Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's a nasty neighbour one with diagram!

489 replies

bathroomwindowargh · 25/04/2023 11:53

So much of this is tedious backstory, but better to contextualise and not drip feed, so here we go. Also I’d prob be wise to change details but on the other hand I can barely get my head round it myself so this is all straight facts. Name changed though!
We live in a weird house, and when I moved in with now DH 15 years ago, as part of a revamp we built a new bathroom in part of the existing garage, bathroom had no window. The back wall of our house and garage and therefore the outer wall of the bathroom is a wall in someone else’s garden. I know I’m gonna have to add a diagram and I will!
The someone else was an elderly neighbour who I really loved and visited a lot, but she died a couple of years ago, and the house was empty for a bit.
This just happened to coincide with us re-doing the bathroom and DH thought it was a chance to put a window in. He didn’t put one in first time round because we asked elderly neighbour’s late DH and he said no, so fair enough we didn’t push it. But this time DH thought the timing meant he could get away with it. I was a bit unsure but he basically just went ahead.
In the process he a) informed the son of late elderly woman that window was happening and could he please tell any buyers.
b) informed the estate agents to please tell any buyers.
c) got planning permission.

Basically he kept in touch with son and EA so we thought all good. Window finished. New neighbours moved in. A couple in their 30s, new to the village (yes we live in a village, so it's rural). The bloke hit the roof at the window, and claims no one told him, but we have our suspicions that he might be telling porkies.
Now the window cannot be seen at all from their house (I know this for a fact because I spent plenty time in their house visiting elderly friend, and I’m well aware what parts of the garden are visible from the house and what are not). This wall is not. It’s not a large window it’s a wide but shallow window from top to bottom window and the glass is not remotely see through, proper obscured glass. But the bloke hates it and is obviously very pissed off.
I have some sympathy for this to be honest, I did think DH was chancing it building the window while the house was empty, even though he played it all by the book.

Now to the meat. Since they moved in bloke and DH are at loggerheads but managing to be sort of surface polite, bloke came round and discussed it with DH and DH agreed to a window limiter so window would only open a couple of inches. Not happy but agreed. I was away so I haven’t met them.
However – DH says bloke was subtly threatening and bullying, and since we agreed to window limiter bloke has put both a shed overlapping one end of the window, a trellis right up almost touching and – worst and most aggressive – a piece of wood against the outside of the window so that effectively we can’t open it all all, not even a centimetre. DH very upset. It does feel like a bullying act of aggression, especially given we agreed to limit the window from our side, and it means we can’t clean the outside of the window by opening it and with the trellis etc DH thinks it’s going to get quickly fouled up with trapped leaves.
Meanwhile the pretence at being civilised carries on apace and DH, who bumps into the bloke fairly regularly (I never seem to see them but I’m away a lot) has invited them both round for coffee and to see the bathroom, to which they’ve just replied they’ll get back to us with times.
DH wants civility to prevail and wants me to re-open the question of a window limiter and could he please kindly remove his fucking aggressive stick from our window (my words, I’m getting angry writing this).

My problem is I’m a post-menopausal harpy and I feel only capable of two modes with this. 1. Play dumb and nice but not get involved. 2. Give it to bloke with all barrels, tell him what I think of his piece of wood and call him out for bullying DH. DH is a totally non-macho pussycat by the way and probably mildly autistic, hence walking into this by blithely building his bloody window.
I could do without ANY of it! By the way there are no other windows on the back of our house except three roof skylights in the upstairs living room.

Help – what should I do? I’ve been putting off even thinking about it but it’s now upon us – the civilised visit – and I’m going to have to meet these people and say something. But what? AIBU to want to fight the bully?
Sorry so long. Really didn’t want to drip feed.

It's a nasty neighbour one with diagram!
OP posts:
Cakeorchocolate · 25/04/2023 21:20

Haven't rtft, read OPs updates.

I can't see why you feel the need to apologise or get DH to. From your posts, there is pp for the window. Therefore no-one has done anything wrong.

The most I would do when speaking to the neighbour is acknowledge that you understand it must be frustrating for them if they were unaware of the change but that you / DH had specifically spoken to everyone you could to ensure potential buyers were informed of the planned window.

I also can't see why they're making such a big deal about it from your diagram.

MrBit · 25/04/2023 21:15

If I were the neighbour I'd want it bricked up my side, there's no saying what other people would do if it was sold on otherwise

ReadersD1gest · 25/04/2023 21:08

maddy68 · 25/04/2023 21:06

I would also do this.

You haven't got panning permission for the window. Only for the extension

I doubt the neighbour will forget it's there. Why should he?

maddy68 · 25/04/2023 21:06

Floralnomad · 25/04/2023 20:04

Unless you can take the window out I’d just seal it up , stick a blind up on the inside and pretend it’s not there . The fact that the old neighbour said no should have given you a hint as to how this would go down with any buyer - and you got on well with them . I don’t blame your neighbour for covering it up as I’d likely do the same , and as he is on his own property I doubt there is much you can do .

I would also do this.

You haven't got panning permission for the window. Only for the extension

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 25/04/2023 21:05

I think, whilst erecting this window, a mess has been made on the neighbours' side and they are pissed off.

Iloveajacketspud · 25/04/2023 20:45

Convenient you seem to be away when lots of things have been signed off and approved

I think your dh is panicking (and rightly so!) as he’s tried to pull a fast one and new neighbour isn’t happy

as you’ve had this long without a windows just resign yourself to not having one and if you do get some light that’s a bonus

Itsmebutnotme · 25/04/2023 20:24

@bathroomwindowargh Has your neighbour threatened legal action and you have come on here to find out where you stand?

MattTebbuttsDenimShirt · 25/04/2023 20:22

Imagine sitting out by candlelight on a lovely summers Eve and part of your garden gets lit up every time someone has a wee, a shower, whatever, uses the bathroom. It would drive me mad(der).

Floralnomad · 25/04/2023 20:04

Unless you can take the window out I’d just seal it up , stick a blind up on the inside and pretend it’s not there . The fact that the old neighbour said no should have given you a hint as to how this would go down with any buyer - and you got on well with them . I don’t blame your neighbour for covering it up as I’d likely do the same , and as he is on his own property I doubt there is much you can do .

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 25/04/2023 19:56

RestrictiveCovenant · 25/04/2023 16:47

We had one of these in a hallway in our previous house op. It wasn’t possible to have a window (very odd lay out), but this went up to a higher roofline and let in a ton of natural light. Might work tunnelled up through the garage.
https://solatube.co.uk/residential/

This is pretty much what I currently have in my downstairs, windowless bathroom, it's a light well. My bathroom is in a single storey extension (very old cottages), and goes up through the ceiling and then up to the roofline. I'd love to have it replaced with a full glass roof, but it means raising the whole ceiling up to the roofline, so I'm still thinking about it. But the lightwell works really well to bring natural light into an otherwise unilluminated room!

JudgeRudy · 25/04/2023 19:22

I guess if you've already got planning permission it's tough, however I'm unclear what type of window it is. Doesthe window open on to his gardenie when you open it dies the bottom of the opened window now sit in their garden? I'd be really surprised if you could essentially encroach onto so.eone else's land.
I can understand you wanting light in your bathroom but no way would I want to be taking a bath or using the loo knowing my neighbour (and any of his guests) could look in through the window!

WhoToBeToday · 25/04/2023 19:19

I have a 300 foot garden. I would be seriously unhappy if someone's window (obscured or not) faced onto it. Even though I don't go down there very often, the whole knowledge it was there would feel intrusive.

Your DH fucked up.

DelurkingLawyer · 25/04/2023 18:59

JennyForeigner · 25/04/2023 18:43

That was a wonderfully MN moment. On both sides 😁

I don’t want to be too hard on anyone who reached a different conclusion (although they are wrong!).

Nuisance is one of the most difficult areas of law I do. That’s partly because the principles don’t always seem “fair” to the layman. A recent example is the Tate gallery “overlooking” case where the flats were visible from the viewing platform. Lots of people said “but the Tate was there first” - that’s not a defence to a claim in nuisance (yes you can move in next door to a factory and then complain about the noise - whether it’s a nuisance isn’t decided on a “who was there first” basis).

That’s why I put in the example of the car sometimes overhanging someone else’s drive. Most people can see why that’s not right. A big part of my job is explaining the law in a way that people “get”.

JennyForeigner · 25/04/2023 18:43

ReadersD1gest · 25/04/2023 17:51

The delicious irony of this post following one from a qualified barrister stating the exact opposite has made me laugh. Bless...

That was a wonderfully MN moment. On both sides 😁

DrPrunesquallor · 25/04/2023 18:35

Newmum0322 · 25/04/2023 18:31

Do you need to open the window?

I agree with previous posters that it was silly to put the window in, but you already know this. The fact is, the two parties agreed to an amicable solution and the neighbour has decided to heighten tensions with the wood.

Me, in this exact scenario… I would not open the window (it’s frosted so who cares if it dirty?) I wouldn’t invite them round for peace making, and if you or your husband ever bump into them, ignore them. No eye contact, no niceties, just point blank ignore them.

However, If you absolutely need to open the window then do what you have to do. I personally wouldn’t!

However.
If the window is there as it is for 20years the OP will have acquired an easement over the neighbours land
It won’t work for the neighbour to allow the openable window, as it is, to be there whether they agree to leave it closed or not.

henchhen · 25/04/2023 18:33

Surely this is going to continue to escalate until the neighbours complain officially and the OP is forced to remove the window? Then you'll also have a neighbour disagreement to inform sellers of. Isn't the most straightforward option to remove the window, and therefore the issue?

