Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to visiting inlaws so often

234 replies

PinkMonday · 24/04/2023 07:53

Dh and I have a baby who is 6 months old. The inlaws have been visiting to see our baby every other weekend but now dh wants us to visit them every other weekend instead. His reasoning is that he wants our baby to get used to the car journey. They live 45 mins away.

Back story: we have been together for 14 years. I felt like dh used to emotionally blackmail me into visiting them every weekend when we first got together. This lasted about 10 years! I don't have any family and so I agreed but resented it. Imagine having no weekends to yourself for years! And it was never just popping in for tea, it was always a whole day thing. I did say a lot that I didn't want to go and for him to go by himself, but he wouldn't. It was either I go with him or he wouldn't go at all. I was frightened of being seen as coming between him and his family hence why I reluctantly agreed.

Since covid and now having a baby, I haven't had to go over. I don't mind them coming to us but I don't want to go there. My first thought was to alternate so they come here and then we go there but I don't even want to do that! I feel like I'm being a child stamping their foot. So please tell me if I am!

I'm thinking of saying I will go once every 3 months but is that horrible of me? Aibu to suggest that?

OP posts:
likeafishneedsabike · 24/04/2023 13:25

Butterflyflytoday · 24/04/2023 08:44

It’s pretty dire and compounded by the fact that DH and in-laws are unable to make small talk. I was the one keeping the conversation going but found it exhausting so stopped a few years ago, when they visit there’s a lot of sitting in silence- it’s ridiculous.

I have been reading a lot of linguistic theory recently. This problem is aptly named ‘conversational shit work’ that we have been socially conditioned as females to take on.
Good on you for opting out. Let someone else do the ‘shit work’ …….or not ……..silence.

SquishyGloopyBum · 24/04/2023 13:09

You feel that you are causing trouble or being controlling. Why?

None of this is control- you are happy for him to take DD to see them. You aren't stopping him.

Where is this coming from? It sounds like he's trained you for year not to say anything- because that makes his life easier. Not not yours. You need to start as you mean to go on.

PinkMonday · 24/04/2023 13:01

@Cotton55 thank you! I am going on amazon now to buy a mirror for the carseat! And I will look for somewhere for us all to visit in the middle ready for when I next travel to them.

OP posts:
PinkMonday · 24/04/2023 12:58

mischlerischler · 24/04/2023 12:55

I think you missed part of OP's replies. She is not suggesting her DH or child go less often, she would like to skip some visits herself. That's completely reasonable and fair.

DH, DD & ILs still get to see each other very 2 weeks. They are not losing any time together.

Exactly what @mischlerischler said. Not stopping them but I just need a rest bite.

OP posts:
Bunnywabbity · 24/04/2023 12:57

DH is using you like a human shield with his family. He wants you there to make the visit run smoothly. He can blame you if you both don't go if you decide not to. It seems like he's both avoiding caring for his child by himself and also avoiding having tricky conversations with his parents. You're not his mum, he's an adult and needs to learn to behave like one. This is his problem to solve, not yours.

Cotton55 · 24/04/2023 12:56

You need an open and straight conversation with your dh about why he won't visit on his own. You know his excuse about not wanting to be away from you all day is rubbish as he's well able to manage doing his hobbies. If he feels nervous about being on his own with his own child all day, tell him to man up. You do it all the time. He'll get better the more he does it. Plus he would have 2 parents in the house with him to help if needs be.

If it's that he finds it difficult to chat to them without you, without wanting to sound harsh, tough luck. It's not your job to be a social buffer between him and them. They're his parents!

I remember my mam advising me, years ago, never to let myself get into a scenario where you visit in laws every second weekend (or whatever) as before you know it, you're locked in to that arrangement and it's expected. This is now your case. You should have nipped it in the bud long ago but now, with a new baby, you have the excuse to do it. When do you get a break? Time to yourself? It's not fair that the only time is when the baby is napping. You'll always have an ear out listening for her stirring so it's not a proper break. I'd advise telling your dh you've been thinking about it and you're more than happy to go some days (don't give a set plan of how often) but sometimes he'll have to go on his own as you need/want a child free break for a few hours.

Also, stop sitting in the back of the car with your baby or she won't settle without someone there. Get a mirror for the back so whoever is driving can clearly see her.

