Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU in thinking no point in being mortgage free

214 replies

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 07:39

My husband and I want to be mortgage free and could pay it off when we are in our 50s and 60s respectively. However, I don’t see the point. All it means is that we will have less disposable income now but no better off when we retire. The only way it makes sense is to downsize when the mortgage is paid and use the equity to afford holidays, etc but why not enjoy the holidays now rather than when we are older? If we stayed in the property we are working hard to pay off the mortgage for, all that will happen when we died is the government will take a huge chunk of the equity in inheritance tax.

Am I being unreasonable to think there is no point in paying off your mortgage early if it means you’ll be in your late 50s or over?

OP posts:
Catspyjamas17 · 23/04/2023 10:12

Unless you are both planning to die at once I wouldn't worry about IHT in the short term. Plenty of time to give money to your kids when they are grown ups to minimise it.

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 10:12

Catspyjamas17 · 23/04/2023 10:09

Unless a property tax is brought in you don't get taxed on equity in your main home!

What do you mean? Inheritance tax is applied to the decease’s estate, which include all properties main home or not.

OP posts:
CallintheClownies · 23/04/2023 10:11

Catspyjamas17 · 23/04/2023 10:09

Unless a property tax is brought in you don't get taxed on equity in your main home!

You get taxed via inheritance tax when the house is classed as part of your estate, although £1M is outside IH at the moment if it's left to the children.

Bear in mind all of this may change especially if Labour are in government.

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 10:10

CallintheClownies · 23/04/2023 10:07

Overpaying seems to be creating huge equity that will be eaten up in taxes if we do not live long enough or are not for enough to enjoy it

Your mortgage will still need to paid off at some point or your children will inherit a debt surely?

If you pay it off, your pensions will still be taxed. If you spend willy-nilly that won't be taxed.

What if one of you dies young? And the mortgage is not paid? Can one of you still pay the mortgage?

The property would pay off the mortgage and still leave a lot for our child to inherit.

OP posts:
Catspyjamas17 · 23/04/2023 10:09

Unless a property tax is brought in you don't get taxed on equity in your main home!

CallintheClownies · 23/04/2023 10:09

LeFeu · 23/04/2023 10:06

Our mortgage term has me paying it off at 50, so we’re hoping to overpay to bring that down into my 40’s. Means we can both be part time whilst still young, have time earning without that big expense before retirement, save masses of interest. My DH’s parents are only paying theirs off now in their 60s and they are knackered and done, I don’t want to be in that situation.

That only applies if you never intend to move.

We moved in our early 40s to a larger house and doubled our mortgage. Our income increased so it wasn't a burden. we did avoid moving again as we didn't want to be saddled with an even bigger mortgage in our 50s or 60s.

DaphneduM · 23/04/2023 10:08

For us, it was a huge benefit to be mortgage free from our 40's - when I met my husband we had roughly equal amounts of savings/capital and were able to buy our first home together mortgage free. We had lovely holidays with our young daughter, I had a year out after my parents died - I was emotionally exhausted from caring for them. As our daughter grew we were able to help her with rental on her flat, then later on paid for a lovely wedding and gave them a substantial deposit on their first house.

But the most important thing is it gives you choices. We hit a huge problem when my husband was in his mid 50's with a very stressful front line job compounded by workplace bullying. It was literally killing him - so he was able to retire at 57 and his workplace pension was just about enough to live on due to being mortgage free. Likewise I retired not long after, again having workplace pensions. I'm so happy that we've had about ten years retirement together already, especially so as we didn't meet until we were middle aged.

Never under-estimate the power of being mortgage free. As others have said, there are various things a good IFA can suggest regarding mitigating inheritance tax. Mortgage free gives you choices, freedom and personal autonomy.

Catspyjamas17 · 23/04/2023 10:08

We will have paid our mortgage off by early/mid 50s but not by missing out on holidays and nice things while we were younger. So in my 50s I'll be able to scale back work/go PT again until I retire- or carry on but put more money into pension for a good retirement- you never know what will happen health-wise so it's good to have options.

It has to be a balance for me though, I agree. Some close family members only made it to their 30s and 40s and you only live once. I know people who chose to flog their guts out making massive amounts of money in banking etc in their 20s and "retired" in the early 30s, very well off. But they never saw the light of day in their 20s. To me, you never get your 20s back.

