Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to end a 10 year friendship over this?

282 replies

MrTiddlesTheCat · 24/04/2023 15:53

My DS is 6 and has autism. He can talk but mostly doesn't. He goes to mainstream school.

A few weeks ago another parent approached me in the carpark and told me that she had had to intervene when passing through the playground earlier as a group of much older boys were intimidating my DS. She said he looked absolutely terrified and she thought I should know.

I talked to DS and with much coaxing I managed to get the full story out of him. These big boys have been mercilessly bullying him for months. Every single day name calling, pushing, kicking. It's horrfic and I'm so angry. Angry at the kids doing it. Angry at the school for apparently not noticing. Angry at myself.

I met up with a friend yesterday who I haven't seen for a while and I told her about DS and how awful it had all been. And she bloody well already knew. I was so stunned that it didn't really register what she was saying until I got home. Her DS is in the same class as these big boys and had been telling her all along what was happening to my little boy. But she never said anything.

Maybe it's misplaced anger, but I can't help feeling let down by her. She knew my DS was being hurt and chose to do nothing.

AIBU in thinking this crosses a line and this woman is not my friend?

OP posts:
DaintyDinah24 · 25/04/2023 22:14

As a "friend" she should have said something to you as soon as her son told her. It's pretty despicable that she didn't.
It really is no excuse to say that she assumed you knew. At the very least she should have checked with you and offered her support.
I feel so sorry for your DS and I hope that the school will deal with the bullies effectively.

SpidersAreShitheads · 25/04/2023 22:04

EveryWitchWaybutLoose · 25/04/2023 21:23

The thing that I don’t understand here is how this could have been going on for months, and you didn’t notice????

How would you know if your child isn't able to tell you? If there's no physical marks etc? Communication is difficult for many autistic children even in perfect conditions, and the OP has described her child as frequently nonverbal.

School can be a difficult and complex place for autistic children - and there can be school reluctance, even when there's no bullying. It's not easy to tell when there's an issue and when it's just general overwhelm with school life.

When you have an autistic child who doesn't have great verbal skills, you put a lot of trust in the school to look out for them and to make sure that they're safe.

My DS used to scream, cry and hide about going to school. I had no idea what he did at school because he couldn't tell me. Except I did know because we had a home school diary where the teachers wrote me notes at the end of every day. This is the kind of thing you have to rely on when you have an autistic child. I was the deputy chair of the PTA and also the SEN governor - I spent many, many hours every week actually in the school. So I know he was treated with love and compassion, it was a wonderful school. We had lots of autistic children in the mainstream and the SEN unit and they were just accepted. Yet if you looked at his behaviour you'd think there MUST be an issue. There wasn't. He just hated change, the overstimulation, and being away from home.

It's so hard to put your trust in another person to look out for your vulnerable child in the way that they need - especially when there's 29 other children in the class.

SpidersAreShitheads · 25/04/2023 21:57

Blizzard23 · 24/04/2023 19:00

Well there is your answer!

a) She is just an acquaintance, not obliged to tell you anything

b) She is a school governor, and I imagine she needs to remain neutral.

I have no idea why schools appoint parents as governors. It’s a conflict of interest.

It's not a conflict of interest. Parent governors have the same responsibilities as any other governor. But you are absolutely right - all governors must be neutral.

If there's any conflict of interest, you excuse yourself from the discussion/decision. A decent person will be honest about any conflict of interest, and a decent school will be vigilant for any potential conflict of interest and ask the parent governor to step outside if they feel it is appropriate.

I was a parent governor for more than six years (including being the acting chair of governors for a period).

Governors aren't responsible for running the school - that's up to the senior leadership team. Governors are there to hold the senior leadership team to account, and to make sure the right mechanisms are in place, and the school is performing as it should.

As a governor, I've tipped off our Head about a potential problem I'd been made aware of on more than one occasion. But I couldn't intervene and nor did I (or any other governor) have any influence - how the school handles things is the responsibility of the senior leadership team, unless an official complaint is submitted and I'm one of the governors chosen to investigate it.

OP, I'm autistic too with autistic DC - I get how heartbreaking it is. I think the previous comment pointing out that your friend's DS was looking out for your boy is bang on. I know you're upset and hurt, but I think this should entirely be directed at the school. Your friend/acquaintance probably didn't quite know what to say, or whether it was her place.

