Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Best friends didn’t turn up to ‘surprise’ birthday celebrations

308 replies

user1488481370 · 22/04/2023 17:10

In a nutshell Ive recently had a big birthday.
My sister in law organised a ‘surprise’ birthday afternoon tea for me last weekend. I knew something was going on but wasn’t sure what we were doing, where we were going or who with.
I turned up with my mum to a room
with 1 of my friends, SIL’s mum, my auntie and 2 of SIL’s friends. 3 of the people who I consider to be my best friends never even turned up. Made bull shit excuses to SIL and never put the effort in.

I feel so guilty for feeling the way that I do. SIL has put so much effort in and it was lovely to see the people who were there. But I just can’t help but feel heartbroken. I got home and burst into tears. I was trying to bull shit myself saying that it was maybe money and not being able to afford it but I know deep down that won’t be the case.

I don’t know how to approach this, whether to approach it at all. I don’t think I can be the same with them now. I’m so fucking upset and low right now.

OP posts:
Horsedoglover59 · 23/04/2023 16:04

Is it possible your friends had a falling out with S-I-L? Do they know her and get on with her? Maybe they'd been planning to take you out themselves. I do think you should try to find out why they didn't show, then if the excuses are poor, then they are not real friends. I'm so sorry, OP, and hope you had a good birthday in any case🍾

TedMullins · 23/04/2023 14:22

Whoknewwhat · 23/04/2023 09:33

I actually disagree with this. All relationships between adults involve reciprocity and obligation if the relationship is to survive. Birthday celebrations are to show your love and liking for the person, that they are worth celebrating. It’s obviously painful if you invite a small number of special people and they don’t show up. And the friends will know this is the effect of their no show. We all put ourselves out for friends. Friendships grow that way. Someone who never puts themselves out for a friend, well that is someone who you will cease to have friendly feelings for over time.

I really don’t get this attitude from some on Mumsnet that ‘ well, they are your friend but you can’t expect them to actually do anything for you’. That’s a light acquaintance, not a friend. A friend isn’t just a laugh in the pub. A friend is more than that.

Agree with this. I think there is an obligation to go to friend’s birthdays and do things for them, but good friends would WANT to be there and make the effort. These aren’t good friends.

happinessischocolate · 23/04/2023 14:17

Okthenhun · 23/04/2023 10:18

I say this as someone who (as I’ve got older and more introverted) hates feeling obligated to go to events such as hen dos, birthdays, nights out etc and I usually always stick up for people that don’t want to go to such things on MN:

Your “friends” are total cunts. You have every right to feel upset. I’d be devastated if my friends treated me like this.

Im so sorry OP. Bin them off. 💐

I agree with this.

I was going to suggest having one last conversation with each of them, just to find out their side but if your DH spoke to your BF and she still didn't come, but managed to go to bingo then there's nothing to say really.

whynotwhatknot · 23/04/2023 14:00

poor excuses they arent real friends

FrostyFifi · 23/04/2023 12:41

Why do women make such a fuss about birthdays? I don’t know of any men who do

Don't you? I have a friend who said to me, of course my birth day will really be a birthday week, then started reeling off the list of social events that were to take place in his honour.

Oblomov23 · 23/04/2023 12:18

The more you tell us the worse it gets. I would have to say something. To at least tell them that I was very hurt.

RampantIvy · 23/04/2023 12:17

Colourfingers2 · 23/04/2023 11:19

Why do women make such a fuss about birthdays? I don’t know of any men who do.
I’ve barely even acknowledged my birthday since I was 21 as I no longer saw the point. I was 48 on Friday and I went to my friends funeral I didn’t even mention that I’d been born 48 years before.
I just think yeah so what I was born, who hasn’t been.
Frankly like Christmas it bores me. I make an effort to mark my children’s birthdays because it’s important to them but once you’ve grown up you should grow out of it in my opinion. I did.
After all if you expect everyone to mark every occasion then somewhere along the line you’re going to be disappointed aren’t you OP.

What exactly was the point of your post?
OK, so you are a joy sponge, but why spread your joylessness to other people who do like to celebrate their birthday? It doesn't make you morally superior.

Barney60 · 23/04/2023 12:15

Happy birthday OP.
Have your friends arranged something else?
Have they met your SIL before, do they perhaps not like her?
If they get on, friends not even mentioned your birthday, then in my opinion they are not friends.
Delete them ignore them move on and make new friends that im sure your worthy of.

Eleganz · 23/04/2023 12:11

If they haven't shown interest in your milestone birthday generally then I think you know that it wasn't your SIL's organisational skills that were lacking.

Of course it could be that they all have something very serious but that needs to be kept private going on in their lives, but for 3 people to be affected like that in one friendship group would be really unlikely.

So if you've ruled out poor organisation and personal issues then sadly it may be a case that these friends were more important to you than you are to them.

sofamarathon · 23/04/2023 12:09

I don't think i would confront them

Just leave it but take a step away. They maybe planning something else?

Hsve you been to their birthdays?

moonriverandme · 23/04/2023 11:37

Rise above it op. When people show you who they are, believe them the first time. Find new friends. I'm sorry, something similar happened to me on my 40th birthday.. I still feel hurt to be honest, I'm careful about friendship as a result & always try to behave as a friend I would like to have. It's life. 💐

burnoutbabe · 23/04/2023 11:31

The only way I'd not be upset is if the 3 friends actually had made separate plans to have a meet up anyway with you around the sane time, so no point doing it twice?

