Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to visiting inlaws so often

234 replies

PinkMonday · 24/04/2023 07:53

Dh and I have a baby who is 6 months old. The inlaws have been visiting to see our baby every other weekend but now dh wants us to visit them every other weekend instead. His reasoning is that he wants our baby to get used to the car journey. They live 45 mins away.

Back story: we have been together for 14 years. I felt like dh used to emotionally blackmail me into visiting them every weekend when we first got together. This lasted about 10 years! I don't have any family and so I agreed but resented it. Imagine having no weekends to yourself for years! And it was never just popping in for tea, it was always a whole day thing. I did say a lot that I didn't want to go and for him to go by himself, but he wouldn't. It was either I go with him or he wouldn't go at all. I was frightened of being seen as coming between him and his family hence why I reluctantly agreed.

Since covid and now having a baby, I haven't had to go over. I don't mind them coming to us but I don't want to go there. My first thought was to alternate so they come here and then we go there but I don't even want to do that! I feel like I'm being a child stamping their foot. So please tell me if I am!

I'm thinking of saying I will go once every 3 months but is that horrible of me? Aibu to suggest that?

OP posts:
Thatboymum · 24/04/2023 10:09

This sounds absolutely awful I honestly would not be with a man who dictated that two weekends a month out of four I had to travel to his parents . Fuck that ! I don’t think this is a normal set up at all stand up for yourself and say you will see them once a month and each month alternate who does the travel

Blanketpolicy · 24/04/2023 10:07

I would bin any sort of structured rota for visiting, but imo it is good for kids to be close to their grandparents and the only way that happens is regular contact so I would make an effort for them see them at least once a fortnight - either at yours/theirs and with/without you there.

But it is also important they see you there regularly too, maybe not every visit but not only a couple of times a year either, so they see them as part of their extended family unit rather than just someone they visit with dad.

AgrathaChristie · 24/04/2023 10:00

cpphelp · 24/04/2023 07:58

@ViviPru - once a month? When you're a grandparent, would you be happy with only seeing your grandchild and son 12 times a year?

Yes. With FaceTime, Portal, Skype you can see and talk with grandchildren without having to visit in person for hours. My dgc are at football, rugby, hockey, swimming, horse riding and playing with their friends at weekends, visiting granny for a whole day would be utter boredom.

OP your DH can visit on his own or take the baby to visit, you can’t live your weekends around grandparents and as your child grows you’ll find they have a weekend social life you have to facilitate.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 24/04/2023 09:58

Could you try bringing it up with your In Laws when you're there - making statements like 'I'm going to spend the next couple of weeks catching up with the gardening - I thought it might be nice if DH brought baby over on his own next time so you don't miss out on seeing them'?

That way you avoid the 'she's stopping him from seeing us' as you've already told them he can come on his own. You've given a reason for not coming and you're setting the precedent for him coming with the baby on his own.

user1492757084 · 24/04/2023 09:56

It's fair for the whole family to visit grandparents once per month, I think.
If the baby has a cold or if the grandparents do then you and the baby stay home and let your husband go to see his parents alone.
Vary the visit by meeting at a play park somewhere in the middle for a picnic a few times per year.

Welcome the grandparents to visit no more than once per month too.
You and husband could plan to go out every now and again while the grandparents play with the child for a couple of hours. You can always have a friend over at the same time too
.
Be flexible and enjoy the baby having an extended family while protecting your privacy on other, regular weekends.

What have you got against seeing his family?
I would think, after all this time, you would be family enough yourself now and be able to make plans with them without your husband taking charge.

Eddielizzard · 24/04/2023 09:56

A really liberating moment for me was knowing that I would get blamed for things the in laws didn't like and NOT CARING. Seriously, who cares?! They still have to put up with you. So go when you feel like it. Otherwise he really must go on his own. Invite them over every now and again to break this two week pattern. Eg. invite them for 3 weeks time, saying you've got something on in 2 weeks so you can't visit them then. Just start changing up this whole fortnight habit. get some flexibility in there. It sounds stifling.

BlastedPimples · 24/04/2023 09:51

It all sounds really suffocating.

I'd hate to see the same people over and over so often.

Do you not have friends that you'd also like to see and spend time with at the weekend? Don't your in laws have a social life of their own?

When you're with the in laws, what does your dh do? Is he fully engaged with them or does he leave you alone with them?

Interesting that he's prepared to go off by himself and do his hobbies alone but won't visit his parents alone.

I think once a month is plenty to see them and for half a day.

I think it's really important your cultivate friendships with other people and families so your dc get to meet and hang out with all sorts of people.

oakleaffy · 24/04/2023 09:48

PinkMonday · 24/04/2023 07:58

His reasoning was that he just doesn't want to spend the day away from me but he will spend the day away from me doing his hobbies so it doesn't make sense!

