Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's a nasty neighbour one with diagram!

489 replies

bathroomwindowargh · 25/04/2023 11:53

So much of this is tedious backstory, but better to contextualise and not drip feed, so here we go. Also I’d prob be wise to change details but on the other hand I can barely get my head round it myself so this is all straight facts. Name changed though!
We live in a weird house, and when I moved in with now DH 15 years ago, as part of a revamp we built a new bathroom in part of the existing garage, bathroom had no window. The back wall of our house and garage and therefore the outer wall of the bathroom is a wall in someone else’s garden. I know I’m gonna have to add a diagram and I will!
The someone else was an elderly neighbour who I really loved and visited a lot, but she died a couple of years ago, and the house was empty for a bit.
This just happened to coincide with us re-doing the bathroom and DH thought it was a chance to put a window in. He didn’t put one in first time round because we asked elderly neighbour’s late DH and he said no, so fair enough we didn’t push it. But this time DH thought the timing meant he could get away with it. I was a bit unsure but he basically just went ahead.
In the process he a) informed the son of late elderly woman that window was happening and could he please tell any buyers.
b) informed the estate agents to please tell any buyers.
c) got planning permission.

Basically he kept in touch with son and EA so we thought all good. Window finished. New neighbours moved in. A couple in their 30s, new to the village (yes we live in a village, so it's rural). The bloke hit the roof at the window, and claims no one told him, but we have our suspicions that he might be telling porkies.
Now the window cannot be seen at all from their house (I know this for a fact because I spent plenty time in their house visiting elderly friend, and I’m well aware what parts of the garden are visible from the house and what are not). This wall is not. It’s not a large window it’s a wide but shallow window from top to bottom window and the glass is not remotely see through, proper obscured glass. But the bloke hates it and is obviously very pissed off.
I have some sympathy for this to be honest, I did think DH was chancing it building the window while the house was empty, even though he played it all by the book.

Now to the meat. Since they moved in bloke and DH are at loggerheads but managing to be sort of surface polite, bloke came round and discussed it with DH and DH agreed to a window limiter so window would only open a couple of inches. Not happy but agreed. I was away so I haven’t met them.
However – DH says bloke was subtly threatening and bullying, and since we agreed to window limiter bloke has put both a shed overlapping one end of the window, a trellis right up almost touching and – worst and most aggressive – a piece of wood against the outside of the window so that effectively we can’t open it all all, not even a centimetre. DH very upset. It does feel like a bullying act of aggression, especially given we agreed to limit the window from our side, and it means we can’t clean the outside of the window by opening it and with the trellis etc DH thinks it’s going to get quickly fouled up with trapped leaves.
Meanwhile the pretence at being civilised carries on apace and DH, who bumps into the bloke fairly regularly (I never seem to see them but I’m away a lot) has invited them both round for coffee and to see the bathroom, to which they’ve just replied they’ll get back to us with times.
DH wants civility to prevail and wants me to re-open the question of a window limiter and could he please kindly remove his fucking aggressive stick from our window (my words, I’m getting angry writing this).

My problem is I’m a post-menopausal harpy and I feel only capable of two modes with this. 1. Play dumb and nice but not get involved. 2. Give it to bloke with all barrels, tell him what I think of his piece of wood and call him out for bullying DH. DH is a totally non-macho pussycat by the way and probably mildly autistic, hence walking into this by blithely building his bloody window.
I could do without ANY of it! By the way there are no other windows on the back of our house except three roof skylights in the upstairs living room.

Help – what should I do? I’ve been putting off even thinking about it but it’s now upon us – the civilised visit – and I’m going to have to meet these people and say something. But what? AIBU to want to fight the bully?
Sorry so long. Really didn’t want to drip feed.

It's a nasty neighbour one with diagram!
OP posts:
Tunaormayo74 · 25/04/2023 18:09

DelurkingLawyer · 25/04/2023 17:36

Hi @bathroomwindowargh I am a barrister and I have litigated a lot of cases about nuisance and trespass.

A window that protrudes onto someone else’s property is both a nuisance and a trespass. There are many examples of similar scenarios in the case law - for example if you construct an eaves which overhangs your neighbour’s property even by an inch, or if water from your house drips into your neighbour’s property (even if that only happens periodically).

