Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Letting adult children live at home - wwyd?

62 replies

Lwrenagain · 25/04/2023 14:05

TLDR - wanting DS to have the life he wants but needing realistic ways to achieve it & would keeping him home to save cash make his goals easier to reach?

My very sensible eldest son is the most lovely man to spend time with, both myself and DP (stepdad) adore him and we've younger children at home who also love him dearly.
I'd quite happily keep him at home forever.
But he really wants to live in the fancier part of our local area where his friends live.
I'm very supportive of this and hope he achieves this.
However it's one of the most expensive areas to live locally and for all my sons wonderful qualities he isn't an academic sort. I can imagine he'll work tirelessly for an employer, he just isn't really able to see a future of employment that pays well.
We've considered apprenticeships etc and other things but he's not very good at being practical and he's ASD with a very mild learning disability. Although you'd not know unless you really knew him.

Whilst I don't want to write him off being stuck in NMW jobs like ones I've always had, I have to be realistic because he's working so hard to get into 6th form and the teachers aren't sure he'll get the grades. (He attends afterschool and weekend classes and my DP tutors him. It just isn't sinking in.)

Would I be unreasonable to suggest he stays home once he's found employment and saves up enough for a house deposit which is most definitely cheaper than rent where he wants to live. Rent is over 1k a month for 1 bed flat.
His friends will have more money and are from quite well off families, they will be able to afford renting.

I unfortunately don't have the funds who start him on the property ladder, but I can definitely let him live rent free and cover his meals etc and try and teach him to be good with money?

I can't do anymore to help him become a high flyer career wise but if he gets a decent deposit and savings behind him, maybe that will keep him in good sted long term?

Sorry its a long one and any thoughts or suggestions would be appreciated!

OP posts:
AmaryllisNightAndDay · 25/04/2023 15:38

There's no hurry. I would plan around him moving out at 18+. And not to move into a single rented flat but a room in a shared flat. Living independently is good for young people and quite apart from being much cheaper a shared flat is a great way for youngsters to learn from each other and figure out how to manage everyday household things together, not just having to depend on parents to tell them what to do or to do everything for them.

Mydog1 · 25/04/2023 15:36

Crumpleton · 25/04/2023 15:26

Would it be legal for a 16 year old to sign a tenancy agreement unless they're homeless.

If you're under 18, it's unlikely you'll be able to sign a tenancy contract or mortgage agreement. If you're 16 or 17 and homeless, you'll usually be provided with accommodation by Children's Services at your local council. This is because you'll be considered a 'child in need'.
www.gov.uk › your-rights-to...
Your rights to housing if you're under 18 - GOV.UK

@Crumpleton

Lwrenagain · 25/04/2023 15:36

Crumpleton · 25/04/2023 15:26

Would it be legal for a 16 year old to sign a tenancy agreement unless they're homeless.

I did but that was over 20 years ago now so I have absolutely no idea

OP posts:
Crumpleton · 25/04/2023 15:26

Would it be legal for a 16 year old to sign a tenancy agreement unless they're homeless.

Lwrenagain · 25/04/2023 15:06

Butchyrestingface · 25/04/2023 14:59

I never in my life heard a parent refer to their 16 year old school child as a "lovely man".

Until today. Confused

I'm sure you'll recover from the shock pet. I did mean to say young man but I'm sure that'll still be problematic 🙈

OP posts:
Timesawastin · 25/04/2023 15:04

Lwrenagain · 25/04/2023 14:24

Do you know what I think has worried me? Sounds absolutely bonkers, but just how expensive basics are. How the hell people are supposed to have a hope in hell without as much help as possible is just alot to think about.

He doesn't pay rent, I'm just thinking long term of things I can realistically do.

I'm not overly neurotic usually, it's just I'm reading here people now making 6 figures are struggling and it's just shocking.

If you're making six figures and struggling you have very expensive habits. For straightforward living expenses it's not necessary

Butchyrestingface · 25/04/2023 14:59

I never in my life heard a parent refer to their 16 year old school child as a "lovely man".

Until today. Confused

Lwrenagain · 25/04/2023 14:57

I will say he is very good at cooking and cleaning and laundry etc, that's something that he's always been keen on doing also.

It seems many people are staying at home now until later anyway aren't they?
And if we can make it nice for them and give them independence etc then it'll probably be quite nice for them.

@RosaBonheur thats actually lots to really consider. His gross motor skills aren't wonderful however they're not totally lacking, so I'm very hopeful we can look at him getting some kind of career that he can flourish with

OP posts:
xyxygy · 25/04/2023 14:56

Lwrenagain · 25/04/2023 14:49

@steppemum you're absolutely 💯 spot on.

