Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how do people afford everything?

381 replies

JL642 · 23/04/2023 23:32

Just that. How does everyone afford everything?

Coffee shops etc packed here. Social media full of people doing expensive things.

DH and I ate high earners so I don’t get it.

OP posts:
HistoryFanatic · 24/04/2023 07:17

garfish · 24/04/2023 07:13

Yes of course it's a choice, that was kind of my point. Once you earn over a certain amount, things become about choice. We choose private education, holidays, food - we don't choose housing, cars, skiing beauty etc. It's not a 'sacrifice' - we just choose the things that matter to us. Of course, some people earn more than us and can choose all of it. And lots earn less, and their choices are more limited.

I was saying you can't moan about going without if you choose to spend a lot on school fees. You didn't have to. A bit like not needing a massive house or the latest car.

cushioncovers · 24/04/2023 07:15

Because most of the uk isn't as poor as the media makes out. We are actually a very wealthy country overall. There is genuine poverty and hardship that people experience through no fault of their own obviously but there are also a lot of people who mismanage their finances and create problems that with some better planning they could avoid. I say this as a single parent of 12 years on a lower income.

determinedtomakethiswork · 24/04/2023 07:14

The fact is that a lot of people waste a lot of money. Another fact is that some people brag about everything to make it look like they have more than they have.

garfish · 24/04/2023 07:13

HistoryFanatic · 24/04/2023 06:52

Most of that is a choice though including private school education.

Yes of course it's a choice, that was kind of my point. Once you earn over a certain amount, things become about choice. We choose private education, holidays, food - we don't choose housing, cars, skiing beauty etc. It's not a 'sacrifice' - we just choose the things that matter to us. Of course, some people earn more than us and can choose all of it. And lots earn less, and their choices are more limited.

airofkfoeksowlwomfo · 24/04/2023 07:11

I really don’t get these kind of posts. People’s circumstances are different. It’s not rocket science.

I’m financially comfortable at the moment because I’ve received inheritance after my losing both of my parents in very quick succession recently.

Neither of them managed to retire so whilst I do contribute towards my pension and have admittedly been able to pay off my mortgage, I’ll be damned if I’m not treating myself to coffee, salon trips and days out/holidays with my kids.

Life is too short.

Beezknees · 24/04/2023 07:10

strangerperson · 24/04/2023 06:34

I don't understand how you can earn those figures when you cannot simply work out something so simple like people having different priorities. Some people earn so low that no matter what they do, they wouldn't be able to have the things you currently have. I have a good income compared to my friends which goes towards housing and planning a future for my 3yo which may include private education in secondary school years whereas my friends can't afford any of those and live in social housing/privately rent but they have a much better social calendar to me where they go out for coffees, meals, cinemas, concerts and mini weekends away, drink alcohol out and smoke as well. I never do any of those mainly because my priorities are different to theirs but not because I'm the smarter one, it's because no matter how much they save from their coffees and concerts, they wouldn't be able to afford a deposit and pay a huge mortgage not matter how much they save and scrimp. So while they can afford the social calendar, they cannot afford to pay 3k a month for mortgage and 10k every term for their dc's private education.

This. I'm not allowed to have any more than £6k in savings or it starts getting deducted from my UC, and I could never get a mortgage on my single income of £24k. I have a housing association property anyway so I have a home for life with that. So I do spend on things like coffees out.

GnomeDePlume · 24/04/2023 07:09

Sworntofun · 24/04/2023 07:03

Some people live within this means and some don’t. The cost of living crisis is not evenly spread. I live in a naice place in northern England and also see coffee shops packed full of people but in the past 2 weeks alone one coffee shop and one very good restaurant ( always busy) have just closed. I was a bit shocked tbh as they were both v popular. So maybe my impression of their busyness was skewed. Also have a holiday let in a very touristy spot and bookings have fallen through the floor this year.

