Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel upset about sons no contact

139 replies

otherthanthat · 25/04/2023 10:29

My ds is early 20s and lives back home with us now.
He met a girl a couple of years ago and she took an instant dislike to every member of our family, he moved in with her and they blocked us and went no contact for 18 months until they split and he came home.
He's never mentioned the no contact apart from to say he hadn't wanted to, it was her, and she didn't like anyone. He had a choice too though.

I have a close relationship with DS and we do lot's together but so did we before he met his ex and so I feel sad to know he would just turn his back on us all if someone else wanted him to.

I wouldn't ever mention it to him but I feel hurt that he didn't even give us an explanation, just ghosted us all and then casually tells us 18 months later, don't worry you didn't do anything wrong.
I understand he would put his gf first and would expect him to but 18 months felt like such a long time, and so many people were hurt, my mum died in that time still hoping for a reconciliation.

He lives here now and just behaves like nothing happened, his little sisters were hurt and confused as were other grandparents, but he seems unaffected and just carries on as though we should all be so pleased to see him again.
Maybe I should be grateful but I feel we spend 18 months wondering what we'd done wrong, worried we'd never see or hear from him, for him to say we didn't do anything wrong.
I suppose knowing I couldn't have done that to my beloved mum and that he could do it hurts the most.

OP posts:
MisanthropistToTheCore · 25/04/2023 16:33

Sorry, you’ve misunderstood. Or I have interpreted your post in a way not intended (and if I have, I apologise). I’m aware he is saying that but you seem to be accepting that and not that he needs to take responsibility for himself and his part, or consider, following that he should accept his part in this, that there could be reasons he chose to what he did that directly involve issues within the family.

And to be clear, I’m not blaming you or your family. I’m just suggesting that often there is more than meets the eye in these situations. So it could be worth considering why he thinks he should have ghosted you. The girlfriend is a red herring.

otherthanthat · 25/04/2023 16:25

MisanthropistToTheCore · 25/04/2023 16:15

I find it interesting you’re automatically blaming the girlfriend.

My OH is no contact with his family after a childhood and teen years of bullshit. He had a fall out with a sibling because he spoke up about something he feels strongly about (unrelated to her) which she took exception to and said some mean things. He asked for some space and she decided to interpret that as never wanting to speak to her again, and proceeded to go to all the other family members and spread her bullshit. Not one of them bothered to hear his side or even ask.

Yet the narrative is that I’ve pushed him into being no contact. Because that’s easier than facing themselves.

I haven't blamed the girlfriend, he has.

OP posts:
MisanthropistToTheCore · 25/04/2023 16:15

I find it interesting you’re automatically blaming the girlfriend.

My OH is no contact with his family after a childhood and teen years of bullshit. He had a fall out with a sibling because he spoke up about something he feels strongly about (unrelated to her) which she took exception to and said some mean things. He asked for some space and she decided to interpret that as never wanting to speak to her again, and proceeded to go to all the other family members and spread her bullshit. Not one of them bothered to hear his side or even ask.

Yet the narrative is that I’ve pushed him into being no contact. Because that’s easier than facing themselves.

DivorcedAndDelighted · 25/04/2023 16:14

Babdoc · 25/04/2023 16:06

I would make it a condition of him returning to the family home that he attends a course of family therapy with you, in which all the issues are fully explored with a neutral therapist.
How can he possibly expect to just shove all your emotional pain under the carpet and pick up where he left off? Actions have consequences, and he is refusing to face them.

Great suggestion - an opportunity to intervene which could materially improve both OP's and her son's lives.

Babdoc · 25/04/2023 16:06

I would make it a condition of him returning to the family home that he attends a course of family therapy with you, in which all the issues are fully explored with a neutral therapist.
How can he possibly expect to just shove all your emotional pain under the carpet and pick up where he left off? Actions have consequences, and he is refusing to face them.

