Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel upset about sons no contact

139 replies

otherthanthat · 25/04/2023 10:29

My ds is early 20s and lives back home with us now.
He met a girl a couple of years ago and she took an instant dislike to every member of our family, he moved in with her and they blocked us and went no contact for 18 months until they split and he came home.
He's never mentioned the no contact apart from to say he hadn't wanted to, it was her, and she didn't like anyone. He had a choice too though.

I have a close relationship with DS and we do lot's together but so did we before he met his ex and so I feel sad to know he would just turn his back on us all if someone else wanted him to.

I wouldn't ever mention it to him but I feel hurt that he didn't even give us an explanation, just ghosted us all and then casually tells us 18 months later, don't worry you didn't do anything wrong.
I understand he would put his gf first and would expect him to but 18 months felt like such a long time, and so many people were hurt, my mum died in that time still hoping for a reconciliation.

He lives here now and just behaves like nothing happened, his little sisters were hurt and confused as were other grandparents, but he seems unaffected and just carries on as though we should all be so pleased to see him again.
Maybe I should be grateful but I feel we spend 18 months wondering what we'd done wrong, worried we'd never see or hear from him, for him to say we didn't do anything wrong.
I suppose knowing I couldn't have done that to my beloved mum and that he could do it hurts the most.

OP posts:
Maray1967 · 25/04/2023 14:06

In fact in my family I’d need to open up a conversation with him because there is no way my DF or FIL wouldn’t if I left it.

Maray1967 · 25/04/2023 14:05

TheApplianceofScience · 25/04/2023 10:43

In this house it would go something like this, I am going to talk, you are going to listen, you are going to answer the questions I have and then we will move on.

Actions have consequences but that goes both ways, so let us both clear the air re the MIA period and then move on.

I agree with this. He had a choice - and although I can see he might have been under immense pressure he still needs to acknowledge that he behaved badly. There needs to be understanding on both sides - that he got trapped in a toxic relationship but that he also hurt his family very much.

Rowthe · 25/04/2023 13:58

YANBU

Unfortunately you've brought up a ael-centred son, who seems not to care for others.

In my experience its really common. It's not your fault, but very common.

It sounds like he would do the exact same again, given half a chance.

This is not someone who you can rely on and personally I would be stepping back from the relationship.

Now that he has moved back, you need to sit down with him and discuss what happened,.and let him know how it wasnt appropriate. By doing this you may be causing issues with the relationship and he may decide he wants to move out.

But you need to address it, because right now hes just waltzed back into the family without any consequences, he will definitely do the same again. And again in my experience its usually sons who behave like this.

Personally I would feel so let down by him,.I would struggle to trust him again,.and my relationship would never be the same again.

TheNecessaryWoman · 25/04/2023 13:55

I never got birthday cards or Mother's Day from him in the first place, I don't think he knows when my birthday is.
My daughters never forget and always go above and beyond. I wouldn't take it personally, my brothers cards to our mum were always in his wife's handwriting.

Yeah, this is not the case of an otherwise loving and thoughtful son being held prisoner by his toxic partner, he's just a typical selfish bloke. If he's getting what he wants he's happy. My brother is the same. He's started to engage with the family now because our mother is very frail and he's sucking up to her so she doesn't change her will and leave him out.

DivorcedAndDelighted · 25/04/2023 13:51

I never got birthday cards or Mother's Day from him in the first place, I don't think he knows when my birthday is.