That's interesting about perception of busyness. It is possible for coffee shops & restaurants to look just as busy but suffer a significant drop in income:

Fewer drinks (normally high margin) and more tap water
More shared starters and puddings
Fewer side dishes

It can all add up

CeeJay81 · 24/04/2023 07:09

I'm a low earner but meet a friend for coffee once a week. Sometimes I have cake too. However I live in a fairly small council house, don't own a car, don't spend on beauty, cigarettes, alcohol or little else for myself. My disposable income goes on after school activities and days out in the school holidays for my kids. Last week it was the school holidays, so took my kids to the cinema and met my friend for coffee. So I afford to do stuff like that by not spending on other non essentials and budgeting.

Yousee · 24/04/2023 07:09

Our mortgage is less than half what the bank was willing to lend us. This was a deliberate choice so that when brown stuff started to fly, we would have a lovely big umbrella.
If we had gone for the biggest house we could afford, we would not now be able to afford all the things that people are apparently baffled we can still afford.

HistoryFanatic · 24/04/2023 07:09

Aren't people allowed something nice in their lives?

Sworntofun · 24/04/2023 07:03

Some people live within this means and some don’t. The cost of living crisis is not evenly spread. I live in a naice place in northern England and also see coffee shops packed full of people but in the past 2 weeks alone one coffee shop and one very good restaurant ( always busy) have just closed. I was a bit shocked tbh as they were both v popular. So maybe my impression of their busyness was skewed. Also have a holiday let in a very touristy spot and bookings have fallen through the floor this year.

thesmee · 24/04/2023 07:02

I'm the opposite. My brother and his wife are doctors. They literally earn double what we do and they bought their house for the same as us so I know they don't have a huge mortgage. They don't have children in nursery. They are always complaining how they don't have any money and don't seem to do anything very interesting! I can only assume they save thousands, because I'm pretty sure they're not paying into a private pension even (understandable as both will get NHS pensions based on their decent salaries).

MushMonster · 24/04/2023 07:01

I am very very glad that people are going out and spending their hard earned cash enjoying themselves, while investing on their lovely local retail and catering industries.
Because if we do not, then the business will close, they will stop producing revenue, their employees will go into UC or other welfare (which the tax payer pays for), we will lose the business tax (so the tax payer has to make up for it), the area will not look attractive with an empty closed spot and other business/ tourism will decline (which is tax payer's loss, yet again) and so on and on...
All to the general detriment of the tax payer. So nothing wrong at all with going out for a nice coffee.

Emigratingimmigrant · 24/04/2023 07:00

orangegato · 24/04/2023 06:49

OP I actually agree. Clothes shops coffee shops etc are more swarming than I’ve seen in my life. Can’t move in expensive shopping centres. In a quite poor area too so not sure who’s skint but it’s no one around me.

I believe there are about 750 shopping centres based on google from 2022.
67.3 mil population.
89,733 people per shopping centre.
Of course it will be busy!
You are also there🤷🏻

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 24/04/2023 06:53

We aren't high earners. I would say mid range. 60k between the both of us. We have 1 teen DD.

We have lots of pots for stuff so we have savings, Xmas, holidays, cars, which don't get touched. We have also a pot for shopping, one for DD expenditure, one for the dog 😂, one for family stuff (takeaways etc) but most importantly, we have a pot each where we have £250 per month each to spend on whatever we want. I use mine for Botox some months and buy coffee out. Or go out for a night out. But that £250 is ours and we can do with it what we want.

Can you not do similar OP?

GnomeDePlume · 24/04/2023 06:53

Everyone's situation is different.

18 months ago my household income was about £70k. We were comfortable but not flush. Then I changed job. Now our household income is more like £95k. Our household expenses haven't risen so we have spare cash to spend if we want.

Not everyone is hurt by CoL increases to the same extent. We have been hit by increases but not hurt because we have a decent pad.

