Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help with teacher's meeting

35 replies

Sevenbells · 25/04/2023 14:32

Have NC's for this as it's a bit identifying to anyone who knows me or the situation.

I am meeting my son's teacher on Friday. Long back story but essentially he feels she "hates" him and she's done a few things I'm not happy about.

One is that he was diagnosed with dyslexia last year but she is simply saying he's fine and he needs to read more books.

Two is that he was cold in class (he used to suffer from cold urticaria and really feels the cold) and put his hood on. She said to take it off, so he put his hands over his ears. She then touched his ears and said "Your ears can't be cold, they are red." For the record, he is self conscious about his ears as they do go red and they stick out a little, so I felt this was bullying. I don't want her touching him or commenting on his ears or appearance in general.

I suspect that she is going to do nothing, and I know from other parents that she is a bully and if I take it further ie to the headmaster he will not be at all surprised.

What I want is for him to be given support and encouragement, until the end of the year when we will change his school as we are moving cities. He doesn't want to move before then.

Any tips for handling the meeting? I hate confrontation and she is, shall we say, not a straightforward personality (could use another word but won't.)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Sevenbells · 26/04/2023 12:28

Thanks bluevelvetsofa yes you're right, I will ask what's available.

I'm already working on a different curriculum with him using workbooks at home because when we move he will have to jump ahead six months so that is more of a priority now we know he will be leaving that school and the system here. The maths is very different so that's another issue, but I think his new schooling will be easier with shorter days.

From what I've seen of her in parent teacher nights and previous meetings she will more or less tell me there's no point in him continuing with bilingual education and the school can't help. But I will ask.

Yes the diagnosis was private. But there isn't an NHS so everything is private really, it's just the insurance that is public or private. We had to use this one psychologist as he was being tested in English.

OP posts:
Bluevelvetsofa · 26/04/2023 12:20

I think your best bet is to focus on asking what additional help the school can offer to support the dyslexia diagnosis. What is going to give him greater access to the curriculum? I asked about a private diagnosis because it’s relevant to the report and the recommendations in it. You also say that it’s your feeling that he has dyslexia, which isn’t quite the same thing.

Nevertheless, there’s nothing wrong with asking for further strategies to support his learning.

Sevenbells · 26/04/2023 12:11

@Nimbostratus100 I'm assuming you're a teacher? So would you, having felt a child's ears, then say loudly 'Your ears can't be cold, they are RED!' (to a child with red ears, which mean kids have commented on in a negative way before, so he is aware of them being a bit unusual.)

I also have to emphasise that he does really suffer in the cold - he breaks out in welts, it's a kind of anaphalaxis and not something I'm making up. So if he's cold, he's cold. He doesn't ever get in trouble for being defiant in class, if anything he keeps his head down, so if he was putting his hood up and holding his ears he was actually very cold. I don't doubt him on that, and he's not going to be in serious trouble from me for expressing his discomfort, the classrooms are freezing.

He only told me she did that very late that night, in bed, in the dark, which is how I knew it really upset him. To me drawing attention to a kid's physical appearance is something I'd expect from another kid, not a teacher.

I've seen her interacting with parents and kids and she's not great with people - no warmth, loud, very defensive, critical and shouty. All problems, no solutions. He doesn't respect her and neither do I (and I say that as someone with relatives who are teachers, and as someone who has had a great relationship with all other teachers my kids have had.)

@badgermushrooms You have described her, I think. She has no sympathy for his reading struggles, and is singling him out. We are probably going to try and get through to the summer and then pull him out, he is being badly affected by her attitude towards him.

OP posts:
Pinkdelight3 · 26/04/2023 08:21

Touching his ears surely makes sense if he's putting his hood up - she's seeing if he's as cold as he says. There's no way she'd know he has a thing about his ears, and it isn't acceptable to have his hood up in school.

Agree the focus has to be the approach to his dyslexia, not these other things. She's unlikely to have purposely excluded him from making pancakes and maybe the mix did run out but she didn't remember every detail of who did what when. Shouting - well, it happens sometimes. If the dyslexia conversation goes well, there may be a way to work this in non-confrontationally, emphasising how he responds best to positive encouragement etc. But I think it has to be in that spirit, not with the assumption that she's a bully who has it in for him. You only have to make it work a while longer until you leave after all.

