Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Diane Abbott

894 replies

Flowerly · 23/04/2023 12:02

To say that Diane Abbott is doing her best to help the Labour Party to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory?

Hideous antisemitism seemingly not gone away at all and add that to the horrendous misogyny in the Labour Party I wonder at this point why ANYONE would vote for them.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
33
AnElegantChaos · 23/04/2023 19:08

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/04/2023 18:33

@SpeedSnap

Why are left British people so obsessed with Palistine in particular? Not that there is anything wrong with helping people suffering high inflation abroad

I think some of it is to do with this loathing of the US and other "western imperialists" and the perspective on the left that anyone who is an enemy of America must be a friend (see also Russia). Because of the situation in the occupied territories and because Israel has to a large extent been supported financially and militarily by the US (for understandable reasons), people on the hard left see it as a "puppet state" of the US. I'm far from endorsing this point of view btw but I've heard people make these types of arguments.

But I think there's also a large helping of good old-fashioned anti-Semitism among sections of the left and I don't really know where that comes from, honestly. At the height of the Corbyn ascendancy there was a lot of very unsavoury stuff going on in Labour which was blatantly anti-Semitic and which Corbyn tacitly tolerated.

I was coming around to the idea of voting Labour again before this Abbott thing kicked off but it suggests there still a lot of this around.

I think some of it is to do with this loathing of the US and other "western imperialists" and the perspective on the left that anyone who is an enemy of America must be a friend (see also Russia).

Bingo. This is the ideology Diane Abbot blindly adheres to. Will never forget the way she refused to give actual Syrian victims of Assad a voice during a StWC panel discussion.....on Syria.

AdamRyan · 23/04/2023 19:02

TheHoover · 23/04/2023 18:32

@AdamRyan no, not what she said but her underlying meaning. which was minimising. What made her put pen to paper in the first place.

I see. So now its not what people say but the agenda other people think they have that's the problem.

I read the article she was replying to and could see her issue with it. It was minimising racism, particularly racism against black people.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/apr/15/racism-in-britain-is-not-a-black-and-white-issue-it-is-far-more-complicated

Because the corollary of one third of ethnic minority people reporting that they have experienced racist assault is that two thirds of ethnic minority people have not.
But the Evidence for Equality National Survey report complicates some of the underlying assumptions that many ostensibly progressive people espouse on racial inequality in Britain. One is a narrow idea of what constitutes racism.Anyone who is white is privileged, we are told, and racism only affects people of colour. The problem with this view is that there are certain minorities who are seen as white and yet experience prejudice. In fact, the two groups most likely to say they have experienced racist abuse, according to the survey, are Gypsy, Traveller and Roma communities and Jewish people. [actually incorrect as the graph shows "other black" as second highest behind travellers]
But the problem with this point of view is that the report has already been used to advance the claim that Britain is still plagued by racism – and the very same people who make this claim also emphasise only one kind of racial inequality, one that puts black and Asian people at the very bottom of society, and “white” people at the top.

I think we are in a bad state when a black woman can't write a response to an article like this without a public roasting

Racism in Britain is not a black and white issue. It’s far more complicated | Tomiwa Owolade

A report on ethnic inequality reveals that that Irish, Jewish and Traveller people are among the most abused

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/apr/15/racism-in-britain-is-not-a-black-and-white-issue-it-is-far-more-complicated

EsmaCannonball · 23/04/2023 18:59

Diane Abbott is suffering from that modern social-media induced affliction of seeing everything through the prism of the USA and thinking if something didn't happen in the USA then it didn't happen at all. It's depressing enough seeing this level of self-absorbed ignorance in the over-amplified voices of young American Twitter activists but to see it spread into actual UK politicians just shows how many of them are losing the plot. You'd think the last couple of elections would have taught Labour that they are not standing for office in Portland or Seattle but in Oldham and Doncaster. The country has gone to shit under the Tories, the SNP are fucked; this is not the time for Labour to be making a cheap play for a constituency it doesn't even have.

Maireas · 23/04/2023 18:56

The antisemitism on here is shocking. Minimising their experiences, and centuries of persecution. Just dreadful.

SpeedSnap · 23/04/2023 18:54

I married a man who had Jewish ancestry and carry a Jewish name as a result. I have never experienced anything regarding the name though some of it was removed a few generations ago. I find the history intriguing as my children have that ancestry.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 23/04/2023 18:52

@MagicClawHasNoChildren Thank you for 'seeing' our experiences

AdamRyan · 23/04/2023 18:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 23/04/2023 18:50

SnickersWasAHorse · 23/04/2023 18:45

I don’t deny that at all, and being Jewish is a race as well as a faith, but what I’m saying is that I’m only a few generations removed and no one, including myself would see me as Jewish. However a black or Asian person will be seen as black or Asian in the street.