This is your neighbour’s land. You can’t use it to open your window into - or for any other purpose. There is no difference in principle between this and someone parking their car overhanging their neighbour’s drive (a common situation in threads on here). It might be very convenient for the owner of the car, and it might not happen all the time, or prevent the neighbour from parking their own car. But it still isn’t the parker’s drive to park on.

I’d be amazed if your DH had got planning permission for a window opening into his neighbour’s land for precisely these reasons. Even if he did get permission for an outward opening window, the grant of planning permission is not determinative of whether the window is a nuisance or a trespass, because the courts have decided that planners can’t be lumbered with adjudicating questions of private law between neighbours.

The upshot of that is that even if there was planning permission for an outward-opening window, your neighbour could still sue you in nuisance.

As for him preventing you from opening the window, it is more bad news I am afraid. The victim of a nuisance is entitled to abate the nuisance, which means taking action to remedy the nuisance without taking legal proceedings. Provided the action doesn’t involve more than is necessary to abate the nuisance and doesn’t cause unnecessary damage, it’s legal. Preventing you from opening the window by using a stake strikes me as well within the scope of reasonable abatement.

Wonderfully clear.

MrBit · 25/04/2023 17:57

I dont believe you can @sylvandweller as it could cause structual damage

sylvandweller · 25/04/2023 17:54

Is he allowed to fix things (like a trellis) to your wall?

ReadersD1gest · 25/04/2023 17:51

Lolaandbehold · 25/04/2023 17:48

You've gotten a hard time on this post, OP. I think you're perfectly reasonable. You got permission so he can take it up with the council.
Moreover their garden is enormous and now here near them; it'll barely affect him. Don't get me wrong, if I were the neighbours I wouldn't love it either but it's opaque glass and you haven't done anything wrong..

The delicious irony of this post following one from a qualified barrister stating the exact opposite has made me laugh. Bless...

Lolaandbehold · 25/04/2023 17:48

You've gotten a hard time on this post, OP. I think you're perfectly reasonable. You got permission so he can take it up with the council.
Moreover their garden is enormous and now here near them; it'll barely affect him. Don't get me wrong, if I were the neighbours I wouldn't love it either but it's opaque glass and you haven't done anything wrong..

DelurkingLawyer · 25/04/2023 17:36

Hi @bathroomwindowargh I am a barrister and I have litigated a lot of cases about nuisance and trespass.

A window that protrudes onto someone else’s property is both a nuisance and a trespass. There are many examples of similar scenarios in the case law - for example if you construct an eaves which overhangs your neighbour’s property even by an inch, or if water from your house drips into your neighbour’s property (even if that only happens periodically).

This is your neighbour’s land. You can’t use it to open your window into - or for any other purpose. There is no difference in principle between this and someone parking their car overhanging their neighbour’s drive (a common situation in threads on here). It might be very convenient for the owner of the car, and it might not happen all the time, or prevent the neighbour from parking their own car. But it still isn’t the parker’s drive to park on.

I’d be amazed if your DH had got planning permission for a window opening into his neighbour’s land for precisely these reasons. Even if he did get permission for an outward opening window, the grant of planning permission is not determinative of whether the window is a nuisance or a trespass, because the courts have decided that planners can’t be lumbered with adjudicating questions of private law between neighbours.

The upshot of that is that even if there was planning permission for an outward-opening window, your neighbour could still sue you in nuisance.

As for him preventing you from opening the window, it is more bad news I am afraid. The victim of a nuisance is entitled to abate the nuisance, which means taking action to remedy the nuisance without taking legal proceedings. Provided the action doesn’t involve more than is necessary to abate the nuisance and doesn’t cause unnecessary damage, it’s legal. Preventing you from opening the window by using a stake strikes me as well within the scope of reasonable abatement.

GalaApples · 25/04/2023 17:34
  1. You should have got a party wall agreement for the work on the shared wall.
  2. Your window opens outwards onto their space? YABVU in that case, and it is probably not even legal.
Ryanstartedthefire2 · 25/04/2023 17:34

If I'd just bought a nice new house with what I thought was a private garden and found that the neighbours had sneakily installed an overlooking window after the previous old lady died I'd be annoyed too. You are in the wrong here I'm afraid. Privacy is a big plus point in a garden. He might now hear you pooping and smell your poos and have you snooping on him 😅

Boohisspiss · 25/04/2023 17:32

I would just be too worried about bad blood with neighbours to do this. Have no idea about the legality of the window, but either he blocks with a massive fence, or this issue rumbles on for years. Is it really worth it?