DivorcedAndDelighted · 25/04/2023 16:05

He just feels blameless in it and that it was her not him so why am I asking him for?
When I asked him why she didn't like us he just said she doesn't like anyone and when I asked what we'd done I got nothing mum it's just what she's like.
... he makes short closed answers and then talks about something else, it's clearly just not open to discussion

He's moved back to your home so up do have some say in this and don't have to passively accept what little explanation he gives.
How about saying "But son, you do understand you don't have to just do what a girlfriend says without questioning, don't you? It's not normal or healthy to do that. Do you realise that?"
And
"This caused so much hurt in our family, it makes me worried you don't understand how families or relationships work. How would you do it differently if your next girlfriend makes that sort of demand?"
Or "You're living in our family home so you need to show that you care about your family. That's normal behaviour. It makes me happy when you show you care on my birthday and mother's day. My birthday is on (Date) and I want you to get me a card, OK?"

Couple more articles that might help - exploring the possibility that your own childhood led you to be too accommodating to your son:

Guess what happens if you let your kids treat you like garbage?

How Do I Parent My Disrespectful 19 Year Old Son?

Guess What Happens If You Let Your Kids Treat You Like Garbage? - Dr. Psych Mom

Listen to my podcast on this topic here! In today’s child-centered parenting approach, parents seem to confuse “being kind and validating to your child” with “letting your child treat you like garbage.” Even if you yourself are a masochistic and enjoy...

https://www.drpsychmom.com/2021/02/28/guess-what-happens-if-you-let-your-kids-treat-you-like-garbage

toomuchlaundry · 25/04/2023 16:03

@otherthanthat as others have said why do you think it is okay for men not to care. In your son's relationship would you have expected the gf to sort out communication with you, Christmas presents etc?

Nanny0gg · 25/04/2023 15:59

otherthanthat · 25/04/2023 12:54

Yes ,absolutely
I’ve often thought my second born son will drop us like a stone when he leaves home .we don’t even get birthday cards now ,he’s 22 and didn’t get me a card for my 50 th birthday.
he’s just not that attached to us ….
3 rd ,son and 1 st son are both autistic,and very loving to us .
I think 2nd son is also autistic,but we missed it ,and I don’t think he understands

I never got birthday cards or Mother's Day from him in the first place, I don't think he knows when my birthday is.
My daughters never forget and always go above and beyond. I wouldn't take it personally, my brothers cards to our mum were always in his wife's handwriting.

I'd take it personally!

Why is it ok for (some) men to not care?

readbooksdrinktea · 25/04/2023 15:51

The more you post, he sounds selfish. He might have been in an abusive relationship. One doesn't exclude the other.

otherthanthat · 25/04/2023 15:50

LadyHag · 25/04/2023 15:11

Is there another family member that your son looks up to or holds in some esteem that could meet up and talk with him and ask tje questions you need answers to?

Well that would have been my mum the most but he talks to his dad and step dad me and step mum siblings and cousins aunts uncle's, there's no shortage of support from us.
Maybe he has talked to a friend.

OP posts:
fairycakes1234 · 25/04/2023 15:25

CaramelicedLatte · 25/04/2023 13:12

If he was a DD these responses would be entirely different. He was quite obviously the victim in a toxic, controlling relationship and isn't ready to talk about this yet. You are, of course, completely normal to feel hurt and want an explanation, but I think you need to wait for him to be ready, to have processed what happened himself, before this can happen.

@CaramelicedLatte
not true, if i was my daughter i would also ask, no difference whatsoever

toomuchlaundry · 25/04/2023 15:19

@Chasingadvice OP thinks he could do it again in another relationship, so either she needs to talk to him so he can recognise the signs of an abusive relationship, or he is a selfish arse and he needs to explain why he did what he did including not being there when his nan died.

Chasingadvice · 25/04/2023 15:17

Dhallow · 25/04/2023 10:40

I think he owes you all an explanation.

He owes everyone an explanation for why he was in a toxic and possibly abusive relationship?

LadyHag · 25/04/2023 15:11

Is there another family member that your son looks up to or holds in some esteem that could meet up and talk with him and ask tje questions you need answers to?

fairycakes1234 · 25/04/2023 15:04

What happens if he meets someone else and does it again. No, id be sitting down and having an adult conversation with him explaining how hurt you were and your family. Why shouldn't he be pulled up on his behaviour? Hes living in your house and needs to explain why and what happened, or even that its not acceptable to do something like that. I would find it hard not to say anything.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 25/04/2023 15:01

It was her not him? Well it was him that chose to stay with her, that chose to listen to her rather than set some boundaries in place, that chose to continue to ignore his entire family when his gran died, that has refused to acknowledge the hurt this has caused and the affect it has had on relationships, that has not shown in any way that he has learnt from this or would do something differently if the same situation arose now. So no, it wasn't all 'her' and he needs to address this if he wants the relationship to go back to what it was. Does he really truly not have any idea of what it would feel like if others in the family did the same to him? Ignored him for 500 days just because someone theyd only just met told them to?

toomuchlaundry · 25/04/2023 14:52

Have you ever told him you are hurt that he doesn't even know when your birthday is?

Quitelikeit · 25/04/2023 14:50

You need to change your approach!

he might not want to talk but you do!

tell him that you were all put out by his behaviour and ask how you know he won’t do it to you again?! Tell him you are worried about it

LimitIsUp · 25/04/2023 14:50

Well you must handle it in a way that feels right for you, but personally I'd be asking him what happens in future if another girlfriend takes an irrational dislike. I would want assurances that he wouldn't drop his family like a tonne of bricks and I would also be articulating just how hurt and sad we all were and make him own his decisions

otherthanthat · 25/04/2023 14:45

LimitIsUp · 25/04/2023 14:38

I think I would have to have a full and frank discussion with him to ascertain whether he has learnt from the experience

He just feels blameless in it and that it was her not him so why am I asking him for?
When I asked him why she didn't like us he just said she doesn't like anyone and when I asked what we'd done I got nothing mum it's just what she's like.
As much as I want to understand I don't want to keep on and he makes short closed answers and then talks about something else, it's clearly just not open to discussion and he's trying to move on so we should.
I am here if he wants to talk but he doesn't.

OP posts:
LimitIsUp · 25/04/2023 14:38

I think I would have to have a full and frank discussion with him to ascertain whether he has learnt from the experience

moose62 · 25/04/2023 14:27

I agree with some of the others - he had a choice and he chose to blank you all when it suited him to do it. You realise that and don't see any merit in asking him for an explanation.
I wouldn't either but I would sit him down and ask him to listen to you, not to answer necessarily, but to understand how you feel. I would tell him how upset and disappointed the whole family was with his behaviour etc. and whilst you are happy to have him back if he takes this route again the door might not be open again.
I think he needs to know that what he did have consequences.

toomuchlaundry · 25/04/2023 14:26

Have you treated him differently than your DDs. Can’t believe he has never got you cards. I have a DS, even from a very early age he has been involved in cards and gifts. He was so proud the first year he was able to go to the shops on his own and buy me and DH little gifts for Christmas. There is no excuse for boys not to do this.

Does he do chores round the house?

Has he mentioned your DM at all?

If you think he would do it again in a heartbeat then I doubt the gf was toxic/abusive, it is just he was selfish. He probably thought she would do all the contacting like his sisters do, and she refused.

Greensleeves · 25/04/2023 14:09

Ideally you need family therapy to work through the hurt and mistrust that has been caused, especially for his younger sisters, and around the death of your mother during his absence.

If he's anything like my younger son though, he'd rather chew his own feet off than engage with a therapist...so I would just keep trying, calmly and reasonably, to talk to him about what happened and how it affected everyone. If he was in an abusive relationship and cut off against his will, he needs to address that and understand it so that it doesn't happen again.

It's so hard with young men.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 25/04/2023 14:07

I never got birthday cards or Mother's Day from him in the first place, I don't think he knows when my birthday is. My daughters never forget and always go above and beyond. I wouldn't take it personally, my brothers cards to our mum were always in his wife's handwriting

Why are you normalising this?

The more you post, the more it sounds like your son is selfish and not a particularly nice person - and I was defending him upthread.

It's not normal for sons to behave like this. Unless you're about to drip that your relationship has always been fractious, he has no excuse not to remember your birthday, or buy you a Mothers' Day card.