Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I the villain here?

109 replies

GilChesterton · 22/04/2023 18:38

I work for a regional branch of a large company. During the pandemic I was promoted to manager of our branch, and then promoted a junior member of our team into the role I had just vacated. We worked from home all through the pandemic and various lockdowns, and only in the middle of last year did we start to look at moving to return to the office.

I have instructed our team that they can continue to work from home some of the time, but have to have a minimum amount of time in person in the office. This one member of staff is refusing to return to our office, and during one of the lockdowns actually relocated to be nearer his family, and is not in commutable distance of our office.

Our jobs can technically be done wholly remote, but I feel we lose a lot of team working, accountability and quality if we are not meeting in person regularly, and providing a proper service to our clients does mean being available in person.

I have issued an ultimatum to this team member, saying they either have to follow the guidance or find another job. I am now being accused of ruining his life.

Given the job can be done remote I have begun to doubt myself. AIBU?

OP posts:
theGooHasGone · 22/04/2023 19:36

He's enjoyed three years of remote work from a different location, but now the ride is over. He signed a contract saying he's office based and chose to move away. His fault and his problem. Relocate back or find a new job.

Ilovetea42 · 22/04/2023 19:30

With the cost of rent and mortgages in certain areas I can see why he took the opportunity, a girl I know was able to save 1500 a month on rent moving in with her parents during covid and it meant she didn't have to isolate alone with no support. However he should have made work aware of this. Can he provide short notice zoom or teams support and provide 'face to face' support that way? I would suggest that nobody can always be available for in person short notice meetings because life happens. But if a client can sit down with him remotely and cover the same concerns and information then I'd say you're still providing an adequate service. The kicker here will be the knock on effect on other staff. If you allow him to work solely or mainly from home you'd need to be open to offering that flexibility to the rest of your team where its requested. I'd personally come up with a minimum amount of days you want each individual in the office weekly or monthly depending on what suits and then give them flexibility the rest of the time. I'd say this is temporary and depends on maintaining performance levels and then monitor these how you see fit for a certain trial period. If it works well then you know it works and efficiency isn't affected- if it doesn't then you go back to your team with the evidence you collect and explain they all need to be in the office every day as a result of an overall dip in performance.

Daffidale · 22/04/2023 19:23

GilChesterton · 22/04/2023 18:51

"regardless of where the person is?"

If they are not available at short notice then we can offer less of a service to our clients, who are more and more expecting us to return to an in person service. If someone else then has to cover it places a burden on the rest of the team (or our clients go elsewhere).

This sounds like it’s not really true that the work can be done entirely remotely. Or at least people need to be able to be available in person for client work, often at short notice.

I think you are both being a bit unreasonable TBH. He chose to move an “uncommutable” distance from where his job is located and is now blaming you for the consequences. You’re issuing ultimatums. What’s not clear is whether the two of you have had a grown up, professional conversation about how to make this work. Can he travel in once a week, or for a run of a few days each month? And definitely you need to discuss how he is going to make himself available at short notice for clients.

If this doesn’t work for him at all, then given he is presumably an otherwise valued employee, can you facilitate him finding a new role within the organisation at another office closer to his new home? I would perhaps offer an exception for eg 6 months with support to seek a lateral move, but with understanding that after 6 months it’s either suck up a long commute once a week, or find another job

Hereward1332 · 22/04/2023 19:22

With many jobs it's possible to WFH and perform most of your job ok. What you miss is sharing ideas between teams; helping less experienced staff who you overhear struggling; learning from others. A solo mentality is the mark of a "computer says no" type. It's possible to WFH, but diminishes the effectiveness of the whole. OP is not unreasonable in wanting the best performance for her team, and that means no-one works entirely remotely.

Oysterbabe · 22/04/2023 19:19

We've recently hired a couple of junior staff and I've been going in every day to support them. They've spent a lot of time looking over my shoulder, I've fielded a steady stream of questions, they've listened to me talking to clients etc.

WFH has it's place but if your job is hybrid you can't whine about going in.

Restinggoddess · 22/04/2023 19:16

For those of us who worked face to face during the pandemic- the fact that some people are still working from home bemuses me

If we ring a company these days - it takes ages for someone to answer
WFH seems to be an excuse not to work at the standard once held in offices where people could see what was going on
Time for a return to the office - some of us never left the workplace during covid

Suzi888 · 22/04/2023 19:13

Is he reliable and does he do a good job?

We are hybrid. For an exceptional candidate we would allow 100% remote, but with say two hotel stays a year for a couple of days or overnight to meet the team etc. (Management roles only which are audit/subsidy/stat report based).

BananaSpanner · 22/04/2023 19:11

He was stupid to move house without a guarantee that he could work from home permanently. That is his problem not yours.

Ive been in a similar position. Our department can work remotely but we function better as a team when we are all in. Following the pandemic there was a real reluctance to return to the office and some really dug their heels in. Two staff members left but have been replaced by two very good and keen new people. The remaining staff are used to it again now, and Will begrudgingly admit that we are more effective in the office. However, there is still plenty of scope for flexibility and letting people work from home on an ad hoc basis when they have a pressing need.

Hold your ground.

SquidwardBound · 22/04/2023 19:09

FlyingCherries · 22/04/2023 19:07

Have you recruited much recently? The labour market is very tight. If he’s any good, it might be worth compromising rather than trying to recruit a replacement.

Not if it causes 3 other people to leave because they feel they’re being treated worse than him.

FlyingCherries · 22/04/2023 19:07

Have you recruited much recently? The labour market is very tight. If he’s any good, it might be worth compromising rather than trying to recruit a replacement.

neilyoungismyhero · 22/04/2023 19:07

Surely you'll be setting a precedent allowing him to work exclusively from home.

If all the others decide it's a good idea you'll be the only one there.

pillowpuff · 22/04/2023 19:07

You can't be seen to be treating him differently to the rest of the team, that'll create bad feeling & you'll be the target of it.

Againstmachine · 22/04/2023 19:06

A lot of people need to be forced back into the office.

My local council you can't get in touch with anyone these days as two thirds are still working from home and uncontactable.

This guy chose to move further away, by that token he is a idiot with no foresight, this is a him problem.

Aquamarine1029 · 22/04/2023 19:02

I have issued an ultimatum to this team member, saying they either have to follow the guidance or find another job. I am now being accused of ruining his life.

If the little prince doesn't immediately abide by the terms of his employment, send him packing. Him moving away shows a horrendous lack of judgment, and it's laughable that's he's whinging about you "ruining his life." If you give in to him, you will soon have other members of your staff trying to pull the same trick.

SquidwardBound · 22/04/2023 19:01

It’s not just about him though. If he’s allowed to live too far from the office and never come in, then others are likely to resent having to come in to the office. Especially if the people in the office are having to pick up work because he is WFH miles away.

It’s not as simple as ‘if he’s good at his job, you don’t want to lose him’. The perception of unfairness is likely to cause others to leave.

SnottyLittleMango · 22/04/2023 19:01

Was there anything in your organisation's guidance during the pandemic that indicated that WFH would be permanent? For example my company was clear that some roles would be hybrid, but others would definitely need to return to the office as soon as it was possible. If not YANBU

DDivaStar · 22/04/2023 19:01

You're not being unreasonable. The same conditions should apply to everyone. If you allow him notvyo come in ot could breed resentment in the other staff.

It is awkward but he really should have considered this before moving.

OakleyStreetisnotinChelsea · 22/04/2023 18:56

It is like all those people we saw in sob story newspaper articles who sold their London house and moved to three outer Hebrides in lockdown then were all surprised when their offices stayed to all them to occasionally come in once it was allowed again. Fully remote covid working was a temporary measure. It is great that it has shown us how effective remote working can be but in person interaction is also important and many, many places have a hybrid approach now with some days at home but other days when the team gets together in person for certain parts of their job. The only person who is responsible for "ruining" their life is the eejit who moved away during a temporary working situation when their contractual base hadn't changed.

IhearyouClemFandango · 22/04/2023 18:55

He ruined his own life, by that token. Very short sighted

catgirl1976 · 22/04/2023 18:53

You say the job can be done fully remote but then say it can’t because you can’t offer the full service if clients aren’t met in person.

If it’s the former let them WFH (ideally through a flexible working request so it’s formal and contractual) if it’s the latter then don’t but be clear about why you are refusing it in terms of impact on the service and be prepared to lose them.

Leeds2 · 22/04/2023 18:53

Given that his contract specifies an office base, I don't think YABU to ask for specified time in the office. I am not sure he has applied for a flexible working pattern, given that he doesn't seem very flexible!
I also wouldn't take kindly to be accused of "ruining someone's life." Very immature.

Oysterbabe · 22/04/2023 18:53

If you allow him to call the shots you'll never get any of the staff into the office.

Catsonskis · 22/04/2023 18:53

This is what annoyed me about people moving when they ended up wfh during the pandemic.

up to you what you do but if you don’t make this person come in then you have to treated everyone the same, including new hires - they don’t have to come in either.

I would tell him to apply formally through flexible working request and you can review the request with hr/your manager so it’s done formally and officially. If you all decide that business requires 1 day in for team building or accountability or whatever I’m sorry but he has to suck it up buttercup.

accusing you of ruining his life is both immature and unprofessional and would not put him in good position to be considered sympathetically.

his contract states office based, he’s signed it therefore that’s that!

Dacadactyl · 22/04/2023 18:52

Unless you have other concerns about his work then I think YABU.

However, I also feel he was a bit bonkers to move so far away without clearing it with work first!

GilChesterton · 22/04/2023 18:51

"regardless of where the person is?"

If they are not available at short notice then we can offer less of a service to our clients, who are more and more expecting us to return to an in person service. If someone else then has to cover it places a burden on the rest of the team (or our clients go elsewhere).

OP posts: