Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WHO Pandemic Preparedness Treaty - what's your view on this?

41 replies

pansiesinmygarden · 24/04/2023 19:37

Just that, really.

After all we've been through over the last 3 years, it's surprising this has not been given much visibility in MSM

Do you think a referendum should take place before we commit ourselves to such major supranational commitments?

https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-9550/

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
justteanbiscuits · 02/05/2023 15:31

It could force our government not to ignore pandemic preparedness exercises, and decide not to do things such as keeping a stock of PPE...

pansiesinmygarden · 02/05/2023 15:21

AZ was selling covid vaccine at cost to developing countries anyhow, so there wouldn't be any difference from their POV. IIRC, they were also assisting in development of industrial infrastructure for vaccine manufacture

They did this voluntarily. They were not forced. It's very different

OP posts:
lljkk · 27/04/2023 16:54

How do you think you or your family would have fared during Covid if the UK had been forced to surrender vaccine lots to other countries?

My family would have been Fine, since you ask. All 30 first cousins, their spouses, the living 9 uncles & aunts, their spouses & grandkids, too, my kids, my kids' 2nd cousins & a handful of grandchildren, my inlaws AND my elderly parents.

Have fun spreading your paranoia.

AngryCatFace · 27/04/2023 15:28

The treaty does not cover national level decisions about who gets which vaccine or on what schedule.

The treaty will most certainly impact national level decisions about not just vaccines, but literally any other measure related to potential public health emergencies. That’s the point. The amendments are so sweeping and vague that anything that might constitute a potential (ie speculative) threat to public health will fall under WHO jurisdiction, and the WHO will no longer issue guidance but edicts, which member states must follow in spite of national laws and constitutions.

Or else.

I don’t think people understand how bonkers the treaty actually is. To the point where if the proposed amendments are accepted, I wonder how they would even be enforceable (and would rather not find out!)

This analysis is the best I’ve seen which not only provides context for the WHO both past and present, but a break-down of each proposed amendment, and its implications.

It’s madness. Utter madness.

Amendments to WHO’s International Health Regulations: An Annotated Guide ⋆ Brownstone Institute

Amendments to the IHR place the WHO as having rights overriding that of individuals, erasing basic principles developed after WW2 regarding human rights and sovereignty of States.

https://brownstone.org/articles/amendments-who-ihr-annotated-guide/

meditrina · 27/04/2023 14:22

How do you think you or your family would have fared during Covid if the UK had been forced to surrender vaccine lots to other countries?

UK was one of the biggest contributors to COVAX. If everyone was asked to join in, proportional to the size of their economy, our contribution would probably go down.

AZ was selling covid vaccine at cost to developing countries anyhow, so there wouldn't be any difference from their POV. IIRC, they were also assisting in development of industrial infrastructure for vaccine manufacture.

The treaty does not cover national level decisions about who gets which vaccine or on what schedule. It's at the level of international co-operation to promote reasonably fair access for every country regardless of economic strength.

pansiesinmygarden · 27/04/2023 10:53

But handing over power to an unelected supranational body seemingly ruled by corporations does not appear to be the answer

OP posts:
pansiesinmygarden · 27/04/2023 10:51

meditrina · 27/04/2023 10:26

No that's not what it means!

Climate change and land use means tackling things like deforestation and the encroachment into animal habitats and the consequent increased risk of zoonosis

It does not go anywhere near telling a government how specific land must be used.

Are you seeing abrogation of our participation in climate change treaties too? For they cover the same areas

Are you seeing abrogation of our participation in climate change treaties too?

These seem to be already causing problems in terms of access to affordable fuel for many nations and negative economic consequences (e.g. the Netherlands). So I'm not sure what the best way forward would be

OP posts:
pansiesinmygarden · 27/04/2023 10:46

lljkk · 27/04/2023 10:00

Apathy or paranoia because of rampant misinformation spreaders all over internet and on social media sites like Mumsnet?

Gee whiz, excuse us for being cynical about claims by randoms on the Internet.

How do you think you or your family would have fared during Covid if the UK had been forced to surrender vaccine lots to other countries?

Or companies like AZ forced to give up intellectual property rights or profits? The AZ vaccine might not have been developed in the first place

What about people who for whatever reason could not take a preferred vaccine (e.g. Pfizer due to allergies) and needed an alternative? Would this be coordinated by supranational bureacrats too?

It's a really bad idea. Cooperation absolutely, mandates, no

OP posts:
AngryCatFace · 27/04/2023 10:41

@meditrina It does not go anywhere near telling a government how specific land must be used.

it mentions interventions to address drivers of disease, including climate change and land use.

so it certainly doesn’t rule out telling governments how to manage land. That’s the point, really. The wording is so vague and open-ended, it’s impossible to guess how it could be applied in the future. Which is all the more reason to put a stop to it, until there is better clarification of terms and scope, at the very least.

pansiesinmygarden · 27/04/2023 10:41

Climate change and land use means tackling things like deforestation and the encroachment into animal habitats and the consequent increased risk of zoonosis

It does not go anywhere near telling a government how specific land must be used

I don't see your point. It could absolutely 'go anywhere near' telling a country how it should use its land

OP posts:
meditrina · 27/04/2023 10:26

No that's not what it means!

