Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's a nasty neighbour one with diagram!

489 replies

bathroomwindowargh · 25/04/2023 11:53

So much of this is tedious backstory, but better to contextualise and not drip feed, so here we go. Also I’d prob be wise to change details but on the other hand I can barely get my head round it myself so this is all straight facts. Name changed though!
We live in a weird house, and when I moved in with now DH 15 years ago, as part of a revamp we built a new bathroom in part of the existing garage, bathroom had no window. The back wall of our house and garage and therefore the outer wall of the bathroom is a wall in someone else’s garden. I know I’m gonna have to add a diagram and I will!
The someone else was an elderly neighbour who I really loved and visited a lot, but she died a couple of years ago, and the house was empty for a bit.
This just happened to coincide with us re-doing the bathroom and DH thought it was a chance to put a window in. He didn’t put one in first time round because we asked elderly neighbour’s late DH and he said no, so fair enough we didn’t push it. But this time DH thought the timing meant he could get away with it. I was a bit unsure but he basically just went ahead.
In the process he a) informed the son of late elderly woman that window was happening and could he please tell any buyers.
b) informed the estate agents to please tell any buyers.
c) got planning permission.

Basically he kept in touch with son and EA so we thought all good. Window finished. New neighbours moved in. A couple in their 30s, new to the village (yes we live in a village, so it's rural). The bloke hit the roof at the window, and claims no one told him, but we have our suspicions that he might be telling porkies.
Now the window cannot be seen at all from their house (I know this for a fact because I spent plenty time in their house visiting elderly friend, and I’m well aware what parts of the garden are visible from the house and what are not). This wall is not. It’s not a large window it’s a wide but shallow window from top to bottom window and the glass is not remotely see through, proper obscured glass. But the bloke hates it and is obviously very pissed off.
I have some sympathy for this to be honest, I did think DH was chancing it building the window while the house was empty, even though he played it all by the book.

Now to the meat. Since they moved in bloke and DH are at loggerheads but managing to be sort of surface polite, bloke came round and discussed it with DH and DH agreed to a window limiter so window would only open a couple of inches. Not happy but agreed. I was away so I haven’t met them.
However – DH says bloke was subtly threatening and bullying, and since we agreed to window limiter bloke has put both a shed overlapping one end of the window, a trellis right up almost touching and – worst and most aggressive – a piece of wood against the outside of the window so that effectively we can’t open it all all, not even a centimetre. DH very upset. It does feel like a bullying act of aggression, especially given we agreed to limit the window from our side, and it means we can’t clean the outside of the window by opening it and with the trellis etc DH thinks it’s going to get quickly fouled up with trapped leaves.
Meanwhile the pretence at being civilised carries on apace and DH, who bumps into the bloke fairly regularly (I never seem to see them but I’m away a lot) has invited them both round for coffee and to see the bathroom, to which they’ve just replied they’ll get back to us with times.
DH wants civility to prevail and wants me to re-open the question of a window limiter and could he please kindly remove his fucking aggressive stick from our window (my words, I’m getting angry writing this).

My problem is I’m a post-menopausal harpy and I feel only capable of two modes with this. 1. Play dumb and nice but not get involved. 2. Give it to bloke with all barrels, tell him what I think of his piece of wood and call him out for bullying DH. DH is a totally non-macho pussycat by the way and probably mildly autistic, hence walking into this by blithely building his bloody window.
I could do without ANY of it! By the way there are no other windows on the back of our house except three roof skylights in the upstairs living room.

Help – what should I do? I’ve been putting off even thinking about it but it’s now upon us – the civilised visit – and I’m going to have to meet these people and say something. But what? AIBU to want to fight the bully?
Sorry so long. Really didn’t want to drip feed.

It's a nasty neighbour one with diagram!
OP posts:
Jonei · 26/04/2023 11:19

I'd brick it up and look at the ceiling daylight options that someone posted upthread.
If I was the neighbour I'd be putting a fence right along that window and blocking it entirely.

GoodChat · 26/04/2023 11:18

Op could you black out the window from their side and put lights between the blackout and the pane so you still get what looks like natural light?

Although I guess you're screwed when a bulb goes

ReadersD1gest · 26/04/2023 11:16

GasPanic · 26/04/2023 11:14

I think people posted the solution in the first few posts. Recessed sash window.

That is if you actually have pp.

That won't solve the overlooking / nuisance issue.