This is extremely abnormal and suggests there was more going on here than just his former relationship. Some people don't have much empathy but can learn to be more empathic and emotionally intelligent. Here are a couple of excellent podcasts on teaching empathy to kids & what to do if your kids forget your birthday /mother's day - may still be useful to you while he's living at home and you have some influence, but more useful perhaps to parents of younger kids who are wondering how to avoid this happening to them:

open.spotify.com/episode/3B9eSOyROyEStrTIXpj0l8?si=SlBleF_nQFKor6r0HauemQ&app_destination=copy-link
How to raise emotionally intelligent kids

open.spotify.com/episode/7wnFQrWGYisIIHaRS0iSCN?si=TGKdB9-3RxKLvprvsMAd8A&app_destination=copy-link
Summary : Some people get a rude (literally) awakening at how selfish their kids are when they don't do anything for events like this! But this oversight isn't really your kid's fault. Of course, it's ideal for the other parent/co-parent/your partner to help them get something together for you, YOU CAN AND SHOULD MAKE SURE YOUR KIDS RECOGNIZE YOU ON THESE DAYS! Of course it still "counts" if you have to teach kids this, just like it counts that they can read if you teach them to read, or any other thing you teach them! In this episode we discuss which parents won't do this, the cognitive distortions that make them think they shouldn't have to self-advocate, and how this ends up hurting your kids.

Beautiful3 · 25/04/2023 13:49

I don't think I could get past it , without family counselling.

Neverquitehappy · 25/04/2023 13:41

Wait, so your mum, his nan sadly passed away within these 18 months? Did he not see/speak to you or her during this time? If you lost your mum and didn’t hear from your son when you’d done nothing wrong I would be very hurt.

ittakes2 · 25/04/2023 13:41

I personally think you need to sit down and address this with him as your feelings are valid. My brother cut off some of my family for about 15 years - reconciled and all lovely with my parents helping him and his new wife buy a home and baby sitting for 3-4 years...then they had a falling out (he doesn't like the way my parents were grumpy with each other in front of his daughter but they have been together for almost 60 years) and he cut them off again. No effort to resolve falling out just giving my parents instructions you need to do X and X if you want to have a relationship with me. Its an immature way of dealing with things and getting what you want - and your son needs to understand the impact of his behaviour or he might do it again.

CaramelicedLatte · 25/04/2023 13:12

If he was a DD these responses would be entirely different. He was quite obviously the victim in a toxic, controlling relationship and isn't ready to talk about this yet. You are, of course, completely normal to feel hurt and want an explanation, but I think you need to wait for him to be ready, to have processed what happened himself, before this can happen.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 25/04/2023 13:09

Thelnebriati · 25/04/2023 13:00

I would ask him to go for counselling. Perhaps he got into an abusive relationship. Perhaps he just went along with it because its what she wanted. But ultimately, it wouldn't hurt him to understand why and how he ended up in that situation so he doesn't repeat the same mistakes.
It also wouldn't hurt him to apologise. Even if he was in an abusive relationship, he can own the way he behaved towards you.

I don't know. The more I hear about him, the more I think he's more than likely just a bit self-obsessed and selfish. It may have been a controlling relationship, but I'm starting to think it was a case of 'out of sight out of mind' for his family. When it all got difficult, he just turned around and came straight home, rather than striking out on his own, so maybe home life is just a bit too comfortable...

Thelnebriati · 25/04/2023 13:00

I would ask him to go for counselling. Perhaps he got into an abusive relationship. Perhaps he just went along with it because its what she wanted. But ultimately, it wouldn't hurt him to understand why and how he ended up in that situation so he doesn't repeat the same mistakes.
It also wouldn't hurt him to apologise. Even if he was in an abusive relationship, he can own the way he behaved towards you.

otherthanthat · 25/04/2023 12:54

Yes ,absolutely
I’ve often thought my second born son will drop us like a stone when he leaves home .we don’t even get birthday cards now ,he’s 22 and didn’t get me a card for my 50 th birthday.
he’s just not that attached to us ….
3 rd ,son and 1 st son are both autistic,and very loving to us .
I think 2nd son is also autistic,but we missed it ,and I don’t think he understands

I never got birthday cards or Mother's Day from him in the first place, I don't think he knows when my birthday is.
My daughters never forget and always go above and beyond. I wouldn't take it personally, my brothers cards to our mum were always in his wife's handwriting.

