Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’ve turned my emergency alert off because I’m such a rebel!

514 replies

StupidFaces · 23/04/2023 09:47

Urgh

Facebook … numerous posts over the last days consisting of:

“EMERGENCY ALERT SWITCHED OFF!!”

“Leaving my emergency alert on so I can reply and tell them to go and fuck themselves!”

“Remember everyone, emergency alerts can and should be switched off by tomorrow!”

“That’s my emergency alert turned off lol”

Why??? What’s so big and clever about turning the alert off? Don’t people realise that most countries have had this for years? Turning it off doesn’t make you Billy Big Bollocks and boasting about it just makes you look stupid!

YABU - I’ve turned mine off and I’m proud of it! Down with the establishment!

YANBU - people are ridiculous

OP posts:
Okunevo · 23/04/2023 12:17

ShowUs · 23/04/2023 12:04

The ridiculing of autistic people and those with mental illnesses on these threads is appalling.

How loud do you think it’s going to be?

The amount of parents who would rather their child be put in harms way rather than deal with a potential, unlikely meltdown is very concerning.

I assume these autistic children never watch TV or play computer games with the sound on, have smoke alarms in their homes, play with other children who tend to scream and shout, go to the cinema or play sports, don’t go to school with other SEND kids or have school bells, never goes in a car incase of someone beeping and don’t leave their homes incase there is a loud noise.

I am autistic, my child is autistic and I work with autistic children.

No one I know will be turning off the alarm because they care about their kid’s safety and it is better that they hear the sound in a non-emergency in the safety of their own homes, than in an emergency when it is much more difficult to cope with a meltdown.

If you have an autistic child you will also have ear defenders which they can wear.

I meant autistic adults and adults with mental illness. It's not just this thread, it's others. People seem to understand when it's a child.

We are all different, if it went off in public I would find that easier, I expect unexpected things to happen when I am out, I accept I can't control everything. My home is my safe space, I don't want it in my home.

Iwantmyoldnameback · 23/04/2023 12:17

SpeedSnap · 23/04/2023 12:08

The IRA sent coded warnings ahead of attacks back in the day.

I remember being turned away from a small bomb by the police.

They did, where I worked was evacuated and the alarm was different to the normal fire sound. This meant the assembly point was further from the building than usual. It was actually a false alarm to occupy the police while they left the area after shooting a well known personality.

WhatTheHeckyPeck · 23/04/2023 12:16

Leftbutcameback · 23/04/2023 11:42

Flood warnings are provided on a property basis to people who live in flood risk areas, but not everyone. If there was a severe flood warning it wouldn’t reach tourists or commuters / those travelling. This could be useful in those circumstances.

But if the emergency alert is area specific then surely those outside of those areas at the time it is issued (tourists and commuters to use your examples), wouldn't get it anyway would they?

SpeedSnap · 23/04/2023 12:14

KvotheTheBloodless · 23/04/2023 12:12

But how on Earth is you having yours off making any kind if difference?! Are you religious, and believe Sunday is a day of rest? I am Catholic and think Sundays should be a day of rest where possible for Christians (I understand not all jobs/lifestyles allow this though), but I doubt even the Pope would have an issue with a test on a Sunday.

As for 'climate lockdowns' - how does a phone alert remotely link in to that? Do you not understand how the technology works?

I am laughing at the thought of the Pope shrugging at a trial emergency alert and giving people a side eye for not wanting their day of rest being interrupted.

ShimmeringShirts · 23/04/2023 12:14

And I say that as someone with ASD and two children with ASD and ADHD.

ShimmeringShirts · 23/04/2023 12:13

@ShowUs its as ridiculous as saying you’d rather not give your child their immunisations in case it “turns them” autistic. The amount of people that would rather dead children than autistic children (or would rather autistic children are put in harms way rather than have them deal with an alarm sound for a second) is ridiculous. Idiocy like that should not be allowed to reproduce.

lidolemon · 23/04/2023 12:13

I have turned mine off. I haven't announced it on FB, or actually discussed it much past my family. I'd prefer to have a system, where you could choose to get a text but not a noise, as well as both, or none.

I fully accept the consequences of that decision.

KvotheTheBloodless · 23/04/2023 12:12

LlynTegid · 23/04/2023 10:10

Mine is off because I object to it being on a Sunday afternoon. I value Sundays being different from the rest of the week and want some of the few differences to remain.

I think it is an attempt by this government to distract you from their failings by timing it just before local elections.

But how on Earth is you having yours off making any kind if difference?! Are you religious, and believe Sunday is a day of rest? I am Catholic and think Sundays should be a day of rest where possible for Christians (I understand not all jobs/lifestyles allow this though), but I doubt even the Pope would have an issue with a test on a Sunday.

As for 'climate lockdowns' - how does a phone alert remotely link in to that? Do you not understand how the technology works?

Parker231 · 23/04/2023 12:11

afterdropshock · 23/04/2023 12:07

I try not to have my phone on me all the time, turn off mobile data and location. So I would likely be at home in the event of my phone going off. I turned it off in protest as I never opted in to this or gave my number willingly. I can understand people sharing how to turn off alerts to share info, or to be an anti establishment voice. Not showing off.

You don’t opt in or give your number. It will have been one of the regular updates on your phone which you consent to by updating your phone.

Jenasaurus · 23/04/2023 12:11

Leftbutcameback · 23/04/2023 12:05

For those who are interested to know what the noise sounds like here it is (from a previous test)

Thanks for sharing this, I found myself watching it a few times! I was weirdly transfixed by the sound. Why do they all go off at different times, is it due to the phones settings?

Needmorelego · 23/04/2023 12:11

@Mueslikid a factory fire could be a danger to life though.
I don't know the stats but I believe more people have died of cancer etc from the dust from the World Trade Center collapse on 9/11 than actually died in the buildings.
If a local factory is on fire it could be blowing out all kinds of chemicals in the air.

BurscoughBooths · 23/04/2023 12:11

oOiluvfriendsOo · 23/04/2023 11:50

What about the missing or abducted children that are found through these alerts in countries that currently use it.
Mass hysteria over something that could prove very useful.
Keep it on, turn it off, no need to tell the world......

The government have NOT said it will be used for missing children.

Gov website says:

Reasons you might get an alertYou may get alerts about:

  • severe flooding
  • fires
  • extreme weather
ShowUs · 23/04/2023 12:10

DiscoDragon · 23/04/2023 12:00

How rude! I live in a small village on Dartmoor where most of these fantasy scenarios of impending doom are highly unlikely to ever happen, and even if they do it would be all over social media and the news anyway. If I somehow still manage to miss out on the alert that terrorists have decided to attack our small farming community I'm 100% certain that my family/friends/neighbours would let us know!

This is what I don’t understand though.

You are ok with getting the information from the news or social media but not a text on your phone?

The news and social media are always behind because it takes time for someone to report on it and get to the area etc.

Social media is faster than the news but you need to be on it at the right time to know anything.

I live in a tiny village in Cornwall and doubt anything will happen here but I still go shopping and leave my village sometimes.

I never thought I could get shot dead whilst in Plymouth.

GroovyGangConscript · 23/04/2023 12:10

I'm quite looking forward to it going off.

#Not much happening in my life at the moment

DiscoDragon · 23/04/2023 12:10

ShowUs · 23/04/2023 12:04

The ridiculing of autistic people and those with mental illnesses on these threads is appalling.

How loud do you think it’s going to be?

The amount of parents who would rather their child be put in harms way rather than deal with a potential, unlikely meltdown is very concerning.

I assume these autistic children never watch TV or play computer games with the sound on, have smoke alarms in their homes, play with other children who tend to scream and shout, go to the cinema or play sports, don’t go to school with other SEND kids or have school bells, never goes in a car incase of someone beeping and don’t leave their homes incase there is a loud noise.

I am autistic, my child is autistic and I work with autistic children.

No one I know will be turning off the alarm because they care about their kid’s safety and it is better that they hear the sound in a non-emergency in the safety of their own homes, than in an emergency when it is much more difficult to cope with a meltdown.

If you have an autistic child you will also have ear defenders which they can wear.

I have no idea how loud it's going to be and that's the problem! My son doesn't get distressed by all loud noises but he gets very panicked when there are siren/alarm type noises like our smoke alarm. I just don't see the need to willingly subject him (or myself) to that for no good reason. There is no threat to my childs safety, it's only a stupid test today!

SpeedSnap · 23/04/2023 12:08

SirTarquin · 23/04/2023 12:04

Seems a load of fuss about nothing really.

Biggest use of emergency alerts is extreme weather which we don't really have here in the sense of tornados or tsunamis appearing out of nowhere. Most extreme weather here is pre-warned via forecast several days in advance.

Terrorist attack news (in terms of avoid the area after the event) spreads quickly on main news and social media.

Pre-terrorist attack unexpected event (eg. Manchester arena) there is no chance to warn because that is precisely how it occurred- under the radar.

So - unless the government are going to abuse it with daft alerts about a burst watermain in the local high street - you are looking at an microscopic amount of situations where an emergency warning is going to be warranted or likely.

The IRA sent coded warnings ahead of attacks back in the day.

I remember being turned away from a small bomb by the police.

afterdropshock · 23/04/2023 12:07

I try not to have my phone on me all the time, turn off mobile data and location. So I would likely be at home in the event of my phone going off. I turned it off in protest as I never opted in to this or gave my number willingly. I can understand people sharing how to turn off alerts to share info, or to be an anti establishment voice. Not showing off.

Mueslikid · 23/04/2023 12:07

I feel I only want an actual sirening alert if my life is in imminent danger, and I need to take immediate action.

Not that there’s a factory on fire down the road and I should maybe close the windows, or that certain roads are closed Confused.

I’m not convinced about the terrorist scenario. Perhaps I’ve seen too many crime dramas where someone is hiding from a gunman, and then their phone rings and gives their hiding place away.

Extreme weather/meteors/wildfires/floods etc, there is going to be a bit of warning. I’d expect to see that sort of thing on the news (as I do currently). So I don’t feel I need an audible alert. I’d be happy with a silent text.

If it’s a warning of nuclear attack, well, there’s absolutely nothing I could do, it’s far too late by that point. So I’d rather have 4 minutes of ignorance.

Trinity65 · 23/04/2023 12:06

GoodChat · 23/04/2023 11:18

This is exactly why I've left it on. I want to know what it sounds like and how it works.

Same here

Okunevo · 23/04/2023 12:06

Parker231 · 23/04/2023 12:01

Mn is not the real world where I don’t know anyone who is considering blocking the alert. It’s a test - a non event . Some Mn users seems to have a huge amount of paranoia.

We are here in the 'real world', people who feel the need to turn off the alert just may have reduced face to face interactions because of the same disabilities or mental health issues that mean they have turned off the alarm.

Readinstead · 23/04/2023 12:06

My dsis wants to turn hers off but won't because "if you don't respond " they" will cut off your phone and it won't work anymore". She didn't tell me this, but told our dm who is in her 80's and not at all tech minded - dm told her that she was being ridiculous.
We are at a child's softplay birthday party today at 3.00pm so that should be fun when all the phones go off just as they are calling the dc for x's party to go to the room for food!

ShowUs · 23/04/2023 12:04

The ridiculing of autistic people and those with mental illnesses on these threads is appalling.

How loud do you think it’s going to be?

The amount of parents who would rather their child be put in harms way rather than deal with a potential, unlikely meltdown is very concerning.

I assume these autistic children never watch TV or play computer games with the sound on, have smoke alarms in their homes, play with other children who tend to scream and shout, go to the cinema or play sports, don’t go to school with other SEND kids or have school bells, never goes in a car incase of someone beeping and don’t leave their homes incase there is a loud noise.

I am autistic, my child is autistic and I work with autistic children.

No one I know will be turning off the alarm because they care about their kid’s safety and it is better that they hear the sound in a non-emergency in the safety of their own homes, than in an emergency when it is much more difficult to cope with a meltdown.

If you have an autistic child you will also have ear defenders which they can wear.

SirTarquin · 23/04/2023 12:04

Seems a load of fuss about nothing really.

Biggest use of emergency alerts is extreme weather which we don't really have here in the sense of tornados or tsunamis appearing out of nowhere. Most extreme weather here is pre-warned via forecast several days in advance.

Terrorist attack news (in terms of avoid the area after the event) spreads quickly on main news and social media.

Pre-terrorist attack unexpected event (eg. Manchester arena) there is no chance to warn because that is precisely how it occurred- under the radar.

So - unless the government are going to abuse it with daft alerts about a burst watermain in the local high street - you are looking at an microscopic amount of situations where an emergency warning is going to be warranted or likely.

Hellybelly84 · 23/04/2023 12:03

I was just having this conversation with DH today. Its just trying to be awkward (unless reasons such as domestic violence/hidden phone etc).

They will be the first ones complaining when there’s something like a flood and they dont get the alert to get out quick. Its a teeny tiny chance it will ever be used but i’d rather have it than not.