Else it seems like this party was a low effort way for them to celebrate with you so they should make the effort (if nothing else planned by them and you)

Blizzard23 · 23/04/2023 11:28

Colourfingers2 · 23/04/2023 11:19

Why do women make such a fuss about birthdays? I don’t know of any men who do.
I’ve barely even acknowledged my birthday since I was 21 as I no longer saw the point. I was 48 on Friday and I went to my friends funeral I didn’t even mention that I’d been born 48 years before.
I just think yeah so what I was born, who hasn’t been.
Frankly like Christmas it bores me. I make an effort to mark my children’s birthdays because it’s important to them but once you’ve grown up you should grow out of it in my opinion. I did.
After all if you expect everyone to mark every occasion then somewhere along the line you’re going to be disappointed aren’t you OP.

It’s irrelevant that you do not celebrate birthdays or see the point, the fact is if it’s important to a friend, regardless of what it is, you make the effort. It communicates that you care and value them.

Birthdays are a lovely way to make time for people in the hectic scrum of life. Not to feel ‘special’ necessarily but nothing wrong if you do, but to make the time to tell people they are important to you once a year, it is not hard nor taxing.

justlurkinghere · 23/04/2023 11:25

FrostyFifi · 23/04/2023 11:00

So many people making excuses for these shit friends, so many people obviously have the bar set very very low when it comes to friendships

I suspect it's more that the people making excuses are similar to the shit friends and feel entitled to be that way, and are incenced at the implied critisism.

Actually I'm a very good friend and I'd have gone to this sort of event, whether I wanted to or not, unless there was a significant reason not to.
I also know what it's like to have a child is a long-term chronic unpredictable illness that leads to last minute cancellations and what it's like to lose friends because of that, so I give people a fair amount of benefit of the doubt. I know that probably isn't the OP's friends specific situation. I have just learned to not analyze these things too much unless there's a pattern that there isn't a good reason for. I'm very loyal but also very easygoing as a friend because life isn't straight forward for many of us.

annonymousmouseinyourhouse · 23/04/2023 11:24

Your a bank friend op, a friend when it suits them/need numbers or a shoulder to cry on.

All they had to do was turn up for a low cost evening. 1 went out anyway, 1 completely ignored you and the other said she was ill. They do not value you.

It's shit and I'm sorry you had to go through this.

CharlotteUnaNatalieThompson · 23/04/2023 11:24

phoenixrosehere · 23/04/2023 11:19

I never make a fuss for birthdays, it’s the first time anyone has ever bothered to plan anything special like this for me, I’m not used to having all attention on me and was a bit worried about it but thought if my closest friends were there it would be easier and flow a bit more freely.

Is it possible that since you never make a fuss, not used to having all the attention on you, and it was your SIL planning this surprise party that they presumed it was something you didn’t actually want?

I was about to post exactly this.

On the face of it it sounds as though your friends are shit. But I wouldn't go to a surprise party arranged for someone I thought would hate a surprise party (including my husband!). So maybe ask your friends why they weren't there first and see what they say.

If this is the reason they'll be really upset to have hurt you and probably try to arrange something else. If they are defensive or flippant about their other plans I'd probably rethink the friendships. But don't do this without getting their perspective first

phoenixrosehere · 23/04/2023 11:20

I would still go but would be wondering if it was really what you wanted and/or planned a separate outing to celebrate.

Colourfingers2 · 23/04/2023 11:19

Why do women make such a fuss about birthdays? I don’t know of any men who do.
I’ve barely even acknowledged my birthday since I was 21 as I no longer saw the point. I was 48 on Friday and I went to my friends funeral I didn’t even mention that I’d been born 48 years before.
I just think yeah so what I was born, who hasn’t been.
Frankly like Christmas it bores me. I make an effort to mark my children’s birthdays because it’s important to them but once you’ve grown up you should grow out of it in my opinion. I did.
After all if you expect everyone to mark every occasion then somewhere along the line you’re going to be disappointed aren’t you OP.

phoenixrosehere · 23/04/2023 11:19

I never make a fuss for birthdays, it’s the first time anyone has ever bothered to plan anything special like this for me, I’m not used to having all attention on me and was a bit worried about it but thought if my closest friends were there it would be easier and flow a bit more freely.

Is it possible that since you never make a fuss, not used to having all the attention on you, and it was your SIL planning this surprise party that they presumed it was something you didn’t actually want?

FrostyFifi · 23/04/2023 11:00

So many people making excuses for these shit friends, so many people obviously have the bar set very very low when it comes to friendships

I suspect it's more that the people making excuses are similar to the shit friends and feel entitled to be that way, and are incenced at the implied critisism.

DomPom47 · 23/04/2023 10:52

Why don’t you just send them both a message saying you’re disappointed they were not able to turn ip especially given the notice and the fact that it was all paid for. Would have been nice for them to come and celebrate a special birthday of yours just like you have been with them for special occasions.

PinkyFlamingo · 23/04/2023 10:50

So many people making excuses for these shit friends, so many people obviously have the bar set very very low when it comes to friendships, yes they had months of notice and no it wouldn't cost anything.
To actually go to the bingo instead of a celebration for your best friend is so poor.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 23/04/2023 10:50

I don’t think your being unreasonable though, to be clear

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 23/04/2023 10:50

I suppose each of them had their own reasons (even if not good) just thought “oh well the others will go” and didn’t think about the cumulative affect of them all not being there.

People often don’t like to be the one left “holding the baby” of having to go to an event that is low on numbers too.

Sleepyandconfused · 23/04/2023 10:49

Only read page 1 but finding it odd that people are making excuses for the friends. There are very, very few events in the world that would be important enough to make me miss my best friends birthday. Maybe my own wedding, the birth of my own child, or something absolutely essential for work (and even that I’d try and move!). Other than that, I’d be there. Wouldn’t dream of missing it!