Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU in thinking no point in being mortgage free

214 replies

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 07:39

My husband and I want to be mortgage free and could pay it off when we are in our 50s and 60s respectively. However, I don’t see the point. All it means is that we will have less disposable income now but no better off when we retire. The only way it makes sense is to downsize when the mortgage is paid and use the equity to afford holidays, etc but why not enjoy the holidays now rather than when we are older? If we stayed in the property we are working hard to pay off the mortgage for, all that will happen when we died is the government will take a huge chunk of the equity in inheritance tax.

Am I being unreasonable to think there is no point in paying off your mortgage early if it means you’ll be in your late 50s or over?

OP posts:
BloomstoShrooms · 23/04/2023 13:51

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 11:12

On reflection, I think what is really bothering me is that we will likely have a rather large estate when we die. With only one child and given inheritance rules, a lot of that hard work building up that estate would have been for what?

I get the social responsibility and that it will be used for those less fortunate but working so hard now to build up net equity only for it to be taxed away.

I get that I’m being unreasonable but there is something about working hard (even if striking a good balance) to build up assets that one never really get to use or enjoy.

'Building up the estate'? Presumably you're enjoying your larger house? If asset building was your primary concern you should've stuck the money into investments. Especially as you have only one child.

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 13:38

prh47bridge · 23/04/2023 13:28

So your house is worth over £1M?

Let's do some sums. Let us imagine that your estate, including the house, is worth £1.4M and you have a £500k mortgage. If you die, the mortgage will have to be paid but there will be no inheritance tax, so your child will inherit £900k. If you pay off the mortgage, there will be no mortgage to pay but your estate will be over the IHT threshold by £400k, giving IHT of £160k. Your child will inherit £1.24M.

I could put in other figures, but the result will always be the same. Your child will inherit more if you pay off the mortgage. Keeping the mortgage to avoid IHT is not a good idea.

Does one child really need this whilst we could enjoy some of it by not paying down all the mortgage?

It would seem that paying off a mortgage is partly storing up money for others to enjoy, including the taxman.

Just to be clear, I appreciate the peace of mind argument for paying the it early and less the interest paid.

@CallintheClownies that’s probably the crux of it. Accepting that we will be taxed heavily in death.

OP posts:
prh47bridge · 23/04/2023 13:28

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 10:04

The house is worth well over the inheritance tax threshold even if our child benefits from the allowance attached to both of us.

Pension very good for me. Okayish for DH but we are not extravagant.

Overpaying seems to be creating huge equity that will be eaten up in taxes if we do not live long enough or are not for enough to enjoy it.

Sorry for being so sour and depressing with my outlook.

So your house is worth over £1M?

Let's do some sums. Let us imagine that your estate, including the house, is worth £1.4M and you have a £500k mortgage. If you die, the mortgage will have to be paid but there will be no inheritance tax, so your child will inherit £900k. If you pay off the mortgage, there will be no mortgage to pay but your estate will be over the IHT threshold by £400k, giving IHT of £160k. Your child will inherit £1.24M.

I could put in other figures, but the result will always be the same. Your child will inherit more if you pay off the mortgage. Keeping the mortgage to avoid IHT is not a good idea.

3dogsandarabbit · 23/04/2023 13:23

Tunaormayo74 - We didn't have critical illness cover at the time. When we took out our mortgage in our late 20s we had life insurance but there was a big difference in the monthly payments if critical illness cover was included. At the time we were young and when you're young you never think you're going to get seriously ill when you're older. There isn't much help financially if you have a mortgage and are unable to work. We only had £12,000 left to pay so decided that we would just pay that off.

CallintheClownies · 23/04/2023 12:09

You must have heard the famous quote by Franklin that there are two things you can't avoid in life- death and taxes.

If you accumulate a lot then some will be taxed. You need to get your head around it and do some inheritance planning but not on mumsnet!

How old is your child? Have you factored in university costs at all? We were paying more than our mortgage at one point when both were at uni- their accommodation costs.

I disagree with your point of downsizing but it does depend on the house you have. We have a pretty normal 4-bed house but as it's SE it's worth quite a bit. I'd not want anything smaller because we will the space easily when family stay over.

ThinWomansBrain · 23/04/2023 12:08

I had an interest only mortgage, paid it off in my 50s - I didn't have to forgo stuff to do that, but although I still have a hefty service charge, it's a relief not to have to pay rent or mortgage if I want to take a break from working.

SweetSakura · 23/04/2023 12:06

*wouldn't fritter, that should say!

SweetSakura · 23/04/2023 12:06

Thatsridiculous · 23/04/2023 11:50

I certainly wouldn’t overpay if it meant cutting back on things we enjoy.
But it’s sensible to overpay if it’s affordable. Which for us, it is.

Life is for living now.
But I also don’t want to be a poor pensioner.

I agree. It's all about striking a balance.

I wouldn't live miserably now for a future that isn't guaranteed (and I am shocked by those who do)

But equally I would fritter my money on pointless stuff and status symbols at the expense of a comfortable older age.

So - we do spend plenty on holidays and activities. But we prioritise overpaying the mortgage over "stuff" (we both drive very modest cars given our salaries; I buy clothes and books 2nd hand).

MegaManic · 23/04/2023 11:59

I would think the interest saving on a large mortgage would be worth it even accounting for inheritance tax but as many people have pointed out there are other factors to consider (peace of mind, security in your retirement etc)
If you want to avoid inheritance tax then you can give cash to your child (or whoever you want) well before you die or downsize the house and give them the cash.
If you are passing on your property it will have to be worth over £1m before you child pays tax (assuming you whole estate is less than £2m).

NewNovember · 23/04/2023 11:59

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 09:02

No guarantee we will have more disposable income when DH retires as he will be near that age. Also how long will we be in health to enjoy and what will happen to all the equity gained from paying less interest? Inheritance tax? Payment for care?

That's even more worrying then. How are you going to pay for the morgage and upkeep?

Phoebo · 23/04/2023 11:52

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 11:12

On reflection, I think what is really bothering me is that we will likely have a rather large estate when we die. With only one child and given inheritance rules, a lot of that hard work building up that estate would have been for what?

I get the social responsibility and that it will be used for those less fortunate but working so hard now to build up net equity only for it to be taxed away.

I get that I’m being unreasonable but there is something about working hard (even if striking a good balance) to build up assets that one never really get to use or enjoy.

How old is your DC? Why don't you downsize, then put any extra cash away to help them also buy a house? Fair enough if you don't want it all going to tax, but the alternative if you purposely don't want to pay it off quickly means it's going to a bank instead, which seems much more depressing!

Thatsridiculous · 23/04/2023 11:50

I certainly wouldn’t overpay if it meant cutting back on things we enjoy.
But it’s sensible to overpay if it’s affordable. Which for us, it is.

Life is for living now.
But I also don’t want to be a poor pensioner.

tsheet · 23/04/2023 11:48

I would love to be mortgage free, instead without any inheritance we'll be paying a mortgage well into our 60s. In many ways we don't have the freedom and security some on this thread have and it comes with stress. However it's a choice. We live in a 5 bed house in the south east with small kids and it's expensive here. We could move away from the south east and be mortgage free because we have enough equity to buy outright elsewhere in the UK. We can downsize in the future and be mortgage free if we want. So we have choices. We'd be looking at being mortgage free in the next 3-5 years if we'd stayed in our tiny starter home but I didn't want to stay there and prefer where we live now for the time of our lives we are at.
I'm sure mortgages to 70 will be the norm soon unless the market changes.

LittleMiceSing · 23/04/2023 11:47

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 11:36

I’m don’t understand your point about me having no savings. Did I ever say that or even hinted at that?

You said the equity in the property would end up paying the mortgage off?
Presumably this means there will be no cash in the estate?

If there is cash then when finalising outstanding debts it would be used first rather than the property being sold.
Funeral costs, outstanding debts etc are paid out of the estate with cash being used first.

Oopsididitagaintomorrow · 23/04/2023 11:42

What made a big difference in our finances was DD starting full time school and not having to pay so much childcare x

Oopsididitagaintomorrow · 23/04/2023 11:41

Myself and DH are in our very early 50's and mortgage will be finished by the time we are 55 (not the same as paying early I know).
What it will do when we are mortgage free is give us an extra £450pm which will make a huge difference and allow us to do a lot more x

FilthyforFirth · 23/04/2023 11:39

A bit irrelevant to the thread but lots and lots saying they overpay on the mortgage, when did you start doing that? I am 38 with a quite hefty mortgage (4 bed detached south east) but my youngest is 2 and doesnt get free hours until Jan '24.

I always feel so behind reading these threads, and would love to overpay but literally cannot afford it at the moment. Just wondering if most start once the kids are a bit older?

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 11:36

LittleMiceSing · 23/04/2023 11:19

Ok I'm assuming you will have property plus £ in your estate when you die.
If the property has mortgage debt still outstanding then presumably the £ from your estate will pay of the outstanding debt.
You are still left with a property over the IHT threshold.
If however you have zero savings AND anticipate not paying the mortgage off before your death, well that's a different matter.
Tbh I would feel very anxious about this moving into my lateryears and consider downsizing as it seems your mortgage isn't affordable if you have no savings .

I’m don’t understand your point about me having no savings. Did I ever say that or even hinted at that?

OP posts:
Badbudgeter · 23/04/2023 11:21

I do wonder if this is more pressing if people have large mortgages that take up a bigger proportion of income. The monthly cost of my car is about the same as my mortgage. £700 a month give or take. Combo of car loan, tax, insurance and £400 of petrol. Food and bills cost more these days but used to be about the same. The depressing trinity of living costs. Whilst it’d be lovely not to have to pay the mortgage it’s not a life changing amount of money.

LittleMiceSing · 23/04/2023 11:19

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 11:13

I’m not sure I understand your train of thought in relation to the point I’m making.

Ok I'm assuming you will have property plus £ in your estate when you die.
If the property has mortgage debt still outstanding then presumably the £ from your estate will pay of the outstanding debt.
You are still left with a property over the IHT threshold.
If however you have zero savings AND anticipate not paying the mortgage off before your death, well that's a different matter.
Tbh I would feel very anxious about this moving into my lateryears and consider downsizing as it seems your mortgage isn't affordable if you have no savings .

Ariela · 23/04/2023 11:19

I would reduce future outgoings by insulation, solar + batteries etc. first. Then pay off the mortgage.

OK you'll have a large estate - but you can downsize, gift to child on the assumption you'll last 7 years+/spend on holidays etc to lower the tax burden on child and give you £££ to enjoy in retirement (Top tip : don't buy a property abroad, you've the potential of leaving inheritance hell for your child)

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 11:16

3dogsandarabbit · 23/04/2023 11:12

We paid off our mortgage about 6 years ago. We are both late 50s. It was the best thing we did. I was diagnosed at the time with a life threatening illness and was unable to work and I only work part time now. I wouldn't want to be paying a mortgage after retirement age especially if you haven't got a good private pension.

Could you not have downsized, paid off the mortgage and still have some money left from the equity built up?

Other than paying off mortgage early, downsizing can allow you to pay off and deal with financial issues. That of course won’t work for all but it is an option vs overpaying. So paying a mortgage post retirement is not necessarily a must.

OP posts:
midgemadgemodge · 23/04/2023 11:16

Could you afford to go part time when it's paid off giving you more time for yourself before you retire ?

Tunaormayo74 · 23/04/2023 11:13

LittleMiceSing · 23/04/2023 11:05

So you have zero savings?

I’m not sure I understand your train of thought in relation to the point I’m making.

OP posts:
3dogsandarabbit · 23/04/2023 11:12

We paid off our mortgage about 6 years ago. We are both late 50s. It was the best thing we did. I was diagnosed at the time with a life threatening illness and was unable to work and I only work part time now. I wouldn't want to be paying a mortgage after retirement age especially if you haven't got a good private pension.