CallintheClownies · 23/04/2023 10:07

Overpaying seems to be creating huge equity that will be eaten up in taxes if we do not live long enough or are not for enough to enjoy it

Your mortgage will still need to paid off at some point or your children will inherit a debt surely?

If you pay it off, your pensions will still be taxed. If you spend willy-nilly that won't be taxed.

What if one of you dies young? And the mortgage is not paid? Can one of you still pay the mortgage?

LeFeu · 23/04/2023 10:06

Our mortgage term has me paying it off at 50, so we’re hoping to overpay to bring that down into my 40’s. Means we can both be part time whilst still young, have time earning without that big expense before retirement, save masses of interest. My DH’s parents are only paying theirs off now in their 60s and they are knackered and done, I don’t want to be in that situation.

CallintheClownies · 23/04/2023 10:04

You need to think long term and also consider the possible worst case scenarios- ill health, death, etc.

If for example, you pay £2K a month in a mortgage now and pay it off early by overpaying, where does that leave you?

Would that £2K go on holidays or into a nest egg for old age?

You've not mentioned your pensions. Poverty in old age is not fun!

We paid off our mortgage in our mid-50s by overpaying. We then saved some of the amount and are now lucky in old age to have a very large savings pot and a pension that is in the higher tax bracket, excluding the state pension.

You may live for 30 years after you retire and you don't want to be scrimping.

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 10:04

CallintheClownies · 23/04/2023 09:54

Kindly, you need to take advice from an FA @Tunaormayo74

You need to think about what you can invest now in maybe a private pension and how that would grow, compared to what you are going to end up paying in mortage + interest, over the coming years.

How old are you both? What is your pension going to be if you are going to still pay a mortgage from it in your 60s? Presumably you have occupational pensions and not just the state pension?

You also need to gen up on inheritance tax. The remaining spouse will inherit the other's allowance. If you have children, you can pass on £500K tax free to them. Your own allowance is £325K and this doubles when one spouse dies.
At current levels, you'd pay IH of 40% on your estate, minus the house, if that's left to children.

The house is worth well over the inheritance tax threshold even if our child benefits from the allowance attached to both of us.

Pension very good for me. Okayish for DH but we are not extravagant.

Overpaying seems to be creating huge equity that will be eaten up in taxes if we do not live long enough or are not for enough to enjoy it.

Sorry for being so sour and depressing with my outlook.

OP posts:
marmaladeone · 23/04/2023 10:03

I'm mortgage free but have no income so nothing is perfect

MiniCooperLover · 23/04/2023 10:00

We are 50 and late 40s and paid ours off this year. I thought my DH would be less stressed now but he still worries about the gas bill, has asked me to stick to a budget when looking for summer holidays (which is fine but not necessary as we are both in good paying jobs) and I thought it would make him happier. I think it'll just take a little while for him to relax into it 🤷‍♀️

CallintheClownies · 23/04/2023 10:00

@Dinofantastic You can only avoid IH on property/ estate (depending on its value) if the house is in your children's names when you are still alive and don't die within 7 years or it is seen as avoiding tax. Otherwise it's as @UggyPow says.

I'm interested in your pensions. How can you fund a (large?) mortgage out of a pension and what is your pension?

I'm assuming you are in your 40s now if you are asking about paying off your mortgage later in life.

Don't assume the state pension will provide as there are predictions the age may rise to 70.

What if one of you dies early? How much would you have to live on?

If you pay off the mortgage earlier, then that money which is now an 'excess' should ideally be invested in a pension that you can take tax free. Currently the government gives 20% uplift (tax relief) on a private pension if you are building one.

updin · 23/04/2023 10:00

We are not prioritising our mortgage until the kids are grown. We could over pay now and be mortgage free earlier, but to what end? So we have more money to go on holiday in our 50s? We need money for our family now, we had kids young (so will actually have a lot of our 40s to over pay anyway) and I don't want to make sacrifices now in their childhoods so we have more money in middle age, that just doesn't make sense.

missmollygreen · 23/04/2023 10:00

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 09:05

I’m I out of touch in terms of what age is now feasible to pay mortgage off early? With house prices as they are and people having to either upgrade or move to bigger properties for much needed space, don’t many people pay off their mortgages in their 40s even after moving from their starter home and with no inheritance to help them pay off the mortgage?

Lol no, no they dont.
Most people will have been renting, then managed to scrape together the minimum deposit they needed on the biggest mortgage they could afford.
This was done when rates were silly low and to keep monthly payment low most people took a mortgage term of 30 years.
Most people will not be paying their mortgage off in their 40's, especially now with interest rates rising.

My mortgage was originally set to run until im 70 years old, there is no way im letting that happen

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 09:59

ShagratandGorbag4ever · 23/04/2023 09:57

Don't underestimate the joy of being mortgage free. I've had lots of lovely holidays, but I don't think about them every day. Remembering that the roof over my head is paid for is a daily source of quiet satisfaction.

I get that psychological safety and no doubt it the value attached to it is incredibly high. In terms of the quantifiable monetised aspect, is it worth it?

OP posts:
Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 09:57

lionsleepstonight · 23/04/2023 09:39

OP you seem to be steadfastly ignoring or misunderstanding the benefits of paying off your mortgage early.

I always have over paid but only to the point it didn't hamper my day to day spends, so holidays etc still happened.

We've enjoyed those things and will repay a 25 year mortgage in 16 years. We'll save thousands in interest (have you worked your potential savings out?) We're 50 and 54.

We'll use that mortgage money now for investments for retirement and even more holidays.

I’m not ignorant of the benefits of repaying early otherwise why would I have started on that journey. I’m questioning whether it is really worth it when (1) you might not be in a position to really enjoy that financial freedom for long when you retire and (2) it will only benefit the tax man. Overpaying now involves opportunity costs no matter how much of a stretch it may or may not be.

In other words, when you weigh up the costs and benefits, is it really a benefit?

OP posts:
ShagratandGorbag4ever · 23/04/2023 09:57

Don't underestimate the joy of being mortgage free. I've had lots of lovely holidays, but I don't think about them every day. Remembering that the roof over my head is paid for is a daily source of quiet satisfaction.

CallintheClownies · 23/04/2023 09:54

Kindly, you need to take advice from an FA @Tunaormayo74

You need to think about what you can invest now in maybe a private pension and how that would grow, compared to what you are going to end up paying in mortage + interest, over the coming years.

How old are you both? What is your pension going to be if you are going to still pay a mortgage from it in your 60s? Presumably you have occupational pensions and not just the state pension?

You also need to gen up on inheritance tax. The remaining spouse will inherit the other's allowance. If you have children, you can pass on £500K tax free to them. Your own allowance is £325K and this doubles when one spouse dies.
At current levels, you'd pay IH of 40% on your estate, minus the house, if that's left to children.

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 09:53

Dinofantastic · 23/04/2023 09:10

See an IFA to sort out Inheritance tax now. If you put a plan in place then that should offset the amount due when you've died, and your child won't have a huge liability. I know A LOT of people who do this. It's very common.

Thanks. We’re planning on doing that. I’m it’s part of my worry. It’s making all this effort only to see it taken away in some inheritance tax or other stealth tax.

OP posts:
UggyPow · 23/04/2023 09:52

OP I think you really need to look into IHT Estate planning.
Some advice here is incorrect, as a couple your estate can be £1mill (£325k plus the uplift of £175k) depending on the value of the property.
Money in pensions can be IHT free.
Care fees only come into play for the 2nd partner as if the first needs care it is still the others home.
When my husband died in his 40's I chose to not pay off the mortgage due to low interest rates & became a landlord as I needed monthly income for my children - now I am working hard to pay it off due to rising interest rates.
I will be mortgage free by around 50

Badbudgeter · 23/04/2023 09:50

Not the same thing but I have a car loan I put spare money into. It’s a whopping 10.1% interest as it was a bit of an emergency purchase.

It’s quite nice as every time you make an additional payment it tells you how much you’ve saved in interest (about a 1/3 of the payment currently) and if you’ve knocked a month or two off the loan.

Im sure there are calculators that’d do the same for your mortgage. That said life is a balance and I’m not going to live on beans on toast/ cancel kids activities/ miss out on social stuff just to hammer down the debt. There has to be a happy medium where you allow yourself some treats, a holiday every other year for example, whilst still being relatively frugal and oaying it off a bit faster.

LittleMiceSing · 23/04/2023 09:49

I think Op is doing that thing of ignoring the benefits as it's unlikely they will be able to pay off early.
Similar to the " why buy when you can rent"threads from people who can't afford to buy.😬

Op you are forgetting that between 50s- 60s and death there is hopefully plenty of life left to live.
We paid ours off at 44, just whacked it for a few years and it was so, so worth it.
Such peace of mind.
We have now inherited and as we don't need to money, it's going to skip a generation and get our DC on the property ladder.

Swipe left for the next trending thread