the liklihood of a TPO being in place, some local authorities are more proactive than others in this regard, but unlikely on a Eucalyptus, but do check, just to cover your backside.
Not willing to comment on the quotes you have received, but since this work would require a 'climber' to carry out safely and qualified 'climbers' do not come cheap (their personal and public insurance liability premiums are horrendous!), not outside the ball park. I would expect it to include chipping of the 'arisings' and small limbs. You could always sell the larger sections to someone with an open fire or woodburner to defray costs a little - once seasoned Eucalyptus would burn well and smell gorgeous.
And, yes, since Eucalytus are so vigorous ( they regenerate even following forest fires), you would need the stump grinding out, including the roots, to prevent it suckering and regrowing.

aberlot · 25/04/2023 19:09

@Tiredalwaystired

Are you my neighbour?

Obviously not, I said their opinion was completely irrelevant, not that we used their garden and caused damage.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 25/04/2023 19:08

Stettafire · 25/04/2023 16:58

If in the UK, check with your local council if the tree has a tree preservation order. Otherwise you could get into trouble. There isn't just native trees that get that status either. I've got a post oak near me that has it, and post oaks are native to North America.

I had Leylandii with a TPO in my garden.

cocksstrideintheevening · 25/04/2023 19:07

A eucalyptus will not be subject to a tpo.

I wouldn't cut a tree down for fun but in this case I would and replace it with something native.

Did the neighbours and their amenities if they want a tree they can have it on their land!

Bodenesque · 25/04/2023 19:04

I had a giant eucalyptus and the shallow roots extended to the front of my home, hit the foundations and doubled back leaving 20 ft cracks along the paving stones.
I had it trimmed down significantly but on a follow up visit the tree surgeon recommended removal as the shallow root system meant it just wasn't stable.

FlyingPandas · 25/04/2023 19:02

We had a large eucalyptus tree in our garden when we moved in, along with various other trees and large shrubs. We have a tree surgeon we have used for years (so respect his opinion greatly) and asked him round to have a look at the various trees in the new garden. His first recommendation was to take the eucalyptus out - for all the reasons highlighted by PP.

Eucalyptus trees are beautiful - their leaf foliage is so lovely - but they just grow too big, too fast. I would have it taken down OP but check for TPOs first and definitely don't mess around getting a random garden person to do the work for you - get a qualified tree surgeon and check out feedback on their work before you hire them.

Tiredalwaystired · 25/04/2023 18:57

aberlot · 25/04/2023 17:50

I had a big tree cut down earlier this year. Did I fuck discuss it with my neighbour. I had it taken down because it was causing me problems and next doors opinion would have been completely irrelevant.

Are you my neighbour?

Chimneypotblues · 25/04/2023 18:49

Trees in gardens often outgrow the space they were planted in, don't think there's anything morally wrong in cutting one down that's got too big, especially if you replace it with something more sensible

DogInATent · 25/04/2023 18:46

TomeTome · 25/04/2023 18:36

I find the hate of non native trees weird. What about a huge ginkgo or a magnolia would you want to take them down and replace with a hawthorn? It’s a garden not an ancient hedgerow. Personally I think eucalyptus is beautiful and ours is full of birds and squirrels etc. Just get it pruned don’t kill it.

Not all non-native trees. But eucalyptus specifically has problems as a garden tree - they're very fast growing and tend to have fragile branches prone to breaking. They're just not appropriate unless you're prepared to put in regular maintenance.

For wildlife value a native species is best, but as you mention it I think ginkgo is probably the finest of all garden tress - it looks stunning in spring and autumn. A close runner-up is katsura. Unfortunately I don't have a garden big enough for all the trees I'd like to have!

ErrolTheDragon · 25/04/2023 18:38

The farmer behind our house planted about a dozen eucalyptus trees when our estate was built - maybe he thought they'd be a screen but they shot up rapidly so they were tall spindly trunks with the leaves high up. And then some of them fell over in high winds, I think one damaged a neighbour's fence but also blocked the farm lane. This was within maybe 15 years, they were not venerable old trees!

Anyway, he got rid of them and has replaced them with much more appropriate trees, hazels I think.

As others have said, these are not appropriate trees for a U.K. garden. Get rid and replace with something else. Your neighbours and wildlife will thank you.

TomeTome · 25/04/2023 18:36

I find the hate of non native trees weird. What about a huge ginkgo or a magnolia would you want to take them down and replace with a hawthorn? It’s a garden not an ancient hedgerow. Personally I think eucalyptus is beautiful and ours is full of birds and squirrels etc. Just get it pruned don’t kill it.

DorritLittle · 25/04/2023 18:25

neverknowinglyunreasonable · 25/04/2023 16:00

I found this passage which I think is relevant

"And the Lord sayeth unto them "Lest none of you cut down a tree or bush. I tell you now any person who destroys a tree, destroys me. Unless there is a danger the tree should fall unto a child or garden room, in which case go ahead". And the crowd were amazed and went back to their homes in wonder."

😂

pussycatinfluffyslippers · 25/04/2023 18:17

Our neighbours have half a dozen eucalyptus trees that the previous owner planted about 5 yrs ago. One is taller than the house, 2 others fall over when it gets windy and have to be tethered to concrete fence posts. Bloody awful trees.
Don't worry about nesting birds. We have loads of sparrows, starlings, blackbirds, tits, robins and woodpigeon that won't go near the bloody things, let alone nest in them.

Get them to take the stump out if you can.

megletthesecond · 25/04/2023 18:10

You cannot cut it in nesting season. Can you have the height taken off and keep some of it for birds?

I've just reported a company for hedge cutting at the weekend. People like me report everything 😁.

Goodread1 · 25/04/2023 18:08

I really think @Honeysuckle16 suggestion is good sound, about your tree 🌳

So this will lesson mimise the risk to your children

Just maitening properly effectively cutting it back
Op@Mamabear04

DogInATent · 25/04/2023 18:07

AP5Diva · 25/04/2023 17:16

He’d need a tree felling license to cut it down.
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/tree-felling-overview

Tree felling for certain reasons might be VAT exempt as opposed to pruning/cutting back. I’m not clear on the rules.

It's a garden. You don't need a tree felling license.

YouCould · 25/04/2023 17:55

Not read all the posts but I'd say it would be a sin NOT to cut down the tree. Eucalyptus trees are a terrible choice for domestic gardens. They aren't suitable for lots of reasons. I'd cut it down, then wait a while then replant a more suitable, prettier native tree that's more beneficial to the local wildlife ( assuming you don't have a local Koala 🐨 population)