Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel upset about sons no contact

139 replies

otherthanthat · 25/04/2023 10:29

My ds is early 20s and lives back home with us now.
He met a girl a couple of years ago and she took an instant dislike to every member of our family, he moved in with her and they blocked us and went no contact for 18 months until they split and he came home.
He's never mentioned the no contact apart from to say he hadn't wanted to, it was her, and she didn't like anyone. He had a choice too though.

I have a close relationship with DS and we do lot's together but so did we before he met his ex and so I feel sad to know he would just turn his back on us all if someone else wanted him to.

I wouldn't ever mention it to him but I feel hurt that he didn't even give us an explanation, just ghosted us all and then casually tells us 18 months later, don't worry you didn't do anything wrong.
I understand he would put his gf first and would expect him to but 18 months felt like such a long time, and so many people were hurt, my mum died in that time still hoping for a reconciliation.

He lives here now and just behaves like nothing happened, his little sisters were hurt and confused as were other grandparents, but he seems unaffected and just carries on as though we should all be so pleased to see him again.
Maybe I should be grateful but I feel we spend 18 months wondering what we'd done wrong, worried we'd never see or hear from him, for him to say we didn't do anything wrong.
I suppose knowing I couldn't have done that to my beloved mum and that he could do it hurts the most.

OP posts:
GoodChat · 25/04/2023 11:44

I wouldn't ever mention it to him but I feel hurt that he didn't even give us an explanation

Why wouldn't you mention it to him? He's an adult. He should be aware of the pain he's caused.

He owes apologies to the people he hurt.

DivorcedAndDelighted · 25/04/2023 11:42

Taking a problem - solving approach may help. You can factually, not accusingly, tell him the impact it had on you and other family members. Because it must have been HUGE for you, wondering what you'd done wrong, if you'd ever see him again. He may not have thought this through and may not really understand, but to be a decent human being, and hopefully to be a decent partner and possibly parent in the future, he needs to get a bit better at communication than just refusing to discuss the past. Make it clear you're not blaming him, and that you don't know what may have been going on in his relationship, but you want to help him have a better toolkit for coping with relationships in future. Raise the possibility of seeing a counsellor, eg an online one. He may pooh-pooh this, but you are still setting the tone that it's a reasonable thing to do, and that these are people who can help us better manage relationships. He may not agree to now, but may be more open-minded about the possibility of he needs it in future.

My heart goes out to you OP - as the mother of children that age I can imagine how turbulent this period has been for you. Flowers

mamabear715 · 25/04/2023 11:42

Meh, men are a bit weak.. not half as tough as us lasses..

DisquietintheRanks · 25/04/2023 11:41

otherthanthat · 25/04/2023 11:30

You might just come up against a wall of frustration and “I’ve already told you, you did nothing wrong, it was her, just leave it”.
I know him and yes this is exactly what I'd get if I brought it up which is why I never have.

Then it sounds like his relationship with you is conditional on him getting what he wants. That's sad, sorry. It also means you are likely to be deprioritised in the future.

HurryShadow · 25/04/2023 11:37

When I was your son's age, I was in a relationship that took me away from home. During that time I ended up distanced from my friends and family. Not NC, but gradually distanced.

I look back now and can see that it was a combination of my boyfriend being a bit controlling, but also pure naivety of me wanting to focus on my relationship (he was my first boyfriend and I thought my world had to revolve around him).

When we split up, my parents (like you) welcomed me back with open arms and I got back in touch with old friends too (and even stole my now-ex's friends in the break up too 😂)

I've never really discussed that time with my parents as ultimately I'm quite embarrassed that I missed out on that time with them. Your son may be feeling similar and he's just ultimately grateful that he (or she) didn't ruin your relationship forever.

Please focus on the now. Support him and love him and be there to guide him with future relationships.

I am now married and my DM particularly adores my DH!

otherthanthat · 25/04/2023 11:30

You might just come up against a wall of frustration and “I’ve already told you, you did nothing wrong, it was her, just leave it”.
I know him and yes this is exactly what I'd get if I brought it up which is why I never have.