That's your experience though. DH (and many others) is seen as Jewish and cannot hide it in the street and has been victim of racism, that's why DA's comments were ignorant and ill informed

DojaPhat · 23/04/2023 18:50

@Flowerly I can see how you arrived at the conclusion that I meant none of this is her doing by my comment which said she should have never bothered responding i.e. to write her letter in response to that article, thereby paving the way for her own downfall. Fabulous comprehension, second to none.

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/04/2023 18:49

@malapast

There undoubtedly have been numerous atrocities committed against Palestinians by Jewish terrorists and by the Jewish state. I have no particular skin in the game for the Jewish state. This particular iteration is loathsome.

But Palestinians are not routinely considered to be suspect by the hard left because of the behaviour of extremists among them. Whereas many Jews have the experience of being made to feel by people on the left that they have to "pick a side" (ie, denounce the state of Israel) or be considered complicit. As if English Jews have any responsibility for the behaviour of the state of Israel. It's a very strange phenomenon that the left singles out Jews for this.

Tracker1234 · 23/04/2023 18:48

I have always suspected she has some sort of early onset dementia or perhaps something else. She speaks very strangely and I don’t understand why she still wants to be in post with all her various gaffes. Nothing to do with her colour, it’s her ability to undertake effectively a Shadow Minster role up until recently whilst not being able to stop what comes out of her mouth.

After her comments I think she should be removed.

MagicClawHasNoChildren · 23/04/2023 18:47

These threads invariably become a shitshow of antisemitism and antisemitic apologetics. I don't know how Jewish people in the UK cope with the casual dismissal of their very real experiences. I know quite a few left wing people who would be horrified at the idea that they're racist but who are also happy to say that they think that Jewish people need to stop banging on about the Holocaust, for example, or that Jewish people control various prestigious industries. They also invariably want Jewish people to justify the actions of Israel, regardless of their nationality or political affiliation.

David Baddiel has it exactly right. Jewish people are 'too white-passing' to experience racism, and yet too other not to be targeted with some frankly bizarre presumptions and prejudices. They can never win.

SpeedSnap · 23/04/2023 18:46

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/04/2023 18:33

@SpeedSnap

Why are left British people so obsessed with Palistine in particular? Not that there is anything wrong with helping people suffering high inflation abroad

I think some of it is to do with this loathing of the US and other "western imperialists" and the perspective on the left that anyone who is an enemy of America must be a friend (see also Russia). Because of the situation in the occupied territories and because Israel has to a large extent been supported financially and militarily by the US (for understandable reasons), people on the hard left see it as a "puppet state" of the US. I'm far from endorsing this point of view btw but I've heard people make these types of arguments.

But I think there's also a large helping of good old-fashioned anti-Semitism among sections of the left and I don't really know where that comes from, honestly. At the height of the Corbyn ascendancy there was a lot of very unsavoury stuff going on in Labour which was blatantly anti-Semitic and which Corbyn tacitly tolerated.

I was coming around to the idea of voting Labour again before this Abbott thing kicked off but it suggests there still a lot of this around.

This makes no sense. Not you, their logic. The USA supported the Irish as did Corbyn.

Flowerly · 23/04/2023 18:45

DojaPhat · 23/04/2023 18:37

@AdamRyan She really should have never bothered even responding at all to that article. The author of the article has set his sights on the lucrative business of poc contrarianism, he was managing just fine dancing on that slippery pole. Diane need not have risen to it and now in doing so laid the groundwork for her own downfall and for various degenerates to come out of the woodwork specifically because they've been salivating for a day like this.

So none of this horror show is of her doing then? Well...it's a view.

OP posts:
SnickersWasAHorse · 23/04/2023 18:45

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 23/04/2023 18:36

@SnickersWasAHorse My DH looks Jewish and has been subjected to multiple racist attacks on the street (he does not wear a yamulke or tzitzit). I don't look Jewish, but have received anti-Semitic abuse when leaving synagogue or the community centre, you can be Jewish and experience both racial and religious prejudice in the UK.

I don’t deny that at all, and being Jewish is a race as well as a faith, but what I’m saying is that I’m only a few generations removed and no one, including myself would see me as Jewish. However a black or Asian person will be seen as black or Asian in the street.

malapast · 23/04/2023 18:43

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/04/2023 18:33

@SpeedSnap

Why are left British people so obsessed with Palistine in particular? Not that there is anything wrong with helping people suffering high inflation abroad

I think some of it is to do with this loathing of the US and other "western imperialists" and the perspective on the left that anyone who is an enemy of America must be a friend (see also Russia). Because of the situation in the occupied territories and because Israel has to a large extent been supported financially and militarily by the US (for understandable reasons), people on the hard left see it as a "puppet state" of the US. I'm far from endorsing this point of view btw but I've heard people make these types of arguments.

