Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be totally hacked off at DH’s refusal to do any housework?

138 replies

SoLittleTimeToday · 24/04/2023 08:12

This is a longstanding bone of contention in our marriage. He simply will not pull his weight. If challenged he becomes incredibly defensive, and either claims to be doing loads, says the kids should do more, or says my standards are too high (believe me, with four DC and doing everything on my own, they are not!)

We had another row about this yesterday. He said that to ‘show me that he is doing loads’ he is going to stop doing anything for a week. AIBU to think that this is incredibly immature for a grown man and not very supportive in a marriage where we are supposed to be working as a team?

(For context we both work FT, children aged 4 - 11. One cleaner once a week for 2.5 hours which frankly doesn’t scratch the surface of the mess, laundry, cooking and general chaos!)

OP posts:
shutthewindownow · 25/04/2023 06:23

Why did you have four kids with him
I doubt he became useless overnight

Mrsmozza123 · 25/04/2023 05:37

There was a study done once where couples were individually asked to give a % of what they believed they contributed to the household chores. The average couples score added up to 150% or something, showing that most people overestimated what they do compared to their partner.

If there is resentment people need to create structure so that it’s transparent what the balance is otherwise each side could be massively underestimating what the other does.

That said, some flexibility would be needed in our house we recognise that our energy levels differ each week and if one of us is having a particularly challenging week for whatever reason then the other will pick up the slack a bit.

BOYBANDLOVER · 25/04/2023 00:17

your issue is you have allowed it to happen

you should have nipped that\laid down the law from day 1

before i even moved in with mine he was told im not his mother or his housekeeper and we were 20/21 with no kids at the time moving in to a 1bedroom flat.
we were together 5 years before my first baby came along

2 kids later(both have special needs)and 22years later he did everything he should have done.

he left us for my ex best friend in oct 2020 but that's another story. my reply is to say that there are decent men who are not sexist out there

in fact i would say he did more that the average man as he was a full time carer so couldn't work(as was/am i) and home educator(we home educate)

we never married as i don't agree with marriage but we had a very happy life

im 42 and will never pick up after a man just becasue im female
even though my boys have disabilities they have been taught that people are equal not matter what sex they are and try to help best they can, they are 18 and 12

i was brought up in the 80s,teenager in the 90s and unusual at the time my parents were equal partners so my mother never put up with that nonsense either

CuriousMoo · 24/04/2023 23:26

pinkyredrose · 24/04/2023 12:52

How do you know the cleaner is female? Oh let me guess - sexist stereotyping.

It's much, much more likely to be a female cleaner in her home.

Apologies to any male cleaners reading this and feeling left out.

anon666 · 24/04/2023 22:24

Literally the same as my DH.

I've had to keep lowering the bar until it reaches his threshold. It never has. We live in a hideous pit of dust and cat furbombs.

I dream of moving out one day.

slowquickstep · 24/04/2023 18:58

OP after reading you last post i think you are your own worst enemy, either stop making excuses for downing tools or learn to live with the situation.

Brefugee · 24/04/2023 16:43

tonyele · 24/04/2023 12:43

In fairness it is going to change soon DW is a solicitor and now a partner in her firm, so as I'm hitting 45 next year, and in quite a physical job, the plan is for me to retire and take over childcare for DS (14) holidays and weekends when he is home from boarding school, which should be good, lots of fishing and camping planned.
Dare say I might drift over to the pink list in the weeks when nothing else on, but I've got plans with DS to do a proper full on Hornby railway round the loft with all the landscaping etc. so that will take time.

the time to have stopped posting was before the first one you made in this thread.

You are insulting all people who pull their weight at home. Just stop it. You're not big. You're not clever and you most certainly aren't amusing.

Gcsunnyside23 · 24/04/2023 16:29

tonyele · 24/04/2023 10:58

Ok chap here so ready for incoming flak!!

Me and the wife have a pink job list and a blue job list - complicated stuff like laundry, hoovering, washing up is her domain, apparently according to her I can't do it properly so should leave it alone, on the blue list is easy stuff like washing the car, mowing the lawn, putting in a new kitchen, re-hanging the front door etc.

Works for us.

Well done for using your incompetence as a way of getting out if doing the every day jobs and getting yourself a nice little gig of pottering around once a month to do a couple of jobs.
You've just said she does the hard stuff and you do the easy stuff, do you not see how shit that is for your wife

Verv · 24/04/2023 15:49

I think if you down-tools for a week it will backfire as you'll have to clean up after the strike as Mr wont budge his arse.

