Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Diane Abbott

894 replies

Flowerly · 23/04/2023 12:02

To say that Diane Abbott is doing her best to help the Labour Party to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory?

Hideous antisemitism seemingly not gone away at all and add that to the horrendous misogyny in the Labour Party I wonder at this point why ANYONE would vote for them.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
33
AnElegantChaos · 23/04/2023 17:08

@Dorisbonson No, not everyone is racist.

MalagaNights · 23/04/2023 17:07

Jewish MNers must feel sick reading this thread.

ReUseRepeat · 23/04/2023 17:07

Her contempt for Jewish people is palpable. To bring redheads into the conversation is more offensive to Jewish people than words can say. She's got away with an awful lot and I hope the Labour Party get rid of her and the rest of the antisemitism who are lurking in the wings.

Dorisbonson · 23/04/2023 17:07

Everyone is racist. Everyone has some degree of prejudice whether it's against weight, colour, sex, class, accent or any other factor. It's impossible not to have . Hopefully though

MalagaNights · 23/04/2023 17:07

DojaPhat · 23/04/2023 16:58

However I still think she's entitled to point out that black people have been systematically oppressed in a unique way, and have no term to describe that experience.

Which is a very very clever thing if you think about it. If "everyone" can suffer racism then there's no need for specific language to describe specific forms of racism because 'it's all bad'. And given that someone like Rachel riley is jewish, she is at equal risk as someone like Alison Hammond, a Black woman, from experiencing racism. Very smart.

Jews have been oppressed in a unique way too.

Racism covers both.

If we need more specific language for the differing experiences within that, find it. But don't minimise what the Jews experience.

TheHoover · 23/04/2023 17:06

However I still think she's entitled to point out that black people have been systematically oppressed in a unique way, and have no term to describe that experience.

do you actually think she wasnt minimising?

Whataretheodds · 23/04/2023 17:05

Coffeeandbourbons · 23/04/2023 14:32

The modern day Conservative party is less racist than Labour. And less sexist. Despite intuitive assertions due to where they feature on the ‘spectrum’.

How so?

MalagaNights · 23/04/2023 17:04

I'm not sure how the comparing who has racism worse helps anyone.

There have been different experiences.

I tend to think death camps and extermination of 6 million Jews is the worst thing to happen in Europe in the past century.

That doesn't mean other groups haven't experienced racism.

LucifersLight · 23/04/2023 17:02

The red-head thing is a bit of a “red herring” here to be honest.

I know a red-head that as a child had to physically fight bullies every day at school and had verbal abuse daily too. Abuse of red-heads is rooted in racism and stems from anti-scot anti-irish anti-celt prejudice.

That said, her main point or opinion is that in reality only people with non-white skin suffer racism, which is clearly bonkers and disgraceful. To her it is all about skin-colour and nothing else comes close, therefore she herself is simply a racist.

DojaPhat · 23/04/2023 16:58

However I still think she's entitled to point out that black people have been systematically oppressed in a unique way, and have no term to describe that experience.

Which is a very very clever thing if you think about it. If "everyone" can suffer racism then there's no need for specific language to describe specific forms of racism because 'it's all bad'. And given that someone like Rachel riley is jewish, she is at equal risk as someone like Alison Hammond, a Black woman, from experiencing racism. Very smart.

onirgellep · 23/04/2023 16:57

Coffeeandbourbons · 23/04/2023 16:51

I wonder why the silly Jews didn't think of this and just take off their skull caps and blend in?? Why didn't Ann Frank just pretend she was a Christian Dutch girl?? I wonder if they didn't think of this? or if they did why it didn't work?

Here is some information about how Nazis identified which people were Jewish:

German officials identified Jews residing in Germany through the normal records created by a modern state. They used census records, tax returns, synagogue membership lists, parish records (for converted Jews), routine but mandatory police registration forms, the questioning of relatives, and from information provided by neighbors and municipal officials.

https://aboutholocaust.org/en/facts/how-did-the-germans-know-who-was-jewish

I hear what you say - the hounding of jewish people by the nazis was utterly
appalling and unforgivable

No-one would have to go to that much trouble to identify my black DC - they would just need to spot him across the road

Can you not acknowledge that this constant visibility is an aspect of anti-black racism?

SpeedSnap · 23/04/2023 16:56

MalagaNights · 23/04/2023 16:17

I feel there has been a real shift in how Jews are talked about and viewed in the past 20 years.