Oh I meant to add, I'm happy for him to take our baby there by himself but I don't want to go to.

Well that sound eminently fair, @PinkMonday .

You aren't stopping your husband or baby from seeing your In~ laws, I should stick to it.

In all honesty, the In Laws probably will like it!

My MIL definitely liked it 😂

Elliania · 24/04/2023 09:36

We used to visit a grandparent every week when I was a kid and I can tell you from my persepective, it was not fun. They didn't really interact with me (I used to be sent to play in another room when I got older) and I know my parent who was not the child of this grandparent resented the weekly routine. It left us with no family time at weekends really.
Tell your DH that you (and the baby when they are older) want to ENJOY seeing his parents, not resent it. Therefore it's better if visits aren't rigidly structured and not as frequent so that when you do spend time with them, everyone enjoys it. Otherwise it's too easy to fall into the mindset that it's a chore, an obligation and not a fun outing. You could also sometimes invite them to little outings like if you have nice parks near you or walks to go on.

Sugarfree23 · 24/04/2023 09:33

Alternate fortnightly.

Your LO is still very new and they'll come a time when you want to get a break and for your kids to stay over at Grannies that can only happen if they know one another.

Willowthecrisp · 24/04/2023 09:33

why does it have to be some kind of regular arrangement? My in laws are about an hour away and sometimes we’ll invite them over for a BBQ/birthday party/roast, sometimes they’ll invite us for something. There is always some kind of plan for Easter/bonfire night/birthdays, we go on the odd weekend away together. I’d say we typically see them about twice a month, sometimes it’s more, sometimes less. But the key is that we arrange things when everyone is on board. We don’t go and sit in their house for a day every 2 weeks just for the sake of it. Sounds miserable.

Tallulasdancingshoes · 24/04/2023 09:32

Once every 3 months isn’t very much really. That’s only 4 times a year. That’s not going to be enough if you want your child to be close to their grandparents. I think the real problem is the whole day thing. 45 minutes isn’t very far really. Maybe you could visit them once a month and they could visit you once a month but just for a few hours in the afternoon? Or maybe for tea? It doesn’t need to be a whole day all the time. Also, now the weather is improving maybe you could meet them half way and go for a walk/picnic so you’re not just sat in their house all day.

redskylight · 24/04/2023 09:31

I personally find short frequent visits to family are easier than longer, less frequent visits. Also, if you go to theirs, you can decide how long you stay. If they come to you it's harder to (politely) get rid of them. That said, alternating seems fair anyway.

Your baby is still very young. I found that family visit naturally become less frequent as children get older. You going back to work will also be a natural change point (if you are). So I wouldn't worry overly that you are setting something in stone for ever.

HyacinthBookay · 24/04/2023 09:29

You were deprived of your weekends for years and now you are to be deprived of restful weekends after having had a baby (if such a thing exists for new mums - I don't know as I am child free). I'm with you. YANBU. If dh goes on his own with baby you would be able to have some valuable time to yourself. A good compromise is that you go with dh and baby every other visit.

LookItsMeAgain · 24/04/2023 09:25

Let us get this straight - you married him only right? There were no terms and conditions in the marriage vows that included taking on his mother and father to the degree that you've been doing? I might even (jokingly) throw that into a conversation with him that you only married him and that his parents, while they are grandparents are not your folks and you're allowed have time away, in the same way that he gets to do whatever his hobby is, without you, without his child and without his parents.

Next, I need to ask you a question - has your DH ever been left in his own house with his own child....ALONE??? By that I mean have you ever made a hair appointment or arranged to meet your friends and left your baby with him and gone out without him or your baby? If you haven't, start doing that now.
The reason I'm suggesting this is because (from what you've written), it sounds like he isn't confident in looking after his own child without you. Otherwise why would you need to be making the trips to his parents with your child? He should be well able to do that.

Lastly, I would think that you are not trying to make trouble - he is. He's not being remotely flexible in the visiting. He's presented it, to all intents and purposes as a done deal, this is what is happening, deal with it. Well, you can establish good boundaries where you will not build resentment of having to make these trips and you won't begin to resent your inlaws. Unfortunately though, this is a DH issue that you have to nip in the bud because if you don't, he'll begin to expect you showing up.

YOU decide what works for you! Then you'll slot in with whatever is happening on that given weekend if it works for you.

CuriousMama · 24/04/2023 09:25

@PinkMonday I think you need to explore why it is you're scared of voicing your opinion and owning it? Is it something from your childhood? Is it how he reacts?
You're a mother now you need to find your strength.