You could offer a trade deal?
He stops contributing for a week and YOU agree to pick up the slack.
You stop contributing to the housework for a week and HE picks up the slack.

I think we both who is going to end up with a plateful.

Also, he sounds like a petulant twat.

Seas164 · 24/04/2023 15:45

The more I think about it, the more I think we need more help but I actually resent organising a team of people to run around doing all the stuff he is too lazy to do! And I also don’t think it sends a good message to the DC…

By the sounds of it you'd still end up spending the vast majority of the energy and time that needs doing to run a house and raise a family, even with more practical outside help.

"We both contribute equally" sends a better message to the kids than, one of us runs round like a blue arsed fly and feels resentful about it, and one of us feels entitled to pick and choose our efforts and get defensive when pressed for what's fair.

Lcb123 · 24/04/2023 15:43

id Try making a list of tasks (daily, weekly,
monthly) and agree a schedule, and it can include the kids to.

SoLittleTimeToday · 24/04/2023 15:38

Freefall212 · 24/04/2023 15:11

Your belief that your children will be harmed if you relax in any way and let him manage (maybe poorly) says that there is some rigidity on your part. Sure the house may be a little messier and the clothes a little wrinkled but it is doubtful he will starve the children. With kids that are 4-11 and a cleaner - they can do a lot of chores and the cleaner will keep the house in some slight order even if he does almost nothing. You should go away for a full or long weekend and leave him and the kids. If you can't do that and have decided that no one can function without you and your standards - then you are both part of the problem that needs to be fixed and maybe it is more the dynamic of interacting that has become the issue.

Have you ever gone away and left the kids with him for an extended period of time?

He wouldn’t starve them, no. However, conditions at home would deteriorate and no doubt be my problem to fix when I returned home! So leaving him to it is not a long term solution. I want him to pull his weight day to day, not hold the fort for periods of time whilst I frantically run around doing all the work before and after.

The more I think about it, the more I think we need more help but I actually resent organising a team of people to run around doing all the stuff he is too lazy to do! And I also don’t think it sends a good message to the DC…

OP posts:
Turfwars · 24/04/2023 15:36

Men can’t treat us like 1950s housewives AND cash cows.

An excellent point @IAmTheWalrus85 - they can only treat us like that if we let them.

DH thankfully, is smart enough to have never tried to treat me as anything except totally equal to him. I did get once or twice "I did the dishes for you" and it was answered with a glare and an evenings worth of taking the piss which ensured he never uttered that particular phrase again!

Freefall212 · 24/04/2023 15:11

Your belief that your children will be harmed if you relax in any way and let him manage (maybe poorly) says that there is some rigidity on your part. Sure the house may be a little messier and the clothes a little wrinkled but it is doubtful he will starve the children. With kids that are 4-11 and a cleaner - they can do a lot of chores and the cleaner will keep the house in some slight order even if he does almost nothing. You should go away for a full or long weekend and leave him and the kids. If you can't do that and have decided that no one can function without you and your standards - then you are both part of the problem that needs to be fixed and maybe it is more the dynamic of interacting that has become the issue.

Have you ever gone away and left the kids with him for an extended period of time?

FinallyHere · 24/04/2023 13:38

he is going to stop doing anything for a week

I wouldn't be able to resist asking him for a list of the jobs he is going to not do this week. Then keep track of those jobs the following week.

But then I'd be pretty petty if I thought someone wasn't pulling their weight.

And/or significantly up the cleaners hours and make sure the additional cost doesn't impact you.

In our house, DH has significantly reduced mobility so just can't do lots of things. We agreed to up the hours and start using an outside laundry. Why should it be me who picks up the slack.

ChocolatGateaux · 24/04/2023 13:34

tonyele · 24/04/2023 10:58

Ok chap here so ready for incoming flak!!

Me and the wife have a pink job list and a blue job list - complicated stuff like laundry, hoovering, washing up is her domain, apparently according to her I can't do it properly so should leave it alone, on the blue list is easy stuff like washing the car, mowing the lawn, putting in a new kitchen, re-hanging the front door etc.

Works for us.