Climate change and land use means tackling things like deforestation and the encroachment into animal habitats and the consequent increased risk of zoonosis

It does not go anywhere near telling a government how specific land must be used.

Are you seeing abrogation of our participation in climate change treaties too? For they cover the same areas

pansiesinmygarden · 27/04/2023 10:19

meditrina · 27/04/2023 10:09

I think your understanding is skewed.

The Treaty principally concerns

"alert systems, data-sharing, research and local, regional and global production and distribution of medical and public health counter-measures such as vaccines, medicines, diagnostics and personal protective equipment"

That's not relinquishing control of any part of day-to-day life

Are you also going to call for UK to withdraw from other international treaty obligations which require things like sharing information on technical and controls on trade of certain items?

It doesn't seem to be exchange of information only. There are several other angles which could be problematic if dictated centrally

Take the following, for example. An unelected supranational body could state how the UK uses land and what for.

The Parties will identify and integrate into relevant pandemic prevention and preparedness plans interventions that address the drivers of the emergence and re-emergence of disease at the human-animal-environment interface, including but not limited to climate change, land use change, wildlife
trade, desertification and antimicrobial resistance

Full draft below

https://apps.who.int/gb/inb/pdf_files/inb4/A_INB4_3-en.pdf

https://apps.who.int/gb/inb/pdf_files/inb4/A_INB4_3-en.pdf

OP posts:
AngryCatFace · 27/04/2023 10:12

The WHO pandemic treaty is a terrible idea. If it passes, then functionally we might as well give up on the idea of liberal democracy, because we will have entered a new chapter of rulership and governance.

The WHO, an unelected body, will be able to override constitutions and laws to impose lockdown, mandates, forced quarantining and surveillance not just when a pandemic is declared, but even when there is just potential for an emergency.

we can say goodbye to the hard won fundamental rights we expect in a liberal democracy, like freedom of movement, freedom of assembly, bodily autonomy etc. These will become privileges instead of rights, granted conditionally by a supra-national organisation which is not accountable to the citizenry.

As others have noted, the WHO is largely funded by private companies now. There have been whistleblowers who have spoken out about the influence private funders have over WHO policy.

I don’t know how people cannot see how chilling this is.

An unelected body will be able to override the constitutions and laws of nation states.

meditrina · 27/04/2023 10:09

pansiesinmygarden · 26/04/2023 10:57

As I understand it, the proposed treaty demands the UK relinquishes control of many aspects of our everyday lives to a supranational global unelected body. Their decisions would be legally binding.

Certainly this has not existed before and it's one of the reasons many people voted for Brexit.

I think your understanding is skewed.

The Treaty principally concerns

"alert systems, data-sharing, research and local, regional and global production and distribution of medical and public health counter-measures such as vaccines, medicines, diagnostics and personal protective equipment"

That's not relinquishing control of any part of day-to-day life

Are you also going to call for UK to withdraw from other international treaty obligations which require things like sharing information on technical and controls on trade of certain items?

pansiesinmygarden · 27/04/2023 10:03

lljkk · 27/04/2023 10:00

Apathy or paranoia because of rampant misinformation spreaders all over internet and on social media sites like Mumsnet?

Gee whiz, excuse us for being cynical about claims by randoms on the Internet.

Where is the disinformation? Please explain This is being discussed in Parliament.

OP posts:
lljkk · 27/04/2023 10:00

Apathy or paranoia because of rampant misinformation spreaders all over internet and on social media sites like Mumsnet?

Gee whiz, excuse us for being cynical about claims by randoms on the Internet.

pansiesinmygarden · 27/04/2023 09:44

The apathy displayed around this from the general public, the MSM (and MN!) is rather concerning. It's such a fundamental piece of legislation.

It's also shocking that there had to be a petition for this to be even considered by Parliament. What if there wouldn't have been? Would this have gone through without discussion?

OP posts:
pansiesinmygarden · 27/04/2023 09:33

Pandemics are a global problem and need a global solution

Of course they are a global problem, but the main reason we were out of the woods relatively quickly from Covid (considering the sheer havoc and mayhem it caused) was that each country had total freedom to research, investigate, speak and come up with solutions.