@xyxygy this is really interesting because he has said for years he'd love to have a summerhouse or habitable shed!
He likes the idea of being close enough to see us daily, (we facetime when he's with his dad etc and he rings every day if he's on holiday with dad and dsm) but he wants to have space. It's definitely worth considering he might be a bit overwhelmed with a busy household. His younger brother is quite severely autistic (I know I shouldn't say that) but I think he can drive him a bit mental with his noises and things. So I'm definitely going to discuss this with him!

Thanks everyone x

For what it's worth...after my parents split, my mother gave my younger brother the (old stone) shed as a living space from 15-19, and he absolutely loved having his own independent space. He could retreat there when he needed alone time, he'd often invite his friends round to his "house", and it all worked out relatively well.

RosaBonheur · 25/04/2023 14:51

You're getting ahead of yourself, OP.

Plenty of people do live with their parents in their twenties or even later to save money. It's very normal these days. But obviously you don't want him to stay at home with you forever, which means that at some point he'd need to be earning enough to support himself living independently.

The best thing you can do for your son right now is encourage him to explore the different career options available to him.

What does he enjoy? And what is he actually good at?

If there's a question mark over whether he is good enough to go to sixth form then it doesn't sound like he's university material. Knowing this now is actually an advantage. Many young people these days go to university and get into tens of thousands of pounds worth of debt for a degree which doesn't even lead to a better paid job. Meanwhile, some people who don't go to university are several years into their chosen occupation by the time their friends graduate, without any debt.

Depending on his skill set, he could do a manual trade such as builder, plumber, electrician etc. Alternatively there may be jobs in the public sector which don't require a degree, or other self employed options which would involve taking qualifications but not going to university, such as becoming a driving instructor for example. (He'd need to do something else before that one though, as I don't think you can teach anyone else to drive until you're over 21 and have had a licence for at least 3 years.)

Rather than thinking about where he is going to live, when it sounds like that isn't an immediately pressing concern right now, help him identify what his skills are (or could be) so that he can find a way of making a decent living. That way, by the time he's 21 or 22 he could be living with you, be several years into his working life, and have some savings behind him already.

2bazookas · 25/04/2023 14:50

Would I be unreasonable to suggest he stays home once he's found employment and saves up enough for a house deposit which is most definitely cheaper than rent where he wants to live.

In the light of his inexperience, issues, career and earning potential, is it likely to think he will ever qualify for a mortgage/be ab;e to buy a home? If not, then he's going to be a lifetime renter; probably of more modest property than he wants. He's not going to be a "high flyer, or high earner.

Sounds like you both need to be a great deal more realistic. First, you need to make sure he has all the skills he needs to leave home; know how to buy and cook food, do his own laundry, clean his home, budget his income, prioritise spending.

Charging him some rent to live at home would at least help him understand that domestic costs are not free gifts from heaven; food, heat, wifi and TV, hot showers etc cost money.

Lwrenagain · 25/04/2023 14:49

@steppemum you're absolutely 💯 spot on.

@xyxygy this is really interesting because he has said for years he'd love to have a summerhouse or habitable shed!
He likes the idea of being close enough to see us daily, (we facetime when he's with his dad etc and he rings every day if he's on holiday with dad and dsm) but he wants to have space. It's definitely worth considering he might be a bit overwhelmed with a busy household. His younger brother is quite severely autistic (I know I shouldn't say that) but I think he can drive him a bit mental with his noises and things. So I'm definitely going to discuss this with him!

Thanks everyone x

OP posts:
Lwrenagain · 25/04/2023 14:43

@ShipSpace that's truly shit. I'll never understand some people.

@SnuggleBuggleBoo it's absolutely disgraceful that you work so hard and still can't get somewhere. I'm really sorry. It's a joke.

I probably should really tell him we'll discuss all this when he's older, he's just so excited that I don't want to piss on his parade.

Youth and freedom are exciting until you realise you're poor and it gets boring 😂

OP posts:
xyxygy · 25/04/2023 14:42

OK, here's a question: what's his motivation behind wanting a plan to move out? Is it because he's feeling like he needs his own space?

That's very common with folk with ASD. I'm one of them, and I felt like everything I was doing at school was precisely geared towards the goal of moving out and becoming my own person so I could build my life around my own needs without necessarily needing to consider others. I felt a bit selfish in that respect at the time, and being diagnosed autistic three decades later kind of puts it in a different context - looking back, it was more of a recognition that my needs were different to the rest of the household.

Anyway, if it's something like that, then could you work towards him having his own slightly-more-independent space in the house (or even an outbuilding that's "his" - do you have a brick shed that could be made practical for living?).