OP posts:
MissyB1 · 25/04/2023 12:46

I would want him to acknowledge that he needs to be a lot more careful who he gets into a relationship with in future. How he is going to ensure that he doesn’t get controlled and manipulated again? He needs to have some self awareness and be able to reflect on what went wrong. It’s not about you “telling him off”, it’s about helping him to understand what happened, and the impact it had on himself and everyone else. Has he learned anything? That’s what I would want to know.

Summerpetal · 25/04/2023 12:41

TheNecessaryWoman · 25/04/2023 10:40

I think a lot of men have an "out of sight out of mind" attitude, and, being largely self centred, are content in the set up that works best for them. So many threads on here women mention arranging contact with her husband's or partner's family, remembering their birthdays etc. because if she didn't they'd never see his family and his family wouldn't get cards and gifts.

He ghosted you because it benefited him more to keep his girlfriend happy. He's happy to be back home because it works for him, for now. Be careful not to build your life around him because when he meets someone else his focus will be elsewhere.

Yes ,absolutely
I’ve often thought my second born son will drop us like a stone when he leaves home .we don’t even get birthday cards now ,he’s 22 and didn’t get me a card for my 50 th birthday.
he’s just not that attached to us ….
3 rd ,son and 1 st son are both autistic,and very loving to us .
I think 2nd son is also autistic,but we missed it ,and I don’t think he understands himself.

CovertImage · 25/04/2023 12:37

Christ, the bar for being "toxic" and "abusive" is so bloody low now on MN.

I'd bet my next wage that OP's son is a selfish little scrote who thought of nothing else but getting his end away and his family being fallout didn't bother him in the slightest. He's now doing the age-old man thing of not wanting to talk about it because - I reckon - he doesn't think he should be called out on anything ever.

VelvetUndergrounds · 25/04/2023 12:33

My brother did this. Three times. With three different women. Each time it went wrong he came running back to us. One woman was especially vile to me - had a personal vendetta against me. They were all really threatened by how close my brother and I were. But he also turned his back on the rest of our family, every time. My mum was so hurt and thought that he was ashamed of her. Truth was, he was ashamed of where he came from as we grew up poor - but our family were very close, regardless.

Each time it happened it was with women who came from very middle class families with big houses and [what he thought were] respectable families. Turns out they were all as bad as everyone else in society and actually our family had better moral codes.

I am still friendly with my brother now but I was incredibly hurt several times by him and it has definitely changed how I view him and feel about him in later life which is a real shame.

Ramunea · 25/04/2023 12:24

I agree with you. I would be hurt and I would need to talk about it with him to get closure.

I had a brother who did this when we were younger. He met a girl and fell head over heels and after a few months; moved out and cut all contact with family for 4 years. We didn’t know if he was alive or anything. It really hurt me also as we are only a year apart and we have always done everything together and told each other everything so when he essentially wrote us off and turned on us; it effected all of us.

When he returned; my parents didn’t want to question him as they were just happy he was home and even showered him with gifts, money and attention I felt to keep him happy and avoid him disappearing again. But I had to ask and even after getting an explanation; I still can’t believe he put us through that.

otherthanthat · 25/04/2023 12:17

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 25/04/2023 11:52

OP, do you feel that it was genuinely a case of a toxic and controlling relationship where your son couldn't make contact with you? Or do you suspect that he was too busy shagging and keeping gf happy to think about all of you? Because it rather depends on what kind of person your son is. It does sound as though his gf wasn't happy with your family (but if you're all very close and generally in one another's pockets, she may have just wanted to get away from that), but do you believe she was completely behind your son's cutting of contact?

If you think he was manipulated into going NC, then you need to have a little talk with him about avoiding manipulative girlfriends. If you think that your family unit may be a little too tight for many incomers to cope with, then possibly loosen up a little (most men in their 20's don't do 'lots' with their mums). But if you think it was maybe that he might have discovered sex and having a girlfriend full time - then you have to prepare yourself, because he will do it again.

I do feel she didn't treat him wonderfully and was fearful that he'd talk to friends/family and he'd be advised that her behaviour was unreasonable or come to realise this.
I also believe that's the reason she wanted us all out of the picture so she could control him without anyone questioning it.
I also believe he was so wrapped up in having a girlfriend that he bent over backwards to keep her and if it meant walking away from his family and friends to be with her then so be it.

I also believe he left because he couldn't keep up with her demands as he told his dad she was too high maintenance in the end.
I do think he would do the same again in a heartbeat in the future.

OP posts:
Iloveautumncolours · 25/04/2023 12:11

My sister was in a relationship like this in her mid 20’s. Her partner took an instant dislike to us (no idea why but they had severe mental health issues)and my sister stopped coming back home to visit us, my mum was devastated as we had previously been a very close family. It went on for 3 years until it became apparent dsis was in an abusive relationship, so I helped her to leave.
Tbh, even 20+ years later this has still left an unspoken dent in all of our relationships even though we are all now close again, it’s something we never really talk about with my sister as I think she is deeply ashamed and embarrassed that she caused us so much pain (there were many things which went on during that time).
You must be so very relieved that your ds has managed to step away from a controlling relationship, it’s one of my fears that one of my dc will go through this having seen how it can wreck families.

HeyDiddleDumplings · 25/04/2023 12:08

This sounds really difficult OP. I acknowledge the pain and hurt this has caused, with a bereavement in that time as well.

From experience it’s hard to live with this pain even if you know that it was due to an abusive / toxic relationship.

I think this is a heavy load and the impact is deeply felt. I’m not sure how to raise it with your DS. But I do think you need the space and time to talk about it. I’d consider counselling to work through some of this. 💐

FrenchandSaunders · 25/04/2023 12:02

How did the conversation go when he got back in touch to say he had split up with the GF and wanted to come home?

Clarinet1 · 25/04/2023 11:59

I think, at best, he thought he had to give top priority to the GF (he’s not the first young person to do that and he won’t be the
last); At worst, he was totally coerced by the CF into cutting you off and we hear a lot about coercive relationships on MN.
If he is behaving in an acceptable way mostly (thoughtful around the house, funding himself etc) maybe what he needs is space to process what he has been through. It may only be when he is in a new relationship that he sees the contrast with the previous one.

piedbeauty · 25/04/2023 11:56

You haven't mentioned it to him? I wouldn't have been able not to.

You should tell him that he should have come to you. That he can talk to you about anything, that you will support him. I'd also mention how much he hurt you.

Even though he was in an abusive relationship, he had a choice. He could have left, he could have contacted you.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 25/04/2023 11:52

OP, do you feel that it was genuinely a case of a toxic and controlling relationship where your son couldn't make contact with you? Or do you suspect that he was too busy shagging and keeping gf happy to think about all of you? Because it rather depends on what kind of person your son is. It does sound as though his gf wasn't happy with your family (but if you're all very close and generally in one another's pockets, she may have just wanted to get away from that), but do you believe she was completely behind your son's cutting of contact?

If you think he was manipulated into going NC, then you need to have a little talk with him about avoiding manipulative girlfriends. If you think that your family unit may be a little too tight for many incomers to cope with, then possibly loosen up a little (most men in their 20's don't do 'lots' with their mums). But if you think it was maybe that he might have discovered sex and having a girlfriend full time - then you have to prepare yourself, because he will do it again.

PurpleParrotfish · 25/04/2023 11:50

otherthanthat · 25/04/2023 11:30

You might just come up against a wall of frustration and “I’ve already told you, you did nothing wrong, it was her, just leave it”.
I know him and yes this is exactly what I'd get if I brought it up which is why I never have.

But what about your own feelings, are you not allowed to express those? That being cut off like that was a horrible thing to go through, for all of his family and it makes you feel worried that it might happen again.

I would be really hurt that there was no sign of any empathy at all for what you’d suffered, as if you and the rest of his family somehow ceased to exist when he wasn’t around, like minor characters in his own personal soap opera.

Of course you should also empathise with his problems, but why on earth can’t it be a two way thing?