OP posts:
coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 25/04/2023 11:29

toomuchlaundry · 25/04/2023 11:23

@coffeecupsandwaxmelts is the difference that a woman would probably talk about it and blame herself, whereas the DS just appears to carry on as if nothing happened. Obviously, if it was an abusive relationship you wouldn't blame the person but would be providing support and guidance on recognising red flags, as common for people to enter another abusive relationship

I don't think that's relevant, really. He probably does blame himself and feel guilty, he just doesn't want to walk about it.

Anyway, anyone who has been in an abusive relationship should be treated the same by outsiders regardless of whether they outwardly blame themselves afterwards or not.

Maybe he will talk about it in time.
Maybe he's embarrassed or ashamed.
Maybe he was hoping for a bit more understanding from his mum.

Some of the comments on here are just horrible.

toomuchlaundry · 25/04/2023 11:23

@coffeecupsandwaxmelts is the difference that a woman would probably talk about it and blame herself, whereas the DS just appears to carry on as if nothing happened. Obviously, if it was an abusive relationship you wouldn't blame the person but would be providing support and guidance on recognising red flags, as common for people to enter another abusive relationship

Catspyjamas17 · 25/04/2023 11:20

People can do daft and selfish things in their early 20s. Some people do actually manage to grow and change as a person after that. Also I think you have to let young adults go, and make their mistakes. You don't then endlessly punish them and go on about what they did for the rest of their lives. I'd express how sad it made me feel and that I missed him then move on. You might find that if you maintain an open dialogue he will open up about what happened, if he even knows why, or some emotional development will occur on his side and he will actually work out why he did it.

Mrsjayy · 25/04/2023 11:18

Starlitestarbright · 25/04/2023 10:34

Just leave it he's back sounds like he was an in abusive relationship.

Yes this it is easy to say he coulda,shoulda but at the time he wanted to please her. Least its over now.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 25/04/2023 11:18

In this house it would go something like this, I am going to talk, you are going to listen, you are going to answer the questions I have and then we will move on.

This is all a bit soap opera. What would you do if the answer was “No”?

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 25/04/2023 11:17

The bottom line is, what do you want more - your son back, or the big confrontation where you get to air your grievances about this? Because you might not get both.

By all means push for a further explanation, but be prepared that you might not get the “I’m so sorry, please can you forgive me?” response you’re hoping for. You might just come up against a wall of frustration and “I’ve already told you, you did nothing wrong, it was her, just leave it”.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 25/04/2023 11:17

This thread makes for pretty grim reading.

A man is seemingly cut off from his family, and everyone piles on to say it's his fault, he needs to take responsibility and it doesn't matter that his girlfriend may have been controlling or abusive.

I suspect if this was a daughter who had been cut off, people would be full of sympathy and saying she mustn't blame herself, that the abuse wasn't her fault etc.

MalagaNights · 25/04/2023 11:15

I think this is so hard because the hurt he has caused hasn't been acknowledged.

It's not that he needs to explain more, but he should acknowledge and be sorry for the hurt he caused.

You can't treat people as he treated you and his family and just expect them to move on without some shared understanding of what everyone experienced.

If I was you I'd find some time and tell him how you feel, what you went through and how it's still upsetting you.

Tell him what you need from him. You probably need reassurance that he loves and appreciates you and regrets the way he treated you.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 25/04/2023 11:13

What a bananas thing to say. Most people who have a good relationship with their family could say with a high or even absolute level of confidence that they would not cut their family off for no reason just because a partner didn’t like them.

Yep - and lots of people would also say they'd never stay in a toxic relationship, or with a cheater - and yet millions do.

If your daughter was cut off from you by an abusive partner, would you be angry with her and tell her she needs to take responsibility? Or would you be sympathetic and tell her not to blame herself?

Mabelface · 25/04/2023 11:12

I think I'd start by asking if he's okay after everything that happened, continuing with that you're there for him to talk to. It may look as if he's swanned back in without a care in the world, but you don't know what's going on in his head, nor how he was stopped from seeing family.

Yes, I bet it hurt, but I also bet he was put in the position where he had to choose between the gf and his family. There are so many ways he could have been coerced into this. Threats of suicide are a common one in abusive relationships.

If this was a daughter rather than son, how would you view it?

trulyunruly01 · 25/04/2023 11:03

She may well have been abusive/toxic but your ds either didn't recognise this, or felt unable to resist it. Aside from your own (justified) feelings about it all, that's an issue too.
So I would want to talk about it for twofold reasons - to explain how hurt you and the family felt about it because a significant part of your unit was missing; and whether he now sees it as controlling behaviour and whether he feels he has the insight to recognise and avoid it in future.

toomuchlaundry · 25/04/2023 11:02

Does he contribute to the house, rent, chores etc?

capitanaamerica · 25/04/2023 11:00

If he was in an abusive relationship, has he received any kind of help to understand why that happened and take steps so that something similar doesn't happen again? If he is getting appropriate professional help it may be fine to leave him to it if he's not yet able to talk. If not - I'm not sure letting him sweep it under the rug, if that's what he's doing, is best for him long term. He's technically an adult, but he is still young and he's still your son and he's living in your house; I don't think you should be shamed for wanting to make sure he is OK and to understand something about his behviour that has hurt you and your family.

His conduct regarding his grandmother was hurtful and can't be undone. It may not have been "his fault", but there still were and are consequences. I would be worried about facilitating bringing him back into direct everyday contact with other family members - especially if his sisters live with you and are minors.

MsRosley · 25/04/2023 11:00

TheNecessaryWoman · 25/04/2023 10:40

I think a lot of men have an "out of sight out of mind" attitude, and, being largely self centred, are content in the set up that works best for them. So many threads on here women mention arranging contact with her husband's or partner's family, remembering their birthdays etc. because if she didn't they'd never see his family and his family wouldn't get cards and gifts.

He ghosted you because it benefited him more to keep his girlfriend happy. He's happy to be back home because it works for him, for now. Be careful not to build your life around him because when he meets someone else his focus will be elsewhere.

This is exactly it. Your son just chose to do what suited him. And he'll probably do it again.

There are a lot of sons like this around.

CheekyHobson · 25/04/2023 10:57

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 25/04/2023 10:40

You also have absolutely no idea how you'd behave in the same circumstances, so it's a bit bold to say "I suppose knowing I couldn't have done that to my beloved mum and that he could do it hurts the most."

What a bananas thing to say. Most people who have a good relationship with their family could say with a high or even absolute level of confidence that they would not cut their family off for no reason just because a partner didn’t like them.

Delia123 · 25/04/2023 10:57

He met a girl a couple of years ago and she took an instant dislike to every member of our family, he moved in with her and they blocked us and went no contact for 18 months until they split and he came home.
He's never mentioned the no contact apart from to say he hadn't wanted to, it was her, and she didn't like anyone. He had a choice too though.

He might be ashamed that he allowed himself to be controlled by her and felt he had no choice. You don't know what their relationship was like but from what he's told you it appears as if she was limiting his choices. If this were a daughter I suspect you would be viewing this very differently. Just be pleased he's back and let him know he can talk to you if he wants to.

Quitelikeit · 25/04/2023 10:55

No that’s not a good enough reason! I’m afraid he isn’t entirely innocent here

otherthanthat · 25/04/2023 10:54

ConcernedCatmother · 25/04/2023 10:44

Was there absolutely no falling out or reason she took a dislike to the entire family?

He just said she didn't like any of the family and also his dad and step mum and siblings that side so it was both sided of his family.
He assured us we hadn't done anything wrong.

OP posts:
Quitelikeit · 25/04/2023 10:53

You are well within your rights to want to talk about this further.

What he did was incredibly hurtful and selfish.

You need to know because I guess you are worried he might do it again

yes we all know about abusers cutting people off from their family but it doesn’t sound like you are convinced that is what actually happened?

Swipe left for the next trending thread