Ultimately, it's not practical for most under-25s to comfortably live on their own these days, unless they land a unicorn job (which, from your description, doesn't sound realistic right now).

steppemum · 25/04/2023 14:41

good grief he hasn't even sat GCSEs!

At the moment there is a whole world out there and he has no idea how he is going to fit into it.

Wait and see how he goes. He may move out to share with friends, he may not. He may last 2 months and come home because your cooking is better!
Concentrate on training. What does he want to do in sixth form? What is his back up plan if he doesn't get into sixth form?
If he isn't academic, have you thought about a trade? Plumber? Electrician? Builder? Good earnings, in demand and needs less academic qualifications.
If he does A levels, then what?

try and get him to focus on training, not on where he is going to live. He will need to live at home for at least the next 2 years and he will not be entilted to anything and he is expected to be in school or training.

cestlavielife · 25/04/2023 14:38

Leave him be
Let him plan
Let him live his life
If that is renting innice part in his 20s so be it
His life to live

Mydog1 · 25/04/2023 14:38

Lwrenagain · 25/04/2023 14:17

He's 16 which seems so young to me, but he's planning all these things and whilst I love he talks to me and keeps me in his loop, I guess I'm worried he'll just up and off and get into debt etc to keep up with his pals.

I've clearly given this quite alot more thought than I needed to, but I remember being 16 and fending for myself and I just don't want him to struggle.

I'm just thinking. If he's only 16. And gos into an estate agent and says I would like to rent that flat. They are going to do affordability checks which from what I understand he won't pass ? Due to know realible income .

Lwrenagain · 25/04/2023 14:37

My son is literally the only person who was born in the 2000s who happens to be exceptionally crap at technology! 😂

He actually would like to do some kind of work with trauma and grief, he lost lots of family quite tragically when he was younger, which really affected him, so he thinks that's something he'd enjoy, helping others come to terms with grief. However again, I'm not sure how academic he'd need to be for that.

I do need to chill. I've read these replies and I can see I'm just being absolutely daft. So I thank you for kind replies.
I'm a hormonal pregnant mess also, so I'm just over thinking obviously.

I suppose everyone just wants their kids to have things easier than they did don't they? Thanks for kind words and advice and reality check x

OP posts:
SnuggleBuggleBoo · 25/04/2023 14:35

I'm in my 30s and live 'at home' because it doesn't seem to matter how much I save, house prices are rising faster. I earn around £25k a year and I'd be surprised if your son is on more than that before he's 25 or so without an apprenticeship or degree.

ShipSpace · 25/04/2023 14:34

My son’s best friend couldn’t finish 6th form due to a serious injury and too much time off school.

He already had excellent GCSE’s.

His parents made him get a minimum wage job and pay them most of his salary in rent at the age of 17.

How he’s ever supposed to move on from that now, I have no idea 😡

Floralnomad · 25/04/2023 14:33

Just stop engaging with any talk of moving out , if he mentions it again just tell him it’s a few years off and worry about it when it’s closer to happening .

Mabelface · 25/04/2023 14:30

Chill, my lovely. Don't write him off just yet! Being academic isn't the only route to well paying jobs. What are his interests? It may be worth investigating to see if they're something that could potentially lead to a good job. One of mine with asd started out doing an apprenticeship in Web development and he's started on this path and doing very well. The tech industry is full of nd people.

Lwrenagain · 25/04/2023 14:29

ShipSpace · 25/04/2023 14:27

Yes, it is incredibly difficult for young people now.

Either you have help with a deposit, have extremely high earnings, or you are stuck renting for an eternity.

The most realistic way to help for most parents is to have them live at home without charging any rent.

Makes me very angry indeed that some parents who are in a position to do this, chose not to, under the pretence of some kind of life lesson in money.

It's horrible isn't it? Unless you struggle with your DC's company or something I can't understand why you'd not help them.

OP posts:
ShipSpace · 25/04/2023 14:27

Yes, it is incredibly difficult for young people now.

Either you have help with a deposit, have extremely high earnings, or you are stuck renting for an eternity.

The most realistic way to help for most parents is to have them live at home without charging any rent.

Makes me very angry indeed that some parents who are in a position to do this, chose not to, under the pretence of some kind of life lesson in money.

Lwrenagain · 25/04/2023 14:24

Do you know what I think has worried me? Sounds absolutely bonkers, but just how expensive basics are. How the hell people are supposed to have a hope in hell without as much help as possible is just alot to think about.

He doesn't pay rent, I'm just thinking long term of things I can realistically do.

I'm not overly neurotic usually, it's just I'm reading here people now making 6 figures are struggling and it's just shocking.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread