Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Believing in ghosts

293 replies

StupidFaces · 24/04/2023 08:34

I used to, now I think it’s ridiculous. People have been trying to prove the existence of ghosts for over 150 years and yet not one scrap of credible evidence to suggest they exist. I wish they did, I’d love it to be real but it just doesn’t make sense for them to exist does it?

Surely if ghosts were real, abattoirs would be haunted to fuck by the ghosts of dead cows? How come nobody ever sees a ghost dressed in trackies and Nike trainers? Why are they only ever dressed in Victorian/medieval clothes etc?

Do people think ghosts of fish haunt the ocean?

For those that do believe … what do you think about the above scenarios?

For those that done believe … would you be happy to spend a night alone in a supposedly haunted castle?

OP posts:
JennyWren87 · 27/04/2023 00:43

I never used to. But then ten years ago I moved to the UK, started working as a carer in a Dementia home. The home was in an old Victorian building and I saw a few people that didn't live there (old man in the red chair in the corner of the lounge, old lady by the steps to the conservatory). And in the four houses we've rented in the past ten years we've had cupboards fly open, cutlery rattling, vase being moved off the sideboard, whisk flying at my fiance. Honestly I can't count the amount of shit we've experienced.

Just seems crazy to me that I lived in Germany and Austria for 25 years before that and NVER had any kind of paranormal experience.

Luredbyapomegranate · 27/04/2023 00:38

StupidFaces · 26/04/2023 14:21

Oh I’ve had a few at work too.
Working on a ward … patient in his last few hours in bed at night, hadn’t moved for days. Was expected to die that night or the next day. I went in to check on him and his arm was outstretched as if someone was holding his hand … I was terrified and backed out of the room and went to get another nurse - told her what I’d seen … she came to look and he’d died - arm still outstretched (he was alive when I went in as could hear him breathing). Nurse said it happens a lot on that ward, it’s the ghost of a nurse who used to work there that they all knew, she died of the same condition that they treat on there and she now holds hands of dying patients. I believed it at the time but now … I dunno, why wouldn’t she hold the hand of all the dying patients? Why only some?

Another one - a different ward … night shift … went for my break and walked past one of the bays to see a nurse standing near the window not moving. I passed another nurse and joked “who’s that in there just staring out of the window?” She went to look - nobody there.

Same ward … elderly patient one morning asked me why we let kids in her room on a night, it’s hard enough trying to sleep without kids messing around. Obviously no kids were in there but the ward used to be the paediatric ward.

But none of these are at all remarkable

The elderly patient could have his arm stretched out for any reason, perhaps he was imagining his wife there, or dreaming, or it was just a sensory thing.

Either you saw a nurse and she moved or it was just a trick of the light.

The elderly lady that heard kids was dreaming.

Luredbyapomegranate · 27/04/2023 00:30

millypeggyandpandora · 24/04/2023 17:19

My daughter saw a ghost only last week, while sipping her morning coffee. A young boy ran across the room and disappeared. But, it could have been a time slip, who knows!

Ummm, time slips aren’t real either.

MissConductUS · 27/04/2023 00:28

Dithyramb · 27/04/2023 00:14

The journal in which most of this man’s ‘research’ has been published is the outlet of the Society for Scientific Exploration, notorious for pseudoscience like studies of alien abduction, UFO. and extra-sensory perception:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Society_for_Scientific_Exploration#:~:text=Journal%20of%20Scientific%20Exploration%20is,parapsychologist%20and%20philosopher%20Stephen%20E.

His academic work has been published in many different journals.

https://med.virginia.edu/perceptual-studies/publications/academic-publications/

Academic Publications - Division of Perceptual Studies

https://med.virginia.edu/perceptual-studies/publications/academic-publications

Dithyramb · 27/04/2023 00:14

MissConductUS · 27/04/2023 00:02

Not about ghosts, but there is some impressive evidence of reincarnation.

https://med.virginia.edu/perceptual-studies/our-research/children-who-report-memories-of-previous-lives/

UVA has a highly respected medical school.

The journal in which most of this man’s ‘research’ has been published is the outlet of the Society for Scientific Exploration, notorious for pseudoscience like studies of alien abduction, UFO. and extra-sensory perception:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Society_for_Scientific_Exploration#:~:text=Journal%20of%20Scientific%20Exploration%20is,parapsychologist%20and%20philosopher%20Stephen%20E.

Society for Scientific Exploration - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Society_for_Scientific_Exploration#:~:text=Journal%20of%20Scientific%20Exploration%20is,parapsychologist%20and%20philosopher%20Stephen%20E.

UnctuousUnicorns · 26/04/2023 23:03

Another incident. It was evening, and I was getting was getting ready to travel somewhere the following day, just for that day; I was returning in the evening.

I had a small rucksack that I was taking with me. I was sure that I'd put my mobile phone in it, but couldn't find it. I emptied the rucksack out completely, every pocket, main compartment, it definitely wasn't there. I checked elsewhere around the house but couldn't find it, so got a spare phone charging so I could use that instead.

Later that evening my mum, who was staying with us, called to me upstairs, from the living room, "Here's your phone, Unctuous, it's in the bottom of your rucksack!" She seemed to think that I just hadn't looked properly.

As I said, I tipped that rucksack upside down, emptied every pocket; my phone was absolutely NOT in it. And my mum wouldn't mess around with me like that, I know that 100%. I couldn't be bothered arguing with her about not looking properly for it. I've had numerous incidents like this over the years, I suppose you just get used to it. 🤷‍♀️

GarlicGrace · 26/04/2023 22:19

Mine is on its last legs. @BungalowLil. But maybe you should check yours is Ok ... 👀

PixieLaLa · 26/04/2023 22:06

WinterofOurDiscountTentz · 26/04/2023 15:08

Oh don't worry, it doesn't mean only you. You and the others like you.

You did not and do not see ghosts, which do not exist. Hallucinations and delusions definitely do exist.

things that exist are generally a better explaination for things than things that do not exist.

What a twat. People are on here to share their stories and experiences, if you don’t like it then move along….

BungalowLil · 26/04/2023 21:58

OK, maybe there are ghosts! Straight after I hit 'post' on that, my cooker blew a fuse 😮😂

No way!!! I just read this after posting my mail about ovens! Hells bells!

BungalowLil · 26/04/2023 21:56

GarlicGrace · 26/04/2023 21:08

If it was a problem (doesn't sound like it is?) you could ask someone to test whether you have standing waves in that room - two appliances that just happen to vibrate at the same frequency and at the right distance & wavelength so the waves meet in the room. It's been found to cause a lot of serious ghost problems, but it's expensive because one or both of the appliances might be quite far from your house.

Another common cause is electricity - either static from man-made fibres or an electrical fault. I've TWICE caught electrical fires because of 'woo' feelings. Once I was on my own, so didn't even consider a ghost. The other time lots of people said they got a bad feeling from my friend's basement. I said no, it's your wiring. That night it caught fire - a couple of hours after they'd called the fire service because I nagged them, and they arrived at exactly the right time.

I can't explain how I 'know' it's a fire but I did prevent two major incidents!

That's so interesting GarlicGrace. We sold the property and moved on about a decade ago now but something you've said really struck a long forgotten chord with me. I'd completely forgotten that the electrics in that house were very odd. E.g. if you put too many lights on and then the oven everything would fuse. We had a lot of rewiring done, including in the basement room but there were still problems. We would hear popping and cracking from sockets and oOne night my husband was asleep in the room I mentioned and woke to find sparks coming from a socket.

I have to say we were so used to odd things happening that we were never scared there and, because we'd had the electrics overhauled we thought the sparks/electric wierdness was down to the 'woo' and just lived with it. Perhaps there was a technical problem.

What an interesting slant on this you've given me. Thank you.

GarlicGrace · 26/04/2023 21:50

GarlicGrace · 26/04/2023 21:08

If it was a problem (doesn't sound like it is?) you could ask someone to test whether you have standing waves in that room - two appliances that just happen to vibrate at the same frequency and at the right distance & wavelength so the waves meet in the room. It's been found to cause a lot of serious ghost problems, but it's expensive because one or both of the appliances might be quite far from your house.