I couldn't be done with routine visiting for a start. Once baby is older you can go for days out. In fact mine went for days out from weeks old. I must have been unaware of the car seat thing? They're both strapping young men so no harm done 😊

Newyearnewmeow · 24/04/2023 09:22

Is your husband a bit controlling in other ways OP?
A strictly structured visiting arrangement never works. It’s stifling!
And bloody boring as hell having to spend all day in the house trying to make conversation.
I would tell him he is welcome to take baby or visit them alone whenever he wants but you won’t be going every other week.
Sounds like they all want to arrange your bloody weekends for you no matter what you would like to do those days.
Time to stand up for yourself and do what you want to do.

Brefugee · 24/04/2023 09:22

i think alternating the locations, so they come once a month and baby visits them once a month is fine. It is up to you how often you go.

You said, OP, that your DH has hobbies. Do you have hobbies? and time away from everything?

toomuchlaundry · 24/04/2023 09:18

How old are they? Do they have a social life outside family? Do you have a social life outside family?

When your little one gets older you will have to factor in parties, clubs, hobbies etc.

Make sure the routine doesn’t have to be so strict you can’t make changes if you want to do something else instead

Also make sure DH isn’t ducking out of chores etc by going to visit his parents, especially once you are back at work

mainsfed · 24/04/2023 09:16

I think dh likes me to go and be the one to chat but I'm trying to be quieter and get him to do the talking.

I think this is why he says he doesn't want to be away from. He wants you to do the conversational heavy lifting. Funny how he is happy to spend all day away from you when doing his hobbies.

On these visits, have you tried not being the one who asks questions or introduces topics of discussion?

Anoisagusaris · 24/04/2023 09:14

45 mins is not a long journey, no need to spend the whole day. Could you suggest calling to see the in-laws before or after you go for a walk/lunch/shopping. Stay for an hour or two. Or meeting them somewhere would be good too. I can’t imagine just sitting in someone’s house all
day every 2 weeks.

skyeisthelimit · 24/04/2023 09:13

When I first met XH he used to visit his family every Sunday and it was the same routine every week, go for lunch, then go to one house, then another, then another, then home. He also worked most Saturdays so we literally had no time to do anything else, like visit my family or go out for the day.

When we moved in together, I asked him if we could make the visits once a month to give us a chance to do other things together.

When we had DD, I suggested that we visit more often so that his mother could get to know her, as I was aware that my parents lived closer and would see her all the time. (A 45 minute to MIL for us too). I didn't suggest that he went without me as that would have been taken as me not wanting to see her.

You are right to try and stop there being any sort of routine. As your child grows up they will have birthday parties, then hobbies/sports etc at weekends, and you won't be able to sustain a routine of going there on a set schedule.

I would go with him, but every 3rd week sounds like a good compromise, then you will also see them on all the occasions etc as well which bumps it up.

bussteward · 24/04/2023 09:13

Every other weekend is insane to expect you to go too. Life only gets busier with DC as they get mobile, accumulate 3,000 bits of Playmobil and grind playdoh into the carpet, develop hobbies, catch endless nits, request playdates, etc. Fitting in chores and life and your own sanity into a weekend is hard enough without a compulsory tally on visiting your in-laws. He needs to (a) take the baby without you as you’re happy with that, and (b) make it less regimented – invite them along on a family outing, for instance, so you all do the thing you were going to do, and the grandparents see the baby, but as a two birds one stone system.

Babies don’t necessarily get used to the car, anyway. Mine screamed about it til she was two, then switched to complaining, and only now at four can cope for more than 10 minutes without dramatics.

Schnooze · 24/04/2023 09:10

PinkMonday · 24/04/2023 08:45

The oven could do with a clean ;)

Not just one off tasks. The stuff you do while baby naps or goes to bed. You relax at those times and save up that basic housework for whilst they are at yours or when dh takes the baby to them.

You can be busy while they are at yours. You don’t have to sit and entertain them. Or. You don’t have to go to them because you have housework to do. Or you don’t have to go because you are having your equivalent “me” time that dh has with his hobbies.

You just don’t have to go for any reason if it’s too much and you don’t want to. If he doesn’t go then that’s his choice. Just make sure that the in laws know that you are ok with him taking the baby on his own. Tell them that yourself if dh doesn’t.

Bunnywabbity · 24/04/2023 09:09

It isn't your responsibility to deal with this. You're being emotionally manipulated - DH saying he doesn't want to be without you when going to his parents, whilst happily going off on his own to do hobbies. If he wants regular trips to his parents he needs to be able to care for the baby himself and you can join when it suits you. You are entitled to defend yourself and stand up for your own needs. These people are supposed to be loving family, not your dictatorial boss.