And 45 minutes in a car really isn't far. That's roughly how far my parents were from us. I was always over and back but didn't feel the need to always spend the whole day there.

Do what other posters suggested and randomly offer to meet them in a park central to all of you, especially now that the weather's getting nicer. Just give them a couple of days notice. It'll gradually get them into the idea that you're delighted to meet with them but just not always at the weekend in their house.

Good luck!

mischlerischler · 24/04/2023 12:55

averylongtimeago · 24/04/2023 12:47

Let's unpick this:
DH is an only child.
Pil are the only other family on both sides.
Pil are generally ok people who treat you well (if sometimes a bit overbearing).
They live 45 minutes away - so about 30/35 miles?
Pil and your DH would like to see each other (and the grandkids) regularly, you less so.

Why does everything have to be set in stone? Seeing each other every couple of weeks sounds fair to me- I saw my in-laws and my mum at least that often, and wider family regularly too. I would be very unhappy if I was restricted to a set day once a month to see my only child and grandchildren, and would have been beyond cross if DH had tried to restrict my contact with my mum (I'm an only child too).

Why not continue to see them every couple of weeks, sometimes at your house, sometimes at theirs and sometimes on a day out to the play park/zoo/shopping trip/meet for Sunday lunch.
They are not that far away, it's not like they live in Scotland and you live In Cornwall, it doesn't have to be always at one place and it doesn't always have to be both of you. I would go out with mil and the dc sometimes, DH would go on his own occasionally if I was working or busy.

I think you should be prepared to compromise here, unless there's a back story you are not sharing?

I think you missed part of OP's replies. She is not suggesting her DH or child go less often, she would like to skip some visits herself. That's completely reasonable and fair.

DH, DD & ILs still get to see each other very 2 weeks. They are not losing any time together.

PinkMonday · 24/04/2023 12:54

averylongtimeago · 24/04/2023 12:47

Let's unpick this:
DH is an only child.
Pil are the only other family on both sides.
Pil are generally ok people who treat you well (if sometimes a bit overbearing).
They live 45 minutes away - so about 30/35 miles?
Pil and your DH would like to see each other (and the grandkids) regularly, you less so.

Why does everything have to be set in stone? Seeing each other every couple of weeks sounds fair to me- I saw my in-laws and my mum at least that often, and wider family regularly too. I would be very unhappy if I was restricted to a set day once a month to see my only child and grandchildren, and would have been beyond cross if DH had tried to restrict my contact with my mum (I'm an only child too).

Why not continue to see them every couple of weeks, sometimes at your house, sometimes at theirs and sometimes on a day out to the play park/zoo/shopping trip/meet for Sunday lunch.
They are not that far away, it's not like they live in Scotland and you live In Cornwall, it doesn't have to be always at one place and it doesn't always have to be both of you. I would go out with mil and the dc sometimes, DH would go on his own occasionally if I was working or busy.

I think you should be prepared to compromise here, unless there's a back story you are not sharing?

@averylongtimeago

I'm not stopping dh and pil from seeing each other at all. But why do I have to attend every time?

Going forward I would like to travel to them occasionally. They can come to us any time they want. Every week if they wanted. Dh and dd can travel to them as often as they want. Again every week if he wants. But I myself don't want to be tied down to their visits. Is that UR?

OP posts:
averylongtimeago · 24/04/2023 12:47

Let's unpick this:
DH is an only child.
Pil are the only other family on both sides.
Pil are generally ok people who treat you well (if sometimes a bit overbearing).
They live 45 minutes away - so about 30/35 miles?
Pil and your DH would like to see each other (and the grandkids) regularly, you less so.

Why does everything have to be set in stone? Seeing each other every couple of weeks sounds fair to me- I saw my in-laws and my mum at least that often, and wider family regularly too. I would be very unhappy if I was restricted to a set day once a month to see my only child and grandchildren, and would have been beyond cross if DH had tried to restrict my contact with my mum (I'm an only child too).

Why not continue to see them every couple of weeks, sometimes at your house, sometimes at theirs and sometimes on a day out to the play park/zoo/shopping trip/meet for Sunday lunch.
They are not that far away, it's not like they live in Scotland and you live In Cornwall, it doesn't have to be always at one place and it doesn't always have to be both of you. I would go out with mil and the dc sometimes, DH would go on his own occasionally if I was working or busy.

I think you should be prepared to compromise here, unless there's a back story you are not sharing?

AnnPerkins · 24/04/2023 12:47

sunflowerdaisyrose · 24/04/2023 08:02

I wouldn't like anything quite so structured either way. Feels like an obligation then. We invite/get invited to our families' houses and (and vice versa) and then accept or decline depending on if we are busy.

This!

I'm allergic to any sort of regular commitment. My in-laws tried to get into a routine of visiting me and baby DS every Thursday at 1pm. It didn't happen.

Nosleepforthismum · 24/04/2023 12:45

I don’t think it needs to be as regimented as what you are proposing. The next Saturday you are due to visit just tell your DH that you had a rough night with your DC and need to just have some time to yourself at home. Tell him to pass on your apologies to his parents/text them yourself and shove him out the door with baby.

To keep them feeling included, arrange days out. Trips to the zoo/farm/swimming/playgroup/park and extend the invite to them. It’ll only be a couple of hours but on your terms and it’ll help ease that guilt when you decline the next weekend invitation. You just need to get a bit more assertive, especially with your DH.

PinkMonday · 24/04/2023 12:45

Newyearnewmeow · 24/04/2023 12:32

It’s quite obvious that he doesn’t want to visit them on his own because then he would have to make small talk for hours. He is using you!
What is it that makes you feel unable to bring it up now before he mentions it?
Could you start a conversation saying that it’s only fair that you get your alone time the same as he does when he does his hobbies so he can take baby to his parents and you can have a few free hours to do as you wish. You will of course visit too on occasion but not to a schedule.
Get it off your chest and be firm. Do not let him bully/coerce you into agreeing to his/their selfish plans.

I feel like I have challenged his behaviour quite a lot recently and by voicing my opinion I feel like I am causing trouble yet again. I know I am not causing trouble but I don't want to be negative. He doesn't have any issues with me (that he has voiced) so I don't want him to feel like I am picking on him. Until I had my daughter, he was my number 1 priority. I always put him first and thought about him. But he has always put himself first too. He is getting better because I've pointed out that x and y isn't fair. And he has changed it. He doesn't mean to be selfish. It just doesn't come naturally to think of others. So I think I will wait until he brings up going on the visit and I will nicely tell him that I don't want to go every time but for him to go on his own with dd if he wants.

I know he won't go. Which then makes me feel like I am the controlling one! But I need to look after myself too. I will go but every couple of months. And they can visit us every week if they wanted! I have no issue with seeing them in my own house.

OP posts:
Newyearnewmeow · 24/04/2023 12:32

It’s quite obvious that he doesn’t want to visit them on his own because then he would have to make small talk for hours. He is using you!
What is it that makes you feel unable to bring it up now before he mentions it?
Could you start a conversation saying that it’s only fair that you get your alone time the same as he does when he does his hobbies so he can take baby to his parents and you can have a few free hours to do as you wish. You will of course visit too on occasion but not to a schedule.
Get it off your chest and be firm. Do not let him bully/coerce you into agreeing to his/their selfish plans.

PinkMonday · 24/04/2023 12:22

LookItsMeAgain · 24/04/2023 12:15

As I keep reading your thread @PinkMonday, I get the feeling that your DH is completely enmeshed in the Fear Obligation and Guilt cycle or FOG as it is also known.

He has a Fear that all hell would break loose if he doesn't go and visit his parents on such a regular basis so he is therefore Obliged to visit them on a regular basis and then there is the Guilt that something might happen if he doesn't visit them as often as he is.

I mean what would actually happen if he didn't see them for one week? How about 2 weeks? What happens when you go on holidays?

By stretching out the time between visits, you'll also have more things to talk about because more will have happened in the intervening time.

This is interesting, I think it's exactly like this. He doesn't seem to enjoy the time with his parents (maybe he does but doesn't show it). He's a lot quieter with them.

I don't know how they would react if he wanted to delay a visit for a few weeks. I think his mum would probably guilt trip him. I try to stay out of organising things because she's quite overbearing for me. Maybe that's because I don't have any family so it's too full on for me to deal with. Years ago we thought we didn't want any kids and when my husband brought it up she cried. To be honest, I think he only changed his mind because of her. There's lots of other overbearing things but I don't want that to influence the opinions of me going over there or not.