There was no central global beaurocratic body telling others what alternative could be explored, giving permission to think or dissent and administering 'the truth'

See how shambolic everything became by mid-2021 when politics started to influence the course of action in the EU, Russia, etc

OP posts:
EmmaEmerald · 26/04/2023 13:46

Nimbo yes, the pandemic preparedness we had was well planned. As I said at the time, anyone working on a BCP will have knowledge of it.

then they decided to stop doing it

then they did a massive social experiment.

so...yes...perhaps I was naive about why they stopped.

but I have realised that people are begging to be controlled, so I've hit the point where I can only hope I'm dead before the next instalment of all this.

nojudgementhere · 26/04/2023 13:35

It's massively concerning. The WHO are partly funded by private donors who will have influence over any policies put in place. These donors are unelected, and therefore unaccountable to us, and their interests may well not be the same as ours as well as being heavily motivated by profits.

Some of the policies put into place in other countries during the Covid pandemic were extremely damaging and undemocratic. Seeing people locked into their buildings, small, infected children isolated from their families and vaccine mandates imposed really upset and worried me. The WHO are heavily funded and influenced by China, who behaved in an alarmingly authoritarian manner throughout the pandemic. I'm amazed people are so happy about relinquishing control to them and wonder how they would feel if it were their own children being forcibly removed to isolate next time?

taxguru · 26/04/2023 12:28

@Nimbostratus100

Of course it was predictable, and predicted, and so is the next one. Everyone knows pandemics happen and will keep happening at random dates in the future.

Absolutely true. Partly, I think the World may have become a little blase after other recent cases like asian bird flu, H1N1, etc didn't spread and weren't as serious as expected.

With Covid, a lot of the World "locked down" simply because they could for the first time in decades due to the internet. It was like a social experiment to see how much we (I mean the World, not just the UK), could survive with as much as possible closed down.

The nature of World travel, transport of goods, etc., was also very different with the sheer number of people, shipping containers of goods, aircraft etc moving around the World.

So many things were different from earlier pandemics, and we (again the World) simply didn't have the "tool kit" to know what to do. Go back a few decades and the spread would have been a lot more localised, probably devastating to a much smaller localised area, but with hard barriers preventing people and goods travelling in and out. It's certainly how the small pox outbreaks were dealt with, but simply can't work on a Global scale!

I hope that there is a huge amount of research, analysis and other planning on a Global scale to deal with future pandemics in a much better way than just locking down so much, in some many places. Research and analysis should tell us which methods worked, which didn't, so that a coherent plan and strategy can be put in place for the future, with different strategies for different types of country, different types of transport, different types of personal contact, etc. So much of the 2020 response was little more than guesswork and hope rather than based on science and history which can't be allowed to happen again.

Pandemics are a global problem and need a global solution.

Nimbostratus100 · 26/04/2023 12:12

Throwncrumbs · 26/04/2023 11:15

People forget that it was the blind leading the blind last time. No one knew how it was going to pan out, we have never had anything like what happened ever happen in our lifetime before. The government did the best they could with the limited information they had at the time. Whatever any one says lockdowns probably saved many lives. As someone who spent time in hospital over the first lockdown, I can’t tell you it was terrifying, for me and the staff who had to work through it. The whole world, not just the UK was affected, but people still talk in terms of themselves and how it stopped them doing what they wanted. Hopefully we won’t see anything like it again in the future, but no one though it could happen back in 2020, did they!

Much of this is untrue. Of course it was predictable, and predicted, and so is the next one. Everyone knows pandemics happen and will keep happening at random dates in the future. It could have happened it 2020 or at any time, and it will happen again, and we always were prepared - I have family involved in the civilian emergency preparations that were in place until about the early noughties, when the government stopped maintaining pandemic preparations

taxguru · 26/04/2023 12:07

pansiesinmygarden · 26/04/2023 11:05

And how do you propose these major decisions are stopped, when they seem to be so life-changing and many would not agree with them?

And please don't say vote Labour as they would most likely also sign us up for a dictatorial treaty as we have seen it happen in Left leaning governments during the pandemic (e.g. NZ and Canada)

Well, first thing in the UK at least would be for voters to actually think about who they vote for to represent us and not just always vote blue/red because their family have always voted that way, etc., and also to vote for the "bigger picture" rather than reject a candidate because of a particular (often minor) policy of their party!

If we had a better political system and a higher calibre of politicians, then we'd stand a fighting chance of our politicians doing the "right" thing rather than lining their own pockets or blindly following some dodgy political dogma of the past.

Just look at the Libdem referendum on voting change in the coalition. It could have been a catalyst for change but because it wasn't exactly the full fat proportional representation that a sizeable minority wanted, they voted against it so we're stuck with first past the post for decades to come! If we'd have voted for the "middle ground" libdem option, it would have changed voting patterns and could well have led to future changes. But no, baby out with the bath water again!

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 26/04/2023 11:59

araiwa · 26/04/2023 11:00

Letting morons vote on stuff they don't understand doesn't often work out well

Moron = people who don’t agree with me , I suppose.

I thought ‘Moron’ wasn’t an approved term anymore, btw.

Coyoacan · 26/04/2023 11:54

The idea of imposing the same rules on disparate countries is really dangerous. In Mexico, for example, we had a relatively short total lockdown because a lot of people work hand-to-mouth.