Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you gifted money to your grandchildren...

439 replies

HarperElla · 24/04/2023 14:46

...say £50-£150 per birthday/Christmas and the odd other occasion like Easter or random gifts, would you mind if their mother put the money towards a holiday for them and their parent? I've been doing this, I have a 4 year old, he has too many toys, I have a really good savings pot for him already etc etc. I want to take him on holiday to Egypt before he goes to school, and put any money which is given to him by family members towards this. I've made sure that it doesn't extend past the fare for his flight. I've been told by a family member that I'm out of order doing this and that I should either put it in his savings or buy him gifts with it. I've made it clear to him that the family members who gave us the money helped us pay for it and that we should be grateful to them that they helped us go on holiday (explained in terms he can ubderstand). He has 4k in savings, 1k a year put in my me. WIBU to do this?

OP posts:
Skybluepinky · 24/04/2023 17:41

No it should be put in savings, not u spending it.
Don’t assume big inheritance they could end up in care homes at £1500 a week each and could be in their until their money dries up.

toomuchlaundry · 24/04/2023 17:40

Also for those saying £18k won't be enough for her son, what sum will be enough? Should OP go without and her son have no treats at all, until he collects his money at 18?

Should no parents go on holiday or have any treats until they have a savings pot for all their children that will pay for a wedding, house deposit and university fees?

WhyamIinahandcartandwherearewegoing · 24/04/2023 17:40

YABU you can’t in good faith spend money other people intended for your son on anyone other than your son, and that includes you. You should pay for your son’s (and your) holiday.

N27 · 24/04/2023 17:40

Put the gifted money in his savings.

Take some of your money out of his savings to pay for it.

Net effect is the same but you can morally say it’s your money that paid for it

BotterMon · 24/04/2023 17:38

Stop putting money in his savings account yourself and pay for your own holiday?

YABU as you appear to be stealing his money to pay for a holiday for the two of you.

I would be pissed off if my daughter did that (but it wouldn't even cross her mind)

Twillow · 24/04/2023 17:36
  1. You say you have put £1000 of your own money in so use that 'portion' - and no more. More than ample for child's flight.
  2. Where in Egypt are you going? If it's Sharm el Sheikh then he won't see anything of interest other than sun loungers.
Cantthinkof1rightnow · 24/04/2023 17:35

I think you should. At the end if the day, it will be an enriching experience for him and a good use of the money....better than buying tat.

Hellzbellz25 · 24/04/2023 17:35

You can't make your child pay for their own holiday 🤣🤣 yabvu!

wrinkleintime · 24/04/2023 17:34

Newmumatlast · 24/04/2023 17:32

I agree 18k isnt enough (though more than many) but OP may be better saving additional sums, if she can afford it, in her own name. We cant control what our kids do with money in their own names and they could just spend it all when they get access. OP has time to replenish if she sees fit down the line.

They could spend it all frivolously on holidays... like OP is already doing...

toomuchlaundry · 24/04/2023 17:34

For those saying he won't remember it don't you do anything with children until they are about 7?

I am one of the first to question people taking their children to Disney when they are very young, not because they won't remember it, but because when we took DS there were younger children there tired, grumpy and petrified of all the people in costumes, so it's not that they won't remember it but because they might not appreciate it.

It appears the OP's son is obsessed by Egypt and so he might not remember the holiday when he is older, but sounds like he will really appreciate it and mum gets to see him so excited about it. I think if I was any of OP's relative who had given money (for saving or gifts) I would be looking forward to the 4yos tales of adventure and pictures of his happy face in front of the pyramids. You would have to be a real curmudgeon if you begrudged the OP spending your £100 birthday gift for the little boy to spend on what will probably be the most exciting adventure he has ever been on.

The OP is not wealthy, she is being careful and hoping to save £18k for her son, which is more than many children will be getting on their 18th birthday. If her son wasn't obsessed by Egypt it sounds like this would not be the OP's holiday destination of choice, so she is doing it for him.

