Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU in thinking no point in being mortgage free

214 replies

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 07:39

My husband and I want to be mortgage free and could pay it off when we are in our 50s and 60s respectively. However, I don’t see the point. All it means is that we will have less disposable income now but no better off when we retire. The only way it makes sense is to downsize when the mortgage is paid and use the equity to afford holidays, etc but why not enjoy the holidays now rather than when we are older? If we stayed in the property we are working hard to pay off the mortgage for, all that will happen when we died is the government will take a huge chunk of the equity in inheritance tax.

Am I being unreasonable to think there is no point in paying off your mortgage early if it means you’ll be in your late 50s or over?

OP posts:
Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 11:12

On reflection, I think what is really bothering me is that we will likely have a rather large estate when we die. With only one child and given inheritance rules, a lot of that hard work building up that estate would have been for what?

I get the social responsibility and that it will be used for those less fortunate but working so hard now to build up net equity only for it to be taxed away.

I get that I’m being unreasonable but there is something about working hard (even if striking a good balance) to build up assets that one never really get to use or enjoy.

OP posts:
LittleMiceSing · 23/04/2023 11:05

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 11:04

Debt is not taxed but equity is. Inheritance tax is on the net value of the estate.

So you have zero savings?

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 11:04

LittleMiceSing · 23/04/2023 10:25

But IHT will still apply whether the property is paid off or not.
All that will happen is some of the cash estate will go towards paying the remaining mortgage off then your property is worth well over the IHT threshold anyway.
Your logic is baffling tbh.
You are not thinking about the life in between retiring and dying and how you will fund that.

Debt is not taxed but equity is. Inheritance tax is on the net value of the estate.

OP posts:
LittleMiceSing · 23/04/2023 11:01

LittleMiceSing · 23/04/2023 10:59

It will when you have them at Uni.
My DD student loan didn't even cover her rent and bills.
Being MF meant it was such a struggle.

Wasn't!

forgotmyusername1 · 23/04/2023 11:01

It is all about balance.

Don't stick every penny into the mortgage at the expense of life or pensions.

Maximise any employer pension contributions first
Stick some money to the side for fun money/ holiday money
Overpay the mortgage.

We have overpaid the mortgage and looking to be done in 4 years when hubby turns 50 and I am 44. We started at 260k in 2014 so will have paid it off in 13 years all being well. We do though also have holidays and days out with the kids - we do though prioritise experiences rather than expensive clothes and beauty treatments.

Once the mortgage is done then we will redirect the overpayment so additional savings for a year or so (currently pay 1500 a month mortgage) and then may drop my hours at work a bit.

burnoutbabe · 23/04/2023 11:00

Isn't it really 2 different discussions

First is saving versus spending now. Yes some people do drop dead on retirement day. But even if I did, I'd have spent the previous years happy I would have a nice retirement with income to spend. That's worth alot.

Then it's -I shall save money - do I use that to over pay mortgage or invest (I did second when my mortgage was base rate +0.15%) or push it into pension due to tax breaks and employers matching (if they do)

But the second discussion can only happen if you are happy to sacrifice now for future options)

(Other things that help -no kids and also only buying one place and not keep trading up/extending mortgage-easier to do without kids of course)

caringcarer · 23/04/2023 10:59

If you pay it off quicker you pay less interest. I've overpaid for almost 9 years now and I've taken over 6 years off my mortgage end date. I've only overpaid what I can comfortably afford without leaving me short for general living and holidays. In my view the quicker it's repaid DH and I will be over a thousand pounds off per month. We can do other stuff with that money.

LittleMiceSing · 23/04/2023 10:59

Heatherbell1978 · 23/04/2023 10:30

It's a good point OP. DH and I are trying to work out if we can afford to send kids to private school atm (they're 6 and 8) and eldest would potentially start in 2.5 years. This would mean us not overpaying our mortgage which would mean it's paid off when I'm 64 rather than 55. But at the age of 55 we can't retire anyway so although it would be nice to not have that additional monthly cost, it doesn't feel like a huge deal to have it paid off earlier.

It will when you have them at Uni.
My DD student loan didn't even cover her rent and bills.
Being MF meant it was such a struggle.

CallintheClownies · 23/04/2023 10:56

Seriously @Tunaormayo74 you should see an independent financial advisor. A good one (like ours) will explore your hopes and dreams for the future and how to spend and invest both short and long term.

You are talking as if you have to choose between some kind of hedonistic lifestyle now and paying (over paying) a mortgage.

Can't you do both?

At it's max when we were paying ours, it was around £800 a month. On a joint 6-figure income, we managed to overpay it and also have holidays (not really expensive ones - as that's not our thing) and pay for 2 kids at uni for 7 years.

We paid it off when we were mid-late 50s. We could have moved upmarket further but a) didn't see anything we liked and b) didn't want another huge mortgage. When we inherited from one side of the family, we passed most of it to the DCs towards buying houses.

TBH it didn't change our lifestyle at all. We saved most of it.

You should also factor in any likely inheritances you may get, if your parents are alive and own property.

As someone else said, you are missing out the part of your life between retiring and dying - and provision for it.

You need to look very carefully at your pension and how they will be valued in 25 years and if they are index linked.

You also might want to look at private medical cover which for me is worth more than a holiday and which we've had for decades both through work and now in retirement.

AnneElliott · 23/04/2023 10:37

I think there's such a great relief once the mortgage has been paid off. It means if the worst happens you still have your home.

We over pay (and still have holidays) and it should be paid off before I'm 50. It will mean we can help DS and maybe go part time. I wouldn't want a mortgage in my 60s. I think that would feel risky although accept that people don't often have a choice.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 23/04/2023 10:36

loislovesstewie · 23/04/2023 08:37

For me it was just the fact that the house couldn't be repossessed if either of us fell ill, could no longer work etc. We didn't have to worry about where we would live in the event that a tragedy happened. But I used to be a homeless officer and, for me, having a roof over my head was the be all and end all. I've seen too much misery caused by losing a home.

Yes, it depends how important the above is to you. Everyone is different. I agree with @loislovesstewie .

I would rather forgo holidays and have them later as I don't think holidays are important. If you do, then don't pay off your mortgage.

Mildmanneredmum · 23/04/2023 10:36

Catspyjamas17 - Bodenesque says she lost her death in service benefit as well. So no lump sum payment for her. They're usually linked to being in the pension scheme.

Heatherbell1978 · 23/04/2023 10:30

It's a good point OP. DH and I are trying to work out if we can afford to send kids to private school atm (they're 6 and 8) and eldest would potentially start in 2.5 years. This would mean us not overpaying our mortgage which would mean it's paid off when I'm 64 rather than 55. But at the age of 55 we can't retire anyway so although it would be nice to not have that additional monthly cost, it doesn't feel like a huge deal to have it paid off earlier.

Catspyjamas17 · 23/04/2023 10:27

Bodenesque · 23/04/2023 10:18

A work friend worked so hard to pay of the mortgage on his home and a holiday rental apartment. He died in his mid 50's and it was only then his wife realized that he had opted out of his work pension which had been sitting at 35 yrs contributions. He had done this to pay the mortgages which would have been paid on his death anyway and his widow list his death in service payment. Check your finances carefully before making any decisions.

But then his widow got 4 x salary as a lump sum and didn't need to use it to pay off the mortgage. Surely not that bad.

LittleMiceSing · 23/04/2023 10:25

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 10:04

The house is worth well over the inheritance tax threshold even if our child benefits from the allowance attached to both of us.

Pension very good for me. Okayish for DH but we are not extravagant.

Overpaying seems to be creating huge equity that will be eaten up in taxes if we do not live long enough or are not for enough to enjoy it.

Sorry for being so sour and depressing with my outlook.

But IHT will still apply whether the property is paid off or not.
All that will happen is some of the cash estate will go towards paying the remaining mortgage off then your property is worth well over the IHT threshold anyway.
Your logic is baffling tbh.
You are not thinking about the life in between retiring and dying and how you will fund that.

Hopedun · 23/04/2023 10:24

We don't actually have a choice. We have 7 years til our life insurance expires. H has CKD which means no one would insure him again. So we overpay the mortgage so in the event of his untimely death, me and the kids will be fine.

We still have a very good quality of life by not buying a house which is more expensive than we can easily afford.

That can happen to anyone so I'd rather have the security of a home which is ours not the bank's.

Catspyjamas17 · 23/04/2023 10:24

I don't understand where you are coming from @Tunaormayo74. There is of course a balance between standard of living now and making overpayments so the mortgage term will be shorter. But I don't see how IHT is a consideration. It's not a tax you will ever have to pay on your own property, and one you have plenty of time to minimise for your kids.

Dinofantastic · 23/04/2023 10:24

@CallintheClownies sorry - I meant that IHT planning can be done now, depending on the potential size of the estate etc etc. I don't mean you can avoid paying it. Sorry if I wasn't clear.

Ponoka7 · 23/04/2023 10:20

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 10:12

What do you mean? Inheritance tax is applied to the decease’s estate, which include all properties main home or not.

Gift what you can before it's looking like you will need care within seven years. Either way they'll still get something.

WCRoulade · 23/04/2023 10:19

Your plan doesn't sound terrible but it is about what you're comfortable with. I agree you need to have a balance and live life now especially as none of us know how long we've got and if we will even make it to retirement

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 10:18

I’m 46.

@Catspyjamas17 so basically, the gains I get in reducing the interest I would have paid is taken by the 40% of the excess.

OP posts:
Bodenesque · 23/04/2023 10:18

A work friend worked so hard to pay of the mortgage on his home and a holiday rental apartment. He died in his mid 50's and it was only then his wife realized that he had opted out of his work pension which had been sitting at 35 yrs contributions. He had done this to pay the mortgages which would have been paid on his death anyway and his widow list his death in service payment. Check your finances carefully before making any decisions.

Ponoka7 · 23/04/2023 10:18

You've got to plan according to your individual circumstances. I was lucky to be mortgage free thanks to inheritance. In your 40's, while in good health, you've got to start thinking about how your 60+ years will look, allowing for poor health and no one wanting to employ a 60+ year old. If you will need major repairs doing to the house, or you'll need/want equity release. If your partner dies, how will that make a difference. We've had nice lower cost apartments built for the over 55s, a lot of 65+ year olds are opting to sell up and buy one. So think about were you live and figure in the possibility of not driving, because of medical issues.

Catspyjamas17 · 23/04/2023 10:14

And even then it's only 40% over the threshold, not 40% of everything. And the threshold will have gone up. And even if they do pay IHT they would be bloody well off on the rest.

CallintheClownies · 23/04/2023 10:14

@Tunaormayo74 You need to pan for your retirement. If that means spending now and not paying off your mortgage, do that. Also you can't predict house prices. There may be a crash- who knows? You may both lose your jobs. Or retire early with ill health. You have to think about worst case scenarios.

How old are you now?