Nimbostratus100 · 26/04/2023 08:10

badgermushrooms · 26/04/2023 08:03

I spent a couple of years at a secondary school which has a good reputation for dyslexia support. We used to get a lot of kids starting at random times through the year when their parents gave up on their previous schools. One of the things a really striking number of my dyslexic friends had in common was that teachers at their old schools had been really vile to them. This was in the 90s when dyslexia wasn't that well known about and these teachers had basically seen a perfectly intelligent child claiming to struggle with basic reading and reached the conclusion not that they needed extra help but that they were being needlessly difficult. Loads of my friends had been told they were lazy or had an attitude problem. I suspect the OP's son has ended up with a particularly backward teacher who doesn't believe dyslexia is a thing.

or a very highly trained and knowledgeable teacher who understand that dyslexics need to read and write MORE than other children to reach the same standard

I am being a bit devil's advocate here, maybe she is terrible, but maybe she is simply doing her job and your son is getting a persecution complex

Jifmicroliquid · 26/04/2023 08:08

Perhaps your sons behaviour is challenging and he is defiant. Putting a hoodie on and then covering his ears when told to remove it is poor behaviour and you seem to be brushing that off and focusing on the teachers actions.
If I had behaved like that at school, regardless of the actions of the teacher afterwards, I’d have been in serious trouble with my parents for being rude! It seems children can do what they want nowadays and parents will always leap to their defence and blame the teacher. So glad I’m out of that now, I saw it far too much.

Nimbostratus100 · 26/04/2023 08:08

I rarely touch children, but gaging their temperature is likely to be an exception - I ask first, but that would depend on the age of the child, most likely

Nimbostratus100 · 26/04/2023 08:06

Sevenbells · 25/04/2023 14:47

bluevelvetsofa she opens the windows, according to my son.

in line with covid guidance....

badgermushrooms · 26/04/2023 08:03

I spent a couple of years at a secondary school which has a good reputation for dyslexia support. We used to get a lot of kids starting at random times through the year when their parents gave up on their previous schools. One of the things a really striking number of my dyslexic friends had in common was that teachers at their old schools had been really vile to them. This was in the 90s when dyslexia wasn't that well known about and these teachers had basically seen a perfectly intelligent child claiming to struggle with basic reading and reached the conclusion not that they needed extra help but that they were being needlessly difficult. Loads of my friends had been told they were lazy or had an attitude problem. I suspect the OP's son has ended up with a particularly backward teacher who doesn't believe dyslexia is a thing.

OldGrannyish · 26/04/2023 07:49

@Sevenbells dC also in a school in Europe near a bilingual region.

Teachers will think nothing of touching the child to see if they are cold, happened to my DC when she didn't believe he wasn't cold (wearing shorts in winter), so I don't think that's too unusual.

In our experience, and we were warned by the paediatrician and psychologist who did DS's private assessment:
You can go through the school system and have an assessment. Any findings and recommendations are binding, the school has to implement what the school psychologist recommends and make adjustments for the diagnosis.
You can go privately and get an assessment/diagnosis. Any findings are viewed purely as recommendations and do not have to be accepted and adjusted for by the school. The school can choose to accept and follow (this might be the case for one teacher agrees, the following year the new teacher doesn't) but they have no legal requirement to make any allowances.

If you want school to take note, you really have to get a diagnosis through the school system.

Sevenbells · 26/04/2023 07:32

@Ibouncetothebeat I find it odd that you completely dismiss everything I've said, tell me I'm a difficult parent and nothing I've described sounds bad - shouting at a child, touching his ears - and you then ask for more information from me in a series of rather hectic questions

Why on earth would I give you more information? I don't know you. You're bad mannered. Bounce off!

OP posts:
Ibouncetothebeat · 25/04/2023 20:52

This does not sound like bullying. You sound like you are a difficult parent believing every word of an emotional child. None of these examples sound particularly bad.

Re the dyslexia, in his diagnosis were there suggestions and guidance on what the teacher should do to support him? What recommendations were given? Is she not following these?

electriclight · 25/04/2023 19:42

The issue with the hoody does rather paint your ds as a pita and you as the indulgent pita parent who inadvertently encourages it.

It makes me doubt the other things your son says, such as with the pancakes and the shouting.

It may be that the truth is somewhere in the middle. The pancake mixture ran low and your son refused to make one that might have been smaller than his peers for example.

Assuming he is telling the truth about the lack of dyslexia support - just ask what strategies are in place to support him. 30% of our school year are dyslexic so we have dozens of strategies in place for everyone - the dyslexic children wouldn't necessarily know. And it could be that he would also benefit from reading with you more, that doesn't necessarily mean that the teacher is dismissive of his diagnosis.

Seashor · 25/04/2023 19:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

cansu · 25/04/2023 19:22

Kids are not allowed to sit with hoodies on in class. The crap about him feeling the cold is just that - a rubbish excuse.

Sounds like he also gets into trouble in class. Her job is to manage the class so she may need to tell him off. He is hardly likely to tell you if he was doing anything wrong.

Encouraging children to read more books is good regardless of dyslexia. He still needs to read. What specific support has he not received?