GasPanic · 26/04/2023 11:14

I think people posted the solution in the first few posts. Recessed sash window.

That is if you actually have pp.

HeadNorth · 26/04/2023 10:22

Never mess with a boundary wall unless you've got no choice

I agree - it is right up there with 'never invade Russia in the winter' as a piece of wisdom to live your life by.

GoldDuster · 26/04/2023 10:17

I'd be pissed off if my neighbour did this. I have zero wish to listen to the sounds of him straining echoing off his bathroom tiles of a morning while I'm in the garden with a coffee.

The window wasn't there, should't be there, and your husband needs to rectify his own fuck ups, not look to you to deal with the neighbour who is rightly annoyed.

Never mess with a boundary wall unless you've got no choice. It's the hot potato of neighbourly disputes. Brick it up and call it a lesson.

henchhen · 26/04/2023 10:03

crossstitchingnana · 26/04/2023 09:59

I think your neighbour is being a dick. There is as much chance of you watching him from there as from your own garden. And as for "encroaching on his property" that is so petty. It's 5cm if that. How's that going to affect him? Christ some people have no life.

Well, I mean it's going to affect him directly as it looks into his garden. Just what they want, being able to see their neighbours getting showered while they're sat in their garden

crossstitchingnana · 26/04/2023 09:59

I think your neighbour is being a dick. There is as much chance of you watching him from there as from your own garden. And as for "encroaching on his property" that is so petty. It's 5cm if that. How's that going to affect him? Christ some people have no life.

monsteramunch · 26/04/2023 09:48

So for clarity's sake OP, have you seen written confirmation of PP for the outward opening window?

Surely since this thread, if you've been chatting to your DH about all this like you say, you'd have asked him to show that to you so you know for sure either way...

ReadersD1gest · 26/04/2023 09:42

Which claim the dh claims to have pp for it
Unfortunately op is being deliberately vague / ambiguous on that point.
It's not actually clear at all that pp has been secured.

Cakeorchocolate · 26/04/2023 09:37

SofiaSoFar · 25/04/2023 23:01

@Cakeorchocolate

Haven't rtft...

Clearly. 🙄

Is coming to a thread and proudly announcing that you couldn't be arsed to read it before posting incorrect advice/assertions supposed to prove something..?

Excuse me for not having time to read 17+ pages of comments and having no way of knowing there's "an experienced barrister" who has posted.

I gave my opinion based on ops posts. Which claim the dh claims to have pp for it.

I didn't set out to prove anything! It's not uncommon to not rtft and just read ops posts.
MN welcoming as always!

ReadersD1gest · 26/04/2023 09:26

meatbaseddessert · 26/04/2023 00:35

Quite. I have a 200 METER garden and this would fuck me off.

Our new neighbours moved in and chopped down a load of trees on their side of the boundary which means that when ever we go to the bottom of our garden we can see right into their bathroom. Irrespective of the window privacy film we can still see errr 'outlines' which is pretty unpleasant when tending to a herbaceous border or sharing a gin with a friend Hmm

I'd imagine it is 🤢
It beats me why op actually wants a bathroom window positioned such that the neighbours could actually draw up a chair and sit right outside the glass should they so choose 🤯

bathroomwindowargh · 26/04/2023 09:22

delilabell · 26/04/2023 09:12

Just wanted to say @bathroomwindowargh it's so lovely that both you and dp are listening to the points on here. Aibu's hardly ever change their opinion!

Thank you, I appreciate that. I'm pretty upset about the whole thing this morning and really seeing it from neighbour's POV.
I wish I'd thought more about it pre-window and objected strongly but frankly I doubt it would have made a difference as DH probably still thinks of this as more his house than my house and would have just overrode me.
He is, though, fully intending to apologise to them now. And we're obviously not going to object to the wood or anything else.
I'm going to have to try and balance a kind of neutral stance with an apologetic one without looking too much like I've not got DH's back. Although he does now know I'm angry with him - I told him yesterday that he's put us both in this situation.
I really just let him get on with it because I thought he knew what he was doing. That was my mistake.

OP posts:
delilabell · 26/04/2023 09:12

Just wanted to say @bathroomwindowargh it's so lovely that both you and dp are listening to the points on here. Aibu's hardly ever change their opinion!

CleverLilViper · 26/04/2023 08:55

I can see the neighbours POV to be honest.

It seems you both knew this was going to be an issue as your previous neighbours said no and you decided or your DH did to put it in when no one was there. Quite sneaky.

I don’t think I’d be happy. If it’s a bathroom window I assume the glass will be frosted with limited visibility anyway and maybe showing the neighbours that may help ease the tension.

however I’d worry if I were your neighbour about right to light and what you could start dictating about their garden in the future.

I think you need to start with showing the planning permission and trying to be reasonable and understanding of the issues your neighbours have with it.

L1ttledrummergirl · 26/04/2023 08:42

chocolatebunnybop · 26/04/2023 00:27

Is there not a right of access in the titles to allow you to maintain your external wall/window etc or for repairs? Wouldn't they be obstructing that clause?

My dp had similar, the neighbours built a shack right up to the boundary line, and didn't apply for pp (it's outside permitted development). They have gutter hanging over the fence. The council are awful, next stop is the ombudsman for a complaint as the council complaints policy was followed, upheld and ignored.

They told my dp they needed to put scaffold in their garden to do some essential work to their house, and were aghast that dp said no. I don't understand how they could have assumed they could just take over dp garden whenever they like.

What about the ops posts gives you the idea that they can breach a person's boundaries whenever they like?

Mortimercat · 26/04/2023 06:56

Cakeorchocolate · 25/04/2023 21:20

Haven't rtft, read OPs updates.

I can't see why you feel the need to apologise or get DH to. From your posts, there is pp for the window. Therefore no-one has done anything wrong.

The most I would do when speaking to the neighbour is acknowledge that you understand it must be frustrating for them if they were unaware of the change but that you / DH had specifically spoken to everyone you could to ensure potential buyers were informed of the planned window.

I also can't see why they're making such a big deal about it from your diagram.

@Cakeorchocolate

I don’t always read a full thread either. But in this case, if you had read the full thread, you would have read the very credible response from a barrister that deals in nuisance law. And it is very clear that there is no way PP would have been granted for an outward opening window over somebody’s garden, because it would be trespass and nuisance. (And you would note OP is deliberately vague and definitely has not said they have pp for it).

If I were the neighbour, I would be taking them to court to get this window taken out before it becomes an easement.

meatbaseddessert · 26/04/2023 00:35

WhoToBeToday · 25/04/2023 19:19

I have a 300 foot garden. I would be seriously unhappy if someone's window (obscured or not) faced onto it. Even though I don't go down there very often, the whole knowledge it was there would feel intrusive.

Your DH fucked up.

Quite. I have a 200 METER garden and this would fuck me off.

Our new neighbours moved in and chopped down a load of trees on their side of the boundary which means that when ever we go to the bottom of our garden we can see right into their bathroom. Irrespective of the window privacy film we can still see errr 'outlines' which is pretty unpleasant when tending to a herbaceous border or sharing a gin with a friend Hmm

chocolatebunnybop · 26/04/2023 00:27

Is there not a right of access in the titles to allow you to maintain your external wall/window etc or for repairs? Wouldn't they be obstructing that clause?

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 25/04/2023 23:21

Get your husband to deal with it....... it seems that this is all his fault anyway!

SofiaSoFar · 25/04/2023 23:01

@Cakeorchocolate

Haven't rtft...

Clearly. 🙄

Is coming to a thread and proudly announcing that you couldn't be arsed to read it before posting incorrect advice/assertions supposed to prove something..?

OrwellianTimes · 25/04/2023 22:33

Your husband is a chancer here and it hasn’t paid off.

ReadersD1gest · 25/04/2023 22:25

Rollercoaster1920 · 25/04/2023 22:10

For a lot of properties a new window didn't need planning permission because it would be permitted development.

Permitted development doesn't allow for overlooking or extending across boundaries.

Rollercoaster1920 · 25/04/2023 22:10

For a lot of properties a new window didn't need planning permission because it would be permitted development.

Lolaandbehold · 25/04/2023 21:49

ReadersD1gest · 25/04/2023 17:51

The delicious irony of this post following one from a qualified barrister stating the exact opposite has made me laugh. Bless...

I only read the OPs.
But I’m not a barrister with any knowledge of the law, ‘tis true. In my defence I have dealt a fair bit with the planning department of the local council and my conclusion is they’re generally assholes. I’m actually amazed that the OP got planning at all.
I still think the NDN is being a dick for the sake of it.