Pumpkinspice13 · 25/04/2023 21:33

I would be very upset. I’m would ask her how long she had known and why she didn’t tell you. I don’t know if I would stop being friends as I’m not in that situation but you have to do what you feel is best for you.

EveryWitchWaybutLoose · 25/04/2023 21:23

The thing that I don’t understand here is how this could have been going on for months, and you didn’t notice????

ittakes2 · 25/04/2023 21:04

MrTiddlesTheCat · 24/04/2023 16:53

I can't remember the actual words but we were talking about it. I was in tears because it's so painful to feel so helpless because I didn't know it was happening. I said something about how I don't believe the school didn't know and she said something like, no she didn't believe either because every time her DS brought up the bullying he mentioned that he'd told a teacher what was happening. And then she asked what the school was doing so the conversation moved on.

Oh dear - you painted in your OP that this 'friend' had not told you...but she told you her son was bringing it up with the teacher. I am guessing she assumed you knew. If a child was getting bullied at school and the teachers knew - I would assume the teacher had told the parent. I think you need to ask her why she had not said anything to you. Maybe she is a friend but not a close friend. The fact she is also a governor adds another layer - she is likely to let the teachers get on with their jobs. Its your son's teacher I would be most angry with - not your friend and not yourself.

Learningtofeminist · 25/04/2023 19:59

For clarity: by ‘fails to do this’ I meant ‘fails to inform the school’ not ‘fails to consider moving their own child from a school that apparently can’t tackle bullying’. Just realised that was ambiguous 😁

Learningtofeminist · 25/04/2023 19:54

If my child told me another child - ANY child - at his school was being bullied, I would be straight on the phone to THE SCHOOL bloody well demanding assurances that meaningful action would be taken. If my child kept coming home saying he was still witnessing it, I’d be telling the school every damn time. Never mind wondering whether the parents knew (not all parents even have capacity to tackle an issue like this with a school but their children still deserve to be protected). Honestly, if my own child was at a school where this was allowed to continue I would definitely be looking at moving him even if he wasn’t (yet) a victim.

Anyone who fails to do this is complicit in allowing bullying to continue, and not someone I’d be very interested in spending time with.

(Obviously, I’d also tell the parents if I knew who they were. And let them know I would be an additional thorn in the school’s side as long as their child was being mistreated.)

My parents found out I was being bullied when another parent rang them to say she’d seen my class teacher deliberately turn her back when the other children started kicking me. I can only assume the posters making excuses for your ‘friend’ have no experience of bullying (but even if so, it’s not that fucking hard to work out 🙄).

carriedout · 25/04/2023 19:44

but friend (who I now realise is aquaintance rather than actual friend) is one of the governors. She told me yesterday that the parent of the ringleader in the bully group is also a governor. That's disgraceful - if these are governors I would report them to everyone I could and start looking for another school.

Really sorry this has happened to you and your DS.

oosha · 25/04/2023 19:39

You must be so upset, I would be livid with her. I don’t understand why she wouldn’t have told you as soon as she found out. That’s not a friend I’m sorry.

Aweebitpainful · 25/04/2023 19:32

I was trying to work out how I would have acted if I were your friend and I realised you didn’t know (when I thought you had). Did she apologise profusely? I would have been mortified

humus · 25/04/2023 19:27

So sorry that your son and you are going through this. From your update I would say that the anger at your friend is justified as she knew, she is a governor so has a safeguarding responsibility and seems to have put having a easy life ahead of her duty to your son and the school AND her friendship to you. Her son in the other hand sounds like a much nicer person!

Ailsamary · 25/04/2023 19:25

I'm sorry I would be angry as well, did she really think you knew when the bullying was still going on? And even then I would've asked how they both were getting on

CuriousMama · 25/04/2023 19:15

I'm furious for you and your poor little boy. I'd get the police involved. It's criminal. ☹️

Sage71 · 25/04/2023 19:13

Sorry but I do not accept the ‘she assumed you knew’ excuse. If my child came home and told me a friends child in a lower year was being bullied by older children I would be calling straight away to offer support which would immediately flag it up if friend didn’t actually know. Another woman who was not a friend was able to approach you and tell you. I would want to know why she didn’t tell you and if it wasn’t really good I would be calling it a day. My first priority though would be to raise the bullying with the school. In this instance you have another adult as a witness which is a huge help. The school need to deal with this firmly and if they don’t you involve your LEA or Ofsted. I cannot bear bullying in any circumstances but older children on a younger child who is not a confident communicator through no fault of his own just sickens me.