Posters on here who give money for birthday presents and who give it directly to parents when the children are younger and expect it to go in savings accounts, what do you do when the children are older, give it direct to the child and tell them to save it or let them spend it on what they want.

If relatives are so precious about what the money is spent on, they should set up their own savings account for the child to be transferred to them on their 18th birthday

HarperElla · 24/04/2023 17:34

OliveOilly · 24/04/2023 17:30

@HarperElla Just lay off it , eh?

You are picking on me when many other posters have said exactly the same thing but you've not gone back to them and tried to contradict them. why not?

Ok, I missed the bit about your friend teaching him the Arabic words.

But I agree 100% with this post which says exactly what I think other than questioning his memory skills.

I made the same points and you came at me, all guns blazing. Maybe turn your annoyance to others now? You're getting tedious.

ArmatureDramatics · Today 17:13
@HarperElla It's good that your mum is happy for you to spend the money as you see fit - but blimey. My oldest child has Asperger's (I know it's not called that now, but it was when he was diagnosed), and had various obsessions on a par with your son's obsession with Egypt (and the same degree of knowledge about them at a similar age).

All I can say is it's a very nice thought to base your entire holiday and to throw huge amounts of money at something that will doubtless make him very happy while it happens - but it could also be a massive error. If you had more than one child, you wouldn't be doing this, and I'm not sure that it's a good idea to put a small child's current interest before absolutely everything else. It also potentially sets him up to think that when he develops an obsession with outer space, you'll just take him to the Moon. Sometimes children who tend to be obsessive are best indulged up to a point, but not beyond that. I'd say the British Museum would do the job until he naturally fixates on something else.

Yeah because you really can't see why your posts are a little bit different to all of the others on here 🙄 Crack on honestly it's actually quite funny now.

OP posts:
ArDi · 24/04/2023 17:33

To those saying £18k won’t be worth what you think by the time he’s 18 - true, but by the same token the cost of this holiday will also seem like a snip. You/ your son won’t find yourself in 15 years regretting spending the money on the holiday, I’m sure.

KillerSandy · 24/04/2023 17:33

Poppyblush · 24/04/2023 14:48

I think you should be saving this money for your child for university or property etc.

Totally agree!

HarperElla · 24/04/2023 17:32

wrinkleintime · 24/04/2023 17:29

I wouldn't take a 4 year old to Egypt, even if they were interested in it as your son is. I'd wait until he's at least 8 or 9 and could properly experience and remember it.

I certainly wouldn't expect him to give his birthday money towards it.

Would you take it out of his hand if his grandparents had given him cash?

If not, then YABU.

The worst thing is that you think £18k in savings is 'enough' and therefore anything surplus can be spent on holidays. A child can never have too much tucked away. Life is only going to get more and more expensive.

He's going to inherit upwards of 75k from his great grandparents who are in their late 90s. He will get this directly when he's 18. The £400 odd I've used on his flight won't make much of a difference in this respect (that's the argument you're making). 18k is all I can afford currently to save if I continue as I am and that's more than a lot of people who aren't on a huge wage do.

OP posts:
Newmumatlast · 24/04/2023 17:32

wrinkleintime · 24/04/2023 17:29

I wouldn't take a 4 year old to Egypt, even if they were interested in it as your son is. I'd wait until he's at least 8 or 9 and could properly experience and remember it.

I certainly wouldn't expect him to give his birthday money towards it.

Would you take it out of his hand if his grandparents had given him cash?

If not, then YABU.

The worst thing is that you think £18k in savings is 'enough' and therefore anything surplus can be spent on holidays. A child can never have too much tucked away. Life is only going to get more and more expensive.

I agree 18k isnt enough (though more than many) but OP may be better saving additional sums, if she can afford it, in her own name. We cant control what our kids do with money in their own names and they could just spend it all when they get access. OP has time to replenish if she sees fit down the line.

OliveOilly · 24/04/2023 17:30

@HarperElla Just lay off it , eh?

You are picking on me when many other posters have said exactly the same thing but you've not gone back to them and tried to contradict them. why not?