Washing the car... maybe once a week.
Ditto mowing the lawn.
putting in a new kitchen? Once in what, 10 years, maybe longer? Re-Hanging the front door?

Jeez another one who doesn't do anything because he has a penis.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 24/04/2023 13:19

tonyele · 24/04/2023 12:43

In fairness it is going to change soon DW is a solicitor and now a partner in her firm, so as I'm hitting 45 next year, and in quite a physical job, the plan is for me to retire and take over childcare for DS (14) holidays and weekends when he is home from boarding school, which should be good, lots of fishing and camping planned.
Dare say I might drift over to the pink list in the weeks when nothing else on, but I've got plans with DS to do a proper full on Hornby railway round the loft with all the landscaping etc. so that will take time.

🤣 you took it too far

IAmTheWalrus85 · 24/04/2023 13:17

When I had a similar problem with my DH, I threatened to quit paid work. I said I wasn’t prepared to earn more than 50% of our household income while doing 99% of the housework. I said that as he didn’t do any housework, he clearly wanted a 1950s housewife, and I’d be delighted to oblige - I could spend more time with the children, go to the gym more often, which would be nice for me, and he wouldn’t have to lift a finger round the house, which would be nice for him. But he’d need to get a second job to make up for the lost income, and I’d want him to invest a good chunk of his earnings into a private pension for me to make up for the loss of my contributions.

It worked like a charm. Scared the hell out of him. Oddly enough he suddenly became a lot more interested in housework and it’s mostly been plain sailing since then.

I didn’t actually intend to quit work and I wouldn’t advise someone with a lazy husband to quit work, but it might help make the point.

Men can’t treat us like 1950s housewives AND cash cows.

UWhatNow · 24/04/2023 13:08

I voted YABU because it clearly wasn’t a big enough issue to put you off having 4 kids with the selfish prick. You’ve really only got yourself to blame.

fizzyfood · 24/04/2023 13:00

I know it's not the best answer but I'd have the cleaner come twice a week.

ACynicalDad · 24/04/2023 12:56

Let him stop for a week, then you stop for a week. Compare and contrast.

ChickenDhansak82 · 24/04/2023 12:54

Team clean on a Saturday morning?

e.g. ALL of you do the housework together from 10am til 12pm?

That way everyone (including kids) can be allocated tasks and no one gets to stop until everything is done. A reward for those who pulled their weight when it's finished.

(and if he doesn't join in, then no reward for him!)

pinkyredrose · 24/04/2023 12:52

Wexone · 24/04/2023 11:50

Apologies i see now you have a cleaner - Can she come more hours ? Can she help with laundry ? Have you looked at the likes of hello fresh ?Do your kids have age appropriate chores ?

How do you know the cleaner is female? Oh let me guess - sexist stereotyping.

Seas164 · 24/04/2023 12:46

There is no magic wand for this, is there was a way of making useless men pull their weight the divorce rate would seriously plummet.

If you both work full time and you have four kids, you need some more help. This can either be from him, which doesn't sound likely, or you can buy it in.

Don't waste your time and energy trying to come up with a list of tasks for him, or break it down in to man sized chunks which he can handle. That is not your job either. He knows what needs to be done and he is very aware that it's much easier to opt out and not to do it and just defend the flak when you get to the end of your rope and deal with a row every so often.

Double your cleaner hours, so they're in twice a week. Get someone to take away your laundry and bring it back ironed and folded etc. Whatever you can outsource, do it and this gets paid for jointly. Alternatively you can keep pushing against the closed door that is your DH and drive yourself barmy in the process and send out four more people into the world believing that women are hard wired with the capability for neverending drudgery and a love of the smell of flash, or you can leave him.

Naunet · 24/04/2023 12:46

tonyele · 24/04/2023 12:43

In fairness it is going to change soon DW is a solicitor and now a partner in her firm, so as I'm hitting 45 next year, and in quite a physical job, the plan is for me to retire and take over childcare for DS (14) holidays and weekends when he is home from boarding school, which should be good, lots of fishing and camping planned.
Dare say I might drift over to the pink list in the weeks when nothing else on, but I've got plans with DS to do a proper full on Hornby railway round the loft with all the landscaping etc. so that will take time.

Oh even better, she gets to pay all the bills from a high stress job AND do all of “her” daily housework, unless you find yourself with nothing better to do.
What a lucky, lucky woman.

Swipe left for the next trending thread