Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is It Time To End It?

36 replies

LotionsAndPotions995 · 22/04/2023 22:07

Hey,

Not really sure what I want from this thread or if it's in the right place. But overall just a rant as I feel like I'm going crazy.

I have been with DP for a year, I've known him for 10 years but we only made things official at the beginning of last year. In general things are good but there has been huge issues with the emotional compatibility side of things. He really won't communicate with me and when he does it's always picking at my faults, or me being to blame for something.

He also doesn't seem to pick up on general social queues and goes off on me if I'm having an off day because I haven't specifically told him whats wrong and what he must to do comfort me or make things better. His usual response is "well I'll just leave then" and I get a barrage of blame because he's not a mind reader, so thats my fault somehow.

I know mumsnet is very for the "they are not mind readers" argument but personally I feel like your partner should know the difference in you to notice something is wrong and offer some form of comfort, such as a cuddle, without needing it spelt out in black and white what, why and when. Its draining and if I'm honest the off days are just general or because the lack of emotional connection in the relationship sucks and bores the living daylights out of me.

The AIBU is...

IABU- he's not a mind reader and he is intact right that it's not something that can be fixed/comforted without black and white detailed explanation

IANBU- it's normal to be able to offer some form of support/comfort and notice cues if someone your supposed to care about and love is down.

OP posts:
LotionsAndPotions995 · 23/04/2023 00:19

@xyxygy I'm sorry but that is completely untrue. I never once said in the past year I hadn't met his needs/wants by being explicit about my feelings, etc when I'm having an off day. I've done that countless times. But it does get tedious after a year of repeating and nothing improving. I have done my part so from experience can he not learn and also find ways to improve to meet my needs and wants?

What your saying is a complete 1 way street and calling me out for something that isn't true. I've tried to play my part for a whole year... should it only be me that does that for the rest of the relationship?

And to clarify, he does not have any medical problems that would make him like this.

OP posts:
xyxygy · 23/04/2023 00:12

LotionsAndPotions995 · 23/04/2023 00:06

@xyxygy I have told him explicitly what i want, need and how I feel. It constantly falls on deaf ears. So why should i drain myself further by constantly having to describe how I'm feeling, why and what has made me feel like that. Then specifically say word for word what I want/need him to do to comfort, reassure or support me.... wouldn't that be forced and not mean anything at all.

Could you imagine a man parenting a child who couldn't pick up on social cues or changes to know instinctively what to do or how to comfort said child? How am I as a human (yes an adult) any different? Why do I need to spell it out in black and white? What if I was a mute or so distraught in a situation that I couldn't actually speak? Do I deserve to not be comforted deeply and off a gut reaction regardless of wanting, needing or even being able to voice why?

Yes, I can imagine that perfectly. I'm autistic. I've made the exact same request of my DP - "Please tell me what's wrong, because I won't be able to just see it" - and, thankfully, they did exactly that and our life is immeasurably better for it because we can both help each other when something's wrong instead of butting heads at the worst of times.

Yes, you've told him what you want, but you're entirely unwilling to do the same for him. You're tanking your relationship for the sake of an idea because you're unwilling to budge an inch; that's cool, and entirely your prerogative and choice, but at least go into it with the awareness of who has the agency here.

LotionsAndPotions995 · 23/04/2023 00:06

@xyxygy I have told him explicitly what i want, need and how I feel. It constantly falls on deaf ears. So why should i drain myself further by constantly having to describe how I'm feeling, why and what has made me feel like that. Then specifically say word for word what I want/need him to do to comfort, reassure or support me.... wouldn't that be forced and not mean anything at all.

Could you imagine a man parenting a child who couldn't pick up on social cues or changes to know instinctively what to do or how to comfort said child? How am I as a human (yes an adult) any different? Why do I need to spell it out in black and white? What if I was a mute or so distraught in a situation that I couldn't actually speak? Do I deserve to not be comforted deeply and off a gut reaction regardless of wanting, needing or even being able to voice why?

OP posts:
xyxygy · 22/04/2023 23:44

LotionsAndPotions995 · 22/04/2023 22:17

Oh believe me @Nickersnackersnockers I have had the conversation in full detail about what I want, need and what is lacking several times in the past year to the point I'm actually sick of repeating it. I've wrote it in letters and texts aswell so it couldn't be a case of you've never told me, you weren't clear, etc.

How did you manage to last so long with the incompatibility?

Hold on...you're telling him what you want and need and expecting him to give it to you, but when he tells you what he needs - ie for you to be more explicit about your emotional state - he's being unreasonable and should just divine it?

What's so wrong with him asking you to use your words instead?

Youdoyoubabe · 22/04/2023 23:03

Just came on to check this wasn't a suicide thread. Not qualified for relationship advice but I think on Mumsnet LTB is the normal response.

carriedout · 22/04/2023 23:02

there has been huge issues with the emotional compatibility side of things. He really won't communicate with me and when he does it's always picking at my faults, or me being to blame for something. This sounds pretty rubbish. I'd rethink the relationship.

Mumoftwoinprimary · 22/04/2023 22:21

My general view is that if you are in a relationship of a year or less then the only reason that you should be posting on mumsnet is a really annoying stealthboast about the how you have cystitis from shagging so much.

LotionsAndPotions995 · 22/04/2023 22:17

Oh believe me @Nickersnackersnockers I have had the conversation in full detail about what I want, need and what is lacking several times in the past year to the point I'm actually sick of repeating it. I've wrote it in letters and texts aswell so it couldn't be a case of you've never told me, you weren't clear, etc.

How did you manage to last so long with the incompatibility?

OP posts:
ChrisTrepidation · 22/04/2023 22:16

A year in and he's picking at your faults and blaming you for stuff? Not good op.

Some people aren't great at picking up on subtle hints. However his dramatic flouncing when you complain is a massive red flag.

Nickersnackersnockers · 22/04/2023 22:13

Me and dh are a bit emotionally incompatible too. I either suck it up or tell him how it is and what I want. He drives me crazy.

We've been together 35 years.

Pixiedust1234 · 22/04/2023 22:10

In general things are good but there has been huge issues with the emotional compatibility side of things. He really won't communicate with me and when he does it's always picking at my faults, or me being to blame for something.

You should be in the honeymoon period. If this is happening when you are both on your best behaviour then its not a good sign. It will only get worse. Its time to leave.