User339406 · 25/04/2023 17:30

I would fit a new window and suck up the cost of tidying up the window frame.

If you want fresh air in your bathroom you'll need to change the window to one that opens inwards then you can do what you like your side of the boundary, he can do the same on his.

ChickenDhansak82 · 25/04/2023 17:27

@bathroomwindowargh Ultimately it is you and your DH who are in the wrong here.

You can have a window looking out onto the neighbours property, but the window should NOT open outwards as that is trespassing.

The window needs to open inwards or not open at all. A window limiter is pointless. Either install a window that opens inwards or one that does not open. Take it out and turn it round!

Your neighbour is also entitled to block the window and put a shed up against it.

You should be grovelling to these neighbours with an apology.

ExhaustedPigwidgeon · 25/04/2023 17:27

How long did it take to get pp anyway? I thought these things dragged on for yonks!

Elsiedarlingputthekettleon · 25/04/2023 17:26

Sorry, that was in response to DrPrunesquallor.

SoDamnObvious · 25/04/2023 17:25

bathroomwindowargh · 25/04/2023 17:07

The bathroom was put in fifteen years ago.
The window six months ago. And TBH I don't know the details because it's all DH's baby. But quite possibly not.

You absolutely need pp to put a new window into a wall where there wasn’t one before op. We did it at our last house and the window only overlooked our own garden. They came round to inspect before approving.

I suspect you will be told to brick it up if you haven’t even bother to get pp and just went off the old lady’s son giving permission.

Elsiedarlingputthekettleon · 25/04/2023 17:24

If this happened uninterrupted for 20years they they will have acquired an easement.
If less then a county court judgement would have made them block it all up.
Plus if the window is right next to your house, that’s a fire hazard. Again a breach of building regs.

I've no idea how long it had been there but now it's definitely more than 20 years. They have three windows, one is next to the corner of our kitchen extension, the middle one is the one that actually opens, and the end one is next to our brick outbuilding. The latest neighbour knows nothing about the previous issues, and hasn't commented regarding the window not quite opening. It's also been sold again and the new owner who is renting it out hasn't said anything either. I just get on with it now becasuse the issue was resolved, but not sure if the OP may have problems.

Acornsoup · 25/04/2023 17:19

Deal: rabbitgoo Window Film Privacy, Privacy Film for Glass Windows Frosted... https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B01M3RT7MT?ref=cmmswrrapindpp_XM7E6E8KGZQ9VAFRDESX

Brightex, ENVIROVENT EXTRACTOR FAN 4INCH 100MM STANDARD BATHROOM SHOWER TOI... https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0BL1CB14B?ref=cmmswrrapindpp_EETXJZHKRDR5AJZZPG4N

The solution doesn't need to be expensive.
To be fair that corner looks like the private end of the garden (your window aside) if they were thinking of putting in a hot tub for example and restricting views from the other neighbours.

LakieLady · 25/04/2023 17:17

piedbeauty · 25/04/2023 13:37

i do get that but for me the bigger issue would be the smells and sounds coming out of the bathroom. If they leave the window open and have a loud poo - or if they leave the extractor fan on after a shower for ages and leave the window open so you can hear that buzzing sound the extractor makes. Or if you’re sitting on your seating area having a glass of wine and you get to watch the neighbour having their evening shower because they forgot you can see in.

But, @ExhaustedPigwidgeon, with lots of houses you're much much closer to people's bathrooms than the neighbour is here! So is that an issue? It looks like his garden is about 100 feet long. Would he be able to hear anything from there? If you lived in a flat with a garden you'd be much closer to people's bathrooms!

I agree@piedbeauty .

I live in a semi-detached house. Both houses have their bathroom on the outside wall at the back, so as far from the neighbouring garden as it is possible to be.

Despite that, if I'm in the garden and NDNs are using their bathroom with the small transom window open, I can hear them shitting, pissing and Mr NDN hoicking up phlegm and spitting.

It's not nice, but it's part and parcel of living adjacent to other people.

The time for the new owners to object was at the PP stage, and they didn't. If they're pissed off with anyone, it should be their solicitor for not pointing out the application or the recently granted PP.

I think the NDNs are being a bit precious about it, tbh.

DrPrunesquallor · 25/04/2023 17:17

Elsiedarlingputthekettleon · 25/04/2023 17:15

This happened to us. On the party wall to the left of our garden the neighbour took advantage of the house (ours) being empty before we bought it and built a crappy extension/lean to. The house is rented out so we have had several neighbours. The window to the leant to runs all the way along the party wall from our kitchen extension to our brick shed. The window opened onto our garden and they used to just hang in there being nosey, throwing cig butts out etc. In the end we spoke to the person who owned it and they basically said it was years ago, so tough. Then the next renter decided to put a camera up to film. He wasn't mentally well, but still not acceptable.

My DH built a fence. Right along the party wall. Blocks out their window and limits them opening it. They weren't happy, but it's our side and legal, where I would hazard a guess theirs is not.

If this happened uninterrupted for 20years they they will have acquired an easement.
If less then a county court judgement would have made them block it all up.
Plus if the window is right next to your house, that’s a fire hazard. Again a breach of building regs.

bathroomwindowargh · 25/04/2023 17:16

ReadersD1gest · 25/04/2023 17:14

Why not?!

Because, as I said in first post, neighbour (as in deceased DH of more recently deceased elderly neighbour) said no. Which we accepted.

OP posts:
monsteramunch · 25/04/2023 17:16

Just to clarify OP, are you saying that you definitely having planning permission for an outward opening window?

Or that you haven't seen that in writing, you just have your husband's word for it?

If the latter is the case, you need to ask him for the paperwork so you know what's happened more clearly.

Elsiedarlingputthekettleon · 25/04/2023 17:15

This happened to us. On the party wall to the left of our garden the neighbour took advantage of the house (ours) being empty before we bought it and built a crappy extension/lean to. The house is rented out so we have had several neighbours. The window to the leant to runs all the way along the party wall from our kitchen extension to our brick shed. The window opened onto our garden and they used to just hang in there being nosey, throwing cig butts out etc. In the end we spoke to the person who owned it and they basically said it was years ago, so tough. Then the next renter decided to put a camera up to film. He wasn't mentally well, but still not acceptable.

My DH built a fence. Right along the party wall. Blocks out their window and limits them opening it. They weren't happy, but it's our side and legal, where I would hazard a guess theirs is not.

ReadersD1gest · 25/04/2023 17:14

bathroomwindowargh · 25/04/2023 17:14

We didn't ask for pp for a window first time.

Why not?!

bathroomwindowargh · 25/04/2023 17:14

ReadersD1gest · 25/04/2023 17:13

There was a bloody good reason there was no window for 15 years, and your dh waited till the neighbour was dead to sneak an application in!
I don't believe a word about planning permission. It was clearly refused when the original renovation was done, why would it be given permission now?

We didn't ask for pp for a window first time.

OP posts:
DrPrunesquallor · 25/04/2023 17:13

bathroomwindowargh · 25/04/2023 17:07

The bathroom was put in fifteen years ago.
The window six months ago. And TBH I don't know the details because it's all DH's baby. But quite possibly not.

You noted the works were all ‘signed off’.
Planners don’t sign off work. ( they may visit large sites periodically ) The ‘signing off’ would be Building control which has nothing to do with planning.

If you do not have the approval you can check all the documents on your local planning site.
Put in your post code on the council planning applications website and all drawings plus explanation of what’s proposed and the approval notice is there for you / and your neighbour to view.

I suspect you are in breach of planning.

ReadersD1gest · 25/04/2023 17:13

bathroomwindowargh · 25/04/2023 17:07

The bathroom was put in fifteen years ago.
The window six months ago. And TBH I don't know the details because it's all DH's baby. But quite possibly not.

There was a bloody good reason there was no window for 15 years, and your dh waited till the neighbour was dead to sneak an application in!
I don't believe a word about planning permission. It was clearly refused when the original renovation was done, why would it be given permission now?

Swipe left for the next trending thread