OP posts:
uncomfortablydumb53 · 24/04/2023 12:17

@Skyla01
DH is acting like a sulky teenager
They're his parents! He must feel a duty to see them, You and DC should be his priority now so your feelings should matter to him
Funny he can still find time to do his hobbies but not time as a family.
I'm not a GM yet, but I would tell my sons to prioritise their partner and DC
I'm sorry and I hope he will compromise

Littlegoth · 24/04/2023 12:16

Definitely stay home on his travel weekends. Isn’t it the equivalent of you getting some spare hobby time to yourself?

LookItsMeAgain · 24/04/2023 12:15

As I keep reading your thread @PinkMonday, I get the feeling that your DH is completely enmeshed in the Fear Obligation and Guilt cycle or FOG as it is also known.

He has a Fear that all hell would break loose if he doesn't go and visit his parents on such a regular basis so he is therefore Obliged to visit them on a regular basis and then there is the Guilt that something might happen if he doesn't visit them as often as he is.

I mean what would actually happen if he didn't see them for one week? How about 2 weeks? What happens when you go on holidays?

By stretching out the time between visits, you'll also have more things to talk about because more will have happened in the intervening time.

billy1966 · 24/04/2023 12:15

Good for you.

My experience of my friends husbands is many are very focused on doing as little as they can get away with.

Leaving it to sisters and wives.

Several of my friends had busy years running around after children, work, and their parents, before they went to nursing homes or died.

When it came to their in laws their husbands brazenly thought they would do the same for them🙄.

They got a VERY rude awakening on that score.

My friends were having absolutely none of it, and they liked their in laws.

They had juggled alone and had absolutely no intention of going through it all again.

Men in my experience absolutely hate doing appointments etc., and will bleat on about work and being too busy.

My friends pushed back very hard and refused to engage.

Men in my long experience do not like being obliged or inconvenienced.

You are wise to be very clear.

SquishyGloopyBum · 24/04/2023 12:12

Rather than waiting for him to bring it up I think you need to take the bill by the horns and raise it now yourself.

There are lots of good points people have made.

Start booking your own time out too.

Skyla01 · 24/04/2023 12:09

@PinkMonday can you make weekend plans to get you out of this- visit friends, hair cut, new hobby etc. It's crazy to spend so much of your weekend time visiting people you don't particularly want to see so often. I definitely would not be keen on that! Make your DH go on his own if he's that bothered.

billy1966 · 24/04/2023 12:06

It's ALL about him and what suits him.

Selfish and controlling.

Send him with your child and take the break from them both.

You need to realise this is very selfish behaviour and that he doesn't care about you in these visits.

Its all about him.

Keep reminding yourself and him about his hobbies that he so happily enjoys.

Controlling men are very selfish.

Protect yourself.

He sounds the type that would make their elder care your responsibility.

He needs to see HIS parents mostly on his own.

Don't allow him to use you, because that is what he is doing.

PinkMonday · 24/04/2023 12:05

billy1966 · 24/04/2023 11:59

My apologies I missed the post where you have pulled back already over the past 4 years.

Good.

Be very firm.

He is an only child.

Too easy for you to be dragged into a caring role, especially personal care, that you may not want.

Yes I have made it clear to him that I will not be looking after his parents when the time comes so he needs to have a conversation with them about what's going to happen when they need care. I don't think he will talk to them about this and when the time comes he will 100% expect me to do it but I won't. His mum can drive but chooses not to so I am worried this will make it harder if his dad ever gets ill and can no longer ferry her around. But again, not my circus, not my monkeys.

OP posts:
PinkMonday · 24/04/2023 12:01

uncomfortablydumb53 · 24/04/2023 11:57

YANBU
Strange that he won't go on his own
Does he have a particular reason?

He says it's because he wants to spend time with me but he happily spends time by himself when he does his hobbies so I don't think it's this at all.

I believe its because he finds the visits tedious and struggles to make conversation with them. If I go then it's less pressure on him. I think he feels obligated to go rather than wanting to go. Hence he wants me to come to so it's not as boring.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 24/04/2023 11:59

My apologies I missed the post where you have pulled back already over the past 4 years.

Good.

Be very firm.

He is an only child.

Too easy for you to be dragged into a caring role, especially personal care, that you may not want.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 24/04/2023 11:57

YANBU
Strange that he won't go on his own
Does he have a particular reason?