Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Game playing friend - how to deal with it

235 replies

Blizzard23 · 22/04/2023 18:32

I am based in a small village this is not unimportant. When we moved here twenty years ago I made good friends with ‘Belle’ and our dc were friends and we spent many Christmases, birthdays, holidays and were super close. Over the pandemic we only grew closer.

In the interim we made separate groups of friends with different circles of friends but still sharing many local friends. Somewhere along the line once the lockdowns lifted she started prioritising some newer friends and I noticed she didn’t invite me to her birthday etc any longer - I asked her about it, if something was wrong she said no, but was vague and blamed other people for messing up the guest list. Really feeble excuses regarding dinners and parties etc but she still claimed we were the best of friends and nothing had changed. It happened repeatedly.
I continued to invite her to the things I was doing for a very long time, not wishing to be petty and to avoid tit for tat. She accepted all of our invites but never returned them for years! Instead she continued to invite others. Eventually I eased off including her, assuming our friendship was cooling, and moving to a different stage. It was sad at the time ofc but just one of those things.

I have some very close friends elsewhere and have been spending more time with them in the last few years. I have accepted this particular friendship has changed, and even after we spoke about it nothing changed for the better in terms of reciprocity. I am planning a birthday party in the summer and have invited local friends and others.

I have now received an outraged message from this friend demanding to know why she isn’t invited and really kicking off. It appears she expects to have birthdays and parties and not invite me, but I am expected to continue to roll out the invites and red carpet for her…

Can someone please share with me their thoughts on this. I am stumped.

Should I have invited her?
Why is she doing this?

OP posts:
maddening · 24/04/2023 08:19

If you were super close in lockdowns surely it has only been 1 - 2 years max that she has cooled off over not 3-4 years as that is pre lockdown? How many birthdays have you not been invited to?

Yanbu however- if she has cooled off and not communicating with you, ignoring you, not inviting you for 1-2 years it is crazy she is upset now..

Blizzard23 · 24/04/2023 08:14

billy1966 · 24/04/2023 08:01

You are not wrong OP in your assessment that you will see which friends are real.

Remain your calm unruffled self that really doesn't understand this reaction, let that be their image of you, with a core of steel.

Your mutual friend is of her ilk, and you may indeed find others.

As you age it is good to know whom are your friends and who are fair weather acquaintances.

She sounds like an ugly bully.

Exactly billy I would rather find out now in benign conditions, than invest a life time of love, time and effort only to find out this side of her possibly under far more difficult circumstances.

I have spent some time going over her past behaviour, and now realise that even when it looked like she was being a good friend and really kind (when I had cancer for instance, and had surgery) what she was actually doing was visiting to gain the latest instalment so she could share it with everyone else. I always wondered how people knew so much, but was too ill at the time to care. The more I think about it she has always been like this, it was just framed and dressed differently.
A true wolf in sheep’s clothes.

OP posts:
dig135 · 24/04/2023 08:11

I had friends like this who chose to act like 13 year olds. They enjoyed the drama of ostracising previous friends in the group, then posting their meet ups on Facebook so the non-invited people had their noses rubbed in it. Proper mean girl behaviour.

Fast forward 10 years and the 'nice' friends have chosen to separate from the group entirely, leaving a small group of three. People reap what they sow and others start to see that toxicity and bitchiness aren't qualities they want in friends.

billy1966 · 24/04/2023 08:01

You are not wrong OP in your assessment that you will see which friends are real.

Remain your calm unruffled self that really doesn't understand this reaction, let that be their image of you, with a core of steel.

Your mutual friend is of her ilk, and you may indeed find others.

As you age it is good to know whom are your friends and who are fair weather acquaintances.

She sounds like an ugly bully.

Blizzard23 · 24/04/2023 07:46

I often think some women remain locked in year six, stunted emotional intelligence that stalls at pubescent age and they never seem to move past it.
I thought she was better than this, it’s disappointing.

OP posts:
Blizzard23 · 24/04/2023 07:44

RampantIvy · 24/04/2023 07:43

This is the kind of thing 12 year olds do.
What would happen if you cancelled your barbecue?

I am not going to cancel, she would love that!

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 24/04/2023 07:43

This is the kind of thing 12 year olds do.
What would happen if you cancelled your barbecue?

Blizzard23 · 24/04/2023 07:41

This situation is going to test all of my friendships that are linked to Nutty.
It is my feeling that some may let me down, buckle under her command, others might pull through. Either way I am about to find out the wheat from the chaff.

I sense her outrage, I can feel it from here. She has had long enough to do the right thing, be a decent person etc but she has chosen to play games and devalue both our friendship and herself. I can’t and won’t have ‘friends’ like this, that are more interested in village gossip and hierarchy than anything else.

I am prepared that maybe none of these friends will make it, and if that happens they were not friends in the first place and don’t deserve a place at my table.

Village life can give people nervous breakdowns, and it has done in the past even here I am sorry to say. Not everyone can cope with it. I have lived here for 22 years and dream of some autonomy and social freedoms in the city, where you can distance from unscrupulous people without too much difficulty!

OP posts:
OhwhyOY · 23/04/2023 23:41

If I were you I'd get in asap with your side of the story with mutual friends. Next time you see any of them I'd just say 'hey, I had a weird message from [nutty friend] who says she's angry she's not been invited to my BBQ. I just wanted to see what you thought about it as she's not invited me to any of her events for literally years so i thought we'd just drifted apart. I was sad about that but I accepted it as when I'd spoken to her previously she said nothing was wrong' etc etc. And just say you invited her for coffee etc but she's still being weird with you.

I think otherwise you do risk her turning people against you. You don't have to be calculating about it all, just tell them the truth and ask for their opinions.

Fraaahnces · 23/04/2023 23:28

I was going to to warn you to be prepared for a “coincidental” event being planned for the same day now. This type is so predictable.

QueenMegan · 23/04/2023 23:23

Fuck me I'd have a nervous breakdown in your village.
Bollix to her she sounds poison.
If people want to gossip let them.

Jellifulfruit · 23/04/2023 23:02

Mutual and nutty May have done you a favour. Fucking off together = the trash taking itself out 🤣

billy1966 · 23/04/2023 22:32

Mutual and nutty are clearly in close contact so ignoring both is best.

billy1966 · 23/04/2023 22:31

Mutual friend is equally toxic so not engaging with her further is wise too.

Stick to the narrative of it being a small gathering and that you can't see why it has drawn such a reaction.

ejbaxa · 23/04/2023 20:15

I agree you need to be careful re mutual friend. She seems to be a bit of a prodder - she should have left you alone after the first message, but the fact she's sent another just means that she is to be avoided.

Blizzard23 · 23/04/2023 19:44

Gcsunnyside23 · 23/04/2023 16:15

Has the nutty friend or mutual friend replied to you yet?

I am not replying to nutty friend I’m just going to leave it. Mutual friend has replied and said Nutty is ‘terribly upset’ and it’s such a shame there isn’t room for them. I am not going to respond, and aware she may not be a friend I will be desperate to see in the future.

Just waiting for Nutty to organise a counter BBQ and invite the same people. It’s been done before.

OP posts:
Jackiewoo · 23/04/2023 18:25

how to address boundaries I'm still working on it TBH 😁. I've taken a kicking in the friendship any number of times because when you give you are bound to attract a few who only know how to take and so you learn and adjust.

Friendships without agenda are definitely not a disadvantage. People aren't stupid, if you see xx for what she is the chances are that others can too even if they don't say it. Do not change yourself for a dud like xx.

Gcsunnyside23 · 23/04/2023 16:15

Blizzard23 · 23/04/2023 15:34

Thank you to everyone for posting - this thread is really enlightening.

Those enjoying friendships without an agenda, is that a massive disadvantage? I always thought sincerity and authenticity was a good thing? But not if we are simply used as roadkilll. This thread has made me consider all of my friendships more closely.

Has the nutty friend or mutual friend replied to you yet?

Blizzard23 · 23/04/2023 15:34

Thank you to everyone for posting - this thread is really enlightening.

Those enjoying friendships without an agenda, is that a massive disadvantage? I always thought sincerity and authenticity was a good thing? But not if we are simply used as roadkilll. This thread has made me consider all of my friendships more closely.

OP posts:
girlfriend44 · 23/04/2023 15:32

Once it gets like this, the friendship is over, the mere fact that game playing started says it all.

If you were good friends then there wouldn't have been a problem.

Blizzard23 · 23/04/2023 15:31

GasPanic · 23/04/2023 13:17

Typical group power play.

She obviously enjoys her perceived high status amongst the local social scene. Her not inviting you to her events is a power play. It demonstrates that she is one of the big players on the scene, and she can invite who she wants to her events and ignore others, while because she is seen as one of the big players in town everyone has to and wants to invite her to theirs.

Your non invitation is a direct threat to her status. You're basically saying, your not important enough to be able to get away with that power play, and I don't care about inviting you because you are not one of the big players that everyone must invite.

You're threatening her status at the head of the local social scene and challenging her directly. There isn't really any other way she will interpret this.

There are only really two choices, one is to roll over, which is exactly what she wants. The other is to just ignore her, which will deepen the threat and make her act aggressively to counter it.

My guess is she will prosecute the slight aggressively, because once one person shows that she is not high status, everyone else could follow, leaving her no longer with the high status image that is important to her. So if you do decide to fight you may need to be in for the long haul.

Read a few books on chimpanzee behaviour. It will tell you everything about human peer group bonding you need to know. The ejection of one friend from a peer group to cement a leader at the head of the group and to bond the group together more strongly as a result of the ejection is a very common theme on here.

Fascinating post. Really so interesting. Luckily I do have multiple groups of friends so my social life doesn’t hang on her participation. Even so, her extreme reaction makes me think you have hit the nail on the head, she definitely seems very threatened. I am not meaning to challenge her, I am just sick of her behaviour but maybe it’s the same thing.

OP posts:
Blizzard23 · 23/04/2023 15:27

I do have boundaries but will do whatever I can for anyone within reason is my default, so yes probably not able to easily spot the sharks until it is too late. I have no idea how to address that.

OP posts:
Blizzard23 · 23/04/2023 15:24

Jackiewoo · 23/04/2023 14:01

the access oh my days I could write a book 😁. From your posts you sound like an open, friendly 'everyone is included' sort of person, what you see is what you get. For you, friends are precisely that, you don't have an agenda, make friends easily and are trusting and loyal. The trouble with this is that you might lack judgement about who your genuine friends are or healthy boundaries about how you allow yourself to be treated (and how much you give of yourself to others) and you struggle to understand people who are more transactional with their friendships. They're not bad or toxic people necessarily but they only want you around if you can do something for them (eg. a party invite, access to a particular social circle, or because your DC are friends at school, or because you work somewhere they want discount from, take your pick). They’re just being them but it can leave you feeling confused, because you’re picked up when wanted but otherwise forgotten about, discarded and left feeling used. Which is what xx has done. Then there’s the clique and queen bee thing, which is another level of pain in the arse. Or I may be misreading your posts, in which case tell me to STFU.

If it helps at all xx isn't deliberately trying to cause trouble for you, that is just an unfortunate byproduct of her blinkered priorities for herself, and not about you at all.

It’s like you know me inside out, that is precisely what I am like! Love having everyone together, no agendas or strategies just like people just for being themselves. I know some people are more transactional but I am kind of accepting of that too unless they are rude or dishonest with it.

OP posts:
Gcsunnyside23 · 23/04/2023 14:41

Blizzard23 · 22/04/2023 21:12

I am worried she is going to gossip that I am being the uncharitable and unreasonable one, and play the victim. I feel like I am handing her a good reason to be even worse.

I come from a small village and I would definitely go with keep it factual and clear. Don't be snarky and don't ghost her as she sounds like she would use it against you. Then if anything is said you can literally show them the messages. If anything I would get ahead of it and mention it to your mutual friends as in how strange she messaged you for an invite

billy1966 · 23/04/2023 14:06

OP,

She is utterly toxic.

Be as vague and non committal as possible and expect your texts to be passed around, so keep them super light.

Stress that it is a small group for closest friends.

I would be wary of the person who stuck her nose in.
Sounds more nosey than a heads up.

Whatever you do, do NOT invite her.

If anyone asks you about a falling out, act super confused and deny it with a smile🤷🏻‍♀️.

She thought you would remain a doormat and is outraged that you have put in boundaries finally.

Resist the urge to bitch about her, better to be breazy and confused about what her problem is.

Swipe left for the next trending thread