But I think there's also a large helping of good old-fashioned anti-Semitism among sections of the left and I don't really know where that comes from, honestly. At the height of the Corbyn ascendancy there was a lot of very unsavoury stuff going on in Labour which was blatantly anti-Semitic and which Corbyn tacitly tolerated.

I was coming around to the idea of voting Labour again before this Abbott thing kicked off but it suggests there still a lot of this around.

Some of it might have been the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians by Jewish terrorist groups post-war of Arabs that had lived in peace for centuries in their lands. The massacre of Deir Yassin in 1947 where 107 Arabs were ruthlessly murdered to create terror and accelerate the dispersal. Irgun one of the groups that committed that atrocity had within in its ranks Menahem Begin who was to go on to be Israel's 6th PM. It was equal to any of the crimes that Russia is committing in Ukraine but never gets a mention and it was Europeans who killed Europeans Jews lest we forget. But Palestinians don't count. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deir_Yassin_massacre

Deir Yassin massacre - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deir_Yassin_massacre

DojaPhat · 23/04/2023 18:37

@AdamRyan She really should have never bothered even responding at all to that article. The author of the article has set his sights on the lucrative business of poc contrarianism, he was managing just fine dancing on that slippery pole. Diane need not have risen to it and now in doing so laid the groundwork for her own downfall and for various degenerates to come out of the woodwork specifically because they've been salivating for a day like this.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 23/04/2023 18:36

@SnickersWasAHorse My DH looks Jewish and has been subjected to multiple racist attacks on the street (he does not wear a yamulke or tzitzit). I don't look Jewish, but have received anti-Semitic abuse when leaving synagogue or the community centre, you can be Jewish and experience both racial and religious prejudice in the UK.

malapast · 23/04/2023 18:33

notanotheroneagain · 23/04/2023 18:04

Yes, she is.

I forgot that part. Don't know how she is seen as 'anti-semitic' at the same time.

I think the main thing is that 'racist' seems rightly, the worst thing to be. So some may feel prejudices against themselves are not taken as seriously. Hence the defence. I think everyone would agree that racism/homophobia/anti semitism/ colourism (including hair colourism)/misogyny etc. are all bad.

But I think we have to also recognise how some forms of bigotry change and affect someone's life at a deeper level than others.

Will your son just be stopped and searched on the street?
Arrested and tackled by police,(sometimes killed) even when they did nothing wrong?
Police not bother with deep investigation when something happens to you?
Will someone not call you for an interview because of who they think you are based on your name on the CV, or what you look like during the interview or your picture?

Apologises to the posters who took offence about my description of a black person, basically. But I was agreeing with most of what poc are saying on this thread.

Jews can be anti-Semitic - Norman Finkelstein comes to mind. Though he would deny it of course. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norman_Finkelstein

Norman Finkelstein - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norman_Finkelstein

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/04/2023 18:33

@SpeedSnap

Why are left British people so obsessed with Palistine in particular? Not that there is anything wrong with helping people suffering high inflation abroad

I think some of it is to do with this loathing of the US and other "western imperialists" and the perspective on the left that anyone who is an enemy of America must be a friend (see also Russia). Because of the situation in the occupied territories and because Israel has to a large extent been supported financially and militarily by the US (for understandable reasons), people on the hard left see it as a "puppet state" of the US. I'm far from endorsing this point of view btw but I've heard people make these types of arguments.

But I think there's also a large helping of good old-fashioned anti-Semitism among sections of the left and I don't really know where that comes from, honestly. At the height of the Corbyn ascendancy there was a lot of very unsavoury stuff going on in Labour which was blatantly anti-Semitic and which Corbyn tacitly tolerated.

I was coming around to the idea of voting Labour again before this Abbott thing kicked off but it suggests there still a lot of this around.

AndTheSurveySays · 23/04/2023 18:32

Will your son just be stopped and searched on the street?
Arrested and tackled by police,(sometimes killed) even when they did nothing wrong?
Police not bother with deep investigation when something happens to you?
Will someone not call you for an interview because of who they think you are based on your name on the CV, or what you look like during the interview or your picture?

These are all things that happen regularly Gypsy and Travellers. You can add that G and T have had their entire way of life criminalised and at constant risk of imprisonment, fines and having their homes taken from them.

TheHoover · 23/04/2023 18:32

@AdamRyan no, not what she said but her underlying meaning. which was minimising. What made her put pen to paper in the first place.

MegaManic · 23/04/2023 18:31

phoenixrosehere · 23/04/2023 12:29

I was expecting much worse from the way OP made it out to be. I also don’t think the Sky link using the word “whip” is appropriate either.

WTF does this mean - why is using the word whip inappropriate when they are explaining the whip has been withdrawn - what word would you like them to use?