CantFindMyMarbles · 25/04/2023 19:02

I wouldn’t end the friendship but I would have a conversation and let her know how sad I was.

MysteryBelle · 25/04/2023 18:57

She chose to side with the powerful over the powerless.

On purpose she said nothing. Her own son did more than entire school of officials whose job it is to care for their students. Make sure you seek him and and thank him for his bravery and integrity and for trying to stand up for what’s right. He probably thought his mother would do something. He will soon learn that there are very few persons of integrity among us. He is one of them.

She sided with bully because of his powerful parent instead of with your little 6 year old son who couldn’t defend himself and was terrorized by a group of older, larger bullies.

Never forget that. Ever.

Jumpingthruhoops · 25/04/2023 18:53

To all those saying 'the friend must have thought OP already knew about the bullying', I would say that, if I were the friend, suddenly hearing OP's child was being bullied, I'd be getting straight on the phone to OP to tell her - and leave it to her to tell me that she already knew... or in this case, didn't. That's what a good friend would do. All these ifs, buts and maybes are just a cop-out.

Mummywarrior · 25/04/2023 18:48

Nope, no excuse. Even if she did think you knew she should have given you the info her son was giving her. I think this shows a lack of care for you and you son and I would certainly be thinking twice about being close to this woman.
i would also be considering pulling your son out of school until they deal with this horrible and very damaging situation.
Best wishes to you and your son x

Unsure33 · 25/04/2023 18:43

I would concentrate on the school first , especially if the teacher knew . That’s awful .

the other parent ask them why they did not tell you before making any decisions.

Janehowley71 · 25/04/2023 18:40

I would be inclined to think that she assumed you already knew and your son had told you about it. I’d give her the benefit of the doubt.

Goodread1 · 25/04/2023 18:40

Tell school Governors and offsed about this...

As soon as possible

HoldTightandPretenditsaPlan · 25/04/2023 18:38

MrTiddlesTheCat · 24/04/2023 15:53

My DS is 6 and has autism. He can talk but mostly doesn't. He goes to mainstream school.

A few weeks ago another parent approached me in the carpark and told me that she had had to intervene when passing through the playground earlier as a group of much older boys were intimidating my DS. She said he looked absolutely terrified and she thought I should know.

I talked to DS and with much coaxing I managed to get the full story out of him. These big boys have been mercilessly bullying him for months. Every single day name calling, pushing, kicking. It's horrfic and I'm so angry. Angry at the kids doing it. Angry at the school for apparently not noticing. Angry at myself.

I met up with a friend yesterday who I haven't seen for a while and I told her about DS and how awful it had all been. And she bloody well already knew. I was so stunned that it didn't really register what she was saying until I got home. Her DS is in the same class as these big boys and had been telling her all along what was happening to my little boy. But she never said anything.

Maybe it's misplaced anger, but I can't help feeling let down by her. She knew my DS was being hurt and chose to do nothing.

AIBU in thinking this crosses a line and this woman is not my friend?

I know this doesn't directly answer your message, but I wanted to respond as I feel it's important. I saw that you're autistic too, as am I and I know that I have a tendancy to tone myself down so I don't cause offence (from years of being told to watch my tone)... Anyway... Please make sure you use the word complaint and do not under any circumstances use the term "raise a concern". If you raise a concern it doesn't have to be investigated but a formal complaint absolutely does... I'm so sorry your son is dealing with bullies, that you found out your friend isn't a friend and that you're dealing with an alround overwhelming and shitty situation.

AliceOlive · 25/04/2023 18:36

AllyArty · 25/04/2023 18:31

Granted, it was a difficult situation for her to find herself in. But she should’ve told you. Instead, she chose to be a bystander in the hope that maybe the problem would go away. Or that somebody else would tell you. I don’t think it’s worth ending the friendship because u obviously like her (otherwise u would not have let the friendship run on so long) and also you never know what’s around the corner. I would have a word with her and say that whilst you understand how difficult the situation she was in that, if anything like that ever happens again, could she please tell you. Keep her on side.

How is it difficult? She had her own child trying to do something about it. He was probably also quite distressed that his own mother was not doing anything.

She’s a governor and did nothing. What a useless person.

Mumlifeofboys · 25/04/2023 18:34

Oh my goodness! I’m so sorry this has happened to your son! I’m actually pretty gobsmacked myself that your friend chose to say nothing to you! Just unbelievable really that another parent that you don’t know has told you and a “friend” chose not to! X