Another common cause is electricity - either static from man-made fibres or an electrical fault. I've TWICE caught electrical fires because of 'woo' feelings. Once I was on my own, so didn't even consider a ghost. The other time lots of people said they got a bad feeling from my friend's basement. I said no, it's your wiring. That night it caught fire - a couple of hours after they'd called the fire service because I nagged them, and they arrived at exactly the right time.

I can't explain how I 'know' it's a fire but I did prevent two major incidents!

OK, maybe there are ghosts! Straight after I hit 'post' on that, my cooker blew a fuse 😮😂

GarlicGrace · 26/04/2023 21:48

That's a good point about medications, @Highdaysandholidays1. I've been on a couple of threads here, where posters were suffering bad hallucinations with serotonin syndrome. Other common causes are thyroid disorder or thyroid medication, diabetes or insulin, and bladder infections.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 26/04/2023 21:26

The other thing that convinced me these aren't real ghosts is that the reason for these hallucinations is just medicine, lots of antidepressants and other medicines cause strange experiences, voices and seeing things are (rare) side effects of medications as well as mental illness, but people don't know that even though they are listed on the list of side effects! I take a fairly standard medication and it was only when I went online I found lots of people had nightmares, lucid dreams and night-time sleep disorders including hallucinations on them, before that I'd assumed it was some type of trauma disturbance. I need the meds so I just put up with it plus I am not scared to fall asleep as they don't happen often and I know what they are anyway.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 26/04/2023 21:22

I have seen quite a lot of figures, just like stills in a photograph. I have also been swooped on by horrible evil spirits, that's not fun and I have leapt out of bed with my covers on before now. They are all hallucinations in my case, usually on waking in the night, they are known as hypnopompic and hypnagogic hallucinations. They are very common, especially on falling asleep, the commonest one is hearing a doorbell or knock or your name said. I had one just the other day. The ones waking in the night are your more 'ghostly' type if you like, sleep paralysis, hallucinations, spiders, feeling someone pressing on you. I usually just scream really really loudly!

I don't believe in ghosts, even after all those experiences. These are well-known and documented hallucinations to do with the sleep-wake in-between state, it's like you are dreaming but awake for a few seconds.

If I saw something in the middle of the day it might be different, although some people do hallucinate in the daytime if they have dementia or certain diseases or seizures or all kinds. Smell hallucinations are also quite common.

GarlicGrace · 26/04/2023 21:08

BungalowLil · 26/04/2023 20:59

Sorry, I should add that when the guests heard a voice it used their name. When I heard the voice it said my name clearly right by my ear on several occasions randomly over a period of months. It's only ever happened in that room in that house, never anywhere else so is it me or is it something to do with the room, woo or otherwise? Can anyone who understands how the mind works please explain what that could be?

If it was a problem (doesn't sound like it is?) you could ask someone to test whether you have standing waves in that room - two appliances that just happen to vibrate at the same frequency and at the right distance & wavelength so the waves meet in the room. It's been found to cause a lot of serious ghost problems, but it's expensive because one or both of the appliances might be quite far from your house.

Another common cause is electricity - either static from man-made fibres or an electrical fault. I've TWICE caught electrical fires because of 'woo' feelings. Once I was on my own, so didn't even consider a ghost. The other time lots of people said they got a bad feeling from my friend's basement. I said no, it's your wiring. That night it caught fire - a couple of hours after they'd called the fire service because I nagged them, and they arrived at exactly the right time.

I can't explain how I 'know' it's a fire but I did prevent two major incidents!

BungalowLil · 26/04/2023 20:59

Sorry, I should add that when the guests heard a voice it used their name. When I heard the voice it said my name clearly right by my ear on several occasions randomly over a period of months. It's only ever happened in that room in that house, never anywhere else so is it me or is it something to do with the room, woo or otherwise? Can anyone who understands how the mind works please explain what that could be?