Ok, I missed the bit about your friend teaching him the Arabic words.

But I agree 100% with this post which says exactly what I think other than questioning his memory skills.

I made the same points and you came at me, all guns blazing. Maybe turn your annoyance to others now? You're getting tedious.

ArmatureDramatics · Today 17:13
@HarperElla It's good that your mum is happy for you to spend the money as you see fit - but blimey. My oldest child has Asperger's (I know it's not called that now, but it was when he was diagnosed), and had various obsessions on a par with your son's obsession with Egypt (and the same degree of knowledge about them at a similar age).

All I can say is it's a very nice thought to base your entire holiday and to throw huge amounts of money at something that will doubtless make him very happy while it happens - but it could also be a massive error. If you had more than one child, you wouldn't be doing this, and I'm not sure that it's a good idea to put a small child's current interest before absolutely everything else. It also potentially sets him up to think that when he develops an obsession with outer space, you'll just take him to the Moon. Sometimes children who tend to be obsessive are best indulged up to a point, but not beyond that. I'd say the British Museum would do the job until he naturally fixates on something else.

wrinkleintime · 24/04/2023 17:29

I wouldn't take a 4 year old to Egypt, even if they were interested in it as your son is. I'd wait until he's at least 8 or 9 and could properly experience and remember it.

I certainly wouldn't expect him to give his birthday money towards it.

Would you take it out of his hand if his grandparents had given him cash?

If not, then YABU.

The worst thing is that you think £18k in savings is 'enough' and therefore anything surplus can be spent on holidays. A child can never have too much tucked away. Life is only going to get more and more expensive.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 24/04/2023 17:29

And they called my son a genius

Here we go...

Newmumatlast · 24/04/2023 17:29

OliveOilly · 24/04/2023 17:24

You can mock all you like but I am.

I am not disbelieving an obsession. Far from it, so please make sure of your facts before criticising.

The part I query is his being able to speak lots of words in Arabic. He is unlikely to have read those words, so he has been taught them by the OP . She won't say if she speaks Arabic or is bilingual.

Everything else, I do understand.

She has already answered this. Her friend, who speaks arabic, has taught him about 20 words.

OP usually I would say no to using money for a holiday but I do think these circumstances are different. You couldn't afford to take him otherwise, its his passion not yours, the gift given is happy with it and you're not using any of the money for yourself. You can always save this money up again later if you felt like it and whether or not he remembers the experience he will still be enriched by it. I don't recall every holiday but being taken on cultural experiences and learning from them helped develop my analytical skills I'm sure. Enjoy

ArDi · 24/04/2023 17:29

OliveOilly · 24/04/2023 17:25

@HarperElla Could you explain how your child knows all those words in Arabic?

I asked if it was your native language or if you were bilingual but you didn't respond.

I assume he doesn't read them himself?

OP stayed that an Arabic-speaking friend taught him the words.

Newbie198 · 24/04/2023 17:28

Her friend who does speak Arabic taught him a few words. Flippin eck

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 24/04/2023 17:28

WOW. Just WOW.

You are basically stealing money that has been given to your child to go on holiday? But think that by saying 'He likes Egypt' that's a good smokescreen? He's FOUR!

Pay for your own holiday. Disgusting. Put the money in his own account or trust for him to decide what to do with in future.

HarperElla · 24/04/2023 17:26

OliveOilly · 24/04/2023 17:25

@HarperElla Could you explain how your child knows all those words in Arabic?

I asked if it was your native language or if you were bilingual but you didn't respond.

I assume he doesn't read them himself?

I give up 😅

OP posts:
OliveOilly · 24/04/2023 17:26

HarperElla · 24/04/2023 17:25

I've actually already told you how he learnt these words.

Where ? Which post?

OliveOilly · 24/04/2023 17:25

@HarperElla Could you explain how your child knows all those words in Arabic?

I asked if it was your native language or if you were bilingual but you didn't respond.

I assume he doesn't read them himself?