Boughtitdownthemarket · 24/04/2023 06:53

We are above average earners - both of us. I spend money on my hair, clothes and always have money for a nice food shop. I also spend on our daughter's hobbies. The other side of it is that we don't go away much or eat out. We have one modest holiday a year. We very rarely go to the pub. Our social expenses are low. Our house wasn't very expensive either - about 200 thousand pounds. We do have childcare costs but usually we do OK due to low outgoings in other areas. I have friends who are completely different. One of my friends goes away several times a year, also has lots of short breaks, eats out at least once a week etc... she's just cancelled Netflix to save money! I would like a more active social life eventually but I'm giving birth soon so it will have to wait for now.

HistoryFanatic · 24/04/2023 06:52

garfish · 24/04/2023 06:32

If you're looking at high earners, it's all about priorities. We're high (but not stratospheric) earners. Money goes on savings, private school, holidays and food (at home and sometimes out). If you look at just those aspects of our lives, you would 'see' that we're well off. But we don't spend any money on house (small house, mortgage paid off), nights out, beauty treatments, coffees, skiing, nice cars (ours are oldish and cheap), gyms, expensive hobbies, because those things hold no interest for us. If you looked at just those aspects of our lives, you would assume we weren't very well off. And neither of use SM, so if you didn't know us well, you wouldn't 'see' :anything at all. I think housing is the biggest single aspect. We could have bought a big house and taken out a big mortgage, but we'd far rather have a small house and disposable income.

Most of that is a choice though including private school education.

garfish · 24/04/2023 06:52

TheaBrandt · 24/04/2023 06:42

I do t understand the poster who proudly states none of the family ever go to the hairdressers?!

Well, it is a potentially big area of spend. We do use hairdressers, but only an occasional cheap trim for me and a cheapest barber on the high street lor them. So less than 300 quid a year. Some people will spend that much every couple of months on cuts and colours. If we really wanted to save, we could do it ourselves at home, but that's a step too far for me! I don't care about fancy haircuts though.

WordtoYoMumma · 24/04/2023 06:52

We prioritise experience over stuff. We can't afford a lot of either, but as a recent example I was looking at new garden furniture - but if we buy that then we can't afford a mini break we want to do in May half term. So I will be bleaching the old white plastic chairs for another year and we will have our 2 night mini break 😊
There will come a point when I will have to give in and buy new garden furniture though!! But I reckon the crap stuff has at least another year left in it

We both work full time and both earn below the average wage, living in a London borough so times are pretty tough!

PuttingDownRoots · 24/04/2023 06:50

You only see what people spend not want they don't spend.

So we have a ski holiday each year. Carefully researched to get get a balance between good skiing, lessons and price, not a fancy catered chalet in a French/Swiss resort. Otherwise we go camping.

We sometimes have a meal out. But its a proper meal rather than a takeaway or McDonalds or a coffee... those are rare treats as we don't see them as worth the money. We take picnics on days out etc.

One DC plays Rugby. They don't charge high fees... they ask instead that parents help with fundraising and time. As a result, over 100 kids have a completely free sports programme. The club is very well regarded.

You might see us in our SUV. We need it for watersports, camping, skiing etc. Our other car is 15+yo.. it just needs to get us from.A-B.

People prioritise spending.

orangegato · 24/04/2023 06:49

OP I actually agree. Clothes shops coffee shops etc are more swarming than I’ve seen in my life. Can’t move in expensive shopping centres. In a quite poor area too so not sure who’s skint but it’s no one around me.

HistoryFanatic · 24/04/2023 06:48

Vintagecreamandcottagepie · 23/04/2023 23:39

I know what you mean.

There are still alot of people with money around. I think alot inherited wealth.

I can go for a coffee sometimes and we both work minimum wage jobs so not nessarily true. I wonder if OP can't budget properly?

Emigratingimmigrant · 24/04/2023 06:43

DH and I ate high earners so I don’t get it.

No you are not
Nice try.

These weekly "how come shops/restaurants are full" -headtilt- are getting more ridiculous than Meghan threads🙄

TheaBrandt · 24/04/2023 06:42

I do t understand the poster who proudly states none of the family ever go to the hairdressers?!