20/ 30 years ago there was still such a deep all encompassing collective horror of the holocaust, it was at the forefront of what everyone thought about when they thought about the Jews.

You immedaitely thought about the horror, in living memory of people in Europe being rounded up and exterminated in their millions because of hatred of their race. And the confusion we all felt of the horror that fellow 'civilsed' europeans could do this and went along with it.

Yet now we can have an MP 'mistakenly' draft a letter suggesting the Jews don't expereince racism. And people on this thread suggesting it's not as bad for Jews as black people. I cannot fathom what has happened to reach this point so quickly.

I honestly believed when younger that the collective horror at what happened to Jews meant it would never happen again and that they's always now be protected.

But when there are even still holocaust survivors living, we seem to moved on and to be minimising and forgetting, a fellow european nation tred to exterminate a race only 80 years ago.

Jews must be bewiledered and sick.

I would guess as like with the Irish as time marches on the genocide there and holocaust are remembered by fewer. Then sadly other genocides occur like Rwandan happened in the living memory or more people.

A huge amount of Christians are being slaughtered in Nigeria at present, so people are more focused on those suffering at present trying to help them.

As for slavery, I don't remember anyone post here the Irish were the first or only slaves.

Currently there are salves being bought at birth and people clapping it on from all political wings yet raging about historical slavery they can't do anything about and aren't responsible for.

Florenz · 23/04/2023 16:55

She's an idiot, not suited to being in politics in 2023, and probably not suited ever. I don't understand why Labour don't see the need to get their house in order, and never seem to see the need. Just constant conflict in public between the various factions, instead of seeing the need to present a united front in order to get elected and sort out the differences between closed doors. The left wing of Labour can achieve a lot more even with a centrist Labour PM in power than they can in opposition.

CampsieGlamper · 23/04/2023 16:53

Lampzade · 23/04/2023 13:58

Think you may need to read up on what racism entails.

Think you might want to educate yourself on what eastern Europeans have suffered particularly on the UK before Brexit. And for a long time before and sadly after.

TiredandHungry19 · 23/04/2023 16:53

There's so much whataboutery going on here. 'Diane's comments were awful but what about the Tories' what about them? This isn't about the Tories. I have always been a Labour voter, but if the modern brand is 'we're just better than the Tories' as it increasingly seems to be, then senior members of the party cannot be making comments like she did. People expect bad behaviour and attitudes of the Tories. They expect more/better from Labour. You can want Diane and other racists out of the Labour party without it making you a Tory.

Hbh17 · 23/04/2023 16:53

The anti-Semitism is hateful and should - rightly - damage Labour's chances of winning. They may have made some improvements, but they are not there yet.

Coffeeandbourbons · 23/04/2023 16:53

Of course there are physical characteristics associated with being Jewish, but many Jews do not appear physically ‘Jewish’ for example Rachel Riley.

Alexandra2001 · 23/04/2023 16:52

onirgellep · 23/04/2023 16:45

DA was physically unwell when she made that mistake - she explained at the time that she was struggling with poorly controlled DM

Quite possibly it would have been a good time to retire

Long wondered whether DA is unwell, even when she isn't saying something stupid/wrong, she seems to lack any sort of coherence, after all, she is almost 70, could easily have some sort of degenerative illness.

But MN bullies will pile in regardless.

Coffeeandbourbons · 23/04/2023 16:51

I wonder why the silly Jews didn't think of this and just take off their skull caps and blend in?? Why didn't Ann Frank just pretend she was a Christian Dutch girl?? I wonder if they didn't think of this? or if they did why it didn't work?

Here is some information about how Nazis identified which people were Jewish:

German officials identified Jews residing in Germany through the normal records created by a modern state. They used census records, tax returns, synagogue membership lists, parish records (for converted Jews), routine but mandatory police registration forms, the questioning of relatives, and from information provided by neighbors and municipal officials.

https://aboutholocaust.org/en/facts/how-did-the-germans-know-who-was-jewish

How did the Germans know who was Jewish? :: About Holocaust

German officials identified Jews residing in Germany through the normal records created by a modern state.

https://aboutholocaust.org/en/facts/how-did-the-germans-know-who-was-jewish

AdamRyan · 23/04/2023 16:50

I think there's a difference between a comedian making a joke you may find offensive and a sitting MP dismissing racism.
She absolutely was not dismissing racism.
She was saying that the prejudice certain classes of white people face is not the same as the systematic oppression black people face.

She was very stupid to lump jewish people in with white people.

However I still think she's entitled to point out that black people have been systematically oppressed in a unique way, and have no term to describe that experience.

Alexandra2001 · 23/04/2023 16:49

Florenz · 23/04/2023 16:44

Labour come across as a lot more deeply racist than the Tories do. There's a deep vein of anti-semitism that runs right through Labour. They need to cut it right out, scorched earth policy, not just get rid of the most prominent examples.

I honestly don't think the racism in the Tories runs as deeply. If you can advance the interests of the Tory party, you're in, it doesn't matter what race, gender or sexual orientation you are.

Really? in two words... Boris Johnson.

Then there is the total failure to have an inquiry into Islamophobia, promised when 5 Tory leadership challengers ALL promised to hold one but never did.

Of the 66 minority ethnic Members, 41 (62%) are Labour and 23 are Conservatives (35%)
There are two Liberal Democrat MPs from a minority ethnic background. More than half (37) of the 66 minority ethnic MPs are women, the majority in the Labour party

So Labour are deeply engrained racists but have almost double the number of ethnic members.... right!

MalagaNights · 23/04/2023 16:47

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 23/04/2023 16:30

These are my thoughts. I think Diane was ridiculous to even mention red hair to the persecution of Jews, Irish and travellers though.

What absolutely ignorant, blinding stupid, dangerous idiocy these posts are.

I wonder why the silly Jews didn't think of this and just take off their skull caps and blend in?? Why didn't Ann Frank just pretend she was a Christian Dutch girl?? I wonder if they didn't think of this? or if they did why it didn't work?

I wonder how secular Jewish Italians who went into hiding were still found, caught and sent to extremination camps?

If you want to be 'prejudiced' against a group you work out to identify them and if you want to exterminate them you make sure they can't hide.

I am gobsmacked at how far we've come in forgetting this and so quickly.

The Jews are a race. They have been targeted for centuries, wherever they are people know who they are.

I'm sickened by Diane Abbot and by people on this thread.

This type of ignorant racism on MN would not be tolerated against any other group.

SpeedSnap · 23/04/2023 16:46

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/04/2023 15:51

I'd have thought it fairly obvious that she either doesn't care about the experiences of other races, that she lacks the intellect to find out, or that she just plain resents someone suggesting that black people aren't the only ones to suffer - and possibly all three

I think it's more complex than that. Diane Abbott is far from stupid. But she (along with Corbyn and all that Momentum lot) have spent decades living in an intellectual bubble which fixates on hierarchies of injustice and in whose ideology Jewishness is bound up with a hatred of Israel and a perception that Jews are complicit in the "western imperialism" which they rail against the whole time, purely because of Israel.

There is very much a view in these circles that some sorts of racism are more acceptable than others and Jews are often treated by these people as being in a class of their own because they are so obsessed with the Israel/Palestine situation and Jews are (wrongly) positioned as complicit in this. David Baddiel has talked a lot about the way British Jews are often required to state their position on Israel when talking to people on the left as if they required to "cleanse" themselves of any alliance with or support for Israel in order to be classed as an oppressed group of people.

Its childish and a triumph of ideology over common sense, but I don't think its explicit, intentional antisemitism (not that this excuses it), its unconscious antisemitism founded out of an obsession with "the west" (meaning, largely, the US, the UK and Israel) as the font of all world evil.

Why are left British people so obsessed with Palistine in particular? Not that there is anything wrong with helping people suffering high inflation abroad.

You would think their family, ward, constituency, country and content would be a higher priority.

onirgellep · 23/04/2023 16:45

Wiccan · 23/04/2023 16:38

I'll never forget the fuck up she did with the estimated cost for police recruits I don't know how she survived that one .

"Err £300,000 no no umm £500 and something err 70 quid . Eleventy six "?!

DA was physically unwell when she made that mistake - she explained at the time that she was struggling with poorly controlled DM

Quite possibly it would have been a good time to retire

EllaDisenchanted · 23/04/2023 16:44

@Abhannmor I'm not sure what your point is? are you continuing to insinuate that the outrage against Diane Abbott's comments/removal of the whip is due to a mysterious zionist lobby? Why is anything to do with zionism/pro-palestinian being brought in to a discussion about Diane Abbott minimising racism against Jews (and Irish and Traveller people)?

You've ignored my point that we do experience violence and hate on a level that goes far beyond prejudice, and Diane's comments complete dismiss our lived experience of anti-semitism.