If you are concerned about support for his dyslexia, speak to the SENCO.

Sevenbells · 25/04/2023 19:01

RoseslnTheHospital

Agree that the communications book is not helping - I emailed yesterday and was told I shouldn't have done that, I should only write in the book. But she doesn't check the book!

But yes, I am not sure how much to bring up about her treatment as it's his word. She shouts at him and singles him out, for example if he gives the wrong answer she will say NO NO NO! But then the next kid will just get a gentle no, (according to him, but he's not a liar.)

Another odd thing was they made pancakes, but she said that he didn't want to/refused to (really out of character, he loves cooking). When I asked him, though, he said the mix ran out.

I think I am going to ask for more support from the SEN teacher. So at the meeting, if she's not there, I will ask for another meeting to discuss the plan. I have a friend at the school whose son has SEN who has fought tooth and nail for her kid to get support, and done fantastically well for him. So it can be done.

Re Private diagnosis - it's all there is here, really. No NHS. Interesting though that they can be 'bought' - who on earth would want to buy one?! My feeling is that he has dyslexia, it's in both our families, and he can read but it's so hard for him.

OP posts:
lilyboleyn · 25/04/2023 18:03

I don’t think she was unreasonable about the ears. You sound precious about it. He shouldn’t be wearing the hood up and it sounds like she made a throwaway comment. If you go in complaining about that you’ll look insane.

Don’t go in saying she hates him, that’s emotive rubbish.

Be very factual. ‘Just to let you know he’s sensitive about his ears.’ ‘We feel he needs more support with the dyslexia due to X, Y, Z.’

RoseslnTheHospital · 25/04/2023 15:36

So, the diary isn't an appropriate means of communication for things like SEN needs. That needs a face to face meeting, emails, phone calls and so on.

Seeing as you have a face to face meeting, I'd concentrate on the specific adjustments you have been told will help your DS with his dyslexia. That's what needs to be implemented in the classroom.

After you've addressed those issues, I would raise the fact that your DS is unhappy at school and feels that he doesn't have a good relationship with her. You will need to be specific, just saying that your DS feels the teacher hates him isn't going to work. How does that manifest? Is she unfair to him, harsher to him than other students, does she blame him for things without evidence etc etc? If your DS can't be specific then I wouldn't bring it up.

Createausername1970 · 25/04/2023 15:36

I am not sure how schools view private diagnosis.

When DS was being home schooled I though he might be a bit dyslexic and I spoke to our SS about how I could go about getting a test/diagnosis now he wasn't in the school system. I was told the only way would be a private one, but that they aren't worth the paper they are written on, so it was up to me if I wanted to go the private route, but it wasn't recommended. Basically, you can pay anyone to say what you want them to say, whereas one done via a EP/NHS/LA route can't be "bought" by a parent.

I can see you are not schooling in the UK though, it might be different where you are.

NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 25/04/2023 15:35

Presuming the school has copies of the dyslexia diagnosis, you need to ask for the equivalent of a personalised programme which will assure his needs are catered for. This is usually in the form of extra time for tests, differently formatted materials, reduced content in tests and use of computer if appropriate.

I'd leave aside the hoodie. Not many schools anywhere would accept a child putting his hoodie over his ears in lesson time.

NorthStarRising · 25/04/2023 15:33

You need to meet with the teacher and the SENCO at the same time, have a dispassionate meeting. Did you give them both a copy of the diagnosis and the recommendations from the specialist, or just tell them ‘He’s dyslexic’ and leave them to figure out what to do?
Leave the hoodie and the ears out of it, focus on what support he needs to learn in class.

2bazookas · 25/04/2023 15:28

it's more the calling attention to his ears that got me,

It was your son who called attention to his ears, by covering them so he couldn't hear her perfectly reasonable instruction.. To do that when a teacher is speaking directly to him, is both rude and deliberately provocative.

Sevenbells · 25/04/2023 15:06

And yes the dyslexia diagnosis was from a private psychologist. He did hours of tests, it was definitive, but she is simply acting as if it doesn't exist.

OP posts:
Sevenbells · 25/04/2023 15:05

There is a SENCO teacher but there just hasn't been anything done, despite us asking on numerous occasions.

The communication with the teacher is quite restricted - you can only contact her through writing in a school diary the kids carry, and even today she apparently got annoyed as I had left in an old Post-it note from a previous unread note, and she made my son find the right page (on today's date, not hard.)

OP posts:
Bluevelvetsofa · 25/04/2023 14:57

Focus on what support you think he needs to access the curriculum and how you and she can work together to improve the outcomes for him.

Has the SENCo had any input? Was the dyslexia diagnosis from a private EP?