BungalowLil · 26/04/2023 20:52

WinterofOurDiscountTentz · 26/04/2023 15:20

It's not the fact that I personally think they are delusional that makes it so, its that they simply are.

Please don't tell me where I can read or comment , or how to behave. You're not the thread police.

I think I was as convinced as you that it's all nonsense. I utterly believed what Henry Marsh the Neurosurgeon says that he knows too much about how the brain functions to believe that there can be any afterlife of any sort.

Then I heard many people, I mean really sensible, trustworthy people all tell me about hearing voices and sensing 'ladies in white' in my house. The people were paying guests....over a period of years...all with the exact same experience. They didn't know anything about each other or the house.

I don't think people divide into delusional and those who 'know ghosts are nonsense' Sometimes the latter are persuaded there is something going on we can't explain.

If someone could present me with any explanation for that phenomenon however woo or scientific I would be so interested to know the answer. I want to believe it's all nonsense....but I've no proof any other way.

GarlicGrace · 26/04/2023 20:40

a puffa jacket, skinny jeans and trainers (don’t know if they were nike, sorry)

Oh heck, they're wearing gangsta fashion in the next dimension too 😂

Howmanysleepsnow · 26/04/2023 20:34

Well, I’ve seen ghosts in
a dressing gown
a puffa jacket, skinny jeans and trainers (don’t know if they were nike, sorry)
A raincoat and plastic headscarf thingy
A crinoline type (?) dress
1920s clothes (2)

Except the 20s ones I didn’t realise any were ghosts till they disappeared, I even assumed the one in the crinoline was dressed up for tourists or something until she vanished.

CalistoNoSolo · 26/04/2023 20:28

I've only once seen an unexplained thing, but that was ufo rather than paranormal. I have though experienced possible poltergeist activity in two places I've lived (one v v scary, one v friendly) and heard unexplained things in a hotel and a different place I lived.

No idea if ghosts exist but there are more things in heaven and earth than are dreamt of in most peoples philosophy so I remain open minded.

usernother · 26/04/2023 20:21

I never have believed and never will. Absolute nonsense.

GarlicGrace · 26/04/2023 20:19

OK. I have a friend who regularly sees the same two ghosts in her ancient cottage. She's had long conversations with one of them. In the summer, she goes into her garden and shrinks to less than the height of a daisy. Down in the jungle of grass stems, she meets fairies and talks with them about all kinds of stuff. She was diagnosed with stage 4 cancer but, after two chemo treatments, was declared clear.

She isn't mentally ill. She's just a highly creative individual whose mind interprets things differently.
That Japanese artist who sees the world covered in spots is not mentally ill and there's nothing wrong with her eyesight; she's a creative person whose mind prefers a spotted view.
I get ocular migraines and, as I wrote earlier, hallucinate when very tired. The world isn't really full of zigzaggy sparkles, and there's nobody talking in my kitchen; it's just my mind having electrical problems and doing its best to make sense of garbled signals.
If you've had sleep paralysis, it's easy to understand why they used to think they were being attacked by demons in the night. It's a relief to know what it really is, no evil spirits required! Just a briefly misfiring brain.

Like my friend, everybody's welcome to their personal interpretation of unlikely events. As long as they don't force their mythologies on other people, I guess it makes for an interesting chat. But let's not lose sight of how far we have come in terms of understanding ourselves and the wonders of the human mind 🙂

MidlandCatGirl · 26/04/2023 19:56

GarlicGrace Not at all, I was actually pissed off that out of everyone who’d detailed their experiences I was the one quoted and essentially told that I was delusional. I am in no way dismissive of mental health issues so please don’t try to accuse me of prejudice against those that do suffer them.

What I experienced on the Sunday started in the morning and went on til late evening. There is no way possible I could have hallucinated or imagined what happened.

Flyingsparks · 26/04/2023 19:55

Whatalife88 · 24/04/2023 18:52

As someone who has seen a ghost and has had things said to me about a deceased relative that was literally impossible to know, I can assure you they exist and are not just time lapses.

Tell us more!

Swipe left for the next trending thread