Newmum0322 · 25/04/2023 18:31

Do you need to open the window?

I agree with previous posters that it was silly to put the window in, but you already know this. The fact is, the two parties agreed to an amicable solution and the neighbour has decided to heighten tensions with the wood.

Me, in this exact scenario… I would not open the window (it’s frosted so who cares if it dirty?) I wouldn’t invite them round for peace making, and if you or your husband ever bump into them, ignore them. No eye contact, no niceties, just point blank ignore them.

However, If you absolutely need to open the window then do what you have to do. I personally wouldn’t!

DrPrunesquallor · 25/04/2023 18:23

BoogieBoogieWoogie · 25/04/2023 18:21

Not at all. She said it was quite possible it wasnt specific to opening outwards. The actual window was approved by someone from the council. Whether that is the same as PP Im not sure

Guessing this is referring to building regs.
Not planners
There won’t be planning approval for this as it stands.

OP should avoid an injunction ( all costs will be OPs )

GasPanic · 25/04/2023 18:22

DelurkingLawyer · 25/04/2023 17:36

Hi @bathroomwindowargh I am a barrister and I have litigated a lot of cases about nuisance and trespass.

A window that protrudes onto someone else’s property is both a nuisance and a trespass. There are many examples of similar scenarios in the case law - for example if you construct an eaves which overhangs your neighbour’s property even by an inch, or if water from your house drips into your neighbour’s property (even if that only happens periodically).

This is your neighbour’s land. You can’t use it to open your window into - or for any other purpose. There is no difference in principle between this and someone parking their car overhanging their neighbour’s drive (a common situation in threads on here). It might be very convenient for the owner of the car, and it might not happen all the time, or prevent the neighbour from parking their own car. But it still isn’t the parker’s drive to park on.

I’d be amazed if your DH had got planning permission for a window opening into his neighbour’s land for precisely these reasons. Even if he did get permission for an outward opening window, the grant of planning permission is not determinative of whether the window is a nuisance or a trespass, because the courts have decided that planners can’t be lumbered with adjudicating questions of private law between neighbours.

The upshot of that is that even if there was planning permission for an outward-opening window, your neighbour could still sue you in nuisance.

As for him preventing you from opening the window, it is more bad news I am afraid. The victim of a nuisance is entitled to abate the nuisance, which means taking action to remedy the nuisance without taking legal proceedings. Provided the action doesn’t involve more than is necessary to abate the nuisance and doesn’t cause unnecessary damage, it’s legal. Preventing you from opening the window by using a stake strikes me as well within the scope of reasonable abatement.

Thanks.

That taught me something interesting.

MariaRemindsMeOfAWestSideStory · 25/04/2023 18:21

ReadersD1gest · 25/04/2023 17:51

The delicious irony of this post following one from a qualified barrister stating the exact opposite has made me laugh. Bless...

It definitely made me laugh too. There’s the law…and then there’s the law according to internet users!

Daylighteyes · 25/04/2023 18:21

I wouldn’t like this, OP.

What if he wanted to build a summerhouse etc, at the bottom of his garden, or if they want to sit at there on a warm Summer’s evening, when suddenly a you switch your bathroom light on and they’re illuminated and most likely can see your fuzzy outline through the window.

Sorry but your DH took a gamble with this one and gas to admit defeat.

BoogieBoogieWoogie · 25/04/2023 18:21

Hairpinleg · 25/04/2023 18:16

The OP has now said that it's 'quite possible' her husband didn't apply for planning permission for the window after all so that would explain why it wasn't flagged by the solicitor. There was no planning application to flag.

Not at all. She said it was quite possible it wasnt specific to opening outwards. The actual window was approved by someone from the council. Whether that is the same as PP Im not sure

Hairpinleg · 25/04/2023 18:16

StarbucksSmarterSister · 25/04/2023 17:04

Not necessarily but if that's the case, the solicitor should have flagged it. Either they weren't competent or NDN didn't see it as an issue before exchange.

The OP has now said that it's 'quite possible' her husband didn't apply for planning permission for the window after all so that would explain why it wasn't flagged by the solicitor. There was no planning application to flag.

MargaretThursday · 25/04/2023 18:14

IVbumble · 25/04/2023 18:09

Maybe your neighbour wants to sell part of his garden to you - then the window will be in your garden.

If they can't afford to replace the (small they say) window for an inward opening one, then they'll never be able afford to buy part of the garden from an aggrieved neighbour.

IVbumble · 25/04/2023 18:09

Maybe your neighbour wants to sell part of his garden to you - then the window will be in your garden.