Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I the villain here?

109 replies

GilChesterton · 22/04/2023 18:38

I work for a regional branch of a large company. During the pandemic I was promoted to manager of our branch, and then promoted a junior member of our team into the role I had just vacated. We worked from home all through the pandemic and various lockdowns, and only in the middle of last year did we start to look at moving to return to the office.

I have instructed our team that they can continue to work from home some of the time, but have to have a minimum amount of time in person in the office. This one member of staff is refusing to return to our office, and during one of the lockdowns actually relocated to be nearer his family, and is not in commutable distance of our office.

Our jobs can technically be done wholly remote, but I feel we lose a lot of team working, accountability and quality if we are not meeting in person regularly, and providing a proper service to our clients does mean being available in person.

I have issued an ultimatum to this team member, saying they either have to follow the guidance or find another job. I am now being accused of ruining his life.

Given the job can be done remote I have begun to doubt myself. AIBU?

OP posts:
Nottheduracellbunny · 22/04/2023 22:40

This reply has been withdrawn

Message withdrawn - posted on wrong thread

evuscha · 22/04/2023 22:33

You didn’t ruin his life - I was looking with disbelief at all those people moving away (and even buying houses) to rural locations expecting to just WFH forever. Unless your office officially allows fully remote then he’s the unreasonable one. One or two days in the office is a good compromise.

Arightoldcarryabag · 22/04/2023 22:28

determinedtomakethiswork · 22/04/2023 22:22

He is ruining his own life. He's done that all by himself. What a complete idiot, moving house. Does he really think pandemic conditions were going to last forever?

Maybe work from home was impossible or very difficult in the last place they lived. Maybe closer to home/family was the only place they could afford the space to do it comfortably?
Suited the business needs then didn't it.

Arightoldcarryabag · 22/04/2023 22:27

Inkblue · 22/04/2023 22:20

This. It’s become impossible to speak to anyone these days.

It's impossible to speak to someone because companies are prioritising dividend payments to shareholders over investing in staff, in training and in their processes. Because managers get rid of experienced staff because they would rather that than manage a situation of their own making like in this case here.

moonspiral · 22/04/2023 22:23

It's like people who got a lock down puppy then complain about leaving it for a day

determinedtomakethiswork · 22/04/2023 22:22

He is ruining his own life. He's done that all by himself. What a complete idiot, moving house. Does he really think pandemic conditions were going to last forever?

moonspiral · 22/04/2023 22:22

He's ruined his own life

Arightoldcarryabag · 22/04/2023 22:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Inkblue · 22/04/2023 22:20

bamboonights · 22/04/2023 22:13

Spot on. It seems every call centre or customer services department has retained its shitty "sorry we can't answer the phone right now but we are experiencing a very high volume of calls" attitude and it's unacceptable. Every time you need to sort out a utility bill or such like you need to take a morning or afternoon off work. This week I need urgent advice about signage for my business. It transpires that there is no way of speaking to a human being AT ALL, and there are just pages and pages of information and a request for an application fee, for an application I simply don't understand.

This. It’s become impossible to speak to anyone these days.

bamboonights · 22/04/2023 22:13

Restinggoddess · 22/04/2023 19:16

For those of us who worked face to face during the pandemic- the fact that some people are still working from home bemuses me

If we ring a company these days - it takes ages for someone to answer
WFH seems to be an excuse not to work at the standard once held in offices where people could see what was going on
Time for a return to the office - some of us never left the workplace during covid

Spot on. It seems every call centre or customer services department has retained its shitty "sorry we can't answer the phone right now but we are experiencing a very high volume of calls" attitude and it's unacceptable. Every time you need to sort out a utility bill or such like you need to take a morning or afternoon off work. This week I need urgent advice about signage for my business. It transpires that there is no way of speaking to a human being AT ALL, and there are just pages and pages of information and a request for an application fee, for an application I simply don't understand.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 22/04/2023 20:46

I am now fully WFH. There is no real reason for me to go back to the office except some feeling from the management that it is better in some way. If they make me go back in, I will leave. Not all businesses are the same and if it is a burden on other staff, that is not ok. But if there is no good reason, I think you are BU.

VivX · 22/04/2023 20:42

It's bonkers that he's moved house and assumed he can wfh permanently without checking first. This is not you "ruining his life" this is him failing to think through all the consequences.

Tell him he'll need to go through the proper process and put in a flexible working pattern and you can review it formally then.

On a side note, it doesn't seem unreasonable to have some sort of hybrid arrangement. If your clients expect face-to-face and he is in a client-facing role, then it's going to be difficult for him to service clients.

Pandagirl10 · 22/04/2023 20:29

I am having a similar issue with my team but what I am doing is trying to flexible in that rather than (say) doing 2 days a week from the office I arrange for some people to do a full week - they have to arrange/pay accommodation etc or stay with family, if they no longer live in commutable distance.

it’s a nightmare anyway - if you have a team of people working mixed hours (some working 2 days, some 3, some 4, some 5) how do you make it ‘fair’ to all? There’s a fair bit of finger pointing and moaning!

Greenshake · 22/04/2023 20:18

Oysterbabe · 22/04/2023 18:53

If you allow him to call the shots you'll never get any of the staff into the office.

I agree. It’s totally reasonable to ask him to come in once a week or so.

Lou197 · 22/04/2023 20:17

We are having the same issue at our work. We want staff members to return to the office for some of the week, it is just better all round. We offered they could chose which days they wanted to work in the office but then they would have to stick to those days with the odd expection - not happy campers at all. I think you have to be consistant with all. I think a lot of companies are enforcing a hybrid of office / home working if it is suitable.

Tealsofa · 22/04/2023 20:15

GilChesterton · 22/04/2023 18:51

"regardless of where the person is?"

If they are not available at short notice then we can offer less of a service to our clients, who are more and more expecting us to return to an in person service. If someone else then has to cover it places a burden on the rest of the team (or our clients go elsewhere).

So there is a need for them to be physically present in the office to do their job properly

If they are not in the office, then others have to work harder, then you're not unreasonable

batsandeggs · 22/04/2023 20:14

YABU if you don’t recognise that the world of work has changed. Perhaps once a month would be more reasonable? The market is good right now and there are SO many places offering wfh that he’ll probably walk into another job. It sounds like there’s scope to resolve this amicably in a way that works well for you both. Working from home is genuinely life changing for some people, and you have acknowledged that the role can be done from home.

He’s unreasonable for moving without clearing the permanent homeworking first however.

mainsfed · 22/04/2023 20:11

Nope, get rid if the fucker. He’s not special.

GenAndWine · 22/04/2023 20:11

How measurable are the factors you’re saying you ‘feel’ make WFH an issue?

Have you measured performance metrics since becoming the manager?

Do some of your staff prefer working on site and if so can workload be balanced accordingly?

Given the cost of recruitment, and the current job market who would be worse off if this became a hill to die on?

Are there alternatives? An office closer to the staff member’s new home location? An opportunity to come in for four days a month in a row instead of one day a week - they pay travel you pay for premier inn or similar?

KarmaStar · 22/04/2023 20:10

He was unprofessional and reckless,bordering on idiotic,to move away from his workplace.
If he can not come in for the necessary periods of time then he needs to look for a closer job.
You are not ruining his life.
This one is on him.don't doubt yourself.

Hankunamatata · 22/04/2023 19:54

GilChesterton · 22/04/2023 18:51

"regardless of where the person is?"

If they are not available at short notice then we can offer less of a service to our clients, who are more and more expecting us to return to an in person service. If someone else then has to cover it places a burden on the rest of the team (or our clients go elsewhere).

There is your answer. You client's want face to face contact or they take their business elsewhere. The job can't be done 100% remotely as not meeting the expectations of the client's of the business.

FloatingRodger · 22/04/2023 19:47

catgirl1976 · 22/04/2023 18:53

You say the job can be done fully remote but then say it can’t because you can’t offer the full service if clients aren’t met in person.

If it’s the former let them WFH (ideally through a flexible working request so it’s formal and contractual) if it’s the latter then don’t but be clear about why you are refusing it in terms of impact on the service and be prepared to lose them.

Yes this - you don't seem clear as to whether it can be done fully remotely. @Daffidale 's advice seems reasonable.

AlwaysGinPlease · 22/04/2023 19:45

Greensleeves · 22/04/2023 18:49

Well, you kind of are ruining his life. Even if you are in the right legally (I have no idea, it depends on his contract) I think morally you are being petty and unreasonable. If he can do the job from home, he should be allowed to.

This.

FrogFairy · 22/04/2023 19:43

If you let him wfh 100% then you must be prepared for all other staff to do the same.
He “ruined” his life by choosing to move so far away.

L1ttledrummergirl · 22/04/2023 19:36

As a new manager, surely your company provided full training on the legal aspects of decisions like this to you as part of your training in the new role?

What do your companies policies say? What did HR say when you ran this past them?

The advice to stay home through covid ended over a year ago, if they have been performing in that role with no expectation of return to the office, implied terms and conditions may be considered? By changing his contract implied terms, you may find yourself in an employment tribunal.
Tread carefully and with full advice from your HR department.

Swipe left for the next trending thread