Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to deduct stolen money from payment?

181 replies

cocoloco117 · 24/04/2023 15:21

Name changed and tin hat on for this. We recently had someone working in our house, after which I noticed a large sum of money had gone missing. It was a pile of notes that was left under an ornament on a bookshelf in the room in which they were working. Now I don’t need any lectures on the follies of leaving large sums of money lying around the house, stupidly I forgot to move it before they came. But whilst it is a stupid thing to do, does that mean I deserve to be robbed?

No one else has been in the house in the time between when the cash was last definitely seen and when it disappeared, apart from me DH DCs and none of us took/moved it. I haven’t raised this with the company, yet, as it will be an extraordinary awkward conversation. And what would the response be? The worker’s undoubtedly going to deny it so it comes down to my word against theirs.

I was about to let it go and chalk it up to bad experience. But since the day of the work/theft, there’s been a few other issues so we haven't paid the invoice yet. In that time I have spent stewing over it, searching the place upside down and thinking about who else could have been in the house or what else could have happened. Post-stew I am now certain that the only explanation can be that it was taken by the worker. Would it be unreasonable to unilaterally deduct the amount stolen from the invoice and tell them to recover the rest from their light-fingered employee?

I’m almost set on this course of action now, but I’m after a sanity check via the unique brand of constructive criticism only available on MN. So: AIBU to proverbially cancel the cheque?

Thanks in advance but I don’t need any elaborate hypotheticals asking whether the cat/dog/baby might have eaten/buried/hidden it. They haven’t. And tell me that I’m wrong if you like but I am convinced the only reasonable explanation is that it’s been stolen.

OP posts:
cocoloco117 · 24/04/2023 19:58

The “wide range of responses” was a joke, c’mon peeps.

So I can’t do anything because I haven’t got proof but I should have contacted the police despite not having any proof and the fact I searched the house for the money proves I don’t think it was stolen?

The reason I have been hesitant is because I know it’s hard to prove anything in situations these.

Will contact the company and see what they say. And police but am sure they won’t do anything.

OP posts:
musicforthesoul · 24/04/2023 19:49

What outcome do you want?

All that's going to happen withholding payment is a bunch of stress in small claims court and you'll lose there and have to pay anyway.

cocoloco117 · 24/04/2023 19:47

Psychonabike · 24/04/2023 17:05

I don't think you can reasonably deduct it, while not being prepared to report the theft. There are no half measures here. You either suspect them and involve the police (in which case CAB may advise you on what proportion is reasonable to pay until the matter is resolved). Or you simply pay them.

In real life I would actually give them a chance to graciously avoid criminal proceedings:

"I can see a large sum of money was taken from X on XX/XX/XX. I assume that, given where I had left it, Y assumed this was part payment. Shall I deduct this from the total invoiced? If this isn't the case, please let me know so that I can report the theft to the police."

If you want to be extra mischievous, and are certain of your perception of events, you could add: "If this isn't the case, please let me know as I'll then have to go through hours of CCTV to work out what happened and report the missing money to the police".

But honestly, be sure. Strange things happen and we're all fallable.

Thanks have thought about approaching it this way, but not sure about the cctv bin in case they call my bluff. If I had cctv then I’d have the evidence (or not) already.

OP posts:
Treesoutsidemywindow · 24/04/2023 19:35

Sorry OP, I know you said 'I don’t need any lectures on the follies of leaving large sums of money lying around the house' but at the end of the day having done this, you are being extremely unreasonable to blame someone without any proof, especially when your DH or DC's could just have easily taken the money in the hope you would blame the builder. You've also failed, in spite of being asked several times, how old your DC's are, to answer, which might tend to indicate that you have doubts about this possibility yourself. Kids, especially teens, can be EXTREMELY devious if they want to be, I know this from experience! Unfortunately, gut wrenching as it is, I think you have to swallow this one, and learn from it.

SofiaSoFar · 24/04/2023 19:30

@cocoloco117

Doubt I’ll get any joy out the police they not interested when the whole house gets robbed or people get assaulted.

You've reported a robbery and an assault and the police were not interested?

I think don't think you're being truthful.

LemonPledge555 · 24/04/2023 19:29

You can’t just withhold. You need to speak to the company first. Obviously it was a mistake. But you can’t just expect the company to let this large sun of money go on your say so.

WhyCantYourPartnerDoIt · 24/04/2023 19:28

cocoloco117 · 24/04/2023 16:06

Hm, wide range of responses there. 🤔
There’s no issue with the work itself this company has done work for me before.
Doubt I’ll get any joy out the police they not interested when the whole house gets robbed or people get assaulted.
Didn’t report it before because as you’re all saying I can’t prove it and initially thought to chalk it up to experience as you’re all saying.
We moved some stuff around in the room so there was a tiny little chance it got moved so had a thorough search just in case. To make sure. I’m sure that it’s been nicked.

Lol at your “wide range of responses” 84% of people think you’re wrong.

Quveas · 24/04/2023 19:26

It wasn't a large amount of money, but this happened to me. Only 50 euros that I forgot was there. But nobody else in the house. I wrote it off as my fault. But the Google review they got was far more damaging to them...

BayandBlonde · 24/04/2023 19:22

Call the police, make sure your DC are present when they visit (I'm assuming they aren't a baby). Judge the kids reaction!

Solonge · 24/04/2023 19:21

If you want to be taken to court, then dont pay the invoice.

ohdamnitjanet · 24/04/2023 19:14

If you try to deduct it you will be blacklisted from every trade in town.

DeflatedAgain · 24/04/2023 19:00

Have you contacted your home insurance provider on the off chance you're covered for cash theft?

Some policy's will cover a cash theft (not a massive amount, perhaps up to £500 or so) even though it's not a burglary as such.

scoobydoo1971 · 24/04/2023 18:55

I had a very similar problem with builders a few months ago. £100 went missing from my office and it could have only been the builders assistant. I raised the dispute right away and bluffed that the CCTV had picked up movement in my office. He didn't argue and I deducted an amount from final pay for that loss, and further damages caused by his assistant.

Callyem · 24/04/2023 18:52

You entered into a contract, you honour the contract.

Money has gone missing, you report to the police

Two seperate situations, regardless of your gut instinct.

ememem84 · 24/04/2023 18:50

ive taken money off a bill before. Although not for this reason.

the plumber (a friend of a friend of a friend) was seemingly using our place to store his tools and was lying about working at ours. I called him once when I was at home and he was meant to be there to meet someone. He lied and said he was there. In the bathroom. Where I was.

he was also an absolute prick who ruined our bathroom.

I paid him bank transfer (even though he only wanted cash). And took storage fees off of the invoice. And a cleaning fee. Because he spilled coffee on our new carpet.

starfishmummy · 24/04/2023 18:47

Of course you pay the bill. Even if the employee took it, that's not the fault of the company.

You have no proof. I'd be looking closer to home on this.

RunningUpThatMill · 24/04/2023 18:47

I'm not a solicitor, or even legally trained, but common sense would dictate that YABU.

You haven't reported a crime, and you just can't renege on your contract to pay for works carried out, unless they are insufficient and the contractor has broken their contract to you of course. I would think you could find yourself in court.

I'm sorry your money has gone missing and I'm not sure what your next steps would be? But I don't think you can deduct your missing money from the bill.

MrsTerryPratchett · 24/04/2023 18:41

ChickenDhansak82 · 24/04/2023 18:17

You haven't said how old your children are...

Yup.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 24/04/2023 18:37

Legally I don't think you'd have a leg to stand on, as others have said (85% YABU at this point so don't see how you can say a range of opinions) it's two separate issues.

My3cents1 · 24/04/2023 18:37

Go for it…..if you fancy a CCJ

Nocutenamesleft · 24/04/2023 18:35

cocoloco117 · 24/04/2023 16:06

Hm, wide range of responses there. 🤔
There’s no issue with the work itself this company has done work for me before.
Doubt I’ll get any joy out the police they not interested when the whole house gets robbed or people get assaulted.
Didn’t report it before because as you’re all saying I can’t prove it and initially thought to chalk it up to experience as you’re all saying.
We moved some stuff around in the room so there was a tiny little chance it got moved so had a thorough search just in case. To make sure. I’m sure that it’s been nicked.

Wait.

there’s no wide range of answers. It’s pretty much 100% YABU…

SunshineGeorgie · 24/04/2023 18:33

YABU

Don't assume

mainsfed · 24/04/2023 18:33

cocoloco117 · 24/04/2023 16:06

Hm, wide range of responses there. 🤔
There’s no issue with the work itself this company has done work for me before.
Doubt I’ll get any joy out the police they not interested when the whole house gets robbed or people get assaulted.
Didn’t report it before because as you’re all saying I can’t prove it and initially thought to chalk it up to experience as you’re all saying.
We moved some stuff around in the room so there was a tiny little chance it got moved so had a thorough search just in case. To make sure. I’m sure that it’s been nicked.

Reporting it to the police will give you more leverage with the company.

KarmaStar · 24/04/2023 18:32

Hi,report the theft.you must do that.
It is a separate issue from the problems you have with the service provider and you cannot withhold the payment due to the theft they are two entirely separate issues.
Speak to the manager about issues and form an agreement over payment and repairs to the job.
Let the police look into the theft.that should flush out the offender.
if you do as you suggest,look at it from an outsiders pov: you allegedly had some money in a room which was allegedly stolen.
you think it was an employee of a company working in your house and so you are not paying the company as their employee allegedly stole from you.
can you see this could make you appear a bit unhinged? And if trying to get out of paying your bill?

Nocutenamesleft · 24/04/2023 18:28

SoupDragon · 24/04/2023 16:07

I haven’t raised this with the company, yet, as it will be an extraordinary awkward conversation. And what would the response be? The worker’s undoubtedly going to deny it so it comes down to my word against theirs.

all that will be exactly the same when you send in the reduced amount in payment. Awkward conversation, no proof...

Exactly. Time gone by still means the conversation had to happen.

Swipe left for the next trending thread